Modern Indian Literature: Know In Art & Culture With Devdutt Pattanaik EP20 | UPSC Essentials

The Indian Express
26 Oct 202321:48

Summary

TLDRThis video script delves into the evolution of modern Indian literature during the colonial era, highlighting the pivotal role of the printing press and the British educational policies in shaping Indian thought. It discusses how literature, including works by women, became a catalyst for social reform and the independence movement, emphasizing the importance of understanding the context and biases in literary sources for a comprehensive view of history and culture.

Takeaways

  • 📚 The script discusses the development of modern Indian literature, which is largely attributed to the arrival of colonial powers and the introduction of the printing press in India.
  • 🌍 The printing press, initially used for religious texts in Europe, was adapted by the British in India to print science and technical books, facilitating the creation of clerks and spreading new ideas.
  • 👥 The script highlights the role of literature in the Indian independence struggle, showing how education and exposure to Western ideas led to the emergence of nationalism and the desire for self-governance.
  • 📖 It emphasizes the importance of considering the author's perspective when studying literature, as biases and the socio-political context can significantly influence the content and interpretation of texts.
  • 👩‍🏫 The script notes the evolution of women's writing in India, from traditional forms to more modern expressions of agency and new ideas, influenced by Western literature and education.
  • 👑 The British policy of educating Indians to serve as clerks inadvertently sparked a revolution in thought, leading to the questioning of the caste system and the promotion of egalitarianism.
  • 📈 The script points out the limitations of literature as a historical source, cautioning against taking literary accounts at face value without corroboration from other disciplines like archaeology or art history.
  • 🤔 It suggests using the '5W1H' approach (Who, What, When, Where, Why, How) to critically analyze literature, considering the author's intent, context, and potential biases.
  • 📝 The discussion underscores the significance of literature in shaping the national movement in India, with various factions using it to express their views on reform, tradition, and social upliftment.
  • 🌐 The script mentions the importance of understanding the structural changes brought by colonial rule, including new technologies and content, which led to shifts in Indian society and mindset.
  • 💡 Lastly, the script encourages students to think critically about literature's role in culture and history, and to be aware of its limitations and the need for cross-disciplinary verification.

Q & A

  • What is 'Sultana's Dream' about?

    -'Sultana's Dream' is a fantasy written by Begum Rokeya Sakhawat Hossain in the 19th century. It envisions a world where women run all affairs and men live secluded lives.

  • How did the arrival of European powers impact Indian literature in the colonial period?

    -The arrival of European powers, particularly the British, introduced the printing press and education, leading to the spread of new ideas, technologies, and subjects such as science and mathematics. This shift helped propel the modern literary movement in India.

  • What role did the printing press play in the development of modern Indian literature?

    -The printing press, introduced by the Portuguese for missionary work and later used by the British to produce textbooks and technical books, was crucial in spreading education and new ideas. This led to a literary revolution in India by making knowledge accessible to a wider audience.

  • How did literature contribute to India's independence struggle?

    -Literature played a significant role by spreading nationalist ideas and awareness about social and political issues. Newspapers and writings by figures like Surendranath Banerjee and Bal Gangadhar Tilak helped foster a sense of nationalism and resistance against British rule.

  • What impact did British education policies have on Indian society?

    -British education policies aimed at creating clerks, but they also exposed Indians to new ideas about humanism, equality, democracy, and other Western philosophies. This led to social reforms, greater educational opportunities for different classes and castes, and a burgeoning sense of nationalism.

  • How did women's education and writing evolve during the colonial period in India?

    -With the spread of education, initially among elite women and later among lower classes, women began to express their ideas and experiences through literature. They wrote about social issues, gender equality, and personal aspirations, contributing significantly to the cultural and intellectual landscape.

  • Can you name some notable women writers from pre-colonial and colonial India?

    -Notable women writers include Andal and Mirabai from ancient times, Muddupalani from the 17th century, and Rasundari Devi and Begum Rokeya Sakhawat Hossain from the colonial period.

  • What are the limitations of using literature as a source to understand history and culture?

    -Literature can reflect the biases and perspectives of its authors, who often belong to privileged classes or groups. It's important to corroborate literary sources with other types of evidence, such as archaeological findings, epigraphy, and material culture, to get a more accurate picture.

