Which Is Better ? Investing In Dollars v/s INRFind Answer Here

NRI Money Clinic
14 Jun 202420:57

Summary

TLDRIn this episode of 'NRI Money Clinic', Dr. Chandra Khan addresses the dilemma faced by Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) on whether to invest their dollar earnings back home in INR or in the developed world. He explores historical trends, current economic factors like inflation, current account deficit, and FDI flows, to provide insights on currency exchange rates and investment decisions. Khan also discusses investment motives, including speculation, interest rate differences, and need-based factors, and outlines various investment routes available to NRIs in India.

Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ˜€ NRI Money Clinic aims to help non-resident Indians (NRIs) decide whether to invest in dollars or Indian rupees.
  • ๐Ÿ’ต The strength and international acceptance of the US dollar make it an attractive currency for investment.
  • ๐ŸŒ The US economy's significant role in global market capitalization justifies the preference for holding dollars.
  • ๐Ÿ  NRIs may invest in India due to personal ties, potential for higher returns, and higher interest rates on rupee deposits.
  • ๐Ÿ“‰ Historically, the Indian rupee has depreciated against the dollar, but this is not a constant daily occurrence.
  • ๐Ÿ”„ Currency exchange rates are dynamic and can fluctuate, affecting the value of investments in different currencies.
  • ๐Ÿ“ˆ The Indian rupee has periods of appreciation against the dollar, contrary to the common perception of constant depreciation.
  • ๐Ÿ’ผ Factors influencing rupee depreciation include inflation differential, current account deficit, and defense procurements.
  • ๐Ÿ’น The flow of dollars into and out of India can impact the rupee's value, with recent trends showing increased FDI and remittances favoring the rupee.
  • ๐Ÿฆ Interest rate differentials between FCNR and INR deposits have narrowed, reducing the advantage of one over the other.
  • ๐Ÿข NRIs have various investment options in India, including FDs, bonds, mutual funds, PMS, and insurance plans, with some requiring large minimum investments.

Q & A

  • What is the main dilemma faced by Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) when managing their earnings in dollars?

    -The main dilemma faced by NRIs is deciding whether to invest their earnings in dollars in the developed world or to invest the money back home in Indian Rupees (INR).

  • Why do people have an affinity for holding dollars?

    -People have an affinity for holding dollars due to its strength as an international currency, its acceptance worldwide, and the fact that the US economy constitutes about one-third of the world's market capitalization.

  • What are the historical trends of the Indian Rupee's value against the dollar?

    -Historically, the Indian Rupee has depreciated against the dollar over decades. For example, in 1979, 1 US dollar was equivalent to about 12-15 Indian Rupees, whereas today it is around 83 Indian Rupees.

  • Why might the Indian Rupee appreciate or depreciate against the dollar?

    -The Indian Rupee can appreciate or depreciate against the dollar due to factors such as inflation differentials between the US and India, current account deficit, defense-related procurements, and the flow of dollars into or out of the country.

  • What are the three primary reasons for the Indian Rupee's depreciation against the dollar?

    -The three primary reasons for the Indian Rupee's depreciation against the dollar are inflation differences between the US and India, current account deficit, and defense-related procurements.

  • How has the Indian government been addressing the issue of current account deficit?

    -The Indian government has been focusing on renewable energy and energy efficiency to reduce dependence on oil imports, which are a significant factor in the current account deficit. They have also introduced sovereign gold funds to reduce gold imports and the spending of dollars.

  • What is the impact of FDI on the Indian Rupee's value?

    -Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in India is currently very high, which is favorable for the Indian Rupee as it represents a steady inflow of dollars into the country, potentially leading to the appreciation of the currency.

  • What are the three major reasons people invest in either rupees or dollars?

    -People invest in either rupees or dollars for speculative reasons, the potential for higher returns through interest or growth in a particular country, and need-based reasons such as having a specific financial commitment in a particular currency.

  • How has the differential between FCNR interest rates and INR interest rates changed recently?

    -The differential between FCNR interest rates and INR interest rates has become extremely narrow recently, with both rates being almost similar due to the inflation differential between the US and India narrowing down.

  • What are the different ways NRIs can invest in India without bringing their money into the country?

    -NRIs can invest in India without bringing their money into the country through Foreign Portfolio Investment Route (FPI), which may come via Mauritius or Bermuda, or through Gift City in Gujarat. They can also invest in ETFs and mutual funds dedicated to India from their own country.

