Spencer Wells Building a family tree for all humanity
Summary
TLDRThis script details a speaker's journey through 17 countries, exploring human diversity and origins. It delves into genetics, particularly population genetics, to understand how humanity's diversity emerged and the timeframe of our evolution. The narrative highlights the African origin of all humans, traced through DNA, and the recent exodus from Africa around 60,000 years ago. It also discusses the Genographic Project, an initiative that invites public participation in genetic research to map human migration and preserve cultural heritage.
Takeaways
- π The speaker has visited 17 countries and observed the incredible diversity of languages and cultures, highlighting the human species' variety in terms of language, appearance, and lifestyle.
- π The talk focuses on using genetics and population genetics to understand the origin and development of human diversity across the globe.
- 𧬠Charles Darwin's theory suggested that human ancestors likely originated in Africa, which is supported by the fossil record and the genetic similarity with our closest ape relatives.
- πΊ The study of human ancestry has traditionally relied on paleoanthropology and morphology, but this approach has limitations in providing definitive genealogical probabilities.
- π² Linnaeus' classification of human 'races' was based on skull shapes and other physical features, but such classifications have been largely dismissed due to their lack of scientific basis and racial bias.
- π DNA provides a more accurate way to trace human ancestry and construct a family tree. Genetic markers can indicate shared ancestry and help trace lineage back to common ancestors.
- π³ Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and the Y chromosome are used to trace maternal and paternal lineages, respectively, showing that all humans can be traced back to a common African ancestor.
- π°οΈ The 'Out of Africa' theory is supported by genetic evidence, suggesting that modern humans migrated out of Africa around 60,000 to 70,000 years ago, a relatively recent event in evolutionary terms.
- π‘οΈ Around 70,000 years ago, the climate was harsh, with Africa drying out and the human population nearly going extinct. This period of environmental stress coincided with significant cultural and cognitive advances in humans.
- π¨ The development of modern language, art, and more sophisticated tool-making around 50,000 years ago is believed to have facilitated human survival and expansion out of Africa.
- π The Genographic Project, launched in 2005, aims to collect and analyze hundreds of thousands of DNA samples to map human migration patterns and understand our shared ancestry, with a focus on indigenous populations and public participation.
Q & A
How many countries has the speaker visited in the last six weeks?
-The speaker has visited 17 countries in the last six weeks.
What is the main focus of the project the speaker is involved in?
-The main focus of the project is to understand human diversity using the tools of genetics, particularly population genetics.
What is the significance of the diversity in human languages as mentioned in the script?
-The diversity in human languages, with around 6,000 different languages spoken by 6.5 billion people, illustrates the vast cultural and genetic diversity across the globe.
What does the speaker suggest is the 'surface thing' that one takes away from traveling the world?
-The 'surface thing' that one takes away from traveling the world is the recognition of how different we are, rather than the idea that we are all one.
According to Darwin, what was the likely origin of mankind based on the distribution of living mammals and their extinct relatives?
-Darwin suggested that Africa was likely the origin of mankind because each great region of the world has living mammals closely related to the extinct species of the same region, and Africa was the origin of apes, our closest relatives.
What is the difference between studying human ancestry through paleoanthropology and using genetic markers?
-Paleoanthropology studies human ancestry by digging up fossils and analyzing morphology, while genetic markers use DNA to trace ancestry and provide a more precise understanding of genealogical relationships.
What is the significance of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and the Y chromosome in genetic studies of human ancestry?
-Mitochondrial DNA traces a purely maternal line of descent, while the Y chromosome traces a purely paternal line of descent, allowing scientists to construct detailed family trees for all of humanity.
What does the speaker suggest about the timing of when all humans shared a common ancestor, based on genetic evidence?
-According to the genetic evidence, all humans shared a common ancestor, mitochondrial Eve, within the last 200,000 years, and the Y chromosome Adam lived around 60,000 years ago.
What environmental changes approximately 60,000 years ago may have influenced human migration out of Africa?
-Around 60,000 years ago, the world was going into the worst part of the last ice age, causing significant climate changes including drying out of Africa, which may have influenced human migration.
What is the Genographic Project, and how can the public participate in it?
-The Genographic Project is a global initiative that aims to map human migration patterns using DNA samples. The public can participate by ordering a DNA testing kit from the project's website, submitting their results to the database, and contributing to the scientific effort.
