General Intro | Contracts | Contract Definition, What is a Promise, Legal Enforceability

Law Simply Explained
5 Jul 202228:31

Summary

TLDRProfessor Tracy introduces the concept of contracts through the lens of promises. She explains that a contract is a promise or set of promises recognized by law, enforceable through legal remedies. Key elements of a promise include a clear intention to act or refrain from acting, communicated outwardly to justify a promisee's understanding of commitment. The video distinguishes between contractual promises, which are part of an exchange and thus legally enforceable, and gratuitous promises, which lack legal enforcement unless fulfilled. This foundational lesson sets the stage for deeper exploration into contract law.

Takeaways

  • 📚 A contract is legally defined as a promise or set of promises, enforceable by law when a breach occurs.
  • 🗣️ The core of a contract is a 'promise', which is a commitment to perform or refrain from performing a specified action.
  • 👤 The person making the promise is known as the 'promisor', and the person to whom the promise is made is the 'promisee'.
  • 💡 A promise in law must be a clear intention to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, communicated to the promisee.
  • 🗣️ For a promise to be legally recognized, it must be outwardly expressed, not just an internal thought.
  • 🔍 The legal system uses three main tools to interpret promises: ordinary meaning of words, technical meaning where applicable, and surrounding circumstances.
  • 💭 The intention to act or refrain from acting is crucial; a promise must be specific and not just a hope or general statement.
  • 💬 Promises can be made verbally, in writing, or inferred from conduct, depending on the context and clarity of the commitment.
  • 📜 Not all promises are legally enforceable; only 'contractual' promises, which are part of an exchange or have consideration, are typically enforceable by law.
  • 🎓 A 'gratuitous' or 'naked' promise, made without expectation of something in return, is generally not legally enforceable unless other conditions are met.
  • 🏛️ The script introduces an analytical framework for understanding contracts, starting with formation, moving through defenses, interpretation, breach, and remedies.

Q & A

  • What is the legal definition of a contract according to the script?

    -A contract is defined as a promise or a set of promises for which the law recognizes either a duty or provides a legal remedy in case of a breach, which is the failure to fulfill the promise.

  • What are the key elements to consider when determining if a statement is a legal promise?

    -The key elements include a manifestation of intention to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, made in a manner that would justify a promisee in understanding that a commitment has been made.

  • Who are the 'promisor' and 'promisee' in the context of a promise?

    -The 'promisor' is the person making the promise, while the 'promisee' is the person to whom the promise is made.

  • How can a promise be manifested according to the script?

    -A promise can be manifested through spoken or written words, or it can be inferred from conduct, depending on the surrounding circumstances.

  • What is the difference between a contractual promise and a gratuitous promise?

    -A contractual promise is part of an exchange, usually involving a return promise or performance, and is legally enforceable. A gratuitous promise, on the other hand, is not part of an exchange and is generally not legally enforceable.

  • What is 'consideration' in the context of contract law as discussed in the script?

    -Consideration is a return promise or performance given in exchange for a promise, which makes the promise contractual and legally enforceable.

  • How does the script explain the enforceability of a promise in a legal sense?

    -The script explains that not every promise is legally enforceable. A promise is enforceable if it is part of a contract, which typically involves an exchange and provides for legal remedies in case of breach.

  • What are the three interpretive tools used to determine if a promise is a commitment?

    -The three interpretive tools are: giving words their ordinary meaning, using technical meanings for specific terms, and considering all surrounding circumstances to understand the intention behind the promise.

  • What is an example of a gratuitous promise provided in the script?

    -An example of a gratuitous promise is when Bob says, 'I promise to take you to Disney World over winter break,' without expecting anything in return, making it a naked promise that is not legally enforceable.

  • How does the script suggest determining whether a promise is part of an exchange?

    -The script suggests that a promise is part of an exchange if there is a return promise or performance, which is indicative of a contractual relationship and makes the promise legally enforceable.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Introduction to Contracts

Professor Tracy begins an introductory lesson on contracts by defining a contract as a promise or set of promises recognized by law. The focus is on understanding what constitutes a promise, which is the foundational element of a contract. Using the example of Bob promising to take Barb to Disney World, the professor explains the roles of the promisor (the one making the promise) and the promisee (the one to whom the promise is made). The legal definition of a promise is explored as a manifestation of an intention to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, which justifies the promisee's understanding of a commitment being made. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of the promise as the building block of a contract and the need to break down the legal definition into understandable elements.

