K-Silver JH16 modules in depth

Summary

In this video, the host explores the K Silver jh16 modules used in various gaming controllers, highlighting their cost-effectiveness and performance. They compare these modules to cheaper alternatives like the favor Union sticks and the more durable TX switches. The discussion covers controllers from brands like Turtle Beach, Victrix Gambit, and BFG, noting the differences in build quality and materials. The video also delves into the internal mechanisms of these controllers, comparing spring types and the impact on longevity and precision. The host shares their personal experience with controllers using jh16 modules, emphasizing their impressive performance despite the initial skepticism about their use in high-end controllers.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video discusses various thumbstick modules used in gaming controllers, focusing on K Silver's JH16 modules.
• 🔧 Cheaper controllers often use lower-quality thumbsticks with 1 million rotations and switches rated for 100,000 presses.
• 💷 High-end controllers like the Fusion Pro 3 and Nonon Revolution X use standard AlPS thumbsticks for better durability.
• 🔄 Victorix Gambit and BFG controllers use higher-rated modules with 2 million rotations and 1 million button presses.
• 🔩 The Thrust Master CNK modules offer variable spring strengths, providing customization not available with other brands.
• 🧲 K Silver's JH16 modules boast 5 million cycles of service life and use permanent magnets for high-temperature resistance and zero drift.
• 🛠️ The internal construction of thumbsticks varies, with cheaper models using a platform and spring system versus higher-end models with a more robust spring and shaft design.
• 🎮 Snake Bite Hair's GamePad RGB controller surprisingly uses the same K Silver JH16 modules found in much more expensive controllers.
• 📊 The video compares the resolution and performance of different controllers using JH16 modules, with some showing high resolution and others lower.
• 🔩 The video script suggests that the JH16 modules' performance is reliable, even with added weight from accessories like Control Freaks.
• ❓ The video ends with a call for viewer feedback on the longevity and performance of JH16 modules in controllers with extensive use.

Q & A

What types of controllers are using K Silver's JH16 modules?

Controllers like the GamePad RGB by Snake Bite Hair, Nikon Revolution 5 Pro, and Turtle Beach Recon are using K Silver's JH16 modules.

What is the rating of the Hall effect thumbsticks used in cheaper controllers?

The Hall effect thumbsticks used in cheaper controllers are rated for only 1 million rotations and the TX switch is rated for 100,000 presses.

How do the Victorix Gambit controllers differ in terms of thumbstick modules?

The Victorix Gambit controllers use higher module thumbsticks rated for 2 million rotations and a million button presses, which is a significant upgrade from cheaper controllers.

What unique feature does Thrustmaster's CNK module offer that sets it apart?

Thrustmaster's CNK modules offer the ability to choose different spring strengths, providing a customizable rotational force for the thumbsticks, which is not offered by Favor Union.

What is the claim made by Kilver about their JH16 thumbsticks regarding service life?

Kilver claims that their JH16 thumbsticks have a service life of up to 5 million cycles, which is a significant claim compared to other thumbsticks on the market.

What is the difference in construction between cheaper thumbsticks and higher quality ones?

Cheaper thumbsticks have a spring under a platform holding the housing against the shell, while higher quality ones have a larger diameter spring and metal parts, as opposed to the plastic parts found in cheaper modules.

Why might Kilver not have given a life rating for the TX switch used inside the controller?

Kilver might not have given a life rating for the TX switch because they may have decided that the 5 million cycle rating for the thumbstick is the failure point, and they haven't provided a separate life rating for the metal conductive dome inside the stick.

How do the JH16 modules perform in terms of longevity and slop after extensive use?

After extensive use, including over 150 hours of game time, the JH16 modules maintain good performance with minimal slop, even when used with additional weight from accessories like Control Freaks.

What is the reviewer's opinion on the use of JH16 modules in more expensive controllers?

The reviewer believes that the use of JH16 modules in more expensive controllers is justified due to the high rotation claim and the engineering seen in the modules, which suggests they will hold up well over time.

What feature is the reviewer hoping to see implemented in future controllers?

The reviewer hopes that future controllers will implement a true zero dead zone option, as they believe a Pro Controller should not have any dead zones.