What is the purpose of the Legacy Fund associated with the Genographic Project?
-The Legacy Fund is a charitable entity that receives a portion of the funds raised by the Genographic Project. It provides grants to indigenous groups around the world for educational and cultural projects that they initiate.
Outlines
π Global Diversity and Human Origins
The speaker reflects on their travels to 17 countries and the profound diversity they've witnessed among people and languages. They discuss the use of genetics, specifically population genetics, to understand the origins and development of human diversity. The speaker emphasizes the distinction between our common ancestry with apes, which originated in Africa around 23 million years ago, and our human ancestry. They highlight the importance of studying human evolution beyond morphology, using DNA as a historical document to trace our genealogy and understand the timing and process of human diversification.
π¬ The Genetic Approach to Human Ancestry
This paragraph delves into the limitations of traditional paleoanthropology and the transition to genetic analysis for understanding human ancestry. The speaker critiques Linnaeus' racial categorizations and the lack of concrete data supporting the concept of distinct human races. They advocate for a genealogical approach using DNA as a historical record, explaining the basics of DNA structure and the significance of genetic mutations as markers of descent. The speaker outlines how these markers can be used to construct a comprehensive family tree for all of humanity, tracing back to our earliest ancestors.
π³ The African Origin and Maternal Lineages
The speaker explains the genetic evidence supporting the African origin of all humans, with the deepest lineages found within Africa indicating a longer period of mutational diversity accumulation. They introduce 'Mitochondrial Eve', an African woman who lived around 200,000 years ago and from whom all current mitochondrial DNA diversity descends. The Y chromosome evidence also points to a single African male ancestor, suggesting a recent exodus from Africa within the last 60,000 years. The speaker ponders why humans remained in Africa until this point and didn't diversify earlier like other species, such as Homo erectus.
ποΈ Climate, Cultural Shifts, and Global Expansion
Discussing the environmental context of human migration, the speaker describes the harsh conditions of the last ice age and its impact on Africa, causing a significant reduction in habitable areas and a near-extinction event for humans. Around 60,000 years ago, a cultural and behavioral shift is hypothesized to have occurred, marked by the emergence of art, advanced tool-making, and possibly the development of complex language. These changes are believed to have facilitated human survival and expansion out of Africa, with early migrations along coastal routes and into new territories, leading to the global distribution of human populations.
π The Genographic Project and Public Participation
The speaker introduces the Genographic Project, launched in 2005 with the aim of expanding the study of human origins using DNA analysis on a global scale. The project encompasses field research with indigenous populations, public participation through DNA testing kits, and the establishment of a Legacy Fund to support cultural and educational initiatives. The speaker shares the success of the project, with thousands of samples collected and significant public engagement, highlighting the project's contribution to our understanding of human migration and diversity.
Mindmap
Keywords
π‘Diversity
π‘Genetics
π‘Paleoanthropology
π‘Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)
π‘Y Chromosome
π‘Mutation
π‘Genographic Project
π‘Indigenous Peoples
π‘Paleoclimatology
π‘Cultural Stasis
π‘Legacy Fund
Highlights
The speaker has visited 17 countries and experienced a wide range of cultures, emphasizing the diversity of human languages and appearances.
The use of genetics and population genetics to understand human diversity and its origins is discussed.
Darwin's theory suggests that Africa is the most probable origin for human ancestors due to the fossil evidence and the continent's isolation.
The limitations of paleoanthropology and the need for a genealogical approach to understand human ancestry are highlighted.
DNA as a historical document that traces our ancestry and the concept of genetic markers of descent are introduced.
Mitochondrial DNA and Y chromosome are used to trace maternal and paternal lineages, respectively.
African populations have the deepest lineages and the greatest genetic diversity, supporting the Out of Africa theory.
The concept of 'Mitochondrial Eve' and 'Y Chromosome Adam' as recent common ancestors for all humans is presented.
The environmental conditions during the last ice age and their impact on human migration are examined.
A discussion on the behavioral changes in humans around 60,000 to 70,000 years ago that allowed for survival and expansion.
The development of modern language and social networks as a critical factor in human success.
The Genographic Project, launched in 2005, aims to increase sample size and understand human migration patterns.
The project's public participation aspect, allowing individuals to test their own DNA and contribute to the study.