Outlines

00:00

๐Ÿ“ˆ Understanding the Dilemma of NRIs: Investing in Dollars vs. INR

In this episode, Dr. Chandra Khan explores the perennial dilemma faced by NRIs: whether to invest their earnings in dollars within developed markets or in Indian national rupees (INR). The episode aims to provide clarity and guidance on making this crucial financial decision. The importance of understanding the strength of the dollar, the benefits of investing in India, and the fluctuating currency exchange rates are discussed.

05:02

๐Ÿ’ต The Allure and Strength of the Dollar

NRIs often prefer holding onto dollars due to its strength and global acceptance. The US economy's robustness and the international trade dominance of the dollar justify this preference. However, the decision to invest in India is driven by personal ties, potential retirement plans, and higher interest rates on INR deposits. The fluctuating exchange rate, which can either depreciate or appreciate, plays a significant role in these investment decisions.

10:03

๐Ÿ“‰ Historical Perspective on Rupee Depreciation

Over the decades, the Indian rupee has depreciated against the dollar, a trend influenced by higher inflation rates in India compared to the US. Dr. Khan explains that despite periods of rupee appreciation, the general trend has been downward. He emphasizes the importance of understanding this dynamic when making investment decisions, noting that factors like inflation differentials and current account deficits contribute to this trend.

15:06

๐Ÿ“Š Inflation and Its Impact on Currency Value

Inflation rates between countries significantly affect currency values. Historically, India's higher inflation compared to the US has led to rupee depreciation. However, current inflation rates in India and the US are similar, potentially stabilizing the rupee. The discussion includes the implications of current account deficits and how government actions to reduce dependence on oil imports and boost renewable energy can influence the rupee's value.

20:08

๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ Reducing India's Dependence on Imports

India's efforts to reduce its current account deficit involve focusing on renewable energy and reducing gold and defense imports. Government initiatives to produce defense equipment domestically and promote sovereign gold bonds aim to decrease the outflow of dollars, which can stabilize or appreciate the rupee. Dr. Khan highlights the importance of these measures in strengthening India's economy and currency.

๐ŸŒ The Impact of Foreign Direct Investment

Foreign direct investment (FDI) plays a crucial role in the flow of dollars into India. The increasing FDI in India, which is now higher than in many other countries, positively impacts the rupee. Dr. Khan explains that FDI is a 'sticky' investment, meaning it stays in the country long-term, contributing to economic growth and currency stability. He also mentions the significant remittances from NRIs, further strengthening the rupee.

๐Ÿ“‰ Speculative Investments and Interest Rate Differences

Investors consider speculative needs, interest rate differences, and specific financial goals when deciding whether to invest in dollars or INR. While the Indian stock market has historically offered better returns than the US market, short-term movements can be unpredictable. The narrowing interest rate differential between FCNR (foreign currency non-resident) deposits and INR FDs makes it essential to consider potential rupee depreciation when making investment decisions.

๐Ÿ’ฐ Balancing Currency Exposure Based on Needs

NRIs often maintain currency exposure based on personal financial needs, such as repaying loans in dollars or saving for children's education abroad. Tax benefits in countries like the US, Australia, and Singapore also influence investment decisions. Dr. Khan advises on the importance of aligning investments with financial goals and the benefits of seeking professional guidance to create a balanced investment portfolio.

๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ณ How to Invest in India: Options for NRIs

NRIs have multiple options to invest in India, including direct investments in FDs, bonds, mutual funds, PMS, and unit-linked insurance plans. For those who prefer not to bring money into India, options like the FPI route and investments via GIFT City in Gujarat are available, albeit with higher investment thresholds. Dr. Khan explains these options and encourages viewers to seek professional advice to optimize their investment strategies.

๐Ÿ“ข Final Thoughts and Encouragement to Seek Professional Advice

Dr. Khan wraps up the episode by reiterating the importance of understanding the factors influencing investment decisions between dollars and INR. He encourages viewers to seek professional financial advice to build a robust investment portfolio tailored to their needs. The episode ends with a call to action for viewers to like, subscribe, and share the video to help others gain clarity on this topic.

Mindmap

Keywords

๐Ÿ’กNRI

NRI stands for Non-Resident Indian, referring to Indian citizens living outside of India. In the video, NRI is central to the theme as the script discusses financial decisions and investment dilemmas faced by this demographic. The script mentions NRI's earning in dollars and the choices they have regarding investing in either dollars or Indian Rupees.

