BJP's Sudhanshu Trivedi debunks Congress Manifesto 2024

Summary

The script critiques a political party's long history and its governance over four generations, highlighting the contrast between past promises and current realities. It points out the party's claims of what they could have achieved if given the chance, juxtaposed with statistics on inflation and unemployment rates over the past 50 years. The speaker emphasizes the lowest inflation rates and highest growth rates during the party's tenure, challenging the party's credibility and questioning their manifesto promises, including a photo mix-up and historical inaccuracies.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker refers to a party as the oldest, having been in power for 139 years, and having had the opportunity to govern directly for about 55 to 60 years after independence.
• 🏛️ The speaker mentions that despite having the chance to govern for generations, the party claims they will now show what they can do if given the chance to fulfill their dreams and aspirations.
• 📈 The speaker highlights current economic issues, stating that the inflation rate is around 5% and the unemployment rate is around 3.1%, and compares these rates to historical data.
• 📊 The speaker points out that in the last 50 years, the lowest rates of inflation occurred during the party's governance, with specific years and rates mentioned.
• 🌐 The speaker discusses the highest growth rates in the top 10 years, stating that India currently ranks among the top 20 countries with the highest growth rate, but also notes that the highest negative growth rate was during a previous administration.
• 💡 The speaker criticizes the party for claiming they will now do wonders, suggesting that their past performance does not support such claims.
• 🌳 The speaker mentions a photo in the party's manifesto related to water management, which is actually a photo of New York's Buffalo River, indicating a mistake in the manifesto.
• 🌐 The speaker humorously points out that the Buffalo in the photo is a type of buffalo in Hindi, and questions who is sending such photos from abroad.
• 🚀 The speaker discusses the achievements of the country before independence, such as the Shiva Samudram Power Project in 1902 and the Indian Institute of Science in 1916, to contrast with the party's claims of their own achievements.
• 🏥 The speaker mentions that the first hospital in India, and the world, was established in Bangalore before independence, and that many institutions and achievements were established before the party came to power.
• 🏆 The speaker mentions that C.V. Raman won the Nobel Prize in 1930, and contrasts this with the party's claims of their contributions to education and science.

Q & A

What is the claim made by the speaker about the oldest political party in India?

The speaker claims that the oldest political party in India has been in power for about 60 years after independence and has had the opportunity to govern continuously for four generations, yet they are now promising to show great achievements if given a chance.

What is the speaker's argument regarding the inflation rate during the last 50 years in India?

The speaker argues that in the last 50 years, the inflation rate has been at its lowest during the speaker's party's governance, with rates around 5%, and points out specific years and rates to support this claim.

What is the speaker's point about the highest growth rate in the top 10 years?

The speaker points out that the highest growth rate in the top 10 years occurred during their party's term, with specific years mentioned to illustrate this point.

What historical error is highlighted by the speaker regarding the Congress party's claim about infrastructure development?

The speaker highlights an error in the Congress party's manifesto regarding a photo of water management, which was actually a photo of New York's Buffalo Liver, indicating a lack of attention to detail and accuracy.

What is the speaker's response to the Congress party's claim about not having any scams during their governance?

The speaker counters the claim by stating that during the Congress party's governance, there were instances of high inflation rates and negative growth rates, suggesting that their governance was not as clean as they claim.

What is the speaker's reference to the first power project in India?

The speaker refers to the first power project in India as the Shiva Samudram Power Project, which started in 1902 in Mysore, contradicting the Congress party's claim that nothing was built during their governance.

What is the significance of the Indian Institute of Science mentioned by the speaker?

The speaker mentions the Indian Institute of Science, established in 1916 in Bengaluru, as an example of significant development that occurred before the Congress party's governance, challenging their narrative.

What is the speaker's comment on the first hospital in India?

The speaker comments that the first hospital in India, the Mysore Hospital, was established before independence, which again contradicts the Congress party's claims about their contributions to development.

What is the speaker's point about the Nobel Prize winner C.V. Raman?

The speaker points out that C.V. Raman, an Indian Nobel laureate, received his award in 1930, which was before the Congress party's governance, to emphasize that significant achievements were made outside of their rule.

What is the speaker's reference to Dr. Dwarakanath Kotnis and his contributions?

The speaker references Dr. Dwarakanath Kotnis, who represented India as a doctor during the Sino-Japanese War in the 1930s, as an example of India's international contributions before the Congress party's governance.

What is the speaker's comment on the establishment of the Indian Air Force?

The speaker comments that the Indian Air Force was established in 1932, which was before the Congress party's governance, to further emphasize the developments that occurred outside of their rule.