Eastern Philosophy vs Western Philosophy
Summary
TLDRThis script explores the philosophical differences between Eastern and Western thought, rooted in historical, geographical, and cultural contexts. It delves into the contrasting views of reality and progress, highlighting figures like Einstein and Tagore, and examining the impacts of climate, terrain, and agriculture on shaping these philosophies. The script contrasts Eastern emphasis on spirituality and acceptance with Western focus on materialism and change, reflecting on how these perspectives have influenced societal values and individual attitudes towards life.
Takeaways
- 📚 The conversation between Tagore and Einstein highlighted the fundamental difference in Eastern and Western perspectives on reality, with Einstein favoring objective reality and Tagore emphasizing subjective interpretation influenced by quantum physics.
- 🌏 Eastern and Western philosophies diverge in their approach to heroism, with Western heroes typically seeking to change the world and Eastern heroes focusing on self-improvement and acceptance of fate.
- 🏛 Western philosophy, rooted in ancient Greece and Rome, tends to be more pragmatic, valuing physical well-being, science, technology, and individualism.
- 🌄 Eastern philosophy, with its origins in Indian and Chinese civilizations, is more spiritual, community-oriented, and focused on mental well-being, happiness, and spirituality.
- 🛶 The geographical terrain and climate influenced the development of these philosophies, with Greek reliance on trade and navigation contrasting with Eastern reliance on agriculture and rivers.
- 🌾 The importance of farming in Eastern civilizations contributed to a fatalistic view of life, where people were more inclined to accept their circumstances and adapt to nature's cycles.
- 🚢 The Greek need for trade and navigation led to a more open-minded approach to ideas and a focus on rational discourse, which fostered the development of sophisticated sciences.
- 🏞 Eastern philosophies, like Taoism and Buddhism, promote a harmonious existence with nature and emphasize the interconnectedness of all living beings, unlike the Western view of humans as separate from the animal kingdom.
- 🧘♂️ Eastern practices such as yoga and martial arts were developed as means to strengthen the body and promote discipline, aligning with the Eastern focus on self-improvement and spiritual growth.
- 🏟 The Greeks' development of the Olympic Games reflects their warrior culture and the importance of physical strength and competition, in contrast to Eastern philosophies that often promote nonviolence and vegetarianism.
- 🔮 The core difference between Eastern and Western philosophies is the Western emphasis on linear progress and the Eastern view of cyclical existence, with the latter seeking balance and harmony rather than material advancement.
Q & A
What was the central theme of the conversation between Tagore and Einstein?
-The conversation between Tagore and Einstein centered on the idea of reality, truth, and beauty, with Einstein believing in an objective reality and Tagore insisting on the subjective interpretation of reality.
How does Eastern philosophy differ from Western philosophy in terms of its approach to reality?
-Eastern philosophy tends to be more spiritual and focuses on the subjective interpretation of reality, while Western philosophy is more pragmatic and oriented towards an objective understanding of reality.
What is the typical goal of a Western hero according to the script?
-A Western hero typically aims to change the world to make it better for themselves and those around them, often fighting evil to restore justice, peace, and correct the incorrect.
How does the Eastern hero's approach differ from that of the Western hero?
-Eastern heroes often focus on changing themselves, either by accepting their fate or retreating for contemplation, rather than trying to change the world around them.
What is the main distinction between Eastern and Western philosophies in terms of their focus?
-Eastern philosophy is mainly focused on mental well-being, happiness, spirituality, and community, while Western philosophy is focused on physical well-being, rational science, technology, materialism, and individualism.
How did the geographical terrain of ancient Greece influence its philosophy?
-The geographical terrain of ancient Greece, made up of islands and surrounded by water, facilitated trade and the exchange of ideas, promoting a more rational discourse and the development of sophisticated sciences.
What role did rivers play in shaping Eastern philosophy, particularly in China and India?
-Rivers in China and India brought fertile soil from the Himalayas, supporting a large population and self-sufficient agricultural economy. This reliance on rivers for sustenance influenced Eastern philosophy to be more about accepting one's fate and adapting to nature's cycles.
How does the script explain the difference in the perception of time between Eastern and Western philosophies?