๐Ÿ’กCurrency Exchange Rate

Currency exchange rate is the value of a country's currency in relation to another currency. It is a key concept in the script as it discusses the dynamic nature of the exchange rate between the US Dollar and the Indian Rupee, which influences NRI's investment decisions. The script provides historical context, noting how the Indian Rupee has depreciated against the dollar over time.

๐Ÿ’กDepreciation

Depreciation, in an economic context, refers to the decrease in the value of a currency over time. The script discusses the historical depreciation of the Indian Rupee against the US Dollar, which has led to concerns among NRI's about retaining the value of their earnings.

๐Ÿ’กInflation

Inflation is the rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services is rising, and subsequently, the purchasing power of currency is falling. The script explains that inflation differentials between the US and India can impact the depreciation of the Indian Rupee against the Dollar, with higher inflation typically leading to a weaker currency.

๐Ÿ’กCurrent Account Deficit

A current account deficit occurs when a country's imports of goods, services, and transfers are greater than its exports. The script mentions this as one of the factors contributing to the depreciation of the Indian Rupee, as it indicates a higher demand for foreign currency to pay for these imports.

๐Ÿ’กFDI

FDI stands for Foreign Direct Investment, which is an investment made by a firm or individual in one country into business interests located in another country. The script highlights the high levels of FDI in India as a positive factor for the Indian Rupee, indicating increased foreign investment and confidence in the Indian economy.

๐Ÿ’กInterest Rate Differential

Interest rate differential refers to the difference in interest rates between two financial instruments or two countries. The script discusses how the difference in interest rates between Indian Rupee Fixed Deposits (FDs) and Foreign Currency Non-Resident (FCNR) accounts can influence NRI's investment choices.

๐Ÿ’กSpeculative Need

Speculative need refers to the investment decisions based on predictions or expectations about future market movements. In the script, it is mentioned as one of the reasons why NRI's might choose to invest in either dollars or Indian Rupees, based on their speculation about which currency will appreciate or depreciate.

๐Ÿ’กPortfolio

A portfolio is a collection of financial assets such as stocks, bonds, commodities, or cash equivalents that are held by an investor. The script suggests that NRI's can invest in various financial instruments to build a portfolio, which can help them achieve their financial goals and retirement corpus.

๐Ÿ’กTax Benefit

Tax benefit refers to a reduction in the amount of tax that an individual or corporation must pay. The script mentions tax benefits as a reason why some NRI's might choose to invest in certain currencies or accounts, such as 401(k)s in the US, which offer tax advantages.

๐Ÿ’กFPI Route

FPI stands for Foreign Portfolio Investment, which is a route through which foreign investors can invest in a country's capital markets. The script suggests that NRI's can explore the FPI route to invest in India without bringing their money into the country, although it mentions a significant investment threshold for this route.

Highlights

The dilemma of NRI investors on whether to invest in dollars or Indian rupees is a perennial problem.

Dollars are preferred for their strength and international acceptance, with the US economy contributing to one-third of the world's market capitalization.

Investing in India is driven by the potential for higher returns and the familiarity of the home market.

Currency exchange rates are dynamic, with the Indian rupee historically depreciating against the dollar over decades.

The Indian rupee's depreciation is not consistent, with periods of stability and appreciation observed.

Three primary reasons for the rupee's depreciation against the dollar include inflation differential, current account deficit, and defense-related procurements.

Inflation in India and the US is currently similar, which may contribute to the rupee's stability against the dollar.

India's current account deficit is narrowing, which could positively impact the rupee's value.

Increased FDI and NRI remittances are favorable for the rupee, indicating potential for appreciation.

Investment motives include speculation, interest rate differences, and need-based considerations.

The differential between FCNR and INR interest rates has narrowed, affecting investment decisions.

Need-based investments are crucial for managing liabilities and future commitments in specific currencies.

Tax benefits from investing in certain accounts like 401(k)s or super funds can influence currency investment choices.

Investing in India can be done directly through various financial instruments or indirectly through ETFs and mutual funds dedicated to India.

FPI and GIFT City routes offer investment opportunities in India, though they have higher investment thresholds.

The video aims to provide clarity on currency investment decisions for NRI individuals.