  • How did Indian writers react to British racial policies and discrimination?

    -Indian writers, like Surendranath Banerjee, often highlighted racial discrimination and second-class treatment by the British. Their writings and actions fostered a sense of nationalism and the demand for equal rights and self-governance.

  • What new ideas and philosophies influenced Indian literature during the colonial period?

    -Ideas and philosophies such as humanism, equality, democracy, the French and American Revolutions, and Western scientific and technical knowledge significantly influenced Indian literature, contributing to social reform and political awakening.

Outlines

00:00

📚 The Emergence of Modern Indian Literature

The first paragraph discusses the development of modern Indian literature influenced by the arrival of colonial powers and the introduction of the printing press. It highlights the shift from religious texts to scientific and secular writings aimed at creating clerks, which led to a broader education and literacy among different social classes. The paragraph also emphasizes the importance of literature in expressing women's agency and the impact of new ideas from the West on Indian thought during the colonial period.

05:01

🌟 Literature's Role in India's Freedom Struggle

This paragraph explores the significant role of literature in India's struggle for independence. It explains how the British introduced education and the printing press to create clerks, but this inadvertently led to the spread of new ideas and the emergence of nationalism among the educated Indian population. The paragraph also touches on the social and political movements that arose from the educated class, including the works of social reformers and the polarization between reformists and traditionalists.

10:02

👩‍💼 Women's Writing in Modern India

The third paragraph focuses on the evolution of women's writing in India during the colonial era. It discusses how the spread of education among women led to new forms of literary expression and the emergence of women's voices in literature. The paragraph mentions the first Indian women poets and writers who expressed their aspirations and experiences, challenging traditional roles and contributing to the discourse on gender equality and societal norms.

15:03

🤔 Understanding Literature's Limitations

In this paragraph, the limitations of literature as a historical and cultural source are examined. It cautions readers to be aware of the biases and perspectives of the authors, and the importance of considering who, when, where, and for what purpose a piece of literature was written. The paragraph also underscores the need to corroborate literary evidence with other forms of evidence, such as archaeology and art history, to gain a more accurate understanding of the past.

20:05

🔍 The Importance of Source Collaboration in Literature Study

The final paragraph emphasizes the importance of using a collaborative approach when studying literature. It suggests applying the 'five Ws' (Who, What, When, Where, Why, and How) to systematically analyze literature and understand its context. The paragraph concludes by encouraging students to engage with the material, ask questions, and seek a comprehensive understanding of literature's role in shaping culture and history.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Colonial Period

The colonial period refers to the era during which European powers, such as the British, established control over India, significantly influencing its culture, literature, and society. In the video, the colonial period is highlighted as a time when new technologies like the printing press were introduced, leading to the development of modern Indian literature and shaping the mindset of the Indian people.

💡Printing Press

The printing press is a technology for printing text and images, which revolutionized the dissemination of knowledge. In the script, it is noted that the printing press facilitated the spread of literature and education in India during the colonial period, playing a crucial role in the development of modern Indian literature and the Indian independence movement.

💡Modern Indian Literature

Modern Indian literature refers to the body of literary works produced in India after the advent of colonial rule, marked by the introduction of new ideas and the use of the printing press. The video discusses how this literature was influenced by Western thought and played a significant role in the social and political awakening of India.

💡Cultural Expression

Cultural expression in this context refers to the manifestation of ideas, beliefs, and values through various forms of art and literature. The video emphasizes how women, for instance, began to express themselves and their agency through writing during the colonial period, challenging traditional norms and contributing to the evolution of Indian society.

💡Sultana's Dream

Sultana's Dream is a feminist fantasy story written by Begum Rokeya Sakhawat Hossain in the 19th century. The video uses it as an example of the new forms of writing that emerged during the colonial period, reflecting the aspirations and imaginations of women in a society that was undergoing significant changes.

💡Education

Education is the process of acquiring knowledge, skills, values, and habits. In the script, the British are credited with introducing widespread education in India, which was initially aimed at creating clerks but eventually led to a broader social and political awakening, including the rise of nationalism and the independence movement.