Outlines

00:00

🎮 Controller Module Comparison

The paragraph discusses the various joystick modules used in different gaming controllers, focusing on their quality and price points. It starts with the cheaper controllers that use favor Union sticks with a 1 million rotation rating and a TX switch rated for 100,000 presses. The video then contrasts these with higher-end controllers like the Fusion Pro 3 and nonon Revolution X, which use standard Al sticks. The Victrix Gambit and BFG controllers are highlighted for using higher-rated modules with 2 million rotations and a million button presses. The paragraph also introduces the cnk modules, which offer variable spring strengths, a feature not commonly found in favor Union sticks. The discussion concludes with the Kilver jh16 modules, which claim high precision, no drift, and a service life of up to 5 million cycles, with a focus on the permanent magnets' resistance to high temperatures and no temperature drift.

05:02

🔩 Internals and Build Quality of Joystick Modules

This paragraph delves into the internal mechanisms and build quality of the joystick modules. It explains how cheaper modules have a different internal structure compared to higher-end ones, with the spring placement and materials used being key differentiators. The video script mentions that cheaper modules use metal parts and a different spring design, while higher-end modules transition to plastic parts and a larger diameter spring for better quality. The paragraph also discusses the TX switches found on the sides of the modules and how they are integrated differently across various brands. The Kilver jh16 modules are again highlighted, with a focus on their internal design, including the use of tiny magnets and a metal conductive dome for improved durability and performance.

10:04

🕹️ Performance and Longevity of Joystick Modules

The final paragraph discusses the performance and longevity of the Kilver jh16 modules in various controllers. It covers the user's experience with controllers using these modules, such as the GamePad RGB by Snake Bite Hair and the Nikon Revolution 5 Pro, and how they perform in terms of resolution and build quality. The paragraph also touches on the user's personal experience with the G7 SE controller, which has seen extensive use and shows promising durability. The video script invites viewers to share their experiences with controllers using the j16 modules, especially those used with additional thumb grips like Control Freaks. The discussion concludes with the user's positive outlook on the future of Hall of effect sticks and a call for viewer feedback to help inform other gamers.

Keywords

💡K Silver's JH16 modules

K Silver's JH16 modules refer to a specific type of joystick module used in gaming controllers. These modules are known for their high durability and precision, with a claim of supporting up to 5 million rotations. In the video, the presenter discusses how these modules are being used in a variety of controllers, from affordable to high-end, indicating a trend in the gaming industry towards using higher quality components even in budget-friendly devices.

💡Favor Union sticks

Favor Union sticks are another type of joystick module mentioned in the video, which are rated for 1 million rotations and are used in cheaper controllers. The video compares these sticks with the more robust JH16 modules, highlighting a difference in quality and expected lifespan. The mention of Favor Union sticks helps to establish a baseline for what is considered standard in the market, especially for more affordable gaming controllers.

💡TX switch

The TX switch is a component within the joystick module that is rated for a certain number of presses. In the video, it is noted that the TX switch used in cheaper controllers is rated for only 100,000 presses, which is a lower rating compared to other switches. This detail is important as it indicates the potential longevity and reliability of the controllers, with the TX switch being a critical factor in the overall durability of the joystick.

💡Hall of effect sticks

Hall of effect sticks are a type of joystick that uses magnetic fields to detect movement, offering a non-contact feel and high precision. The video discusses how these sticks are becoming more prevalent in gaming controllers, including those from K Silver, and are seen as a step up in technology from traditional potentiometer-based sticks. The presenter's exploration of Hall of effect sticks emphasizes the ongoing innovation in controller design for improved gaming experiences.

💡Gamers G7

The Gamers G7 is a specific gaming controller model mentioned in the video, which uses the JH16 modules. The controller is noted for its affordability despite using high-quality components, suggesting a value proposition for consumers. The inclusion of the Gamers G7 in the discussion serves to illustrate how even budget controllers can offer premium features, potentially changing consumer expectations for what is achievable in lower-priced gaming peripherals.

💡Resolution

In the context of gaming controllers, resolution refers to the sensitivity and precision of the joystick's movement detection. The video discusses how different controllers using the JH16 modules have varying levels of resolution, which can affect the player's control and the responsiveness of the game. The mention of resolution is crucial as it directly impacts the gameplay experience and is a key consideration for gamers when choosing a controller.

💡Zero Dead Zone

A 'Zero Dead Zone' feature in a gaming controller means that there is no area of the joystick's movement that is not detected, providing maximum precision. The video touches on the importance of this feature for professional gamers who require the highest level of control. The presenter expresses a desire for more controllers to implement true zero dead zones, indicating a trend towards more accurate and responsive gaming peripherals.