Transcripts

play00:00

dear viewers welcome to yet another

play00:01

episode of your life your money for nris

play00:05

who earn in dollars there's always a

play00:07

dilemma which is going on in the mind

play00:09

what shall I do with these dollars

play00:10

should I invest in the developed world

play00:12

in the form of dollars or should I

play00:14

invest this money back home in the INR

play00:17

this dilemma is a perennial problem

play00:20

which is there in the minds of nris in

play00:22

this episode I'm going to find an answer

play00:24

for this problem and help you to decide

play00:26

should you be investing in dollars or

play00:28

should you be investing in Indian

play00:30

national rupees this is NRI money clinic

play00:32

for you and I Dr Chandra Khan but your

play00:34

financial guide for a happy

play00:37

[Music]

play00:43

living NRI money Clinic new hype just

play00:46

the right

play00:48

advice nris earned in dollars are the

play00:52

currencies of the developed World their

play00:54

love affair for holding on to the

play00:56

dollars is eternal obviously they are

play00:59

making this Deion because of the

play01:01

strength of the dollar because of its

play01:03

position dollar is an international

play01:05

currency the B trade happens around that

play01:07

us is a very strong economy literally

play01:10

onethird of the world's market

play01:12

capitalization comes from the US market

play01:15

so they are Justified to hold on to the

play01:17

dollars dollars are acceptable in any

play01:19

part of the world you have few dollars

play01:20

you can travel to any part of the world

play01:22

it can be freely exchange you don't need

play01:24

anyone's permission these are the

play01:26

reasons why people have an affinity for

play01:29

dollars why people invest in India they

play01:32

invest in India because you are an

play01:33

Indian you might come back to India and

play01:35

retire here you are also knowing very

play01:38

sure that the rupe deposits give you a

play01:41

higher rate of interest the growth story

play01:44

of India gives you a much better return

play01:46

in India this is the reason why you

play01:49

invest in Indian rupees but the problem

play01:51

is the currency exchange rate currency

play01:54

exchange rate between two currencies is

play01:56

not static it's always Dynamic one

play01:59

currency moves up another comes down it

play02:01

continuously happens it's just like a

play02:03

stock market movement currency is going

play02:05

up currency is coming down historically

play02:07

if you look at it the Indian rupee has

play02:09

constantly depreciated over decades

play02:12

against the dollar when I was studying

play02:14

I'm talking about 1979 period the rupe

play02:17

to Dollar was somewhere at about 12

play02:19

rupees or 15 rupees and where is it

play02:21

today it's at about 83 rupees what was

play02:25

10 12 rupees during my college days has

play02:28

come down to 83 rupees right now so the

play02:31

argument people make is if I hold on to

play02:33

the dollar I will retain the value of

play02:35

the money but if I keep money in the

play02:37

Indian rupees the value against the

play02:40

dollar comes down the answer is right

play02:42

but it does not tell you the full story

play02:44

the full story is that the rupe

play02:46

depreciation against the dollar does not

play02:49

happen on a daily basis at times the

play02:51

markets remain static it will not move

play02:53

at all at times the markets will come

play02:55

down crashing down when I say Market it

play02:58

is a currency Market the rupe May crash

play03:00

down and there are periods where the

play03:02

rupe has appreciated many people do not

play03:04

know the fact that rupe can also

play03:06

appreciate against the dollar we have

play03:08

seen from 45 to 68 rupee crashing down

play03:12

that's a pain Point everybody remembers

play03:14

that we have also seen rupee crashing

play03:16

from 75 to 82 that's a pain Point

play03:19

everybody remembers but what people do

play03:21

not know is rupee has also appreciated

play03:23

at one point of time between I would say

play03:26

2003 to 2008 where it appreciated all

play03:29

the way from 45 rupes per dollar to a

play03:32

level of about 37 or 38 you can pick up

play03:35

such points all along that journey of 30

play03:38

40 years you can find periods where rupe

play03:41

has remained static rupe has appreciated

play03:43

take the recent example 2018 to

play03:46

literally about 2021 or so the rupee has

play03:49

held against the dollar at about 75

play03:51

that's about 3 to 4 years of neither

play03:54

appreciation nor depreciation and rupe

play03:56

held against the dollar very firm later

play03:58

on because of the the reasons of Market

play04:01

movements rupe has slided to about 82 83

play04:04

and it is holding on there you can't

play04:06

keep the two currencies at static Point

play04:08

these are not the pegged currencies like

play04:10

in case of Middle East currencies which

play04:11

are pegged against the dollar so they

play04:13

have a constant exchange rate so the

play04:15

currencies will move up and down so this