-Western philosophy, influenced by the need for long-term planning due to trade and warfare, developed a linear perception of time, focusing on the future. Eastern philosophy, with its reliance on predictable seasonal patterns, is more cyclical and focused on the present.
What is the core doctrine of Buddhism as mentioned in the script?
-The core doctrine of Buddhism, as mentioned in the script, is that material comfort does not lead to long-term happiness, and it emphasizes seeking answers within oneself rather than externally.
How does Eastern philosophy view the concept of good and evil?
-Eastern philosophy, particularly through the concept of yin and yang in Taoism, views good and evil as coexisting within every person, and the goal is to maintain a balance between these forces rather than viewing them as separate entities.
What is the fundamental difference between Eastern and Western philosophies regarding progress?
-The fundamental difference is that Western philosophy believes in linear progress, constantly striving for improvement and perfection. Eastern philosophy, on the other hand, views life as cyclical, with less emphasis on material progress and more on finding balance and inner peace.
Outlines
📚 Eastern and Western Philosophies: A Comparative Insight
The first paragraph delves into the contrasting views of reality and truth between Indian poet Rabindranath Tagore and German scientist Albert Einstein. It highlights the Eastern emphasis on subjective reality and the Western inclination towards objective reality. The paragraph also contrasts the typical hero in Eastern and Western narratives, where the former seeks self-improvement while the latter aims to change the world. The philosophical underpinnings of Eastern spirituality and community versus Western materialism and individualism are discussed, with examples from literature and historical figures like Jesus and Buddha. The paragraph concludes with a brief mention of the influence of geography and climate on philosophical thought.
🌾 Agricultural and Trading Economies: Shaping Philosophical Outlooks
The second paragraph examines the impact of geography and climate on the development of Eastern and Western philosophies. It describes how the reliance on trade by ancient Greeks due to their less fertile land led to a more open exchange of ideas and the development of rational sciences. In contrast, the agricultural self-sufficiency of China and India, supported by rivers bringing fertile soil from the Himalayas, fostered a focus on spiritualism and acceptance of fate. The paragraph also discusses the importance of merchants and farmers in shaping the societies' values and the resulting philosophical outlooks, with the West valuing change and the East valuing adaptability and fatalism.
🏞️ The Influence of Environment on Eastern and Western Worldviews
The third paragraph continues the discussion on the influence of the environment by comparing the Greek reliance on sea navigation and trade with the Eastern reliance on rivers for agriculture. It explores how these differences led to distinct philosophical perspectives, with the West being more change-oriented and the East more fatalistic. The paragraph also touches on the spiritual practices of Buddhism and Taoism, which promote internal reflection and harmony with nature, in contrast to the Western approach of manipulating the environment through science and technology. The cultural practices, such as martial arts and yoga, are mentioned as ways to strengthen the body and promote nonviolence, which aligns with Eastern philosophies.
🌐 Philosophical Foundations: From Reality to Spiritualism and Materialism
The fourth paragraph concludes the script by summarizing the philosophical differences between the East and the West. It emphasizes the Western focus on rational scientific methods and the pursuit of material success, as opposed to the Eastern focus on spiritualism and the interconnectedness of all beings. The paragraph discusses the Western concept of linear progress and the Eastern concept of cyclical time, highlighting the contributions of Greek philosophers Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle to the Western progressive philosophy. It also contrasts the Western view of good and evil as separate entities with the Eastern view of coexisting good and evil within individuals. The paragraph ends by acknowledging the role of Eastern philosophy in providing inner peace in a materially comfortable world.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Reality
💡Subjective Interpretation
💡Quantum Physics
💡Eastern and Western Philosophy
💡Superheroes
💡Buddhism
💡Materialism
💡Rational Science
💡Geographical Influence
💡Cyclical Life
💡Individualism
Highlights
The conversation between Tagore and Einstein on reality, truth, and beauty, highlighting the difference between objective and subjective interpretations of reality.
Einstein's belief in an objective reality and Tagore's emphasis on the subjective interpretation influenced by quantum physics.
The philosophical distinction between Eastern and Western thought, with Eastern thought being more spiritual and Western thought more pragmatic.
The typical hero in the East seeks self-improvement, while the Western hero aims to change the world.
