PEDAS! ROCKY GERUNG POL-POLAN KRITIK BAWASLU #QNA

Summary

The video script discusses the role of the Indonesian Election Supervisory Body (Bawaslu) and the responsibilities of various stakeholders in the democratic process. It highlights the importance of neutrality and accountability in the face of challenges and the need for trust in the government. The conversation emphasizes the significance of addressing issues within the political system and the hope for a better democracy, despite the current shortcomings.

Takeaways

• 😀 The discussion revolves around the role and necessity of the Bawaslu (Election Supervisory Body) in Indonesian democracy.
• 🏛️ There is a debate about whether Bawaslu should be disbanded after elections, with arguments that it is essential for maintaining democratic processes.
• 🤔 The responsibility for the political system is shared among all stakeholders, including the government, legislative bodies, and the public.
• 📊 The importance of transparency and accountability in the political parties and the electoral process is emphasized.
• 🗳️ Issues with the electoral process, such as vote counting and overseas voting, are highlighted as areas of concern that need to be addressed.
• 👥 The role of various institutions, including the KPU (General Election Commission) and Bawaslu, is scrutinized in terms of their neutrality and effectiveness.
• 👮‍♂️ Accountability for any wrongdoings or irregularities in the election process is a collective responsibility, with the need for corrective actions.
• 🔍 The necessity for research and understanding of the political system, including the role of political parties and their leaders, is mentioned.
• 🌐 The script touches on the challenges of overseas voting and the need for proper representation and support systems for voters abroad.
• 📝 The importance of clear communication and explanation of the electoral process, including any technical aspects or manual procedures, to the public is underlined.
• 💪 A call to action for the younger generation and the public to actively participate and contribute to the betterment of the democratic process is made.

Q & A

What is the main topic of discussion in the script?

The main topic of discussion in the script revolves around the role and responsibilities of the Bawaslu (Election Supervisory Body), the political parties, and the citizens in the context of democracy and the election process.

What does the script suggest about the role of Bawaslu in democracy?

The script suggests that Bawaslu plays a crucial role in upholding democracy by ensuring the integrity of the election process and addressing any violations that may occur.

What is the view expressed in the script regarding the dissolution of political parties?

The script implies that dissolving political parties is not a solution to the problems in democracy, as they are an essential part of the democratic system.

What is the script's stance on who should be responsible for the political system?

The script indicates that everyone, including the government, DPR (House of Representatives), BEM UI (UI Student Executive Board), and even university rectors, should share the responsibility for the political system.

What does the script say about the freedom of speech in the context of democracy?

The script acknowledges the importance of freedom of speech in democracy, but also emphasizes that it should not be misused to evade responsibility for wrongdoings.

What is the script's perspective on the accountability of individuals in the political system?

The script suggests that while everyone has a role in the political system, those who are in positions of power, such as members of the DPR or Bawaslu, should be held more accountable for their actions.

What does the script imply about the relationship between the government and the citizens in democracy?

The script implies that there is a complex relationship between the government and the citizens, with both parties having responsibilities and expectations in the democratic process.

What is the script's view on the current state of the democratic system?

The script expresses concern about the current state of the democratic system, suggesting that it is flawed and requires improvement and accountability from all stakeholders.

What does the script suggest as a solution to the problems in the democratic system?

The script suggests that there needs to be a collective effort to address the issues in the democratic system, including better oversight, transparency, and accountability from all involved parties.

What is the script's final message to the audience regarding democracy and hope?

The script concludes with a message of hope for the future of democracy, encouraging the audience to remain optimistic and proactive in shaping the democratic process.

Outlines

00:00

🗳️ Democratic Accountability and Trust in Institutions

The first paragraph discusses the importance of the Bawaslu (Election Supervisory Board) in upholding democracy and the responsibilities of various political entities. It touches on the issue of whether the Bawaslu should be disbanded after an election cycle, emphasizing that democracy is not just about the election process but also about the continuous role of political parties and the essence of democratic principles. The speaker argues that all stakeholders, including the government, DPR (House of Representatives), BEM UI (Student Executive Board of the University of Indonesia), and even university rectors, have a role to play and are accountable for the health of the democratic system. The conversation also delves into the idea that while everyone shares responsibility for democracy, it is the system itself that often needs correction, not the individuals within it.

