The True and the False Self

Summary

The video script delves into Donald Winnicott's psychological concept of the True and False Self. It suggests that a healthy adult life hinges on the ability to be one's authentic self during infancy, where one's needs and desires are fully met without the need to consider others' feelings. This genuine self-expression is crucial for developing a sense of reality and aliveness. Winnicott posits that the False Self, which adapts to societal norms, is only healthy if it follows a period of true self-expression. The script highlights the importance of psychotherapy, offering a second chance to reconnect with one's True Self, especially for those who missed this opportunity in early life.

Takeaways

• 🧩 The concept of the 'True Self' and 'False Self' is central to Donald Winnicott's psychological theory, which suggests that a healthy development requires a period of being one's true self without concern for others' feelings.
• 👶 Winnicott emphasizes the importance of allowing infants to express their 'True Self', which is inherently asocial and amoral, to scream, bite, and be aggressive without guilt, as a part of their natural development.
• 👼 The 'True Self' must be given the imaginative opportunity to 'destroy' the parent and witness their survival, which helps the child understand its non-omnipotence and the resilience of the world.
• 🌱 A gradual and willing development of a 'False Self' is necessary for a child to adapt to external demands, such as school and work, and it is a sign of healthy growth when it follows a period of being the 'True Self'.
• 🚫 Many adults struggle with feeling unanchored and not entirely present due to early compliance with caregivers' demands, which stifled their 'True Self' and led to a premature development of a 'False Self'.
• 🤝 Relationships may suffer as individuals who were unable to express their 'True Self' may become overly polite and attentive to partners' needs at the expense of authentic love.
• 💼 Work performance can be dutiful but lack creativity and originality when individuals have suppressed their 'True Self' in favor of a 'False Self' to meet external expectations.
• 🛑 Psychotherapy offers a second chance for individuals to regress and rediscover their 'True Self' in a safe environment, allowing them to express previously suppressed emotions and behaviors.
• 🧘‍♂️ Winnicott's approach to therapy is characterized by calmness and generosity, allowing patients to act out their 'True Self' without judgment, as part of their journey towards health.
• 💔 The patients' destructive behaviors, such as smashing vases or shouting insults, are seen as necessary steps in their healing process, reflecting their struggle with the 'False Self'.
• 🔄 The journey towards health involves a regressive phase where individuals must experience the 'True Self' before they can usefully adopt aspects of the 'False Self', which is a reminder of the importance of authenticity in life.

Q & A

What is the main concept discussed in the script related to mental health?

The script discusses the concept of the 'True Self' and 'False Self' as introduced by Donald Winnicott, suggesting that being denied the opportunity to express one's True Self in early childhood can lead to mental health issues in adulthood.

Who is Donald Winnicott and what is his contribution to the field of psychology?

Donald Winnicott was an English psychoanalyst and child psychiatrist known for his work on the True and False Self theory, emphasizing the importance of allowing children to express their True Self for healthy psychological development.

What does the 'True Self' represent according to Winnicott's theory?

In Winnicott's theory, the 'True Self' represents the natural, unfiltered expression of a child's desires and emotions, which is asocial and amoral, not concerned with social norms or the feelings of others.

Why is it important for a child to experience being their True Self?

It is important for a child to experience being their True Self because it allows them to develop a sense of authenticity and realness, which is crucial for their emotional well-being and ability to form genuine relationships and be creative in adulthood.

What is the 'False Self' and how does it develop?

The 'False Self' is a part of one's personality that adapts to external demands and social norms. It develops as a child learns to comply with the expectations of their caregivers and society, often at the expense of their True Self expression.

How does the script relate the development of the False Self to societal and work life?

The script suggests that the development of the False Self is necessary for a child to adapt to the rigors of school and, later, work life. It allows individuals to follow rules and meet societal expectations, but only after having experienced being their True Self.

What are some potential consequences of not being allowed to express one's True Self during early childhood?

Potential consequences include feeling unanchored, inwardly dead, and not entirely present in one's life. This can lead to difficulties in forming authentic relationships, being uncreative at work, and a general sense of dissatisfaction and depression.