Western superheroes fight evil to restore justice, while Eastern heroes may accept fate or retreat for contemplation.
The contrast between Western philosophy's focus on change and Eastern philosophy's emphasis on acceptance of fate.
The influence of geography on philosophical development, with Greek reliance on trade and Eastern civilizations' reliance on rivers for fertile soil.
The importance of merchants in ancient Greece due to the need for trade, fostering a more open-minded and change-oriented society.
Eastern civilizations' self-sufficiency and reliance on agriculture, leading to a more fatalistic and spiritual approach to life.
The role of climate and seasons in shaping Eastern and Western philosophies, with Eastern philosophies being more cyclical and Western more linear.
The difference in the perception of time between Eastern and Western philosophies, with the West focusing on the future and the East on the present.
The spiritual focus of Eastern philosophy, with an emphasis on mental well-being and happiness, versus the material focus of Western philosophy.
The communal aspect of Eastern philosophy versus the individualistic nature of Western philosophy.
The concept of good and evil in Western philosophy as separate entities, contrasting with Eastern philosophy's view of good and evil as coexisting within individuals.
The cyclical notion of time and life in Eastern philosophy, as opposed to the linear progress believed by Western philosophy.
The impact of Eastern and Western philosophies on modern life, with Western advancements in technology improving physical comfort and Eastern philosophies offering inner peace.
Transcripts
in the 1930s there was an interesting
conversation between the greatest Indian
poet and philosopher tagor and the
greatest German scientist Einstein the
conversation centered on the idea of
reality truth and Beauty Einstein
believed in an objective reality outside
the human while tagore insisted on the
subjective interpretation of reality to
boil it down Einstein believed in the
old Theory physics solid matter existing
with or without humans while tagor was
alluding to the mysterious theory of
quantum physics that our perception or
observation of matter is never really
objective the conversation Illustrated
the differences in eastern and western
ways of thinking about reality one more
pragmatic while the other more spiritual
now let's look at the typical hero in
the east and west a western hero wants
to change the world to make it better
for himself and those around him while
an Eastern hero wants to change himself
Western superheroes fight evil to
restore Justice justice peace correct
the incorrect while Asian Heroes either
accept their fate or Retreat to a forest
for some contemplation Jesus perhaps the
greatest Western hero confronted
Injustice and paid for it with his own
life as sacrifice to can see manifested
in Harry Potter as well the Buddha the
founder of Buddhism however went to the
forest to change himself ly the founder
of taism retreated the mountains in
other words Western philosophy is about
change while Eastern philosophy is more
about accept in your fate a great
example of this in literature can be
seen in the novels of the Japanese
British Nobel prizewinning author Kazu
shuro his characters obey their fate and
rarely question their somewhat unfair
circumstances however a typical hero in
the west would rebel against their
circumstance to change the world
accepting one's fate or putting up with
an unfavorable environment is seen as a
sign of weakness in the west while those
same traits are seen as a sign of
strength in the east by the East my
focus is mainly old India China and
Japan so a western hero wants to change
the world while an Eastern hero wants to
change himself to adapt in today's world
East and West have come together a lot
because Western mode of production I.E
capitalism has taken over the world but
if you look closer it it deeper you see
a clear philosophical distinction and if
you go back in time the distinction
appears more clear why has is
philosophy's main focus been on mental
well-being happiness and spirituality
and Community while Western philosophy's
main focus has been physical well-being
rational science technology materialism
and individualism of course there's a
broad generalization as there are so
many philosophers on either side who are
exceptions to the rule but generally
speaking the main distinction is
spiritualism versus materialism
Community versus individualism so in
this video I'll look at some of the
answers but also give more detail about
the differences between eastern and
western philosophy does the climate
terrain and the soil have anything do
with it are Merchants more concerned
with materialism and Farmers more with
spirituality Wern philosophy as we know
has its roots in ancient Greece and
later in Rome the Greeks and Romans were
influenced by other civilizations such
as the Egyptians and the Babylonians but
there are very little or no written
records of an organized philosophy prior
to the Greeks Eastern philosophy has its
roots in Indian civilization and the