05:01

🌐 Trust and Distrust in Government: The Role of Hope in Democracy

The second paragraph explores the dichotomy between trust and distrust in government, highlighting the continental European system's view of government as an entity beyond just the presidency, encompassing all state institutions. It emphasizes that responsibility for democratic processes should not be confused with collective guilt for any wrongdoings. The speaker calls for clarity in the legal framework and a distinction between the responsibilities of the election organizers and those of the citizens. The discussion also points out the importance of hope and the role of institutions like Bawaslu and KPU (General Election Commission) in maintaining it. The speaker ends with a message to the youth, urging them to take action and not to lose hope in the democratic process, despite acknowledging the flaws and challenges faced.

Keywords

💡Bawaslu

Bawaslu is the Indonesian Election Supervisory Body, responsible for overseeing the conduct of elections in Indonesia. It is a key concept in the script as it discusses the role and responsibilities of Bawaslu in the democratic process. The script mentions Bawaslu's commitment to neutrality and its function in handling election violations, indicating its importance in maintaining the integrity of the election system.

💡Democracy

Democracy is the theme that runs throughout the script, discussing its essence and the challenges it faces. The term is used to describe the political system where power is vested in the people, and it is the context within which the discussion about the role of Bawaslu and other political entities takes place. The script emphasizes the importance of maintaining democratic processes and the collective responsibility of all stakeholders in upholding it.

💡Political Parties

Political parties are mentioned in the context of being an essential component of democracy. The script discusses the idea of disbanding political parties, which would undermine the democratic essence. It also touches on the importance of political parties in representing different interests and ideologies within a democratic system.

💡Accountability

Accountability is a central concept in the script, referring to the responsibility of individuals and institutions to be answerable for their actions. It is discussed in the context of the roles of various entities, such as Bawaslu, the government, and political parties, in maintaining the democratic system and addressing issues that arise within it.

💡Election

Election is a key term in the script, as it is the process through which democratic systems choose their representatives. The script discusses the importance of the election process and the role of Bawaslu in supervising it. It also touches on issues that can arise during elections, such as violations and the need for transparency and fairness.

💡Trust

Trust is discussed in the script in relation to the government and the democratic system. It refers to the confidence that citizens have in their institutions and the belief that they will act in the best interests of the people. The script mentions 'trust to government' and 'distrust to government,' highlighting the importance of trust in the functioning of democracy.

💡Citizens

Citizens are the individuals who are part of the democratic process, with rights and responsibilities. The script discusses the collective responsibility of citizens in the democratic system and their role in holding institutions accountable. It also touches on the idea that citizens should be informed and involved in the political process.

💡KPU

KPU stands for the General Elections Commission in Indonesia, which is responsible for organizing and conducting elections. The script mentions KPU in the context of its role in the election process and the need for it to address issues such as voter problems abroad, emphasizing the importance of its function in ensuring a fair and smooth electoral process.

💡Hope

Hope is used in the script as a metaphor for the potential and possibilities within the democratic system. It is mentioned in the context of the closing statement, where the speaker encourages a sense of hope and the belief that democracy is still alive and can be strengthened through collective efforts and the resolution of issues.

💡Responsibility

Responsibility is a recurring theme in the script, referring to the duty or obligation of individuals and institutions to act in a certain way. It is discussed in relation to the roles of various stakeholders in democracy, including Bawaslu, political parties, and citizens, and the need for them to take responsibility for the health of the democratic system.

💡Supervision

Supervision in the script refers to the act of overseeing and monitoring the election process to ensure fairness and adherence to regulations. It is used in the context of Bawaslu's role, emphasizing the importance of independent supervision in maintaining the integrity of elections.

Highlights

The importance of Bawaslu in maintaining democracy.

The suggestion to dissolve Bawaslu as its task is completed.