The Legacy Fund, a charitable entity that supports indigenous groups with educational and cultural projects.
The success of the Genographic Project with over 235,000 public participants and its impact on scientific understanding.
The importance of the project in documenting and preserving human genetic diversity and cultural heritage.
Transcripts
these are a few of the languages
that i've spoken little bits of over the
course the last six weeks as i've been
to
17 countries i think i'm up to on this
crazy tour i've been doing
uh checking out various aspects of the
project that we're doing that i'm going
to tell you a little bit about later on
and visiting some pretty incredible
places
places like mongolia cambodia new guinea
south africa tanzania twice i was here a
month ago
and the opportunity to make a whirlwind
tour
of the world like that is utterly
amazing for lots of reasons you see some
incredible stuff
and you get to make these spot
comparisons between people all around
the globe
and the thing that you really take away
from that the kind of surface
thing that you take away from it is not
that we're all one
although i'm going to tell you about
that but rather how different we are
there is so much diversity around the
globe six thousand different languages
spoken by six and a half billion people
all different colors shapes sizes
you walk down the street in any big city
you travel like that
and you are amazed at the diversity in
the human species
how do we explain that diversity well
that's what i'm going to talk about
today is how we're using the tools of
genetics
population genetics in particular to
tell us
how we generated this diversity and how
long it took
now the problem of human diversity like
all big scientific questions how do you
explain something like that can be
broken down into sub questions and you
can
ferret away at those little sub
questions first one is uh really a
question of origins do we all share
a common origin in fact and given that
we do
and that's the assumption everybody i
think in this room would make when when
was that
when did we originate as a species how
long have we been diverging from each
other
and the second question is related but
slightly different if we do spring from
a common source
how did we come to occupy every corner
of the globe and in the process
generate all of this diversity the
different ways of life the different
appearances the different languages
around the world
well the question of origins as with so
many other questions in biology seems to
have been answered by darwin
over a century ago and the descent of
man who wrote in each great region of
the world the living mammals are closely
related to the extinct species of the
same region
it's therefore probable that africa was
formerly inhabited by extinct apes
closely allied to the gorilla and
chimpanzee
and as these two species are now man's
nearest allies it's somewhat more
probable that our early progenitors
lived on the african continent than
elsewhere
so we're done we can go home finish the
origin question well not quite
because darwin was talking about our
distant ancestry our common ancestry
with apes and it is quite clear
that apes originated on the african
continent around 23 million years ago
they appear on the fossil record
africa was actually disconnected from
the other land masses at that time due
to the vagaries of plate tectonics
floating around the indian ocean
bumped into eurasia around 16 million
years ago and then we had the first
african exodus as we call it the apes
that left at that time ended up in
southeast asia became the gibbons and
the orangutans and the ones that stayed
on in africa evolved into the guerrillas
the chimpanzees and us so yes
if you're talking about our common
ancestry with apes it's very clear by
looking at the fossil record we started
off here
but that's not really the question i'm
asking i'm asking about
our human ancestry things that we would
recognize as being like us
if they were sitting here in the room
they were peering over your shoulder
you wouldn't leap back like that what
about our human ancestry because if we
go far enough back
we share a common ancestry with every
living thing on earth
dna ties us all together so we share
ancestry with barracuda and bacteria
and mushrooms if you go far enough back
over a billion years
what we're asking about though is human
ancestry how do we study that well
historically it has been studied
using the science of paleoanthropology
digging things up out of the ground
and largely on the basis of morphology
the way things are shaped
often skull-shaped saying this looks a
little bit more like us than that so
this
must be my ancestor this must be who i'm
directly descended from
the feel of paleoanthropology i'll argue
gives us lots of fascinating
possibilities about our ancestry but it
doesn't give us the probabilities that
we really want
as scientists what do i mean by that
you're looking at a great example here
these are three extinct species of
hominid potential human ancestors
all dug up just west of here and aldo by
gorge by the leaky family
and they're all dating to roughly the
same time from left to right we've got
homo erectus homo habilis and
australopithecus now called paranthropus
boisei
robust australopithecine three extinct
species same place
same time that means that not all three
could be
my direct ancestor which one of these
guys am i actually related to
possibilities about our ancestry but not
the probabilities that we're really
looking for
well a different approach has been to
look at morphology