play04:18

fear of rupee depreciating creates Panic

play04:21

creates doubts in the minds of nris what

play04:23

shall I do if I had waited for some more

play04:26

time probably I would have got more

play04:28

rupees for every dollar that I had let's

play04:30

try to find an answer why rupe

play04:33

depreciates against the dollar I told

play04:35

you about last close to about 4550 years

play04:38

history and it has been a constant

play04:40

downslide over longer periods of time

play04:42

there are three primary reasons why rupe

play04:45

depreciates against the dollar number

play04:47

one is inflation between US versus India

play04:51

the country which has higher inflation

play04:54

the rupe or the currency depreciates

play04:57

against the dollar let's say us had

play04:59

inflation of 2% and India had an

play05:02

inflation of 6 to 8% there is a

play05:04

differential of 4 to 6% this makes the

play05:07

cost of goods and services become

play05:09

expensive to adjust for that the rupee

play05:12

gets depreciated so the simple thing to

play05:14

remember is the country which has higher

play05:16

inflation the currency of that country

play05:19

depreciates against the currency of

play05:21

another country here the case is the US

play05:23

which has lesser inflation what is

play05:25

currently happening historically Indian

play05:27

inflation was higher US inflation was

play05:30

lower but today if you see the Indian

play05:32

inflation and the US inflation is almost

play05:35

similar and many of times the Indian

play05:37

inflation is lower than the US inflation

play05:40

so this point makes your rupe to remain

play05:43

robust and can hold against the dollar

play05:46

because there is no differential which

play05:48

exists going forward for any reason if

play05:51

inflation were to rise in India and the

play05:53

inflation in US comes down we are back

play05:56

to square one then there is a good

play05:58

chance that the rupe will depreciate

play05:59

further but the evidence what we see on

play06:02

the ground today Indian inflation will

play06:04

remain lower RBI says my target for

play06:07

inflation today is at about 4% the US

play06:10

has an inflation of 4 5% it looks very

play06:12

sticky it will remain like that for a

play06:15

few more years looks like maybe slowly

play06:17

it will come down but nevertheless the

play06:19

differential of inflation between us and

play06:22

India is not significant today and

play06:25

because of this the rupe is unlikely to

play06:28

fall down against the dollar the second

play06:31

reason is because of current account

play06:33

deficit a current account deficit

play06:35

primarily refers to the trade account

play06:38

how much of dollars I need to buy the my

play06:41

import requirement I import certain

play06:42

things in India I have to spend my

play06:44

dollars so I need dollars then how much

play06:46

of dollars I earn I export things to the

play06:49

rest of the world and our NRI Community

play06:51

also sends money into India there could

play06:53

be other borrowings and other things

play06:55

which will happen so it's a balance

play06:57

between the dollars we spent and the

play06:59

dollars we earned historically India had

play07:02

a negative current account deficit that

play07:04

means we were spending more dollars and

play07:07

we are earning less dollar now here also

play07:10

we see the equation is turning favorable

play07:13

to India right now it is still a current

play07:16

account deficit country if the

play07:17

statistics are to be believed it is

play07:20

getting bridged it is getting narrowed

play07:22

down and the governmental action is also

play07:24

focused on that why does India spend so

play07:27

much dollar primarily because of its oil

play07:29

Imports India does not have the required

play07:31

amount of energy that it needs for the

play07:33

country so it has to import oil that is

play07:36

the biggest guzzler of dollars in India

play07:39

government is focusing on renewable

play07:41

energy Energy Efficiency and a lot of

play07:44

activities so that the dependence on

play07:46

external source of energy over a period

play07:49

of time slowly comes down the demand for

play07:51

dollars can also come down because of

play07:54

that likewise India has also floated the

play07:57

sovereign gold funds to satiate the

play07:59

demand of gold for its citizens Indians

play08:01

have a fancy for gold they spend a lot

play08:04

of money on gold and because of import

play08:06

of gold we lose a lot of dollars if

play08:08

people instead invest in s in Gold bonds

play08:11

probably the gold import dependence

play08:13

comes down and the spending of dollar

play08:15

can also come down the third reason is

play08:17

because of the defense related

play08:19

procurements India needs arms and

play08:21

ammunition and its industry was not

play08:23

capable enough to produce it at home and

play08:26

because of which you will heavily depend

play08:28

on developed world procure your

play08:30

aircrafts your spares and the latest

play08:33

arms and ammunition for the security of

play08:35

the country this government in the last

