Dedicated GPU NECESSARY for Creators?

Summary

This video explores whether creative professionals need a dedicated GPU in their laptops. Comparing two laptops with the i7 1195 G7 processor, one with an integrated GPU and the other with a dedicated RTX 3050, the video tests performance across Photoshop, video editing, After Effects, and 3D modeling. It reveals that while a dedicated GPU enhances performance in specific tasks and is essential for 3D modeling, integrated GPUs can suffice for Photoshop and basic video editing. The MSI Summit E16, with its mobile processor and dedicated GPU, stands out as a future-proof option for on-the-go creators.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video discusses the evolution of laptop technology, allowing for more choices but complicating the buying process.
• 🤔 The creator has been wanting to make this video for years, highlighting the availability of laptops with mobile processors and dedicated GPUs.
• 💻 Two laptops are compared: one with an i7 1195G7 mobile processor and integrated graphics, and another with the same processor but also a dedicated GPU.
• 🔧 The i7 1195G7 processors in both laptops have a low TDP, meaning they consume less power, produce less heat, and are quieter, beneficial for on-the-go creators.
• 🎨 Photoshop can utilize a GPU, but not necessarily a dedicated one; an integrated GPU is sufficient, though a dedicated GPU can offer better performance in certain tasks.
• 📊 In Photoshop's Puget Systems benchmark, the laptop with a dedicated GPU scored higher, indicating improved performance in GPU-intensive tasks.
• 🎞 For video editing, a dedicated GPU is crucial as it allows for smoother, faster, and more efficient processes, particularly in export times and 4K playback.
• 📈 The MSI laptop with an RTX 3050 GPU showed significantly fewer dropped frames during 4K playback and faster export times compared to the Lenovo Yoga 9i.
• 🚫 The video does not recommend these laptops for editing 6K RAW footage or using DaVinci Resolve due to poor performance and recommends an H series processor or Apple M1 silicon instead.
• 📊 After Effects performance was surprisingly good with the mobile processor, but adding a dedicated GPU improved the score, suggesting a dedicated GPU is beneficial for a smoother experience.
• 🏗 For 3D modeling, a dedicated GPU like the RTX 3050 is necessary for performance, though the video does not recommend these specific laptops as the top choice for such tasks.
• 💰 The video suggests that if budget allows, investing in a laptop with a dedicated GPU can future-proof a creative professional's setup.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the video?

The main topic of the video is to determine whether a creative professional needs a dedicated GPU in their laptop, discussing the performance of two laptops with and without a dedicated GPU in various creative tasks.

Why has the presenter been wanting to make this video for years?

The presenter has been wanting to make this video for years because previously, the only options were laptops with powerful but hot H series processors and dedicated GPUs or mobile processors with less performance and no dedicated GPU. The evolution of technology now allows for more balanced options.

What is the significance of having both a mobile processor and a dedicated GPU in a laptop?

Having both a mobile processor and a dedicated GPU in a laptop is significant because it combines the performance benefits of a dedicated GPU with the power efficiency and lower heat production of a mobile processor, making it ideal for on-the-go creators.

How does the video script address the use of Photoshop with mobile processors?

The script explains that Photoshop can utilize an integrated GPU within mobile processors like the i7 1195 G7, and while a dedicated GPU is not necessary for all tasks, it can improve performance in specific GPU-intensive tasks.

What is the difference in Photoshop performance between the two laptops mentioned in the script?

The MSI Summit E16 with a dedicated GPU scores an 800 in the Photoshop Puget Systems benchmark, while the Lenovo Yoga 9i with integrated graphics scores a 674, indicating that the dedicated GPU provides better performance for certain tasks.

Why is a dedicated GPU important for video editing according to the script?

A dedicated GPU is important for video editing because it allows for smoother, faster, and more efficient processing, which is particularly noticeable in 4K playback and export times, enhancing the overall workflow.

What was the presenter's experience with 6K video editing on the laptops mentioned?

The presenter found that the laptop with the dedicated RTX 3050 GPU and i7 1195 G7 processor dropped about 8,000 frames when editing 6K B-RAW footage, making it usable but not smooth. The Lenovo Yoga 9i with integrated graphics was nearly unusable, dropping around 15,000 frames.

What is the presenter's recommendation for editing 6K video?

The presenter recommends using an H series processor for a much smoother experience with 6K video editing, suggesting that mobile CPUs are not ideal for this task.

Why does the presenter not recommend the laptops in the script for Davinci Resolve?

The presenter does not recommend the laptops for Davinci Resolve because they have observed poor export times with Intel laptops using this software, suggesting that a Ryzen processor or an Apple laptop with M1 silicon would be better alternatives.

What was surprising about the mobile processor's performance in After Effects according to the script?

The presenter was surprised that the mobile processor scored a 471 in After Effects, which is a good score, indicating that it performed well despite not having a dedicated GPU.

What is the presenter's view on using the laptops for 3D modeling?

The presenter believes that while the laptop with the RTX 3050 GPU is capable of 3D modeling, it is not the go-to recommendation for such tasks. However, it would be a good choice for occasional 3D modeling needs compared to the laptop with integrated graphics.

What advice does the presenter give for those who want to future-proof their creative work laptop?

The presenter advises those who can afford it to opt for a laptop with a dedicated GPU to ensure their laptop is future-proof for creative work, as it offers better performance in tasks that require GPU capabilities.