SC-CJI, NEET Leak a Business, Hegde Rips NTA #Lawchakra #supremecourtofindia

Summary

The speaker expresses deep concerns over the integrity of competitive exams, citing the occurrence of 61 toppers and the potential for unfair practices. They argue that the examination agency, NTA, has been lax in its response to paper leaks and has failed to ensure a fair ranking system. The speaker calls for a re-examination for affected students, emphasizing the need for transparency and accountability in the examination process to maintain trust and fairness.

Takeaways

• 😔 The speaker expresses distrust in competitive exams, citing issues with integrity and fairness.
• 📚 There is a mention of a history of paper leaks, suggesting an organized gang is involved in these activities.
• 💼 The speaker criticizes the NTA (National Testing Agency) for not being serious about maintaining the integrity of the examination process.
• 🔍 The speaker points out that the NTA did not cooperate initially with the police or the EOU (Economic Offences Wing) in addressing the leaks.
• 🏥 The government is spending about a crore (ten million) per year per medical student, highlighting the financial implications of these exams.
• 🏆 Students with high scores (690, 640) are not assured of a fair rank, which is a major concern from a student perspective.
• 🔑 The speaker suggests that the NTA continued to deny the existence of a leak and did not take immediate action when informed.
• 🔄 Changes in personnel and the involvement of the CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation) in the investigation were only made later, indicating a delayed response.
• 📈 The speaker mentions that the NTA has not been transparent with data, and the data provided was only after being served with numerous PDF files.
• 🚫 The speaker concludes that the exams cannot be considered fair and that it is not safe to trust the results, advocating for a retest for those affected.

Q & A

What is the main concern raised about competitive exams in the transcript?

The main concern is the lack of trust in competitive exams due to the possibility of paper leaks and the integrity of the examination process.

What is the term 'mots' referring to in the context of the transcript?

The term 'mots' seems to be a typographical error; it should likely be 'most', referring to the majority of toppers in exams.

What is the implication of 'CR' in the context of government spending per medical student?

CR likely stands for 'Crore', which is a unit of Indian currency, indicating the amount spent by the government annually per medical student.

What is the issue with the NTA's handling of the examination process as mentioned in the transcript?

The issue is that the NTA did not show concern for the integrity of the process, continued to deny the paper leak, and did not cooperate with the investigation promptly.

What is the significance of the number '61' mentioned in the transcript?

The number '61' is not clearly explained in the transcript, but it could be related to the number of toppers or a specific data point in the context of the examination results.

What is the term 'Grace Mark' referred to in the transcript?

Grace Mark refers to additional marks given to students to compensate for potential errors in the examination process or to ensure a minimum passing score.

What is the role of the organized gang mentioned in the transcript?

The organized gang is implicated in leaking examination papers as part of their business model, aiming to maximize profit from the time-limited commodity of leaked papers.

What is the situation with the students who scored 690 and 640 as mentioned in the transcript?

These students are concerned that despite their high scores, they are not assured of a fair rank due to the potential manipulation and integrity issues in the examination process.

What is the significance of the 'retest' mentioned for 1563 students?

The retest is a measure taken by the authorities to ensure fairness and accuracy in measuring the students' abilities, in response to the integrity issues with the original examination.

What is the suggestion made for students who scored above 164 in the transcript?

The suggestion is to provide a re-examination for these students to ensure that they are accurately measured and ranked, in light of the concerns about the integrity of the original examination.

What is the final request made by the speaker in the transcript?

The speaker requests that the examination results not be accepted as fair and that the NTA's actions not be approved, suggesting that those involved in the paper leak should not be allowed to get away with it.