play08:37

10 years has worked a lot under this try

play08:40

to do an atbara on defense equipment

play08:43

size they have done deals they are

play08:45

producing it in India technology

play08:47

transfer they're trying to export a lot

play08:50

of these things to rest of the world so

play08:52

what was a deficit for our country is

play08:54

slowly steadily is turning out to be a

play08:57

positive for the country yet another

play08:59

reason for rupe to appreciate or

play09:01

depreciate against dollar is flow of

play09:04

dollars into the country or out of the

play09:07

country for reasons other than the trade

play09:09

people invest money in India so that is

play09:12

why the dollars come in people often

play09:14

sell out of the Indian market that's how

play09:16

they take out their money so there is a

play09:17

constant movement of money coming in or

play09:20

money going out if there is more money

play09:22

which is coming into the country then

play09:24

the rupee will appreciate if there is

play09:26

more money going out of the country then

play09:29

the will depreciate now if we observe

play09:32

the data points here now we can

play09:34

evidently say there is more and more

play09:36

people are pouring money into India the

play09:39

FDI in India is highest today than any

play09:43

other country in the world so we are

play09:45

receiving a phenomenal amount of FDI

play09:47

investment FDI refers to foreign direct

play09:50

investment there is a specific way to

play09:52

look at it and FDA investment is a

play09:54

sticky investment which will remain in

play09:56

India you bring money you invest

play09:58

somewhere you establish factories you

play10:01

create manufacturing units or this money

play10:03

is not something that is not a smart

play10:05

money where you put money today and

play10:07

after a few months you take out the

play10:08

money that's not a smart money here a

play10:11

genuine investor comes into India pars

play10:13

money and that is really growing look at

play10:16

the remittances from nris across the

play10:18

Globe last year we had more than100

play10:21

billion worth of NRA remittances which

play10:24

are coming into India and this figure is

play10:26

only growing from a flow of dollars in

play10:29

in and out of the country it is evident

play10:31

and it's very clear to say that it is

play10:34

favorable to Rupee so if you look at any

play10:37

parameter today what was creating a

play10:39

panic for The Indian rupe in the past is

play10:42

no more evident at this point of time

play10:45

and if the same Trend continues I will

play10:47

not even rule out Indian rupe appreciate

play10:50

against the dollar however the inflation

play10:52

differential as thing stands today still

play10:55

exist between the developed World versus

play10:57

India and that could be one factor which

play11:00

might make rupee slide slowly but

play11:03

steadily that cannot be ruled out so the

play11:05

worst case scenario as I can see is

play11:08

rupees sliding down by about 2 to 3% on

play11:11

an average per year is something which

play11:13

we can factor in now let us look at why

play11:16

people invest in INR or dollar what is

play11:19

the motive behind that there are three

play11:22

major reasons that people invest in

play11:25

either rupees or in dollars number one

play11:28

is the speculative need number two is

play11:31

probability of making more money by the

play11:34

way of Interest or by way of growth in

play11:37

that particular country the third could

play11:39

be the need based I have a particular

play11:42

need because of this I park money in

play11:44

dollars or I park money in the Indian

play11:47

rupees and let's look at these three

play11:49

things a little bit more in detail first

play11:51

let us look at the speculative need the

play11:53

speculative need is or the speculative

play11:55

reasons is I expect Indian rupe to slide

play11:58

further that is why I will not invest in

play12:01

India so you are speculating thinking

play12:03

that the rupee will depreciate or the

play12:05

reverse is also true so if you expect

play12:08

the dollar to appreciate or dollar to

play12:10

depreciate INR to appreciate or

play12:12

depreciate you take a call based on what

play12:15

you perceive or what you are advised

play12:17

with So based on the speculation you

play12:19

calculate where do I make more money

play12:21

that is how you speculate the other

play12:23

speculation that you can make is where

play12:26

will the growth be more and where I can

play12:28

make more money out of for example you

play12:30

have an option to invest in the US Stock

play12:32

Market you have an option to invest in

play12:34

the Indian stock market where will I

play12:36

make more money both are the stock

play12:38

markets both are vibrant markets where

play12:40

will I make money if history is to be

play12:42

believed it is people who invested in

play12:45

the Indian stock market in the last 30

play12:47

35 years have walked out with more money

play12:50

than the people who have invested in the

play12:52

US Stock Market the growth of the US

play12:54

Stock Market is just not very organic it