How can psychotherapy provide a second chance to those who were not allowed to be their True Self in early childhood?

Psychotherapy can offer a safe space for individuals to regress to a point before they started to develop a False Self, allowing them to express their True Self under the guidance of a therapist, which can lead to a renewed sense of aliveness and authenticity.

What was Donald Winnicott's approach to patients attempting to refind their True Self during therapy?

Winnicott was calm and generous, allowing patients to express their True Self without judgment, even when it involved delinquent or aggressive behavior, understanding that this was part of their journey towards health.

What is the significance of the therapist's role in helping patients rediscover their True Self?

The therapist's role is crucial as they provide a safe and containing environment where patients can explore and express their True Self, helping them to experience a new sense of aliveness and to cope with the demands of having a False Self in their daily lives.

How does the script suggest we can achieve contentment and a feeling of reality?

The script suggests that contentment and a feeling of reality can be achieved by first allowing ourselves to be 'almost limitlessly delinquent and selfish' as part of expressing our True Self, before we can be usefully a bit fake or develop a False Self.

Outlines

00:00

🧠 The Struggle with the True and False Self

This paragraph delves into the concept of the True and False Self as introduced by Donald Winnicott. It discusses how adults may face mental challenges due to a lack of permission to be their authentic selves during early childhood. The True Self is described as inherently asocial and amoral, needing the freedom to express itself without concern for others' feelings. Winnicott argues that a healthy development requires a period where one's needs and desires are the center of the world, allowing for the development of a False Self later on. This False Self enables a person to adapt to societal norms and expectations, such as attending school and working. However, if one's True Self was suppressed due to early compliance with caregivers' demands, it can lead to a sense of inauthenticity and emotional disconnection in adulthood. Psychotherapy offers a chance to regress and rediscover one's True Self, allowing for a more genuine sense of self and aliveness.

05:02

🛠️ The Therapeutic Journey to Authenticity

The second paragraph continues the discussion on the True and False Self, emphasizing the role of psychotherapy in allowing individuals to reconnect with their authentic selves. It highlights the importance of experiencing the freedom to be 'difficult' and self-centered as part of the therapeutic process, which can help in overcoming the demands of a False Self that may have been developed prematurely. The paragraph also illustrates Winnicott's approach to therapy, showcasing his calm and generous demeanor towards patients as they attempt to rediscover their True Selves. Despite facing challenges such as vandalism, theft, and verbal abuse from his patients, Winnicott remained steadfast, viewing these actions as necessary steps towards health and authenticity. The paragraph concludes by emphasizing the necessity of embracing one's True Self before adopting societal roles and expectations, suggesting that therapy can provide the space to do so.

Keywords

💡True Self

The 'True Self' refers to an individual's authentic and unfiltered nature, free from societal constraints or the expectations of others. In the video's context, it's the state of being where a child can express their needs and emotions without guilt, which is crucial for healthy psychological development. The script mentions that the True Self is 'asocial and amoral,' highlighting its lack of concern for social norms or the feelings of others, as seen in the example of a child screaming when tired or angry.

💡False Self

The 'False Self' is a concept that describes the part of an individual that conforms to societal expectations and suppresses their genuine feelings or desires. The video explains that a healthy False Self develops as a child grows and learns to adapt to external demands, such as school and work. However, if the True Self is not allowed to flourish first, the False Self can become a facade that leads to feelings of inauthenticity and emotional distress, as the script suggests with the phrase 'the demand to be False.'

💡Donald Winnicott

Donald Winnicott was an influential English psychoanalyst and child psychiatrist who introduced the concepts of the True and False Self. The video credits him as one of the twentieth century's greatest thinkers for his work on understanding healthy emotional development. His theories, as described in the script, emphasize the importance of allowing children to be their True Selves to develop a sense of reality and avoid emotional troubles in adulthood.

💡Mental Health

Mental health in the video is discussed in the context of the impact of early childhood experiences on adult psychological well-being. The script suggests that being denied the opportunity to express one's True Self in early years can lead to feelings of being 'unanchored, inwardly dead,' and lacking a sense of presence in adulthood. Mental health is portrayed as being closely tied to the balance between the True and False Selves.