in humans using the only data that
people really had at hand until quite
recently
again largely skull-shaped the first
person to do this systematically
was linnaeus carl von linney swedish
botanist who in the 18th century took it
upon himself to
categorize every living organism on the
planet you think you've got a tough job
and he did a pretty good job he
categorized about twelve thousand
species in systemic naturai
he actually coined the term homo sapiens
means wise man in latin
but looking around the world at the
diversity of humans he said
well you know we seem to come in
discreet subspecies or categories
and he talked about africans or and
americans and asians and europeans in a
blatantly racist category he termed
monstrosus
which basically included all the people
he didn't like including imaginary folk
like elves
it's it's easy to dismiss this as the
perhaps well-intentioned but ultimately
benighted musings of an 18th century
scientist
working in the pre-darwinian era except
if you had taken physical anthropology
as recently as 20 or 30 years ago
in many cases you would have learned
basically that same classification of
humanity human races
that according to physical
anthropologists of 30 40 years ago
carlton is the best example
had been diverging from each other this
was in the post darwinian era for
over a million years since the time of
homo erectus
but based on what data very little very
little morphology and a lot of guesswork
well what i'm going to talk about today
what i'm going to talk about now is a
new approach to this problem instead of
going out and guessing about our
ancestry digging things up out of the
ground possible ancestors and
saying on the basis of morphology which
we still don't completely understand we
don't know the genetic causes underlying
most
morphological variation what we need to
do is turn the problem on its head
because what we're really
asking is a genealogical problem or a
genealogical question
what we're trying to do is construct a
family tree for everybody alive today
and as any genealogist will tell you
anybody have
member of the family or maybe you've
tried to construct a family tree trace
back in time you start in the present
with relationships you're certain about
you and your sibling share a parent in
common
you and your cousin share a grandparent
and comment and you gradually trace
further and further back into the past
adding these ever more distant
relationships but eventually
no matter how good you are at digging up
the church records and all that stuff
you hit what the genealogists call a
brick wall a point beyond which you
don't know anything else about
your ancestors and you enter this dark
and mysterious realm we call
history that we have to feel our way
through with whispered guidance
who were these people who came before we
have no written record well
actually we do written in our dna in our
genetic code
we have a historical document that takes
us back in time to the very earliest
days of our species
and that's what we study now a quick
primer on dna i suspect
that not everybody in the audience is a
geneticist it is a very long
linear molecule a coded version of how
to make another copy of you it's your
blueprint
it's composed of four subunits a c g and
t we call them and it's the sequence of
those sub units that that defines that
blueprint
how long is it well it's billions of
these subunits in length
a haploid genome we actually have two
copies of all of our chromosomes
haploid genome is around 3.2 billion
nucleotides in length
and the whole thing if you add add it
all together is over 6 billion
nucleotides long if you take all the dna
out of
one cell in your body and stretch it end
to end
it's around 2 meters long if you take
all the dna out of every cell in your
body and you stretch it
end to end it would reach from here to
the moon and back thousands of times
it's a lot of information and so when
you're copying
this dna molecule to pass it on it's a
pretty tough job
imagine the longest book you can think
of war and peace
and now multiply it by a hundred and
imagine copying that by hand
and you're working away until late at
night and you're very very careful
you're drinking coffee and you're paying
attention but occasionally
when you're copying this by hand you're
going to make a little typo a spelling
mistake
substitute an i for an e or a c for a t
same thing happens to our dna as it's
being passed on through the generations
it doesn't happen very often we have a
proofreading mechanism built in
but when it does happen and these
changes get transmitted down through the
generations they become markers of
descent if you share a marker with
someone
it means you share an ancestor at some
point in the past
the person who first had that change in
their dna and it's by looking
at the pattern of genetic variation the
pattern of these markers and people all
over the world
and assessing the relative ages when
they occurred
throughout our history that we've been
able to construct a family tree for
everybody alive today these are two
pieces of dna that we use quite widely
in our work
mitochondrial dna tracing a purely
maternal line of descent you get your mt
dna from your mother and your mother's
mother
all the way back to the very first woman
the y chromosome the piece of dna that
makes men
men traces a purely patronal line of
descent
everybody in this room everybody in the
world
falls into a lineage somewhere on these
trees
now even though these are simplified
versions of the real trees they're still
kind of complicated so let's simplify
them turn them on their sides combine