05:03

🗣️ Manifestation of Intention

This section delves deeper into the concept of a promise as a manifestation of intention. The professor explains that a promise must be outwardly expressed, not just a thought kept in one's head. Using Bob's promise to Barb, the professor clarifies that for a statement to be a promise, it must show an intention to act or refrain from acting in a specific way. The paragraph distinguishes between a mere expression of hope, which does not constitute a promise, and a commitment, which does. The key element is whether a reasonable person in the shoes of the promisee would understand that a commitment has been made. The professor introduces three interpretive tools: ordinary meaning, technical meaning, and surrounding circumstances, which are crucial for determining the intention behind a promise.

10:05

🔍 Interpreting Promises

The paragraph discusses the tools used to interpret whether a promisor intends to make a commitment. It emphasizes the importance of giving words their ordinary meaning, using technical meanings for industry-specific terms, and considering all surrounding circumstances. The professor provides examples to illustrate how these tools are applied. For instance, the word 'swear' in a promise implies a commitment, while 'hope' does not. The concept of 'extra magic hour' at Disney is explained as a technical term that requires understanding within the context of a Disney resort. The paragraph underscores the need to objectively interpret a promisor's intention based on how a reasonable person would perceive the promise.

15:05

💬 Methods of Making a Promise

This section outlines the various ways a promise can be made, which include spoken words, written words, or inferred from conduct. The professor explains that a promise can be verbal or in writing, and it can also be implied through actions. Examples are given to illustrate each method, such as Bob verbally promising to take Barb to Disney World or writing her a letter making the same promise. The paragraph also touches on the more nuanced aspect of inferring a promise from conduct, suggesting that context and surrounding circumstances are essential for understanding whether an action constitutes a promise.

20:07

📉 Contractual vs. Gratuitous Promises

The focus of this paragraph is on distinguishing between contractual and gratuitous promises. Contractual promises are those that are legally enforceable and are part of an exchange, often involving a return promise or performance. The professor uses the example of Bob promising to take Barb to Disney World if she earns an 'A' in contracts, which constitutes a contractual promise because it is part of a reciprocal agreement. In contrast, gratuitous promises, which are made without expectation of anything in return, are generally not legally enforceable. The paragraph highlights the importance of consideration in making a promise contractual and the implications for legal enforceability.

25:09

🏛️ Contract Formation and Consideration

The final paragraph provides an overview of the contract formation process and the role of consideration. It introduces an analytic framework for understanding contracts, which includes contract formation, defenses, interpretation, breach, and remedies. The professor emphasizes that not all promises are legally enforceable, and the presence of consideration is crucial for determining if a promise is contractual. The paragraph sets the stage for further exploration of contract law by outlining the foundational concepts and the importance of exchange in creating legally binding agreements.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Contract

A contract is a legally binding agreement between two or more parties that outlines the terms and conditions of the agreement. In the video, contracts are defined as a promise or a set of promises for which the law recognizes a duty or provides a remedy in case of breach. The concept of a contract is foundational to the video's theme of understanding how promises are legally enforceable.

💡Promise

A promise, as discussed in the video, is a commitment to perform or refrain from performing a specified action. It is the building block of a contract. The video emphasizes that a promise must be manifested, indicating an intention to act or not act in a certain way, and must be understood by the promisee as a commitment.

💡Promisor

The promisor is the party making the promise in a contract. The video uses the example of Bob, who promises to take Barb to Disney World, to illustrate the role of the promisor. The promisor's actions and words are crucial in determining the existence and nature of a contract.

💡Promisee

The promisee is the party to whom the promise is made. In the video's narrative, Barb is the promisee because Bob's promise is directed towards her. The promisee's understanding and reaction to the promise are important in assessing whether a contract is formed.

💡Manifestation

A manifestation, in the context of contracts, refers to the outward expression of an intention to act or not act in a specified way. The video explains that a mere thought is not enough; the intention must be communicated through speech, writing, or other means for it to be considered a manifestation.

💡Intention

Intention, as used in the video, refers to the promisor's plan or resolve to do or not do something specific. It is a key element in forming a promise. For example, when Bob says he will take Barb to Disney World, his intention is to perform the specified action of taking her there.

💡Consideration

Consideration is something of value exchanged between parties that supports the formation of a contract. The video explains that a contractual promise is typically made in return for consideration, which could be a return promise or performance. For instance, if Barb promises to earn an 'A' in exchange for Bob's promise to take her to Disney World, her promise serves as consideration.

💡Contractual Promise

A contractual promise is a promise that is legally enforceable, usually because it is part of an exchange involving consideration. The video discusses how contractual promises are the basis for enforceable contracts, unlike gratuitous promises that lack consideration and are generally not enforceable.