💡Nationalism

Nationalism is the sentiment of loyalty and devotion to one's nation. The video discusses how the spread of education and exposure to Western ideas fostered a sense of nationalism among the Indian population, leading to the desire for self-governance and the eventual struggle for independence.

💡Social Reform

Social reform refers to changes aimed at improving society by addressing issues such as inequality, injustice, and outdated traditions. The script mentions social reformers like Raja Ram Mohan Roy who advocated for changes in Hinduism and the upliftment of women's status, reflecting the transformative impact of literature on Indian society.

💡Literary Movement

A literary movement is a group of writers who share a common goal or aesthetic. The video describes the modern literary movement in India as being propelled by the British, which shifted the focus from religious texts to scientific, secular, and mathematical writings, thereby creating a more educated populace and influencing societal change.

💡Women's Writing

Women's writing refers to the literary works produced by women, reflecting their perspectives and experiences. The script highlights the emergence of women's writing during the colonial period, which contributed to the empowerment of women and the introduction of new ideas about gender equality and women's rights in Indian society.

💡Bias in Literature

Bias in literature refers to the personal or cultural prejudices of the author that may influence the content and perspective of the work. The video cautions about the importance of understanding the limitations of literature as a source, including the biases that authors bring to their writing, and the need to corroborate literary accounts with other forms of evidence.

Highlights

Sultana's Dream, a 19th-century fantasy by Rokeya Sakhawat Hossain, imagines a world where women are in charge and men live secluded lives, reflecting the emerging female agency of the time.

The arrival of the colonial powers in India, particularly the British, brought the printing press, which was pivotal in the development of modern Indian literature.

The British used the printing press to reproduce scientific and technical books, creating a need for educated clerks and propelling the modern literary movement in India.

The printing press's introduction to India bypassed the Ottoman Empire, contributing to the Islamic world's lag in modernity.

Literature and education under colonial rule led to a social revolution, with education becoming accessible across different castes and classes.

Thomas Babington Macaulay's educational policy aimed to create Indians who thought like Europeans but retained their Indian identity.

Modern Indian literature was significantly influenced by new ideas such as humanism, equality, and the rise of democracies, introduced through Western education.

The educated class in colonial India, initially created to serve as clerks, became the bedrock of the Indian independence movement.

Surendra Nath Banerji's experiences with racial discrimination in the civil service sparked his advocacy for nationalism and Indian self-governance.

The emergence of newspapers in various Indian languages facilitated the spread of nationalist ideas and the awakening of political consciousness.

Rabindranath Tagore and Dadabhai Naoroji were among the influential figures who contributed to the shaping of modern Indian literature and nationalism.

The polarization between reformists and traditionalists in the 19th century shaped the political discourse and the national movement in India.

Women's writing in modern India, such as Rokeya Sakhawat Hossain's work, signifies the empowerment and the expression of female agency.

Education and literature in colonial India led to the emergence of women as poets, writers, and public intellectuals, challenging traditional roles.

Rasri Devi's autobiography, 'Amar Jiban', exemplifies the aspirations of women who balanced traditional roles with the pursuit of education and self-expression.

The limitations of literature as a historical source must be considered, including author biases, the context of writing, and the need for corroboration with other evidence.

The importance of cross-referencing literary sources with archaeological, artistic, and material evidence for a comprehensive understanding of history and culture.

The application of the five W's (Who, What, When, Where, Why) approach to critically analyze literature and understand its context and impact.

Transcripts

play00:00

[Music]

play00:00

beam shavat husse who writes um

play00:03

sultana's dream and it's a fantasy about

play00:06

a world where women run all the when

play00:09

women run the Affairs of and Men live

play00:10

secluded lives this is being written in

play00:12

the 19th century so you have these new

play00:15

writings emerging in the 19th century

play00:16

and women are coming out uh and

play00:19

expressing themselves expressing their

play00:21

agency so on this topic of literature

play00:24

and culture we have reached to a point

play00:26

where we are now going to talk about the

play00:28

Modern India or the colonial period

play00:32

let's know more in our today's episode

play00:34

of art and culture with d patnayak

play00:38

[Applause]

play00:40

[Music]