them so that they look like a tree with
the root at the bottom and the branches
going up
what's the take-home message well the
thing that jumps out at you first is
that the deepest lineages
in our family trees are found within
africa
among africans that means that africans
have been accumulating this mutational
diversity
for longer and what that means is that
we originated
in africa it's written in our dna every
piece of dna we look at
has greater diversity within africa than
outside of africa
and at some point in the past a subgroup
of africans left the african continent
to go out and populate the rest of the
world now how recently do we share this
ancestry was it
millions of years ago which we might
suspect by looking at all this
incredible variation around the world
no the dna tells a story that's very
clear within the last 200 000 years
we all share an ancestor a single person
mitochondrial eve
you might have heard about her in africa
an african woman who gave rise to all
the mitochondrial diversity in the world
today
but what's even more amazing is that if
you look at the y chromosome side
the male side of the story the y
chromosome atom
only lived around 60 000 years ago
that's only about 2 000 human
generations
the blink of an eye in an evolutionary
sense
that tells us we were all still living
in africa at that time
this was an african man who gave rise to
all the y chromosome diversity around
the world
it's only within the last 60 000 years
that we have started to generate this
incredible diversity we see around the
world
such an amazing story we're all
effectively part of an extended african
family
now that seems so recent why didn't we
start to leave
earlier why didn't homo erectus evolve
into separate species or subspecies
rather human races around the world
why was it that we we seem to have come
out of africa so recently
well that's a that's a big question
these why questions particularly
in genetics and the study of history in
general are always the big ones the ones
that are tough to answer and so
when all else fails talk about the
weather
what was going on to the world's weather
around 60 000 years ago well
we were going into the worst part of the
last ice age last ice age started
roughly 120 000 years ago
it went up and down and it really
started to accelerate around 70 000
years ago lots of evidence
from sediment cores and the pollen types
oxygen isotopes and so on
we had the last glacial maximum around
16 000 years ago
but basically from 70 000 years on
things were getting really tough
getting very cold the northern
hemisphere had
massive growing ice sheets new york city
chicago seattle all under a sheet of ice
most of britain all of scandinavia
covered by ice several kilometers thick
now
africa is the most tropical continent on
the planet about 85 percent of it lies
between cancer and capricorn
and there aren't a lot of glaciers here
except in the high mountains here in
east africa
so what was going on here we weren't
covered in ice in africa
rather africa was drying out at that
time this is a paleoclimatological map
of what africa looked like between 60
and 70 000 years ago
reconstructed from all these pieces of
evidence that i mentioned before
the reason for that is that ice actually
sucks moisture out of the atmosphere if
you think about antarctica it's
technically a desert it gets so little
precipitation
so the whole world was drying out the
sea levels were dropping
and africa was turning to desert the
sahara was much bigger then
than it is now and the human habitat was
reduced to just a few small pockets
compared to what we have today the
evidence from genetic data is that the
human population around this time
roughly 70 000 years ago crashed to
fewer than 2
000 individuals we nearly went extinct
we were hanging on
by our fingernails and then something
happened
great illustration of it look at some
stone tools the ones on the left are
from
africa from around a million years ago
the ones on the right
were made by neanderthals our distant
cousins not our direct ancestors
living in europe and they date from
around 50 or 60 000 years ago
now the the risk of offending any
paleoanthropologists or
physical anthropologists in the audience
basically
there's not a lot of change between
these two
stone tool groups ones on the left are
pretty similar to the ones on the right
we are in a period of long
cultural stasis from a million years ago
until around 60 to 70 thousand years ago
the tool styles don't change that much
the evidence is that the human way of
life didn't change that much
during that period but then 50
60 70 000 years ago somewhere in that
region all hell breaks loose
art makes its appearance the stone tools
become much more finely crafted
the evidence is that humans begin to
specialize in particular prey species at
particular times of the year
the population size started to expand
probably according to what many
linguists believe
fully modern language syntactic language
subject verb object that we use to
convey complex ideas
like i'm doing now appeared around that
time we became much more social the
social networks expanded
this change in behavior allowed us to
survive these worsening conditions
in africa and they allowed us to start
to expand
around the world we've been talking at
this conference about african success
stories
well you want the ultimate african
success story look in the mirror
you're it the reason you're alive today
is because of those changes
in our brains that took place in africa
probably somewhere in the region where
we're
sitting right now around 60 70 000 years
ago