💡Gratuitous Promise

A gratuitous promise is a promise made without expecting anything in return, which is typically not legally enforceable. The video uses the example of Bob promising to take Barb to Disney World without any condition or expectation of a return action from Barb, illustrating a gratuitous promise.

💡Legal Duty

Legal duty refers to the obligation imposed by law to perform or refrain from performing certain actions. In the context of the video, a contract creates a legal duty on the promisor to fulfill their promise, and if they fail to do so, the law provides remedies such as damages or specific performance.

💡Breach

Breach of contract occurs when a party fails to fulfill their promise or obligation under a contract. The video mentions breach as a failure to perform the promised action, which can lead to legal remedies. For example, if Bob fails to take Barb to Disney World as promised, he would be in breach of their contract.

Highlights

A contract is defined as a promise or set of promises recognized by law, which can be legally enforced.

The law of contracts begins with understanding what constitutes a promise, which is a foundational element of a contract.

The person making the promise is termed the promissor, and the person to whom the promise is made is the promisee.

A legal promise is a manifestation of an intention to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, made to justify the promisee's understanding of a commitment.

A promise must be outwardly expressed, not just an internal thought, to be considered a manifestation of intention.

The intention behind a promise must be to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, which is a key element for a promise to be legally recognized.

The third element of a promise is that it must be made in a way that justifies the promisee's understanding that a commitment has been made.

The use of certain words like 'swear' or 'guarantee' can indicate a stronger commitment and thus a legally enforceable promise.

The ordinary meaning of words and the technical meaning of terms within a specific context are crucial for interpreting the intent behind a promise.

Surrounding circumstances can provide context to understand the intent of a promissor, especially when the language used is ambiguous.

A promise can be made through spoken words, written words, or inferred from conduct, each having different levels of enforceability.

Not every promise is legally enforceable; only those that are part of an exchange, known as contractual promises, typically are.

Gratuitous or naked promises, which are made without expectation of something in return, are generally not legally enforceable.

The concept of consideration is introduced as a return promise or performance that makes a promise contractual and thus legally enforceable.

An analytical framework for contract law is presented, outlining the stages from formation to breach and remedies.

The importance of distinguishing between contractual and gratuitous promises for legal enforceability is emphasized.