💡Thrust Master CNK modules

Thrust Master CNK modules are a type of joystick module that offers customization options, such as different spring strengths, which can affect the feel and responsiveness of the joystick. The video mentions that these modules are used in higher-end controllers and provide a different experience compared to the cheaper Favor Union sticks. The discussion of Thrust Master CNK modules highlights the variety of options available to manufacturers and gamers in terms of controller customization and performance.

💡Control Freaks

Control Freaks are add-ons for gaming controllers that can enhance the grip and control during gameplay. The video discusses the potential impact of these add-ons on the longevity and performance of the joystick modules, particularly in relation to the added weight and stress they may cause. The mention of Control Freaks is relevant as it considers external factors that can influence the performance and durability of gaming controllers.

💡Longevity

Longevity in the context of gaming controllers refers to the expected lifespan and durability of the device. The video explores the longevity of different joystick modules, such as the JH16 modules, by discussing their rated rotations and button presses. The concept of longevity is central to the video as it addresses the value and reliability of controllers, especially when comparing cheaper models with those that use higher-quality components.

Highlights

K Silver's jh16 modules are used in cheaper, licensed controllers like the enhanced by power a hair and the PDP rematch.

Turtle Beach Recon controllers also use the cheaper favor Union sticks rated for only 1 million rotations.

The TX switch used in these controllers is rated for a minimum of 100,000 presses.

Higher-end controllers like the Fusion Pro 3 use standard Alps sticks.

Victrix Gambit uses favor Union's higher module rated for 2 million rotations and a million button presses.

BFG controllers and Thrust Master use sticks with different spring strengths, a feature not offered by favor Union.

Cheaper controllers under $50 with back buttons typically have cheap sticks.

The Gamer G7 is the cheapest controller with two back buttons using the higher-quality Alps sticks.

Kilver claims their sticks offer no drift, high precision, long life, and a non-contact feel.

Kilver's j16 modules have a service life of up to 500 million cycles.

The internal structure of cheaper modules differs from higher-quality ones, affecting durability and performance.

The K Silver sticks are used in affordable controllers like the GamePad RGB by Snake Bite Air.

The Nikon Revolution 5 Pro is one of the most expensive controllers using K Silver sticks.

The Ultra controller using K Silver modules has the lowest resolution among the tested controllers.

The G7 SE by Turtle Beach, using K Silver modules, has performed well over 150 hours of game time.

The future of Hall of effect sticks looks bright, with improvements in performance and true zero Dead Zone options.

The video creator encourages viewers to share their experiences with controllers using j16 modules.