play00:43

hello everyone I am mana sastav and you

play00:46

are watching upsc Essentials of the

play00:48

Indian Express where like always we are

play00:51

in conversation with davat patnayak d

play00:54

that talks about art and culture and

play00:56

those relevant topics which are

play00:58

important for your exams but also life

play01:01

in general so in the previous episodes

play01:04

you've seen that we've covered

play01:06

literature and culture and we have

play01:08

talked about ancient India the medial

play01:11

India and today we're going to talk

play01:13

about Modern India or the the colonial

play01:16

times so D that let's begin with a very

play01:19

General yet very important question that

play01:22

how this modern Indian literature

play01:24

developed in India and really this is

play01:27

the result of the arrival of colonial

play01:29

power into India that is European pass

play01:32

so the Portuguese came to India in the

play01:34

16th century followed by the Dutch and

play01:38

then the French and the English they all

play01:40

came to India in the 17th century 18th

play01:43

century and with them came new

play01:45

technologies the technology which came

play01:47

with them was the printing press

play01:49

remember the printing press was invented

play01:51

in China about 2000 years ago but about

play01:55

500 years ago in the 15th century it

play01:57

reaches Europe and the uh the Europeans

play02:00

really use the printing press to uh

play02:03

print the Bible and the Bible gets

play02:05

accessible to everybody in Europe uh and

play02:08

that creates a huge social revolution in

play02:11

Europe and then the printing press in

play02:13

the 16th century just barely 100 years

play02:15

after that comes to India on its way to

play02:18

Africa but remains in Goa for some

play02:19

reason and this is when the Bible starts

play02:23

being printed in India and really by

play02:26

missionaries uh to promote missionary

play02:28

work in the the 17th century you find

play02:32

this in Goa you find

play02:35

um Bible being translated into conani

play02:38

it's called the kristap puran in conani

play02:41

and basically printing was used to

play02:43

missionary work by the Portuguese people

play02:46

in the 16th century but when the British

play02:48

come they do something different they

play02:50

realize that they want clerks they want

play02:52

babo and therefore they want to start

play02:55

schools in India and therefore the

play02:57

printing press is used to reproduce

play02:59

science

play03:00

uh text books in India um so technical

play03:03

books science books start appearing in

play03:05

India they're printed in Kolkata in

play03:08

alabad in lakau in the 19th century so

play03:10

suddenly the printing press and the so

play03:14

the the technology of the printing press

play03:16

and the shift in focus from religion and

play03:20

conversion to um science and language

play03:24

and Mathematics to create clerks by the

play03:28

British is what really propels the

play03:31

modern literary movement in India

play03:33

remember the printing press was not

play03:35

allowed to uh enter the Ottoman Empire

play03:39

one of the reasons why uh the Islamic

play03:41

World fell back in the world of

play03:44

modernity so from Europe it came to

play03:46

India but it bypassed the Muslim world

play03:48

the ottoman World Egypt Persia Iran Iraq

play03:53

turkey all these places where the

play03:55

ottoman Empires safaid Empires existed

play03:58

they did not like the pr press because

play04:00

they thought the calligraphers would

play04:02

lose their jobs and because of that

play04:04

knowledge remained limited because when

play04:06

you write it down calligraphy it's only

play04:08

available for the elite but when the

play04:10

printing technology comes to India one

play04:12

the technology two the content moves

play04:14

from religious to Scientific secular

play04:16

mathematical writings purpose is

play04:19

different not to convert people but to

play04:20

create clerks um something shifts in

play04:23

society no now people are educated men

play04:26

are educated women are educated upper

play04:28

class men are educated low world class

play04:30

men educated different casts are

play04:31

educated and that creates a revolution

play04:34

that's how uh modern literature began in

play04:37

India so you have to understand these

play04:39

structural changes that happened with

play04:41

the new rulers of India bringing new

play04:44

technology bringing new content bringing

play04:46

new subjects into India and that changes

play04:49

the mindset of course we always talk

play04:50

about m in 1835 his minutes about how he

play04:53

wanted Indians to be look like Indians

play04:56

but think like Europeans to serve as

play04:58

Clerks and we can get very angry with

play05:00

this but really this sort of sparked a

play05:02