Transcripts

play00:00

hey all this is professor tracy from law

play00:03

simply explained with an introductory

play00:07

lesson to

play00:08

contracts

play00:10

so our starting place here is to talk

play00:13

about a promise and you might say well

play00:15

why is that because when we look at the

play00:18

legal definition of a contract we're

play00:21

told that a contract is a promise or a

play00:24

set of promises and we'll dive into the

play00:27

latter half of the definition in just a

play00:29

minute but it tells us that the it's a

play00:33

promise or a set of promises for which

play00:35

the law recognizes either a duty or it

play00:39

recognizes that a breach meaning the

play00:42

failure to fulfill that promise should

play00:45

be given some sort of legal remedy and

play00:48

so our starting place when we think of

play00:50

contracts and the law of contracts is to

play00:53

ask ourselves what is a promise because

play00:56

that's the building block of a contract

play00:59

and so when we think about a promise we

play01:03

need to get some terminology out of the

play01:05

way and to do that we're gonna have bob

play01:08

and barb help us out here so if bob says

play01:11

barb

play01:12

i will take you to disney world over

play01:14

winter break

play01:16

then we know that that's a promise right

play01:19

just like in everyday speech when we

play01:21

tell somebody i will do x y and z that's

play01:24

a promise it's a commitment to do

play01:26

something in here bob is saying i will

play01:29

take you barb to disney world over

play01:31

winter break and so that's no different

play01:35

under the law we're going to break it

play01:36

down in a little more detail in a second

play01:39

but it's still a promise and because

play01:42

we're not very inventive in the law or

play01:44

very creative we say that the person

play01:47

making the promise is the promissor and

play01:50

the person to whom that promise is made

play01:53

is the promise c

play01:55

and

play01:56

we then need to say well what is the

play01:58

legal definition of a promise

play02:01

and we're told that a promise is a

play02:04

manifestation of an intention to act or

play02:08

refrain from acting in a specified way

play02:12

so made as to justify a promisee and

play02:15

understanding a commitment has been made

play02:18

that's a lot going on there right and

play02:20

unlike a class like criminal law or

play02:22

torts which is kind of necessarily and

play02:25

and broken down into elements we need to

play02:29

break this down ourselves so we need to

play02:32

chunk it and break it up into elements

play02:35

and so we can say well what's the first

play02:38

element the promisism has it's a

play02:40

manifestation of an intention an

play02:43

intention to do what to act or refrain

play02:46

from acting in a specified way

play02:49

and it means that it's so made as to

play02:53

justify a promisee remember that's the

play02:55

person to whom the promise is made in

play02:58

understanding that a commitment has been

play03:00

made so let's look at each of those

play03:04

elements

play03:05

so the first one is it's a manifestation

play03:08

of an intention

play03:10

so what do we mean by that well here if

play03:13

bob is just thinking

play03:14

i will take barb to disney world over

play03:17

winter break

play03:18

that's something that's just in his head

play03:21

it's a thought that he's having it's not

play03:24

a manifestation when we use the word

play03:26

manifestation we mean something that is

play03:30

outwardly expressed

play03:33

not something that's just kept in my

play03:36

head but something i have vocalized or

play03:40

written or but somehow outwardly

play03:43

expressed to someone else

play03:46

and so here if bob is saying nothing but

play03:51

just thinking in his head then we don't

play03:53

have a manifestation and when we say an

play03:56

intention we mean that the the person is

play04:00

manifesting that they'll do something in

play04:04

particular so if bob says barb i will

play04:08

take you to disney world over winter

play04:10

break he is now

play04:13

speaking

play04:14

outwardly expressing outwardly through

play04:18

spoken word that he will do something

play04:22

right he has an intention

play04:24

to do a particular thing here that is

play04:27

that he will take barb to disney world

play04:30

over break

play04:32

so that is in fact a promise because

play04:36

it's a he has a manifestation of

play04:38

intention and the other elements will be

play04:40

met as well and we'll look at those in

play04:42

just a second so it's an intention to do

play04:45

what to act or refrain from acting in a

play04:48

specified way

play04:50

so if bob says

play04:52

i promise

play04:54

you that disney world won't be too

play04:57

crowded

play04:59

well there that is not a promise by bob

play05:03

to act or refrain from acting in a

play05:05

specified way right when bob says i

play05:08

promise you that disney world won't be

play05:09

too crowded

play05:11

that is not

play05:13

bob

play05:14

committing to do a particular thing or

play05:16

not to do a particular thing that's him

play05:20

promising something over which he really

play05:22

doesn't have any control at all he's

play05:24

just saying i promise it won't be too

play05:26

crowded but that's not an intention

play05:30

to do something or not do something in

play05:32

particular so

play05:34

it may not even satisfy element one it's

play05:37

certainly a manifestation of spoken word

play05:39

but it's not really an intention to act

play05:42

or refrain from acting in a specified

play05:44

way but if bob says

play05:47

i won't eat the chili this time

play05:49

then that is bob

play05:53

is speaking not only an outward

play05:55

manifestation

play05:57

to

play05:57

