Wife asks 6,16,300/ month From Husband , HC Judge Shocked, #lawchakra #legal

Summary

In a legal dispute over maintenance expenses, the court scrutinizes the wife's claim for a monthly allowance of 6 lakh 16,300 rupees, questioning its necessity given her husband's income and her actual needs. The judge emphasizes the importance of presenting realistic figures and warns against exploiting the court process. Both parties are instructed to submit accurate financial details and the wife's legitimate expenses for reconsideration, highlighting the court's focus on fairness and substantiated claims.

Takeaways

• 📊 The petitioner is seeking a monthly maintenance of 6 lakh 16,300 rupees, which the respondent argues is excessive and unreasonable.
• 💼 The husband is believed to have an income of 10 crores, which is a significant factor in the wife's maintenance claim.
• 👚 The wife claims she needs the maintenance for expenses such as branded clothes, which are costly, and she is currently using old clothes.
• 💍 The wife also mentions expenses on accessories like bangles, chains, and other items, which she estimates at 15,000 rupees per month.
• 🏥 There are medical expenses involved, including treatment for knee joint pain, high fever, tension, and panic attacks, which require regular medication and therapy.
• 💊 The wife has alleged that the husband's negligent actions have prevented her from seeking proper medical treatment, contributing to her financial strain.
• 👶 The husband is accused of neglecting the children, leaving the wife to bear the responsibility and associated costs, which are not being considered in the maintenance claim.
• 🏫 The husband is said to be paying for the children's school and tuition fees but is not taking care of the children's needs, which is a point of contention.
• 📑 The court is requesting detailed documentation and actual figures of the wife's expenses, rather than large, unsubstantiated claims.
• 📝 The court has expressed concern about the exploitation of the legal process and the need for transparency and accuracy in the wife's financial claims.
• 🚫 The court is prepared to dismiss the application if the wife does not provide a reasonable and substantiated breakdown of her expenses.

Q & A

What is the primary subject of the court discussion in the transcript?

The primary subject of the court discussion is the determination of the maintenance amount that the wife should be granted based on her expenses and the husband's income.

What is the wife's claim regarding her monthly expenses?

The wife claims that her monthly expenses amount to 6 lakhs and 16,300 rupees, which she believes she requires for various needs including food, clothing, accessories, medical expenses, and more.

What is the husband's income according to the court's understanding?

The court understands that the husband has an income of 10 crores, which is a significant amount and is considered when determining the maintenance amount.

What does the court suggest regarding the wife's claim for maintenance?

The court suggests that the wife's claim for maintenance is excessively high and not justified based on her actual needs and the husband's income.

What is the court's stance on the wife's argument about her medical expenses?

The court acknowledges the wife's medical expenses but questions the high amount she claims, suggesting that she should provide actual figures and not exaggerated estimates.

What is the court's opinion on the wife's request for an amount without providing a detailed breakdown?

The court is not in favor of granting an amount without a detailed breakdown of expenses, emphasizing the need for the wife to present actual and reasonable figures.

What does the court instruct the wife to do regarding her expenses?

The court instructs the wife to file an affidavit with actual required expenses, and if they are indeed her actual expenses, the court will consider them in the next hearing.

What is the court's view on the wife's claim of having no responsibility for the family?

The court expresses surprise and disapproval of the wife's claim of having no responsibility for the family, stating that the maintenance should be reasonable and not a punishment for the husband.

What is the court's final instruction regarding the wife's maintenance claim?

The court's final instruction is for the wife to file an affidavit with actual expenses and for the husband to file documents with an affidavit serving the same on the wife's counsel, after which the court will pass orders.

What does the court imply about the wife's claim of having shares and bank statements?

The court implies skepticism towards the wife's claim of having shares and bank statements, suggesting that it may be an exploitation of the court process and instructs her to file an affidavit with the actual documents.

What is the court's concern about the wife's legal expenses?

The court is concerned about the wife's claim of 50,000 rupees per month for legal expenses, viewing it as another instance of inflating the figures and potentially exploiting the court process.