Transcripts

hey everyone it's a photot I hope you're

all doing well today's video is on K

Silver's jh16 modules so all the cheaper

license controllers like the enhanced by

power a hair and uh the PDP rematch and

to my surprise even the Turtle Beach

Recon these are using the cheaper favor

Union sticks uh which are rated for only

1 million rotation and that TX switch

that they use is only rated for a

100,000 press as a minimum sort of

rating it's only when you get up to

something like the Fusion Pro 3 that

uses the standard Els sticks or the

nonon revolution x uh again these are

using the standard Al sticks so these

are around $100 $80 to $100 or £ 88,200

here in UK uh but that's basically the

that's the norm has been that the

cheaper controllers under 50 with back

buttons they have cheap sticks and it's

only when you really move up that you

get like you know the better sticks

victrix Gambit is a little bit different

cuz the this one is

using the favor unions higher module so

these are rated for 2 million rotations

and a million button presses so uh

Victor gambade and then we have uh the

BFG controllers they are using these

sticks as well and uh another stick that

I've come across is the thrust Master

the cnk modules now cnk modules I've

mentioned this in the past if you go

online they will tell you that they have

2 million rotations 1 million button

presses but one extra thing the cnk are

doing they're giving you the ability to

basically have a different spring

strength so you can have a different

sort of like rotational force sort of

sticks uh that you can order which is

something that favor union doesn't do on

their order forms for uh their sticks

but thrustmaster is getting from cnk

I've opened them and I've seen the cnk

logo cnk is offering um that option so

all the cheaper controllers are using

these cheap favor Union Saks like I said

only 100,000 presses and they say that

you can order between 1 million and 2

million Cycles but I doubt that

anybody's ordering 2 million Cycles

because these controllers are so cheap

they're probably going for the cheapest

one and the elps like I said you'd have

to either buy a standard controller that

uses the El sticks uh or you have to um

uh move up uh in price to get the

standard l sticks uh you have to get to

the Fusion Pro 3 or you have to get up

to the neon Revolution x uh that's why I

think some of the Chinese manufacturers

they make a point of mentioning the L

sticks used because they are of higher

quality compared to the cheaper ones

also the cheapest controller with two

back buttons that is using the elf

sticks is the gamer G7 the standard G7

so kilver are saying that their sticks

if you basically Translate the text on

their website um they're saying that no

drift High Precision long life and

they're saying zero way um eliminat

drifts the non contact feel is smoother

which yeah I think most of us have

experienced with a j16 The Rocker has a

service life of up to 500 W I think this

is where um gamer have used this and

they they mentioning 5 million Cycles

minimum like you know 5 million minimum

cycles of the sticks and I think that's

to do with the spring and the rocket

that's use is not this the the magnets

because they say and the permanent

magnets are resistant to high

temperature and have no temperature

drift so big claims here uh and uh it's

um they are not giving kilver are not

giving any rating for the TX switch

that's being used inside the controller

and um I have a feeling why they've done

that when I show the internals I'll talk

a bit more about it but yeah they say 5

million Cycles so there is a failure

point and it's a 5 million Cycles

they're mentioning it so it's like more

than double what elps and the higher

favor Union sticks are claiming so here

I have um an L STI well it says is an L6

I doubt it because I bought this off

Amazon um so but it's basically made on

the L STI modules and is supposed to be

identical how uh they work and um we

have you know those normal two potenti

reports inside basically so that's the

base what we have is we have a shaft

that goes inside this resin you know the

shaft that's actually going in the

plastic U sort of thumb stick the spring

is actually inserted inside this

basically so when you are rotating it

this is the it's the spring that brings

uh it back to Center so the spring is uh

essentially sitting in the middle inside

the stick itself these cheaper modules

work a little bit differently they

actually have a spring under a platform

that holds the whole housing against

that shell so the spring is not in a

shaft or anything like you know the

shaft is separa thing it's underneath a

platform that is

holding the the metal um part that's

going in the

potentiometers so it's here it's

basically sits on top of it and uh so

the reentering spring in the cheaper

favor Union ones also is the same thing

in the higher quality ones that are used

by the

cnk uh and um and and and the victrix

Gambit and BFG it sort of like pushes it

up so the spring is underneath is much

uh bigger in diameter if you see look at

that uh compared to the elps ones and um

it's uh in the cheaper controllers the

parts are metal uh the cheaper sticks

and if you go to the higher stick

modules uh the spring changes and the

parts are uh made of plastic so this is

one of the broken modules I bought of

eBay uh it's the cnk ones so for the

thrustmaster and it's the same thing so

the plastic sort of shaft uh and you

have these two holders that sort of like

you know they move the um potentiometers

they sit on this platform and the spring

is underneath but the spring in these

higher modules definitely of better

quality uh than the ones used in the

cheaper module so that's one thing

that's quite apparent when we look at

the spring using the higher modules

compared to the ones in the cheaper ones

now the elps also the cnk the favor

Union and even the cheaper favor Union

they have TX switches on the sides uh

that sort of like you know the housing

has to have a sort of plastic tab coming

out to be able to press them uh but they

are their individual units there like

full they have their contact points they

have to be solded onto the board and

stuff uh but they are separately on the

side now let's let's quickly take a look

at the K silver ones here is the K

silver stick and you can see those two

tiny magnets are held in place inside

the plastic housing and then we have

this little tiny tab here this is