but to also to act or not act in a

play06:00

specified way here it's to not eat the

play06:03

chili so now we have again a promise

play06:07

right because we can

play06:09

say that he is outwardly manifesting an

play06:12

intention to act or refrain from acting

play06:15

in a specified way

play06:16

so

play06:17

that those elements are satisfied and we

play06:20

have the third element it where the

play06:23

promise must be so made as to justify a

play06:26

promisee remember that's the person to

play06:28

whom the promise is made and

play06:31

understanding that a commitment has been

play06:34

made

play06:35

so here one of the important things to

play06:37

know about this element as we look at it

play06:40

and

play06:41

bob is saying

play06:43

i hope we can do the haunted mansion

play06:45

ride

play06:46

he we can look at this and go well it is

play06:49

an outward manifestation

play06:52

uh but it's not of an intention

play06:56

to act or not act in a perfect way in a

play06:59

particular way he's not making a

play07:00

commitment right he's using the word i

play07:02

hope this is something we can do he's

play07:04

not saying we will do this or i promise

play07:07

that we will ride the haunted mansion

play07:10

ride he's he's not doing that so here

play07:15

that the third element wouldn't be

play07:17

satisfied but the thing to understand

play07:19

about this third element of so made as

play07:23

to justify a promisee and understanding

play07:26

that a commitment has been made is that

play07:28

we're asking how would a reasonable

play07:32

person in the shoes of the promise see

play07:35

hear barb

play07:36

would they understand this expression

play07:39

from bob would they understand that a

play07:42

commitment has been

play07:45

made and here the answer is no because

play07:47

of the word that he's using and just a

play07:50

second we'll say well how exactly we do

play07:52

we determine that

play07:54

so the thing to know just right here is

play07:58

we're not looking at what bob in his

play08:00

head thinks that he's saying right that

play08:03

would be subjective but we would say how

play08:06

would this be received by the promised c

play08:10

a reasonable person in the shoes of the

play08:12

promisee

play08:14

and here we can pretty it

play08:16

fairly say that using the word hope

play08:19

means he's not committing to do a

play08:21

particular thing

play08:24

so if though bob says something like

play08:26

this

play08:27

i swear that we will not dress up as

play08:30

mickey and minnie this time

play08:32

now he's using a word here that is not

play08:36

just i hope right some sort of up in the

play08:39

air word but the the reasonable person

play08:42

in the shoes of the promisee barb would

play08:45

think oh based on the word that he's

play08:48

used that he's committing here to not do

play08:52

something in particular which is

play08:55

we will not dress up as mickey and

play08:57

minnie this time so he's made a

play09:00

commitment here

play09:01

that this is something that they will

play09:03

not do so that third element would be

play09:06

satisfied but the question that we've

play09:09

been touching on is well how exactly do

play09:12

we know that

play09:14

about what bob is intending it about

play09:17

whether he's intending to make a

play09:19

commitment or not and there are three

play09:22

sort of basic tools that we use

play09:25

when we are trying to decide whether or

play09:29

not a reasonable person in the shoes of

play09:31

the promisee

play09:33

would interpret bob's manifestation

play09:37

as a commitment

play09:40

whether we can look at it and say yes he

play09:42

has made a manifestation of an intent to

play09:45

act or not act in a specified way

play09:48

and

play09:48

these are tools that we will use

play09:50

interpretive tools that we'll come back

play09:53

to

play09:54

later as we progress through

play09:56

this material regarding contracts

play10:00

but here in this introductory lesson

play10:02

it's important to at least lay some

play10:04

general groundwork and say that when we

play10:07

are trying to decide

play10:09

whether somebody like bob the promisor

play10:12

is intending to make a commitment and

play10:15

how that should be understood then we

play10:17

need to use some basic tools of an

play10:19

interpretation to determine what his

play10:22

intent is and so we'll start by saying

play10:24

we're going to give his words their

play10:25

ordinary meaning and so when we look at

play10:29

him saying something like i swear that

play10:32

we will not dress up as mickey and

play10:33

minnie this time we would look at the

play10:35

word swear and say well what's the

play10:37

ordinary meaning of that is which means

play10:41

to promise you will do something or

play10:44

behave in a particular way

play10:46

that's the ordinary meaning of i swear

play10:48

that this is what we will do or won't do

play10:51

and so we would say well the ordinary

play10:53

meaning leads us to believe that he is

play10:57

making a commitment here when he says i

play11:00

swear we will not dress up as mickey and

play11:02

minnie this time

play11:03

and if there's a technical word that

play11:07

we give it its technical meaning so for

play11:10

instance

play11:11

if bob says to barb i guarantee

play11:15

we will have an extra magic hour each

play11:18

day

play11:19

then the word extra magic hour is a term

play11:24

of art that it has a technical meaning

play11:27

just giving those words their ordinary

play11:30

meaning if we go to the dictionary it's

play11:32

not going to help us

play11:34

that that's not going to tell us what is

play11:36

meant here by bob it's we need to look

play11:39

and say well what does that mean in this

play11:43

particular context of going to a disney

play11:46