Chinese civilization if you look at
their geographies Greek is made up of
some islands between the Mediterranean
Sea and the Black Sea so large bodies of
water sandwiching the land areas so if
you want to move around all you need is
a boat and you could hop from Island to
Island this allows much smoother way to
move things around there's less friction
on water than land the ancient Greeks
heavily relied on imported food due to
its soil not being very fertile as a
result the Greeks relied on traits which
brought goods from Egypt Mesopotamia and
Central Europe and more but with this
commodity trade also came ideas and
knowledge so the region was a hub of
cultural scientific and technological
exchange this promoted a more rational
discourse which allowed the Greeks to
develop a more sophisticated science for
example ukids elements is the oldest
science book which I'm sure was
influenced by the Egyptians the
Babylonians and the Phoenicians
Pythagoras developed his mathematics
Aristotle studied all kinds of things
including animals in fact the first
Greek philosopher Talis was an olive
Merchant himself who based his
philosophy on water being the most
important thing in the world he famously
predicted that good weather I.E lots of
rain produced lots of Olives so he got
very rich so the Greeks relied on trade
which allowed exchanges of ideas and
practical Sciences Indian and Chinese
civilizations however are more centered
around rivers and mountains in other
words quite different from ancient
Greece India and China were blessed by
its many rivers that brought amazing
soil from the Himalayas so their
agricultural economy could sustain a
huge population and big cities making
China and India mostly self-sufficient
trade with other peoples was a plus but
not essential China's yellow and yangi
rivers and ancient India Indus and the
ganis rivers are all start in the snowy
mountains of Himalayas and Traverse
thousands of kilometers which bring the
fertile soil it's no surprise that both
India and China relied on a crop that is
incredibly water thirsty rice it's also
no surprise that sad Guru the greatest
Indian Guru in the world today has a
simple message save the soil because
soil and farming run really deep in
eastern philosophy so gree's
geographical terrain allowed trade to
flourish between various peoples and
cultures while ancient China and India
relied on their rivers to bring good
soil to them the Greeks had to seek food
from somewhere else while the Chinese
and Indians waited for their rivers to
bring food to them as a result from a
survival point of view for the Greeks
Merchants were the most important class
of people while in the East farmers were
the most important class of people since
Merchants are mobile while farmers are
stationary because you cannot carry
around your land these allow the Greeks
to be more open-minded to new ideas new
technology new Sciences Merchants are
also less attached to their ways
therefore easily follow the market or
commodity today you sell rice tomorrow
potato Farmers however have a harder
time to change and adapt quickly so
Western philosophy geared more towards
pragmatic Sciences while Eastern
philosophy geared more towards
spiritualism if Merchants don't like
something they change but if Farmers
don't get enough water they wait for The
Following Season or accept their fate
it's harder to leave your land and
migrate so Western philosophy is more
change oriented while Eastern philosophy
is more fatalistic and other words to
change
yourself climate also plays a role India
and China tend to be warmer throughout
there so it makes sense to be in here
and now which Buddhism teaches also
Seasons play a predictable pattern every
year and people live a more cyclical
life Monsoon comes every year Rivers
flooded specific time of the year in a
way it was very similar to the Egyptian
way of life around the River Nile of
course when you rely on a river you also
experience great famines but they come
every few years or decade the Greeks
navigate the Seas where you're for the
most part in control of where you're
going meanwhile Eastern civilizations
were centered around rivers on Rivers
your course is fixed the river takes you
where the river takes you as a result
Eastern philosophy is more fatalistic
the fate of humans animals and plants
are in the hands of the Same Rivers it
meant that they saw all living beings as
part of one big family so they didn't
put humans as being Outsiders or special
or above everybody else else in Hinduism
Buddhism and taism we are not only from
nature we are nature just like other
living being the Greeks however experien
colder winter so they had to source and
accumulate food for colder days since
they relied on trade Wars always
disrupted trade routs which meant you
had to Source your food from somewhere
else Merchants relied on peace time to
continue trade but they also benefited
from Wars as certain Commodities were
more sought after it is the old adage
War fuels the economy as monies moved
around faster than peace time since
things are pretty unpredictable the
Greeks had to think long term and
prepare not just for the cold winter but