basically used to when you push it in

this is pressing the metal conductive

dome instead of the whole tag switch on

the base plate which we'll look at next

and then the shaft inside is holding the

spring in so here are the sensors on the

base one is here one is there for the

magnets to basically this one reads all

all their output and stuff and this is

the tag switch it's a metal conductive

Dome it's actually not a full tag switch

it's just the innard of a tack switch

and the little plastic tab I showed

basically pushes that in what I really

like is they've used this um film on top

of it so it's not actually metal pushing

against uh the plastic resin whatever

that is so it's not going to wear out uh

they've actually thought about that and

yeah so the contact Point has a covering

on it and uh I guess this is the reason

they haven't given a life rating to it

maybe is it 5 million whatever they've

decided that when they press it that's

what they got so they haven't given a

separate life rating to the metal

conductive Dome uh inside uh the stick

but the sticks are very easy to open and

close and the only one I was able to

actually open and close without damaging

it uh the jh16 modules so that say

something about them Kil j16

spring cnk and FV unions highes stick

module that's the spring the cheaper

sticks found in the cheap controllers

that's the spring from them and then the

elves sticks copy that I got of the eBay

that's the size of the spring there all

right once more we have the kver h16 the

highest favor unit modules the cheapest

ones and then the elves and they have

their Springs basically assembled this

is how internally these are

assembled so the K silver sticks are

being used in really affordable

controllers like the GamePad RGB by

snake bite hair which is absolutely

amazing I can't believe that they've

brought the same sticks that are being

used in like five times more expensive

controllers to this price point so I do

think snake bite is doing something very

unique uh when it comes to uh their

affordable controllers um the RGB and uh

even the pro model uh that's absolutely

amazing that they using the same kilver

j16 modules at first I was a little bit

worried that people you know the cheaper

controllers are using that but after

seeing the stick I think snake bu is

doing an amazing job of bringing these

at the most affordable price Nikon

Revolution 5 Pro is like my most

expensive controller that's using the K

silver sticks it's 008 in UK when I got

it it was like 210 something that I paid

but

different implementation same Stakes but

they have a lot more software options

and uh this is probably the highest yeah

this is definitely the highest

resolution that I've seen uh cuz every

increment is like 3.4 depending on what

shaft insert you are using so um higher

resolution than any other controller

that I've seen but yeah this is the most

expensive one and it's using the cas

stakes and the modules are heavier

because they have metal shafts and the

top is heavy and stuff so we'll see uh

what happens with it in terms of

longevity but yeah so very expensive

controller using the same six stealth

Ultra again using the Kil j16 modules

this one has the lowest resolution I

made a video on it uh you can check it

out but performance- wise again really

good and um this one I would say has

about 50 hours of game time so this I I

I'm going to keep on playing with my G7

SE for the longevity but yet

performance- wise uh with the low

resolution how they've implemented

Turtle Beach yeah this is performing

really well as well my G7 SE has the

most game time at least over 150 hours

now and I am actually uh playing a lot

more with it because I want to see what

the failure point is going to be cuz I

use Control Freaks and I am really

interested to see what happens with that

little spring with the added weight of

control freaks while gaming so I would

like to ask you guys to definitely share

your experience and your thoughts um

especially what you feel like you do you

like the j16 modules are you thinking

that uh it's a mistake for these sticks

to be used in the more expensive

controllers personally speaking for me

after opening them and seeing how

they've been engineered I'm okay I think

I I can see a reason why uh the

manufacturers like nonon and Turtle

Beach decided to go with K Sila uh

because that 5 million rotation claim

that they are making I think it will

hold true cuz I have serious amount of

game time like I said on my G7 SE with

Control Freaks and the sticks are the

slop is actually really good uh

considering what I have with controllers

that have a similar amount of game times

like using a different uh sticks I do

think these sticks are not comparable

like they are not one to one apparity

with a really good implementation of

elps or the favor Union or cnk sticks I

think thrust Master is doing amazing

things with the resolution and how they

have those cnk modules uh calibrated and

stuff but I do think that we can get

there especially now we getting true

zero Dead Zone options uh from a lot of

Manufacturers turtle be still lacking

and I do hope that they Implement a true

zero Dead Zone option as well cuz it's

getting to a point where I don't think

it's a Pro Controller if it has any dead

zones I'll make a separate video on that

talking especially about the bug that

happened to me in the Modern Warfare 3

now it's happened four times now uh but

yeah that's a separate video so I do

think uh the future is definitely bright

for Hall of effect Stakes cuz initially

went this I made a review of the G7 SEI

mentioned that I felt it was very

sluggish uh but yeah no they are

performing well and like I said I would

like to know your thoughts your

experiences and what do you think

especially if you have a controller with

a lot of game time with the J 16 and if

you were using control fix or any other

thumb grip or whatever you know that

adds weight I'm very interested to know

what's happened with your Stakes how

much is the slop what do you think and

what are your thoughts so not only going

to help me out it will help a lot of

other Gamers out as well and once again

guys thank you so much for everyone who

subscribed your support me means a lot

and I hope this video was um you know

had some useful information in there it

was definitely interesting for me thank

you so much for watching it hopefully

I'll catch you in one of my other videos

bye for

now