allowing us not only to survive in
africa but to expand out of africa in
early coastal migration along the south
coast of asia leaving africa around 60
000 years ago
reaching australia very rapidly by 50
000 years ago
slightly later migration up into the
middle east these would have been
savannah hunters
so those of you who are going on one of
the post-conference tours you'll get to
see what a real savannah is like and
it's basically a meat locker
people who would have specialized in
killing the animals hunting the animals
on
those meat lockers savannahs moving up
following the grasslands into the middle
east around 45 000 years ago
during one of the rare wet phases in the
sahara
migrating eastward following the
grasslands because that's what they were
adapted to live on
and when they reached central asia they
reached what was effectively a step
super highway a grassland superhighway
the grasslands at that time this is
during the last ice age stretched
basically from germany all the way over
to korea
and the entire continent was open to
them entering europe around 35
000 years ago and finally a small group
migrating up through the worst
weather imaginable siberia inside the
arctic circle during the last ice age
temperatures of minus 70 minus 80 even
minus 100 perhaps
migrating into the americas ultimately
reaching that final frontier
an amazing story and it happened first
in africa the changes that allowed us to
do that
the evolution of this highly adaptable
brain that we all carry around with us
allowing us to create novel cultures
allowing us to develop the diversity
that we see on a whirlwind trip like the
one i've just been on
now that story i just told you is
literally
a whirlwind tour of how we populated the
world the great paleolithic wanderings
of our species
and that's the story that i told a
couple of years ago in my book the
journey of man and the film
that we made the same title and
as we were finishing up that film it was
co-produced with national geographic
i started talking to the folks at ng
about this work
and they got really excited about it
they you know
they liked the film but they said you
know we really see this as kind of the
next
wave in the study of human origins where
we all came from
using the tools of dna to uh map the
migrations around the world
you know study of human origins is kind
of in our dna and we want to take it to
the next level what do you want to do
next
which is a great question to be asked by
national geographic
and i said well you know what i've
sketched out here is just that
it is a very coarse sketch of how we
migrated around the planet
and it's based on a few thousand people
we've sampled from
you know a handful of populations around
the world studied a few genetic markers
and there are lots of gaps on this map
we've just connected the dots
what we need to do is increase our
sample size by an order of magnitude or
more
hundreds of thousands of dna samples
from people all over the world
and that was the genesis of the
genographic project
the project launched in april of 2005 it
has three core components
obviously science is a big part of it
the field research that we're doing
around the world with indigenous peoples
people who've lived in the same location
for a long period of time retain a
connection to the place where they live
that many of the rest of us have lost so
my ancestors come from all over northern
europe i live in the eastern seaboard of
north america when i'm not traveling
where am i indigenous to nowhere really
my genes are all jumbled up but there
are people who retain that link to their
ancestors
that allows us to contextualize the dna
results
that's the focus of the field research
centers that we've set up all over the
world 10 of them top population
geneticists
but in addition we wanted to open up
this study to anybody around the world
how often do you get to participate in a
big scientific project
the human genome project or a mars rover
mission in this case you actually can
you can go onto our website
nationalgeographic.com
genographic you can order a kit you can
test your own dna
and you can actually submit those
results to the database and tell us a
little bit about your genealogical
background
have the data analyzed as part of the
scientific effort
now this is all a non-profit enterprise
and so the money that we raise after we
cover the cost of doing the testing and
making the kit components gets plowed
back into the project the majority going
to something we call the legacy fund
it's a charitable entity basically a
grant giving entity that
gives money back to indigenous groups
around the world for educational
cultural projects initiated by them they
apply to this fund
in order to do various projects and i'll
show you a couple of examples
so how are we doing in the project we've
got about 25 000 samples collected from
indigenous people around the world
the most amazing thing has been the
interest on the part of the public 210
000 people have ordered these
participation kits since we launched two
years ago
which has raised around five million
dollars the majority of which
at least half is going back into the
legacy fund we've just awarded the first
legacy grants totaling
around five hundred thousand dollars
projects around the world documenting
world poetry in sierra leone preserving
traditional weaving patterns in gaza
language revitalization in tajikistan
etc etc
so the project is going very very well
and i urge you to check out the website
and
watch this space thank you very much
do
you
do
you
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)