The essence of democracy includes political parties and their freedom to associate.

The responsibility of all parties in the democratic system, including the government, DPR, and other institutions.

The role of the KPU and Bawaslu in addressing political issues.

The accountability of all individuals, including government officials, for the democratic process.

The need for transparency and clarity in the actions of political parties.

The potential problems in the democratic system and the importance of not overloading the KPU and Bawaslu.

The call for correction and responsibility from those who are in charge.

The concept of distrust in government and the importance of trust for a healthy democracy.

The role of the European continental system in the context of government trust.

The clarification that the responsibility for election crimes lies with the election organizers, not the citizens.

The expectation of Bawaslu to be neutral and just in its oversight role.

The challenges of evidence and witness disappearance in proving election violations.

The call for the public to understand the manual counting process and its importance in the election.

The hope for improvement in the democratic system and the handling of overseas voters.

The message of hope and the responsibility of Bawaslu and KPU to maintain democracy.

The metaphor of Pandora's box and the importance of hope in the face of challenges.

The call for action and expression from the younger generation and the public.

The final message of hope for the continuation and strengthening of democracy.

Transcripts

[Musik]

dipersembahkan

[Musik]

oleh Ya pemirsa Terima kasih Anda masih

bersama kami di q& langsung saja bersama

Ketua Bawaslu kita Pak Rahmat B Pak tadi

ada saran dari Bang Abar Faisal

mendingan Bawaslu dibubarkan saja karena

sudah selesai jadi ya apagi ini anda

setuju enggak masih diperlukan enggak

sih Bawaslu untuk demokrasi

kita nanti partai politik itu dibubarkan

kalau begitu padahal esensi demokrasi

satunya partai politik He tadi kebahasan

berpendapat berserikat dan lain-lain itu

ada dan itulah esensi demokrasi sekarang

kita berbicara tentang masalah ini

suarat apa suara saya bermasalah itu

juga esensi demokrasi ketika sistem ada

jalan keluarnya maka itu bisa dijadikan

ee alat untuk kemudian tetap

dipertahankan Nah kalau misalnya ada

permasalahan pasti setiap ee pesta

demokrasi ada permasalahan dan kemudian

jangan terlalu dibebankan juga ini

kepada KPU dan Bawaslu ini terhadap

sistem politik kita Menurut Anda siapa

yang paling bertanggung jawab terhadap

sistem politik kita semua semua kita

bertanggung jawab baik pemerintah DPR

semua maksudnya Ya pemerintah DPR apah

BEM UI ikut bertanggung jawab Apakah

Rektor Universitas Iya ikut bertanggung

jawab Man pertang makanya mereka

berbicara bahwa ketika ada masalah

mereka berbicara bukan dari awal justru

dia bertanggung jawab tentang kejahatan

ya itu hak kebebasan berbicara ber tapi

kalau dibilang semua bertanggung jawab

Memangnya anggota DPR atau bawas

diverifikasi oleh BB kan enggak Anda kan

semua datang untuk minta jadi punya

Jabatan itu mengunjungi ketua partai

bukan mengunjungi bmui atau

bmugm jadi bang Roki gimana Apakah bawa

ya Jangan sebut semua bertanggung jawab

ter kesalahan ini kalau begitu

koreksinya siapa Orang yang bertanggung

jawab itu yang mengoreksi kan itu

dasarnya kan jadi menyebut semua

bertanggung

jawab saya maua Saya mau bela dia enggak

ada bela dia dia mesti

pertanggungjawaban kalimatnya semua kita

Saya tidak bertanggungjawab atas kejatan