resort and staying there and going to a

play11:48

park like the magic kingdom

play11:51

what does that mean

play11:53

well what it means is that if you stay

play11:56

at the resort you get an hour either

play11:58

before or after the close of park

play12:01

to as a benefit of staying at the resort

play12:04

you get this extra time where presumably

play12:07

it's a little less crowded you get to

play12:09

enjoy uh disney world in in a context at

play12:13

least for a little while where there's a

play12:14

few less people around

play12:16

so if we give it its technical meaning

play12:18

we can understand what he's saying there

play12:21

that yes he's intending to make a

play12:22

commitment that

play12:24

we're going to

play12:27

stay somewhere that's going to allow us

play12:29

to have this extra hour each day

play12:33

so again he would be making a promise we

play12:36

know that because here we would give the

play12:38

words their ordinary meaning but if

play12:40

there's a technical term like magic hour

play12:42

extra magic hour then we would use the

play12:46

technical meaning for that phrase the

play12:48

other thing to know is sometimes we need

play12:51

to look at all the surrounding

play12:53

circumstances in order to understand

play12:56

what somebody intends so if we're trying

play12:58

to interpret something objectively then

play13:01

we need to account not only for the

play13:03

ordinary meaning of words used in their

play13:05

ordinary sense and the technical meaning

play13:08

of words used in their technical sense

play13:10

but also look at all the surrounding

play13:12

circumstances

play13:14

to understand what was meant here by the

play13:17

promissor and so if we have a situation

play13:21

where bob says oh don't you worry barb

play13:24

we will put the magic and magic kingdom

play13:26

if you know what i mean

play13:28

well

play13:29

it giving those words their ordinary

play13:31

meaning doesn't really help us right and

play13:33

it's not really a technical word but we

play13:36

can look at this and say well if we know

play13:40

all the surrounding circumstance that

play13:42

they're going away on this trip that

play13:44

they're a couple then we can look and go

play13:47

oh what bob is promising there is a

play13:51

romantic time with barb and so we can

play13:54

say yes he is committing to have a

play13:57

romantic time with his uh with his

play14:01

partner barb so we can understand that

play14:05

because we can look at all the

play14:06

surrounding circumstances so

play14:09

if we just to back up a second then we

play14:12

can look back and say in order for us to

play14:14

interpret and to understand

play14:18

whether or not somebody in the shoes of

play14:20

the promise see

play14:22

should understand the promissor as

play14:25

having made a commitment

play14:27

we would need to say well what how do we

play14:29

understand the ordinary meaning of the

play14:32

words used in their ordinary sense the

play14:34

tactical meaning of the words used in

play14:35

their technical sense and all the

play14:38

surrounding circumstances

play14:40

and only then

play14:42

can we answer that question

play14:45

of

play14:46

was there a commitment made is that last

play14:49

element of the promise met well now

play14:51

let's look at the method of making a

play14:54

promise how may a promise be made and

play14:57

here we have again a definition or a

play15:00

rule that says a promise may be stated

play15:02

in words either spoken or written or may

play15:05

be inferred wholly or partly from

play15:07

conduct again we want to chunk something

play15:10

up into its elements when we have a

play15:13

definition like that so we can say one

play15:16

that a promise can be what it can be

play15:19

either spoken or to written

play15:22

or it may be inferred from

play15:24

conduct so let's look at each of those

play15:28

in turn with these three methods said

play15:30

there could be spoken words there could

play15:32

be written words or we can infer it can

play15:35

be inferred from conduct so looking at

play15:37

spoken words if bob says to barb i

play15:40

promise to take you to disney world over

play15:42

winter break that spoken word right

play15:45

that's one method of making a promise he

play15:48

is verbally or orally

play15:51

making his promise so that would work

play15:54

assuming all the elements of her promise

play15:56

are mad that we've covered

play15:59

then it could be written words bob could

play16:01

say dearest barb i promise to take you

play16:04

to disney world over winter break love

play16:06

always bob so it's just written word

play16:09

that works just as well for him to make

play16:12

a promise to barb

play16:14

then it could be inferred from conduct

play16:17

and in this situation that's a little

play16:18

tricky so if bob puts on his mouse ears

play16:23

here

play16:24

that could be him

play16:26

in depending on the surrounding

play16:28

circumstance that could be interpreted

play16:30

perhaps as him making some sort of

play16:32

promise but the normal kind of scenario

play16:35

you would think of here would be

play16:37

situations where

play16:39

the conduct can clearly be understood as

play16:42

making some sort of commitment so for

play16:44

instance if you're at a bar a noisy bar

play16:48

and having drinks with somebody and you

play16:50

raise your hand to get the bartender's

play16:52

attention and gesture something like two

play16:56

bring me two right just sit up

play16:59

stick your hand up with

play17:00

two fingers that would be a way of

play17:03

communicating

play17:04

to the bartender that

play17:06

i would like you to bring another round

play17:09

of drinks for us

play17:10

and

play17:11

i am committing implicitly by my conduct

play17:14

to pay for those drinks and so if the