revolution in Indian thought because we

play05:04

got access to new ways of thinking new

play05:07

knowledge new skills maths science

play05:10

literature new ways of looking at the

play05:12

world new philosophies like humanism

play05:14

equality

play05:15

egalitarianism um new ideas came into

play05:18

India in the schools and colleges people

play05:20

were talking about the French Revolution

play05:22

the American Revolution egality um the

play05:25

end of monarchies the rise of

play05:27

democracies all this shaped modern

play05:30

literature so in this answer of D we get

play05:34

to know about the causes the impact the

play05:38

significance so all three aspects of

play05:41

what is expected in an answer in in in

play05:45

one go in one package so uh that way it

play05:48

is very very uh important and also

play05:52

remember that you know when we talking

play05:53

about how the literature developed

play05:56

modern literature we're talking about

play05:58

technology we're also talking about the

play06:00

content of the text we also talking

play06:02

about the British rule and now speaking

play06:04

about the British rule if DAV that you

play06:06

can elaborate for our students that how

play06:10

uh you know this this modern Indian

play06:12

literature played such an important

play06:14

significant role in The Independent

play06:17

struggle so how did literature play an

play06:20

role in the India's Freedom struggle

play06:22

right um the British sort of introduced

play06:24

education into India it was a shift in

play06:27

policy from what the Portuguese were

play06:28

doing they interested in printing press

play06:32

for missionary activities but the

play06:34

British brought the printing press and

play06:35

education into India and schools and uh

play06:38

in order to create clerks

play06:41

now as time progressed more and more

play06:44

clerks came into so the lot of Education

play06:46

happened lots of people were being

play06:48

educated and they were being exposed not

play06:50

only to maths and science but also to

play06:52

new ideas that were emerging in the west

play06:55

and you have um a gentleman like

play06:57

Surendra Nat banerji who was is an IC

play07:00

Indian civil servant uh but you find him

play07:02

in trouble like he is uh at first he's

play07:05

not given admission uh into the Civil

play07:08

Service on grounds of his age and then

play07:11

he's kicked out uh considering that he's

play07:13

not good enough you know basically for

play07:14

racial grounds he's kicked out of the

play07:16

Civil Service he gets very angry and he

play07:17

realizes that he'll always be a second

play07:20

class person although British talk about

play07:23

equality really Indians will be second

play07:25

and he starts talking about nationalism

play07:27

and the idea of nationhood starts to

play07:29

emerge amongst these educated people

play07:32

that the British created for clerks and

play07:34

that's how the literary Mission starts

play07:37

but people start writing and they start

play07:39

producing newspapers so you have Bengali

play07:42

newspapers and marati newspapers like TR

play07:44

starts caser in Maharashtra you have

play07:47

newspapers uh appearing in uh Bengal you

play07:51

have English papers appearing newspapers

play07:54

knowledge being spread people having

play07:56

opinions about social matters and

play07:58

gradually the idea of nationalism

play08:00

becomes important you have tagore

play08:02

writing about nationalism you have Dad

play08:04

naroi writing about the drain of wealth

play08:06

Theory um you have uh so you see the the

play08:11

knowledge which came into India with the

play08:13

new uh British rule um the literature

play08:16

which came into India the education

play08:18

system which came into India was

play08:19

primarily meant to create clerks but it

play08:21

had two major impacts one was a social

play08:24

impact people said that everybody should

play08:26

be educated upper class lower class

play08:28

upper class lower cast uh across

play08:31

religions women should be educated so

play08:33

there was a social movement that was

play08:34

happening but at the same time a

play08:36

political movement also emerged people

play08:38

started realizing about racism how they

play08:41

would always be treated as second class

play08:42

citizens by the rulers of the land the

play08:45

idea of nationhood emerged the idea of

play08:47

democracy Liberation equality emerged

play08:50

these ideas of Justice emerged uh many

play08:53

of the Indians were trained as lawyers

play08:55

um they studied the law and then they

play08:57

challenged the racial presumption of the

play08:59

law and this is how uh the independence

play09:02

movement started you have one group of

play09:05

what is called the social reformers who

play09:07

spoke about nationalism but you also

play09:09