ini diimana tanggung jawab saya enggak

ada baik silakan kita kasih kesempatan

kepada Pak Rahmad untuk e menjel kita

bertangung terhadap proses demokrasi

yang ada di rep Jang pakai kita you itu

itu Iya salah satunya saya bukan salah

satu cuma itu warga negara semua warga

negara kalau bilang salah satu berarti s

2 1 2 3 semua warga negara tidak ada

warga negara yang beroposisi tidak

bertanggung jawab ter kejahatan Jokowi

masa kita bertanggung jawab gini gini

kalau itu enggak engakini jauh enggak

bisa mau ma Oke Bang semua kita pert

terhadap demokrasi negara ini bukan

semua kita y ngomongnya normal semu

warga negara kejahatan Mahkamah

Konstitusi tanggung jawab Jokowi bukan

tanggung jawab warga negara Enggak

enggak Gini gini

sedikit Bang Akbar k dua orang ini

berkelahi pada dua koridor yang berbeda

tapi sama-sama benar Jadi sebenarnya

lagi maksud saya adalah maksud saya

adalah Rahmat bagia atas nama bawasl itu

itu memang harus bertanggung jawab

tetapi dari apa yang terjadi yang kita

pahami ini bijak di Pancasila dia mau

terangin dia adalah bagian dari sebuah

sistem di mana memang sudah rusak dari

awal sampai akhir saya gunakan kata

rusak saya ya pernah membikin

undang-undangnya Saya pernah memilih

orang-orangnya dan hari ini saya tidak

tahu lagi apa yang mereka lakukan tapi

apakah kemudian rapat bahagia boleh

mengatakan saya tidak ikut bertanggung

jawab enggak Anda harus bertanggung

jawab tapi Sekali lagi saya katakan

sistemnya yang bermasalah kita makanya

saya gunakan tadi kata riset kita

meriset partai politik kita karena sudah

enggak benar ini kok saya sudah tidak

mengenal lagi nanti anakku ketika dia

akan menjadi politisi harus mengenal

ketua umum partai ini sudah salah dari

awal harus berkenalan dengan e nanti

punakannya Om Rahmat bagya supaya

diperhatikan sudah enggak benar Jadi

intinya sekarang kita ingin mendengarkan

pada malam ini Eh Pak Rahmat bagya

seperti apa sih e komitmen bawasl ya

untuk bisa siap bertanggung jawab ee

dengan fungsi dan tugas yang memang

sudah diemban dan sudah

Ee ditetapkan di bawah fungsi tahapan

fungsi pengawasan seluruh tahapan Pemilu

ada pada komitmennya jelas apa yang

terjadi pelanggaran kita akan tindak

lanjuti sejaimana kita bisa percaya

bahwa Bawaslu akan benar-benar netral

dan jurdil silakan dinilai saya kemudian

tidak bisa memuaskan semua kami tidak

bisa memuaskan semua dari sini He jika

kemudian tiba-tiba alat buktinya kurang

cukup kemudian saksinya menghilang dan

itu akan terjadi permasalahan pada saat

pembuktian satu itu masalah teknisnya

kemudian kalau misalnya dianggap

bermasalah ada jalan keluarnya misalnya

kami tidak profesional ada namanya dewan

kehormatan penyelenggara Pemilu silakan

itu and Nah pasti diprotes lagi ya

silakan kalau sudah tidak percaya dengan

itu Ya silakan saja Bang Rocky bagian

dari distrust to government atau silakan

ada dua pihak trust to government atau

distust to government tapi ingat sistem

Eropa kontinental kita mengatakan bahwa

strust government government bukan hanya

bukan Presiden tapi semua lemb negar

Baka ini yang saya maksud you bilang aja

ini kesalahan bukan pada semua warga

negara kan you bilang tadi semua kita

bersalah baik bukan tanggung jawab bukan

bersalah enak statnya dilihat dalam

hukum jelas kalau statement saya bilang

semua kita bertang teradap proses

demokrasi bukan kalau kemudian dianggil

sebagai kejahatan demokrasi beda lagi

perspektifnya jangan dibalik-balikjatan

kejahatan Pemilu itu tanggung jawab

penyelenggara Pemilu bukan tanggung