play17:16

bartender may just nod saying yes i see

play17:19

you i'll send over the drinks and that

play17:22

would be

play17:23

a a set of promises implied by conduct

play17:27

inferred by the conduct here putting on

play17:29

the mouse ears may not be enough uh you

play17:32

would need at least some other

play17:34

surrounding circumstance perhaps if he

play17:36

had packed the car up and pulled the car

play17:39

up and ready to go and then he slapped

play17:41

on his mouse ears then all of that

play17:44

together might be enough to say yes he

play17:46

is committing at that moment to take

play17:49

barb on a romantic trip to disney world

play17:53

over winter break

play17:55

so how do we determine though whether a

play17:58

promise is legally enforceable because

play18:00

remember the first part of what we were

play18:03

looking at was just what is a promise

play18:05

looking at the anatomy of a promise but

play18:07

we said when we looked at our definition

play18:10

of a promise that not only is a contract

play18:12

a promise or a set of promises but it's

play18:16

a set of promises for which either the

play18:19

law is going to provide a remedy

play18:22

or it's recognizing some sort of legal

play18:25

duty meaning that people make promises

play18:28

all the time

play18:30

but not every promise is legally

play18:33

enforceable just because for instance

play18:36

you promise you're going to take

play18:37

somebody to dinner and invite them over

play18:39

your house and you don't doesn't mean

play18:41

that person can run into court and sue

play18:44

you

play18:45

to say well

play18:46

tracy said he would take me

play18:48

out to dinner and he didn't do it or he

play18:51

would have me over his house to play

play18:52

board games and he never did

play18:55

that not every promise creates a legal

play18:59

duty

play19:00

or is something for which the law says

play19:03

if tracy doesn't invite you over to for

play19:06

dinner or doesn't invite you over for

play19:08

board games that the law is going to

play19:10

recognize some sort of remedy for that

play19:12

that you're going to get money damages

play19:14

or some sort of order that tracy must

play19:17

have you over

play19:18

those kinds of things

play19:20

which would be a remedy so not every

play19:23

promise is legally enforceable and that

play19:25

makes good sense but certainly some

play19:28

promises need to be legally enforceable

play19:30

particularly for instance in a

play19:31

commercial context or a business context

play19:34

so how do we know whether something's

play19:37

legally enforceable and the key issue

play19:39

here of knowing whether the law is going

play19:41

to recognize a duty

play19:43

or recognize a remedy and often both

play19:47

is that

play19:48

we need to know is the promise

play19:51

contractual or

play19:53

gratuitous

play19:55

contractual or gratuitous so what do we

play19:58

mean by a contractual promise well

play20:00

contractual promises are those that are

play20:03

legally enforceable so now we're doing

play20:06

that some sorting right where we're

play20:08

saying

play20:09

contractual promises are legally

play20:11

enforceable but gratuitous are not so

play20:14

just like we established that well of

play20:17

course not every promise should allow

play20:20

somebody to run an accord and sue to

play20:23

enforce it because a otherwise the the

play20:26

courts would be ridiculously overrun

play20:28

with people suing and b that you know

play20:32

that would create a very litigious

play20:33

society that we don't want and people

play20:35

make commitments all the time for which

play20:38

we do not

play20:40

allow them to run into court to enforce

play20:42

it to get a remedy etc

play20:45

but we need to know how do we decide

play20:49

which ones the law should recognize a

play20:51

remedy should say there is a legal duty

play20:55

not just a moral duty to follow through

play20:57

in what you commit but an actual legal

play20:59

duty so it's legally enforceable and the

play21:02

way we do that sorting is to say well

play21:05

those promises that are contractual

play21:08

are legally enforceable those that are

play21:10

merely gratuitous as a general rule are

play21:13

not legally enforceable i have an

play21:15

asterisk there because there are often

play21:17

other ways that a gratuitous promise

play21:20

could be legally enforceable and we'll

play21:23

look at those as we progress through all

play21:25

the contracts material

play21:28

so what do we mean by a contractual

play21:31

promise and this is something for which

play21:34

we are going to say a whole lot more but

play21:37

just as an introductory matter it's a

play21:39

situation where the promise is part of

play21:42

an exchange that the promise is made in

play21:46

return for something else usually a

play21:50

return promise or return performance

play21:54

and it's okay if that doesn't make total

play21:56

sense right now it will moving forward

play22:00

so let's look at a quick example here

play22:02

with bob and barb if bob says to barb

play22:05

if you earn an a in contracts i will

play22:08

take you to disney world over winter

play22:10

break he's now not only making a

play22:13

commitment right i will take you to

play22:15

disney world over winter break he's

play22:16

actually looking for an exchange

play22:18

something in return so barb says

play22:22

sounds good

play22:24

i will earn an a in contracts this

play22:26

semester so barb is making a return

play22:30

promise a return commitment

play22:32

so we have a

play22:34

an exchange of promise right a promises

play22:37

it's a set of promises so when bob is

play22:41

making his promise he's getting a

play22:44

promise in return from barb and

play22:48

that return promise we'll see is known

play22:52