have traditionalists who spoke about

play09:11

nationalism so if rajar Raman Roy was a

play09:14

social reformer who spoke about Hinduism

play09:16

in the early part of the 18th century

play09:18

but the latter part of early part of the

play09:20

19th century uh in the latter part of

play09:23

the 19th century you have Chandra Nat

play09:25

Basu uh talking about traditionalism and

play09:27

using the word hindutva for the first

play09:30

time which Savar uses later in the early

play09:32

20th century so you have even at the

play09:35

early stage as political movement

play09:37

emerged the polarization between those

play09:40

who say the new India should have

play09:41

reformist ideas social upliftment and

play09:45

the traditionalists who believe that

play09:47

India should go back to the old ways of

play09:49

varash Dharma which was perfect in its

play09:52

way and women's education was not

play09:53

necessary we forget that tur was against

play09:56

women's education he believed in swaja

play09:58

he believed in self rule he uh so you

play10:01

have these new ideas emerging and that's

play10:03

how the literature the caser newspaper

play10:05

emerges which talks about nationalism at

play10:07

one level but it also says that women

play10:09

should not be educated and uh it talks

play10:12

it favors cast and says about how

play10:15

brahmans should uh get certain benefits

play10:17

and non- bramman shouldn't so you have

play10:19

the tiux writings on this but you have

play10:21

this counter movements by uh rades and

play10:23

golay who say that no India should

play10:25

progress India should transform uh new

play10:28

ideas should come in we should talk

play10:29

about liberalism so all this is

play10:30

happening in the 19th century Which

play10:32

shapes the national movement in India

play10:36

thank you D I think uh this is a very

play10:38

important question which is answered not

play10:40

only because of its content but also uh

play10:43

its relevance in the examination because

play10:47

there's one thing that a question can be

play10:49

directly asked on literature then you

play10:52

have to definitely write about

play10:54

literature uh role literature's role in

play10:57

modern Indian period or indep dependent

play10:59

struggle but also when a question comes

play11:01

on the Freedom Movement or independent

play11:02

struggle even then you have to have at

play11:05

least one paragraph on the role of

play11:06

literature and printing press so things

play11:10

can be directly asked and used or it

play11:13

have to be indirectly you know mentioned

play11:16

as the F of your answer so that way uh

play11:20

these things have to be kept in mind and

play11:23

make sure that you make them a part of

play11:25

your notes and then final answers in

play11:28

your examination

play11:30

now having said that let's move on to

play11:32

the next question and the next question

play11:33

is related to women writing um

play11:38

literature so they that if you can throw

play11:40

light on uh what and how and who among

play11:45

women wrote uh in Indian literature in

play11:48

the modern period so women's writing in

play11:51

India now this becomes interesting it's

play11:53

not that women did not write before uh

play11:56

the British came to India there is a lot

play11:58

of women's right writings in India

play12:00

before uh in ancient times for example

play12:02

you have andal writing bti poetry you

play12:03

have mirabai writing bti poetry um you

play12:06

have a Coran called mudal writing

play12:10

radhika Sanam in ra rather erotic work

play12:14

uh in the 17th century and this is

play12:17

printed by another corisan called

play12:19

Bangalore ratama in the 19th century

play12:21

which creates a huge outrage uh uh in

play12:24

India but you know you have these

play12:25

women's writings happening before um

play12:28

there is um Raman chandra's Raman

play12:32

written by women there are women bti

play12:35

poets like mtab by janabai um so women

play12:38

were writing before but a new form of

play12:41

writing emerges with with the in

play12:44

colonial times as education reaches

play12:46

India and education at first is

play12:48

available only to Elite women so the

play12:51

zamidar the rich men they have these

play12:53

governances educating women in their

play12:55

houses the kings are allowing uh

play12:58

governors to teach writing and reading

play13:00

to the women of the palace so it's a

play13:02

class thing but missionaries meanwhile

play13:05

are also spreading education in the

play13:07

lower casts and lower classes and you

play13:09

have savitri b f j f in Maharashtra

play13:12

talking about how um everybody should be

play13:15

educated not just the elite classes not

play13:17

the traditionally educated people uh not

play13:20

just the brahmins and the kest but

play13:21

everyone should be educated so women

play13:23