💡Authenticity

Authenticity is the quality of being true to one's own personality, spirit, or character, without pretending to be something else. The video emphasizes the importance of authenticity for mental health, suggesting that individuals who were not allowed to be their True Selves as children may struggle with feeling authentic in relationships and at work. Authenticity is linked to the ability to love properly and to be creative and original.

💡Psychotherapy

Psychotherapy is a therapeutic practice that aims to treat mental health issues through dialogue between a patient and a therapist. The script highlights psychotherapy as offering a 'second chance' for individuals who were not able to express their True Selves in their early years. It allows for regression to a time when one needed to be true, providing a safe space to explore and express repressed emotions and desires.

💡Omnipotence

The concept of 'omnipotence' in the video relates to a child's initial belief in their all-powerful influence over the world around them. Winnicott's theory posits that witnessing a parent's survival of the child's rage helps the child realize they are not omnipotent, which is essential for developing a healthy sense of reality. The script uses this concept to illustrate the importance of the child's imaginative opportunity to 'destroy the parent' and witness their endurance.

💡Compliance

Compliance in this context refers to the early adoption of behaviors that meet the expectations of caregivers or society, often at the expense of one's True Self. The video suggests that individuals who had to comply too early due to their caregivers' needs may have developed a False Self that hinders their ability to feel authentic and may lead to a lack of creativity in adulthood.

💡Delinquency

Delinquency in the video is associated with the behavior of a child expressing their True Self without restraint, which may include aggressive or socially unacceptable actions. It is mentioned as a necessary stage for the development of a healthy sense of reality and contentment. The script implies that without experiencing 'almost limitless delinquent selfishness,' an individual may struggle with feelings of unreality and emotional distress.

💡Therapy

Therapy, as discussed in the video, is a broader term that encompasses various treatments and interventions aimed at improving mental health. It is presented as a means to allow individuals to regress and rediscover their True Selves in a safe and supportive environment. The script describes how therapy can help patients experience a 'new sense of aliveness' and cope with the ongoing demand to present a False Self in other areas of life.

💡Contentment

Contentment in the video is linked to the acceptance and expression of one's True Self. It is suggested that true contentment and a feeling of reality can only be achieved by passing through stages of expressing selfishness and delinquency as part of the True Self's development. The script implies that individuals who have not been allowed to be their True Selves may experience dissatisfaction and a lack of a sense of reality in their lives.

Highlights

Adults may struggle mentally due to being denied the opportunity to fully express themselves in their earliest years.

Being overly compliant as a child due to caregiver's needs can lead to feeling unanchored and not fully present as an adult.

Donald Winnicott's psychological theory of the True and False Self emphasizes the importance of experiencing one's True Self for healthy development.

A period of not having to consider others' feelings is crucial for life-sustaining emotional development.

The True Self of an infant is asocial, amoral, and expresses itself without guilt or concern for others.

Allowing the True Self to disturb and disrupt helps an individual feel real and authentic as an adult.

The False Self develops as a capacity to behave according to external reality, enabling societal participation.

A thorough experience of the True Self is necessary before the development of a healthy False Self.

Many people become obedient at the expense of feeling authentic due to early life circumstances.

Psychotherapy offers a second chance to regress and rediscover the True Self in a safe environment.

Therapists provide a space for individuals to express the previously suppressed True Self without judgment.

Winnicott's approach to therapy was calm and generous, allowing patients to work through their True Selves.

Contentment and a sense of reality require passing through stages of selfishness and delinquency.

Therapy can help individuals who were never allowed to be their True Self to take a step back and heal.

Winnicott reminds us that being True is a prerequisite for being usefully a bit fake in society.

The School Of Life offers resources for further exploration of these concepts.