jawab warga negara Oke Baik terima

kasih terima kasih Pak eh boleh untuk

closing statement saja Pak Apa saran dan

juga mungkin ee masukan Anda pros P ya

ada proses yang masih berjalan namanya

manual berjenjang Nanti bilang sangat

teknis Tapi ini harus dijelaskan kepada

masyarakat kita harus plot tin namanya

yang namanya manual berjenjang ini akan

dipakai nanti oleh Mbak Oki dan

kawan-kawan Nah kalau ada sistem yang

rusak kalau misalnya ada pembaca yang

bermasalah dilaporkan ada perbaikan

nanti itulah sistem itu berkembang

selalu jadi jangan sampai ada masalah

ini masalahnya di 2.000 TPS laporan

teman-teman KPU dari 380.000 TPS masalah

image dan lain-lain nah yang 2000 ini

kita perbaiki bukan kemudian 380.000

kita ambil kita hancurkan semua enggak

bisa seperti itu ini negara ini harus

berjalan proses demokrasi berjalan

ketika demokrasi stop maka seluruhnya

bermasalah menurut saya baik terima

kasih Tepuk tangan untuk ketua Bawaslu

kita Mbak Oki singkat saja Mbak

harapannya apa silakan Mbak Iya tentu

tadi ee sistem bisa lebih baik dan tidak

ada ee penggelembungan suara yang

tiba-tiba begitu membuat kita menjadi

cemas dan juga ee berharap agar e KPU

sendiri bisa menyelesaikan

masalah-masalah pemilih di luar negeri

terutama karenaapis saya di luar negeri

seperti misalnya Kuala Lumpur perlu ada

PSU untuk KSK dan posnya itu juga

membuat kami e para celeng harus

menunggu begitu mengenai hasil akhirnya

jadi sekali lagi memang sistem yang

berkesinambungan di mana pun tempatnya

baik di dalam negeri maupun di luar

negeri begitu kak Yana Baik terima kasih

mbak

Ok oke satu kata Bang Roki satu kata

saja untuk penutup satu kalimat maksud

saya Iya kalau satu kata engak mungkin

juga seorangi sat satu kalimat untuk

pesan pada anak-anak muda sekarang atau

masyarakat kita itu pesan

oke tadi saya Terangkan

bahwa seperti kota

Pandora begitu dibuka oleh

Pandora eh Evil evolv itu kejahatan ke

mana-mana tetapi di dasar kota itu masih

ada tulisan Only Hope Remains itu kalau

kita belajar tentang mitodologi kan

sekarang hopes itu pada siapa tuh pada

Bawaslu pada KPU enggak ada hopes itu

Jadi mereka yang berharap ada hop

sebetulnya dari awal sudah gagal

mengharapkan hope Jadi sekali lagi buat

milenials itu Lakukan sesuatu Ucapkan

bahwa ini adalah Pemilu paling dungu

Terima kasih baik Kang Maman silakan

untuk penutup

epilognya katakan Saya masih punya hopes

masih punya harapan bahwa demokrasi di

negeri ini belum Rip masih Urip

belum mati Masih hidup tapi berikan

ruang pada pengharapan untuk mendapatkan

penguatan dengan dibebaskannya

pergulatan-pergulatan perkelahian

kecerdasan atas semua temuan di lapangan

dengan

ditindaklanjutinya secara

sungguh-sungguh semua laporan-laporan

seterang-terangnya sampai akhirnya semua

legawa bahwa hasil akhir yang terpampang

memang itu hasilnya dengan demikian

perubahan kelanjutan atau keberhasilan

melawan

kecuranganalah Bukan semata kemenang

kemangan

kanganon harusnya se ituaratnya kata di

negeri ini Angka moral bukan sem

angkaekoral mengingatkan kitatihati

dengan keheningan karena keningan

biasanya lebih nyaring dari suara

[Tepuk tangan]

senyaringun

B dan rekanrekan diudio terima kas juga

pemirsa sudah bersama

Q kita Kawal terus demokrasi boleh ada

Tras isu tapi kita tidak boleh pesimis

terhadap negeri ini karena kemajuan ada

di tangan kita Dan demikianlah semoga

bermanfaat untuk Anda Terima kasih

sampai jumpa lagi dalam Q selanjutnya

karaap pertanyaan selalu ada

jawend download Metro TV extend

sekarang