play12:57

has happened because of a lot of

play12:59

printing of money lot of liquidity which

play13:01

has been infused into the market very

play13:03

artificial movement of money that is why

play13:06

the US markets went up with all that

play13:08

liquidity infusion the US markets just

play13:11

made about CAG of 7% in dollar terms but

play13:14

if you calculate in India you have got a

play13:16

C of more than 7% in dollar terms during

play13:20

the same period of time so the higher

play13:22

growth in India makes you reap much

play13:25

better benefits but this is in the long

play13:27

term in the short term anything is is

play13:29

possible it could be the US market

play13:30

outperforming or the Indian market

play13:32

outperforming the US market both are a

play13:35

possibility in the long term because of

play13:37

a higher growth in India you expect

play13:40

Indian markets to do better than the US

play13:42

market in the short term it is just

play13:44

unpredictable the second reason why

play13:46

people invest in India is because of the

play13:50

interest rate difference you have an

play13:52

option to bring dollars and hold it as

play13:54

an fcnr or you can bring dollars convert

play13:57

it into rupees and convert into an FD in

play14:00

INR the FD interest rates in INR used to

play14:03

be way higher than the fcnr rates fcnr

play14:06

used to give you 1% 2% whereas the FD

play14:10

rates in India used to be 8% 9% you can

play14:12

say any figure if you look at a

play14:14

particular time frame that could be a

play14:16

possibility but currently the

play14:18

differential between the fcnr interest

play14:21

rate and the INR interest rate is

play14:24

extremely narrow and just a few months

play14:27

before it was almost similar to that

play14:29

that is because of the inflation

play14:32

differential between the two countries

play14:33

getting narrowed down you don't see a

play14:35

much big difference for any reason let's

play14:37

say that Indian rupe has a higher FD

play14:40

interest rate and the fcnr has a lower

play14:42

FD interest rate how should you take a

play14:45

call very simple let's say that fcnr

play14:47

gives you 4% and the rupe FD gives you

play14:51

7% now what happens after 1 year so you

play14:54

made 4% in the fcnr because that offered

play14:57

you 4% interest rate you made 7% in the

play14:59

Indian FD rates because the INR gave you

play15:02

7% 1 year from now if rupees slides by

play15:06

3% against the dollar so if you convert

play15:08

your dollars into the Indian rupees you

play15:11

will get 4% on the dollar the interest

play15:14

earn you will get 3% from the conversion

play15:16

of Dollar to Rupee because rupe has

play15:18

slided so the differential between the

play15:20

interest rate between these two

play15:21

countries is not too much something that

play15:23

you have to depend upon if you have

play15:25

lesser fcnr FD interest rate but

play15:27

whenever you convert it into the future

play15:29

you will get more rupees so even though

play15:31

it gives an impression that I make more

play15:33

rupees but obviously that may not be the

play15:35

truth there could be shortterm movement

play15:37

there could be slight aberations which

play15:39

might happen depending on when you

play15:40

convert things but overall whether you

play15:43

keep it in an fcnr or whether you keep

play15:45

it in an irr FD rate your net outcome

play15:47

will remain the same the third is very

play15:49

important it is the need based I have a

play15:52

need that is why I maintain my currency

play15:55

exposure let's say that there are people

play15:57

who are living in Gulf there are people

play15:59

who are in us and I have got a home loan

play16:01

I've got some personal loan I've got a

play16:03

vehicle loan I have to pay back this

play16:05

money in emis in dollar terms or a

play16:08

currency which is pegged against the

play16:09

dollar so I'll not take a risk of moving

play16:11

this money into India I'll hold this in

play16:13

the form of dollars because I have a

play16:15

commitment against that likewise people

play16:17

who have an intention to send the

play16:19

children to developed countries for

play16:20

Education they would need dollars so

play16:22

they'll not take a risk they will hold

play16:24

it as dollars itself and there are

play16:26

people who have their children living

play16:29

outside these are nris who could be

play16:30

working in Gulf or some other country

play16:32

and for the retirement they come back to

play16:34

India but the children are outside they

play16:36

are concerned about the Legacy transfer

play16:38

they are worried will India permit them

play16:40

to move this money outside of India from

play16:42

a legacy perspective also they might be

play16:45

holding these Investments outside of

play16:47

India in the form of dollars the yet

play16:49

another reason which is a very very

play16:51

powerful reason for you to invest in

play16:53

dollars is the tax benefit that you get

play16:56

let's say if you are living in us if you

play16:57

have invested in 401 Cas or Ro account

play17:01

or if you are living in Australia your