should be educated and so suddenly

play13:24

women's education is becoming important

play13:26

at a social level so it's not just class

play13:29

women but also lower class women in the

play13:31

18th century women start reading novels

play13:34

and when novels is you know Jane

play13:35

Austin's novels these novels start

play13:37

reaching India and these educated women

play13:39

start reading these books and their mind

play13:41

starts to get new ideas they start

play13:43

talking about gender equality

play13:45

opportunities age of consent when should

play13:47

you marry do you have right to say uh

play13:50

you know uh no to your husband these

play13:53

ideas start emerging in India and you

play13:56

have um women writing novels

play13:59

and this creates uh changes the way uh

play14:03

you know um uh India functions uh

play14:07

because women start having opinions so

play14:09

you have uh you know one of the earliest

play14:11

uh Indian women poet is a lady called um

play14:16

so you have tat uh the India's first uh

play14:20

poetist who writes in English um then um

play14:25

rasra Devi writes Amar jivan her

play14:27

autobiography where she talks about how

play14:29

she has 12 children and when she has

play14:31

free time from doing household shows she

play14:34

educates herself and therefore this idea

play14:36

of aspirational women who follow their

play14:38

traditional roles they mothers they take

play14:40

care of the house but they also want to

play14:41

educate themselves so you have uh rasri

play14:44

Davi writing Amar Jan in Bengali writing

play14:47

about a biography so suddenly women are

play14:49

expressing themselves um you have

play14:53

um beam shikat Hussein who writes um

play14:57

sultana's dream and it's a fantasy about

play15:00

a world where women run all the when

play15:03

women run the Affairs of and Men live

play15:04

secluded lives this is being written in

play15:06

the 19th century so you have these new

play15:09

writings emerging in the 19th century

play15:10

and women are coming out uh and

play15:13

expressing themselves expressing their

play15:15

agency and new ideas emerging there is

play15:18

uh there are women who are educating as

play15:20

doctors um you have cases uh they're

play15:24

becoming lawyers these ideas are

play15:26

emerging and that starts happening in

play15:28

the 19th century because of education so

play15:30

a lot of things get cleared Crystal

play15:33

cleared by that answer of D so women's

play15:37

uh writing uh during the Modern India

play15:39

period uh is not just limited to

play15:42

understand the empowerment of women but

play15:45

also from the perspective of what it's

play15:48

contributing so in terms of new ideas uh

play15:52

helping us to understand Society uh

play15:54

history culture and so on and definitely

play15:58

remember

play15:59

the names which are very important for

play16:02

your answers in your Mains or as for for

play16:05

your prelims the questions which are

play16:07

framed around them now let's move on to

play16:09

the last question and today's last

play16:12

question is uh D that I want to talk

play16:14

about literature as source so we have

play16:17

seen um such all you know wonderful

play16:20

things about literature understanding

play16:21

literature how should we go about it

play16:24

what is the content uh but at the same

play16:27

time this these literature have some

play16:29

caveats they have some limitations so

play16:32

why is it important to understand those

play16:33

limitations what are those limitations

play16:36

if you can tell our students so um

play16:39

literature is a very important source of

play16:42

understanding culture and history but we

play16:44

have to be a little careful because

play16:46

remember uh when I'm writing something I

play16:48

use my imagination and I can write

play16:51

anything I want and therefore biases

play16:53

come in bigotry comes in uh so for

play16:57

example most of the Vic literature the

play16:59

shastra literature is written by

play17:00

brahmins and Brahman men and therefore

play17:02

the privilege they give themselves a

play17:04

privileged position that brahans are the

play17:05

most important people men are important

play17:07

than women so we must always ask the

play17:10

question who is writing this and when

play17:12

are they writing it and where are they

play17:13

writing it who is writing when is he

play17:15

writing where is he writing and for what

play17:17

benefit is he writing so therefore when

play17:19

you read a piece of literature if you

play17:20

ask these questions you understand a lot

play17:23

about that uh culture uh it's also

play17:26

important like if a man is writing he'll

play17:27

write differently when a woman is

play17:28

writing differently if uh Greeks are

play17:31

writing about India it's going to be

play17:32

very different than Indians writing

