Why are Muslim Scholars silent about G*za? #Assim #assimalhakeem #assim assim al hakeem

Summary

In this transcript, a speaker addresses the criticism of Muslim scholars for their perceived silence on the oppression in Gaza and other regions. The speaker argues that scholars are doing their best within their limitations, praying, and raising awareness. They highlight the challenges scholars face, including balancing various topics and responding to diverse community needs. The speaker emphasizes the importance of genuine intention in seeking knowledge and supporting the oppressed, rather than merely criticizing scholars.

Takeaways

• 🤔 Muslim scholars are often criticized for not speaking out against the oppression in Gaza, but the speaker questions what the critics themselves are doing.
• 🙏 Muslim scholars are doing what they can within their limits, including praying and making Dua.
• 🚫 There are boundaries and limitations to what scholars can do and say.
• 🙄 Criticizing scholars from a distance without taking action oneself is unproductive.
• 🤷‍♂️ Even if some scholars may be seen as cowards, they still contribute significantly to the community.
• 🌍 Support for oppressed Muslims should be unconditional and extend beyond just Palestine.
• 🗣 The speaker highlights the challenge of addressing every issue and topic as a scholar due to the vastness of Islamic teachings.
• 📚 Scholars cover a wide range of topics, but there will always be more issues that people want them to address.
• 👂 True learning and benefit come from approaching with an intention to learn rather than to criticize.
• 🔍 The speaker emphasizes the importance of focusing on personal growth and learning, regardless of the source of advice.

Q & A

Why are some people questioning the silence of Muslim scholars on the situation in Gaza?

People are questioning the silence of Muslim scholars on the situation in Gaza because they perceive a lack of vocal condemnation and public action against the brutality and oppression occurring there.

What is the speaker's response to accusations that scholars are not doing enough?

The speaker argues that scholars are doing what they can within their limits and boundaries, including praying and making dua, but they cannot be expected to do everything. The speaker also challenges the accusers by asking what they have done themselves.

How does the speaker justify the scholars' limitations in addressing political issues?

The speaker justifies the scholars' limitations by explaining that they have specific boundaries and responsibilities and that they contribute positively to the community in many other ways. He also notes that scholars are not politicians and have a wide range of topics to address.

What is the speaker's view on the criticism of scholars for not speaking on certain topics?

The speaker views this criticism as misguided and rooted in a misunderstanding of the scholars' role. He emphasizes that scholars have a broad range of topics to cover and cannot address every issue simultaneously.

Why does the speaker believe that some people's intentions are to criticize rather than learn?

The speaker believes that some people's intentions are to criticize because they focus on personal dislikes, such as a speaker's appearance or accent, rather than seeking to learn and benefit from the knowledge being shared.

What advice does the speaker give to those who criticize without learning?

The speaker advises those who criticize without learning to focus on benefiting from the knowledge being shared, regardless of their personal opinions about the speaker, and to approach with the intention of getting closer to Allah.

How does the speaker suggest people should approach learning from scholars?

The speaker suggests that people should approach learning from scholars with an open mind, ready to learn from anyone who offers advice, regardless of their perceived level of knowledge.

What is the speaker's stance on the diversity of topics that scholars cover?

The speaker acknowledges the vastness of Islam and the diversity of topics that scholars must cover, indicating that it is impossible to address every single issue in the limited number of speeches or lectures they give annually.

What does the speaker imply about the role of scholars in the community?

The speaker implies that scholars have an important role in the community, contributing positively in various ways, and that their contributions should not be overlooked simply because they may not address every political issue.

What does the speaker say about intentions when learning or giving criticism?

The speaker emphasizes the importance of having the right intentions when learning or giving criticism, stating that those who come to criticize without the intention of learning may never benefit or even reach Jannah (Paradise).