as consideration you don't again don't

play22:56

need to fully understand that now

play22:58

but it will make sense down the road but

play23:01

the thing to know

play23:02

is that a contractual promise is a

play23:06

promise for which there is either a

play23:09

return promise made as here from barb or

play23:12

a return performance is given

play23:16

and we'll explain exactly what that

play23:18

means in more detail later but for now

play23:21

it's enough to say it's part of an

play23:24

exchange and so this promise for a

play23:27

promise this return promise is known as

play23:30

consideration in this context and so

play23:34

it's part of a contract right because we

play23:37

said that a contract is a set of

play23:39

promises

play23:40

and we've uh been unpacking this over

play23:44

and over in this definition so it's

play23:47

probably self-evident to call a promise

play23:50

contractual that it's got to be part of

play23:53

a contract and so it's got to fall

play23:56

within these three things right that the

play23:58

promise

play23:59

it or set of promises is one for which

play24:01

the law recognizes a duty to perform as

play24:04

we've been saying and it gives a remedy

play24:07

for breach and we'll say much more about

play24:11

that but the key thing to recognize is

play24:14

it's part of an exchange right an

play24:16

agreement like we looked at with bob and

play24:19

barb that bob is saying i will take you

play24:22

to disney world over winter break if you

play24:24

get an a and

play24:26

barb is agreeing yes i promise i will

play24:29

earn an a and contract this semester so

play24:32

they've come to an agreement

play24:34

so we would say that bob's promise is

play24:36

contractual in nature but a gratuitous

play24:40

promise we said is not legally

play24:43

enforceable

play24:44

because why it's not part of an exchange

play24:48

it's what we call a naked or gratuitous

play24:52

promise

play24:54

and so when bob says

play24:57

i promise to take you to disney world

play24:58

over winter break

play25:00

then he's made a promise and we've said

play25:02

that sort of over and over again

play25:05

but if that's

play25:06

all that's going on and barb is silent

play25:09

and recognize bob didn't say in this

play25:12

case if you earn an a he's not looking

play25:14

for anything in return

play25:16

and barb is not

play25:18

it isn't there is nothing coming in in

play25:21

return then here we would say that is

play25:24

just a gratuitous promise

play25:27

it's not part of an exchange of promises

play25:30

or a promise for performance so it's

play25:33

merely gratuitous or a naked or a nude

play25:36

promise that we would say as a general

play25:39

rule is not legally enforceable

play25:43

so a promise for a gift whether that's a

play25:46

gift trip like this one in the example a

play25:49

gift trip to disney world or anything

play25:51

right i promise to give you a bicycle i

play25:53

promise to give you a book whatever it

play25:55

may be

play25:56

that that promise is

play25:59

if it's just for a gift it's made

play26:01

without any expectation of receiving

play26:04

anything in return and as a general rule

play26:07

is not legally enforceable

play26:10

so

play26:11

to set the stage here at the beginning

play26:15

i want to give you a quick look at an

play26:17

analytic framework which will organize

play26:20

all of the material

play26:22

in contracts under this subject of

play26:25

contracts so this contracts analytic

play26:28

framework we can look at and say all the

play26:31

way on the left is where we are now that

play26:34

we are under this heading of formation

play26:39

of so contract formation how do we form

play26:42

a contract what are the rules governing

play26:44

the formation of a contract and then

play26:47

we'll look at defenses

play26:49

to formation that

play26:51

things that may come up either during

play26:54

the formation of the contract or after

play26:57

the right after the formation of a

play26:59

contract

play27:00

that would

play27:01

either excuse

play27:03

the uh the performance of the parties or

play27:07

prevent the formation of the contract

play27:09

we'll look at issues of interpretation

play27:12

and implied terms we'll look at breach

play27:14

of the contract and

play27:16

related issues dealing with conditions

play27:19

and repudiation and then remedies which

play27:21

often is money but could be other things

play27:24

so our focus on the first part though is

play27:27

formation and in particular we've we're

play27:30

touching on this idea of consideration

play27:34

we've laid the building

play27:35

sort of the foundation here the basic

play27:38

building block of a contract looked at

play27:40

what a promise is and

play27:42

tried to distinguish between

play27:45

promises that the law recognizes is

play27:47

legally enforceable

play27:49

which are promises that are contractual

play27:51

in nature promises for which there is

play27:54

consideration given meaning a return

play27:57

promise or return performance

play27:59

and those promises that are not as a

play28:02

general matter legally enforceable

play28:04

because they're gratuitous or

play28:07

naked promises

play28:09

so

play28:10

i hope that's helpful to you as you're

play28:12

working your way through contract law

play28:15

thinking about these concepts obviously

play28:17

there's a lot more to delve into

play28:19

if this video was helpful to you i'd

play28:21

appreciate if you would like and

play28:23

subscribe

play28:24

so i will check in with you soon with

play28:27

another video thanks bye

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

相关标签
Contract LawLegal DefinitionsPromise AnalysisConsiderationEnforceable PromisesLegal DutiesContractual ExchangeGratuitous PromisesDisney WorldLaw Education
您是否需要英文摘要?