play17:33

about India when Chinese write about

play17:35

India they bring their own biases into

play17:37

the picture when Buddhists write about

play17:38

India they bring a different view the

play17:41

brahans write a different view when a

play17:43

dalit writes about India he writes a

play17:45

very different view um uh when you read

play17:48

a Brahman document which says that

play17:50

Buddha and the tankar rishabha are

play17:53

avatars of Vishnu you don't take them

play17:54

literally you understand that there is a

play17:56

politics going on an appropriate is

play17:58

going on there is a conflict happening

play18:01

when you hear stories of shankaraya for

play18:04

example written in the 15th century you

play18:06

have got this Sanskrit work which talks

play18:08

about how shankaracharya defeats

play18:10

Buddhist Scholars you have to counter it

play18:12

with taran's writing in the 16th century

play18:14

Buddhist scholar who talks about how

play18:16

Shankar aara is defeated by Buddhists

play18:18

now which is true which is true did

play18:20

shankaracharya defeat the Buddhist as

play18:21

per the Brahman documents but the

play18:23

Buddhist documents say that the

play18:24

shankaracharya was defeated by the

play18:26

Buddhist so now you have two pieces of

play18:27

literature which one do you trust um and

play18:31

that's important kerol Pati is a work

play18:35

written in the 17th century which tells

play18:36

the history of Kerala in a very

play18:38

organized way and it says how pararam

play18:40

brought um brahans to Kerala and

play18:44

civilize the land now uh is it history

play18:47

or is it just fantasy or is it a way of

play18:51

justifying Brahman control of lands in

play18:53

Kerala so literature has to be read very

play18:56

carefully who is writing the story when

play18:58

is is he writing where is he writing for

play19:00

what is he writing and we must

play19:01

collaborate written sources with other

play19:04

information uh epigraphic evidence

play19:07

architecture art um material evidence is

play19:11

very very important for example the Vic

play19:13

literature is oral Traditions but we

play19:15

don't have much material evidence about

play19:17

it so when they are talking about it the

play19:19

only information we have is that in the

play19:21

gtic plane these po these poetries are

play19:24

being written but if they talk about

play19:26

palaces but we don't get any evidence of

play19:28

a palace as per archaeology then did

play19:30

palaces exist really or in the

play19:32

imagination of these poets so when you

play19:35

study literature it's important they

play19:37

give you a window to the Past a window

play19:39

to our culture how human beings not just

play19:42

created the world but also how they

play19:44

imagined the world but we have to always

play19:48

corroborate this information from texts

play19:51

by other uh other subjects like as I

play19:54

said archaeology art history now DNA

play19:57

studies are telling us some things we

play19:58

have to study that so lots of things

play20:00

have to be collaborated to make sense of

play20:03

what is written thank you D for

play20:05

mentioning that collaboration of sources

play20:08

um which is very important and students

play20:11

should know that even in history when we

play20:13

study history we have so many sources

play20:16

and their collaboration becomes uh so

play20:19

important at the same time when you are

play20:21

talking about how to ask literature

play20:24

questions okay so I'm reminded of this

play20:27

five W1 of approach in journalism and so

play20:30

I ask a lot of students to follow this 5

play20:33

W1 Edge approach while studying current

play20:35

affairs also so five ws what when

play20:39

where uh who and then there is of course

play20:44

how so this makes understanding of uh

play20:48

current affairs quite systematic and

play20:50

simple now I believe we've covered

play20:55

almost every aspect of literature and

play20:57

culture in these past three four

play20:59

episodes uh students can write to us uh

play21:03

they can mail me on Manus Shasta at

play21:06

indianexpress.com or you can comment in

play21:09

the comment section of the YouTube uh

play21:12

please subscribe the indianexpress

play21:14

channel or the page of the YouTube and

play21:17

U uh do connect me connect with me on

play21:21

live on the live session at 8:00

play21:25

p.m. every every Thursday that's all for

play21:28

today thank you Dad for enlightening our

play21:30

students on this vast vast topic and uh

play21:34

always remember think smart work hard

play21:38

conquer your goal bye-bye Mana shast

play21:41

signing

play21:46

off

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Indian LiteratureColonial EraCultural ShiftPrinting PressSocial ReformIndependence StruggleWomen WritersModern IndiaEducation ImpactLiterary Analysis