Transcripts

One of the most surprising but powerful explanations for why we may, as adults, be in trouble mentally

is that we were, in our earliest years, denied the opportunity to be fully ourselves, that

is, we were not allowed to be wilful and difficult, we could not be as demanding, aggressive,

intolerant, and unrestrictedly selfish as we needed to be. Because our caregivers were

preoccupied or fragile, we had to be preternaturally attuned to their demands, sensing that we

had to comply in order to be loved and tolerated; we had to be false before we had the chance

to feel properly alive. And as a result, many years later, without quite understanding the

process, we risk feeling unanchored, inwardly dead and somehow not entirely present. This

psychological theory of the True and the False Self is the work of one of the twentieth century’s

greatest thinkers, the English psychoanalyst and child psychiatrist Donald Winnicott. In

a series of papers written in the 1960s and based on close observations of his adult and

infant patients, Winnicott advanced the view that healthy development invariably requires

us to experience the immense, life-sustaining luxury of a period when we do not have to

bother with the feelings and opinions of those who are tasked with looking after us. We can

be wholly and, without guilt, our True Selves, because those around us have – for a time

– adapted themselves entirely to our needs and desires, however inconvenient and arduous

these might be. The true self of the infant, in Winnicott’s formulation, is by nature

asocial and amoral. It isn’t interested in the feelings of others, it isn’t socialised.

It screams when it needs to – even if it is the middle of the night or on a crowded

train. It may be aggressive, biting and – in the eyes of a stickler for manners or a lover

of hygiene – shocking and a bit disgusting. It wants to express itself where and how it

wants. It can be sweet of course but on its own terms, not in order to charm or bargain

for love. If a person is to have any sense of feeling real as an adult, then it has to

have enjoyed the immense emotional privilege of being able to be true in this way, to disturb

people when it wants, to kick when it is angry, to scream when it is tired, to bite when it

is feeling aggressive. The True Self of the child must be granted the imaginative opportunity

to destroy the parent when it is in a rage – and then witness the parent surviving

and enduring, which lends the child a vital and immensely reassuring sense that it is

not in fact omnipotent, and that the world won’t collapse simply because it sometimes

wishes or fears it could. When things go well, gradually and willingly, the child develops

a False Self, a capacity to behave according to the demands of external reality. This is

what enables a child to submit to the rigours of school and, as it develops into an adult,

of working life as well. When we have been given the chance to be our true selves we

do not, at every occasion, need to rebel and insist on our needs. We can follow the rules

because we have, for a time, been able to ignore them entirely. In other words, Winnicott

was not a thorough enemy of a False Self; he understood its role well enough, he simply

insisted that it belonged to health only when it had been preceded by a thorough earlier

experience of an untrammelled True Self. Unfortunately, many of us have not enjoyed such an ideal

start. Perhaps mother was depressed, or father was often in a rage, maybe there was an older

or younger sibling who was in a crisis and required all the attention. The result is

that we will have learnt to comply far too early; we will have become obedient at the

expense of our ability to feel authentically ourselves. In relationships, we may now be

polite and geared to the needs of our partners, but not for that matter able properly to love.

At work, we may be dutiful but uncreative and unoriginal. In such circumstances, and

this is its genius, psychotherapy offers us a second chance. In the hands of a good therapist,

we are allowed to regress before the time when we started to be False, back to the moment

when we so desperately needed to be true. In the therapist’s office, safely contained

by their maturity and care, we can learn – once more – to be real; we can be intemperate,

difficult, unconcerned with anyone but ourselves, selfish, unimpressive, aggressive and shocking.

And the therapist will take it – and thereby help us to experience a new sense of aliveness

which should have been there from the start. The demand to be False, which never goes away,

becomes more bearable because we are regularly being allowed, in the privacy of the therapist’s

room, once a week or so, to be True. Winnicott was famously calm and generous towards his

patients when they were attempting to refind their True Selves in this way. One of them

smashed a favourite vase of his, another stole his money, a third shouted insults at him

session after session. But Winnicott was unruffled, knowing that this was part of a journey back

towards health, away from the deadly fakeness afflicting these patients in the rest of their

lives. We can be grateful to Winnicott for reminding us that contentment and a feeling

of reality have to pass through stages of almost limitless delinquent selfishness. There

is simply no other way. We have to be True before we can be usefully a bit fake – and

if we have never been allowed, then our sickness and depression is there to remind us that

we need to take a step back, and therapy is there to allow us to do so.

Please do comment, like and subscribe

and take a look at our shop for more from The School Of Life.