for the future in case of warfare future
became the most important time not here
now but next month next year you
couldn't afford to be here now like a
Zen Buddhist so this long-term or linear
perception of time became the dominant
way of looking at the world among the
Greeks a famous example is Aristotle's
theological philosophy that everything
has a purpose usually a sing single
destination in the
future Western philosophy also through
an exchange with the Middle Eastern
religions like Judaism Christianity and
later Islam came to understand that
humans were separate from the Animal
Kingdom we are kicked out of the Garden
of Eden punished for our mistakes as a
result you try to compensate for your
past mistakes you want to correct the
incorrect what do you do you fight for
causes if you look at literature heroes
are often people who have sinned or made
terrible mistakes to redeem themselves
they fight Injustice one way to fight
for Injustice is to make other people's
life better often materially you study
the world you invent new technology to
make life easier for others Eastern
philosophers were not looking for
material Comfort but more for mental and
spiritual comfort Buddha and Lai left
the city and their spiritual Quest and
went to the mountains and forests
Solitude allows you to seek answers
inside you not on the outside even today
most Buddhist temples in India Japan and
China are located in the mountains and
forests away from the crowd so people
can get away from other people the core
doctrine of Buddhism is the material
Comfort doesn't make you happy in the
long run the Greeks however gathered in
the city to debate and dialogue like
Socrates who would walk around on the
streets of Athens asking people
questions While others establish schools
like Plato's Academy or Aristotle's Lum
Western philosophy relied on dialog and
exchange like Merchants do to flourish
learn and improve the West built
universities churches and schools in the
middle of town and Villages so everyone
could come not some remote temples that
nobody could go to in is philosophy you
don't force your will on nature to
control or change it but you try to flow
with nature since both India and Chinese
civilization were centered around Rivers
often River flow is seen as a Nature's
Way in which you don't resist or remove
obstacles in your way but move around
those obstacles in other words you
change yourself not the out outside
world a good example is Indian traffic
moves around an obstacle be it a cow or
an accident while in the west a small
accident on the road brings everything
to a halt so Eastern philosophy tells
you to be more fluid flexible like yoga
and less rigid but Western philosophy
realiz on manipulating nature through
Science and Technology to make life
easier for humans as a result we live in
a very comfortable period in history
millions of people couldn't survive to
adulthood but today child mortality is
its lowest in history people live long
longer healthier but this also has
negative consequences for other species
on Earth as the more comfortable we are
the harder it becomes for some other
species in some
areas Asians are an average physically
smaller than Europeans perhaps due to
genetic mutation or sexual selection or
possibly due to eating less protein as
Farmers rely on Rice which is a staple
diet in most of Asia how to cope with
poor diet martial arts in China and yoga
and India are used to strengthen and
discipline the body Eastern philosophy
Center on the body as a vehicle to get
to a higher place and this also means
Eastern philosophy is more about
avoiding conflict rather than
confronting others taism and Buddhism
and Hinduism promote nonviolence
vegetarianism although Trend in the west
today has been practiced in the East for
thousands of years ganism is an Indian
religion that promotes strict vegetarian
diet and Gandhi a pacifist himself
admired gism for that unlike Asians the
Greeks at a lot of bread which is four
times more protein Rich than rice since
the Greek states were constantly
fighting against one another as well as
the Persians they developed the Olympic
Games which was to train soldiers for
Wars it is no surprise that it was the
Greeks who made it all the way to India
through Alexander the Great while we
have no records of invading armies from
India or China going to Persia or the
Middle East it was the nomadic Mongols
who made it to Europe not the more
sophisticated civilization like the
Chinese and Indians and in fact the
Chinese built walls to Shield themselves
from the Mongols and India was ravaged
by a series of invasions by the Greeks
the Persians the Muslims the Mongols and
even the British why Eastern philosophy
is less centered on Conquering the world
but conquering yourself for example
Buddhism is Center on the inner conflict
of fighting or resisting your own
desires if you focus on your inner
conflict you're less likely to engage in
an external physical conflict such as
tribal or ideological and Hindu Yogi
teaching your soul is the real you while
your physical body is acquired through
food you put in your mouth not just that