play17:03

super funds you are living in Singapore

play17:05

you have your cpf funds so you park

play17:08

these money in these accounts the

play17:09

governments have given you certain tax

play17:11

benefits you make best use of that to

play17:14

save on the taxes the taxes that you

play17:16

saved is a gain that you have made so if

play17:18

it gives you the tax benefit it gives

play17:20

you that extra Advantage you park your

play17:22

money in those currencies where your

play17:25

state has given that benefit so now that

play17:27

I have given you all the reasons

play17:29

historical perspectives what might

play17:31

happen in the future the needs and

play17:33

everything now let us look at if you

play17:35

decide to invest in India how can you

play17:38

invest in India by the way we are in the

play17:41

business of helping people set up their

play17:43

portfolios build their retirement Corpus

play17:46

and investment accounts to reach their

play17:48

life goals if you are somebody who's

play17:50

looking for an help in India to set up

play17:52

your portfolios you can make best use of

play17:55

our services we have team of experts on

play17:57

the ground who are ever ready to analyze

play17:59

your life analyze your financial aspects

play18:02

and help you how much money you have to

play18:04

keep it in dollars how much money you

play18:05

have to keep it in India where to invest

play18:08

how to build portfolios a professional

play18:10

work can be done by our team of experts

play18:13

if you have an intention you can reach

play18:14

out to us through a WhatsApp message on

play18:16

the number that is given in the

play18:18

description box below to facilitate we

play18:20

have also provided a link over there

play18:22

just click on the link it takes you to

play18:23

the WhatsApp send us that exploratory

play18:25

message and our team of experts are ever

play18:27

ready to help you why delay send that

play18:30

message now now that you decide to

play18:32

invest in India how can you invest in

play18:34

India number one you can directly invest

play18:36

into India you can invest in the fds you

play18:39

can buy the bonds which are available

play18:41

for the nris you can invest in mutual

play18:43

fund you can invest in PMS you can

play18:45

invest under unit linked insurance plan

play18:48

all the things which are available for

play18:50

nris to invest in the stock markets or

play18:52

the debt markets you can make best use

play18:54

of but if you do not want to bring your

play18:56

money into India but still want to

play18:59

invest in India one of the option that

play19:01

you can explore is fbii foreign

play19:03

portfolio investment route normally it

play19:05

comes via morous Route or via Bermuda

play19:08

route probably in a few weeks from now

play19:11

I'll do a detailed video on how an RIS

play19:14

can invest in India using the fpi route

play19:17

yet another way which is taking off

play19:19

right now is via gift City in Gujarat

play19:22

that is one another medium where in

play19:24

which you can invest in Indian market

play19:26

but one problem with gift City as well

play19:29

as the FBI routes you have a very large

play19:31

threshold I am given to understand that

play19:33

the gift City accepts investment only in

play19:36

exess of $150,000 us and fbii Route

play19:40

takes about 100,000 or more size

play19:43

Investments when you have to invest in

play19:44

India so unless you have so much of a

play19:47

money you can't use these FBI route or

play19:49

the gift City route one another way you

play19:52

can invest in India without bringing

play19:54

your money into India is you can choose

play19:57

the ETFs and the mutual funds which are

play19:59

dedicated to India and from your own

play20:01

country you can choose these ETFs as the

play20:03

mutual fund and you can make best use of

play20:05

the growth prospects which are there in

play20:07

India dear viewers hope the video that I

play20:09

have done today helped you to clarify or

play20:12

get a Clarity around should you invest

play20:15

in dollars should you invest in rupees

play20:17

how much to invest in dollar how much to

play20:19

invest in rupees if it did give you a

play20:20

Clarity do not forget to give me a

play20:22

thumbs up if you are at to subscribe for

play20:24

this channel do hit the Subscribe button

play20:26

and press the Bell icon do not forget to

play20:28

share these videos with your near and

play20:29

dear ones friends and relatives and on

play20:31

all the WhatsApp groups on which you are

play20:33

connected with thank you very much for

play20:35

watching this episode on NRI money

play20:37

Clinic I shall be back with you next

play20:39

Friday with yet another thought on your

play20:41

life your money till then stay safe J

play20:45

hin press the Bell icon for more details

play20:48

and subscribe our Channel

play20:52

[Music]

Rate This
โ˜…
โ˜…
โ˜…
โ˜…
โ˜…

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
NRI InvestmentDollar DecisionRupee DepreciationCurrency ExchangeMarket CapitalizationInflation ImpactInterest RatePortfolio BuildingFinancial AdviceEconomic Analysis