you also acquire your ego or the sense
of self through Impressions and
experiences with others so your soul is
permanent and your body and ego are
temporary fleeting and acquired now
Einstein versus tago conversation on the
nature of reality makes sense Einstein
sees an external World why tagor ises
everything internal in other words Yogi
philosophy is based on the pursuit of
becoming one with the universe quantum
physics has a similar theory that as
soon as you observe something you change
it in other words we are not separate
from the world or Universe we are with
the universe the world is not outside us
but we are the universe it's inside us
so yoga is one way to tap into or get
closer to your Universal Soul by taming
your body and ego and desires the idea
is to let your soul control you not your
body control your soul e Phil is based
on negation of self while Western
philosophy is firmly rooted in the idea
of individual self as a result of this
the East tends to be more communitarian
where the individual is less important
than the community or the universe while
the West tends to be more
individualistic buddhism's core
philosophy is to remove the self to ease
suffering wanting or Desiring is seen as
negative because you are feeding the ego
the Greeks are more of a Merchants
mentality to grow more profit and become
wealthier and wealthier Merchants are
more more focused on material success
and less concerned with his spiritual
side of life as a result it was a Greeks
who developed a more rational scientific
method to understand the material world
this scientific method allowed
objectivity which meant that Greek
Scholars could disagree with their
mentors even thinkers like Plato openly
disagreed with his teacher Socrates and
Aristotle question Plato and the East
however openly questioning your teacher
was and still is a form of disrespect
instead of finding flaws in those older
than you you're supposed to respect this
is especially important in confusion ISM
Sensei is someone you do not
challenge Western philosophy makes a
distinction between good and evil as
almost separate entities and separate
individuals or even groups often in
Warfare the enemy is seen as evil to
motivate your soldiers to die in defense
of good this is true on both sides so
once you assigned goodness with one way
of seeing the world the opposite of that
is naturally bad or even evil this
battle of good against evil allows
progress those Victorious can claim
goodness and they however both good and
bad are seen as more psychological and
less ideological so good and bad are one
or two sides of the same coin the ying
and yang and taism means every person
has dark and light good and evil built
in them good and evil coexists so no
matter how much a site it progresses it
doesn't change the core yingyang
existence we as humans are neither good
or bad but a bit of both our job is to
understand these so we keep a good
balance between the two forces I think
the most fundamental difference between
Easter Western philosophy is the idea of
linear progress in the west versus a
cyclical notion in the East especially
in Indian philosophy the Greeks believed
in progress Socrates developed his
questioning method of getting to the
objective truth Plato introduced the
idea of perfection and Aristotle came
out with Tils for purpose so getting to
Socratic truth plus platonic Perfection
and Aristotelian T laws or purpose give
birth to a western Progressive
philosophy and science so instead of
focusing too much on the spiritual side
of life the West focused on making the
physical life easier by deploying a
scientific method to understand the
world and invent technologies that made
life easier as a result most people
today live a comfortable life thanks to
Western civilization people live longer
thanks to Western medicine and
Technology when survival is no longer an
issue people seek meaning and purpose so
Eastern philosophy plays a major role in
bringing inner peace for millions of
people in the east as well as in the
west who seek meaning Beyond material
comfort so to sum up climate terrain and
food impacted how the East and West
prioritized philosophical understanding
of the world the Greeks relied on
Merchants and trade so the priority went
to practical sciences and rationality
while in the East farming allowed big
cities to flourish and people live
longer as a result philosophers were
seeking happiness not physical Comfort
life expectancy also grew in the East
which allowed more reflection in old age
when young people seek success but in
old age people search for meaning next
I'll discuss the Greek Trio of Socrates
Plato and Aristotle by looking at the
similarities and differences
Browse More Related Video
Linear Time vs Cyclical Time (Western Philosophy vs Eastern Philosophy)
La Filosofía entre Oriente y Occidente. María Dolores Fernández Fígares
A REVOLUÇÃO de JESUS e SUA INFLUÊNCIA na GRÉCIA! - CLÓVIS DE BARROS e ILAN BRENMAN
Fundamental Moral Unit | Concepts Unwrapped
Filosofia e educação: Sócrates, Platão e Aristóteles
Plato and Aristotle: Crash Course History of Science #3
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)