Aplikasi Saham Amerika Paling Cuan (2025) - Pluang vs GoTrade vs Ajaib

Summary

The video provides a detailed comparison of three investment apps—Peluang, Go Trade, and Ajaib—for buying U.S. stocks from Indonesia. The creator tests both market and limit orders using SPY, QQQ, and Nvidia, evaluating performance, fees, and user experience. Peluang consistently performs best in returns and offers advanced features like leverage, options, extended hours, and copy trading. Go Trade excels for simple, mobile-focused U.S. stock trading, while Ajaib is suitable for beginners within its multi-asset ecosystem. The analysis also highlights app-specific strengths in UI/UX, web trading, and feature availability, helping users choose the right platform based on their investment style and goals.

Takeaways

• 📈 The creator compared three investment apps for trading U.S. stocks from Indonesia: Peluang, Go Trade, and Ajaib, using both market and limit orders.
• 💵 Market order tests used a total of Rp150 million, split across the three apps, buying SPY, QQQ, and Nvidia in two rounds per app.
• 🏆 In market orders, Peluang yielded the highest net return (Rp29,670,000), followed by Go Trade (Rp29,575,000), and Ajaib (Rp29,221,000).
• 🛠️ Limit order experiments showed similar results: Peluang again performed best, Go Trade second, and Ajaib initially lacked the feature.
• ⏰ Extended hours trading is available in Peluang and Go Trade, allowing trades outside regular market hours; Ajaib initially did not support this but has since updated.
• 🔧 Peluang offers leverage (2x, 4x) and options trading, while Go Trade offers advanced orders like trailing stop and OCO; Ajaib is limited but evolving.
• 💻 Web trading is supported by Peluang and Go Trade (via TradingView), enhancing pro user experience; Ajaib does not yet support web trading.
• 🎯 UI/UX simplicity favors Go Trade for US stock-focused users, while Peluang and Ajaib are more complex due to multi-asset options.
• -
• 👥 Copy trading is available in Peluang through 'pockets' like Nancy Plus, allowing users to follow expert portfolios; Go Trade and Ajaib do not offer this feature.
• -
• 📊 Overall recommendations depend on user needs: Go Trade for simple US stock trading, Peluang for advanced and multi-asset investing, Ajaib for beginners or all-in-one platform users.
• -
• ⏳ Consistency matters: Peluang and Go Trade are veteran platforms (operating since 2019) with proven results, whereas Ajaib is newer (US stocks since 2025) and still evolving.
• -
• 🔄 Apps are continuously updated; features such as limit orders, extended hours, and advanced tools are improving, making regular reassessment important for investors.

Q & A

Which three applications were tested for investing in US stocks in the video?

The three applications tested were Peluang, Go Trade, and Ajaib.

What was the total investment amount used for the experiment?

The total investment amount used was Rp150 million, divided between market orders and limit orders.

How did the creator allocate funds for market orders across the three apps?

For market orders, Rp90 million was allocated: Rp30 million to Peluang, Rp30 million to Go Trade, and Rp30 million to Ajaib, split further into multiple purchases per stock.

Which app showed the highest return for market orders after selling and withdrawing funds?

Peluang showed the highest return for market orders, with a final balance of approximately Rp29.67 million.

What features were compared beyond basic buying and selling?

The comparison included extended hours trading, leverage, options, advanced orders (like trailing stop and OCO), copy trading/pockets, UI/UX, web trading, stock selection, and all-in-one multi-asset capabilities.

How did the apps differ in supporting extended hours trading?

Peluang and Go Trade supported extended hours trading (pre-market and after-hours), while Ajaib did not at the time of the experiment.

What is the significance of limit orders in the experiment?

Limit orders allowed the tester to buy or sell stocks at predetermined prices, reducing human error and enabling a fair comparison of execution across platforms.

Which app was recommended for users who prefer a simple, mobile-only experience focusing on US stocks?

Go Trade was recommended for users who prefer a simple, mobile-focused experience solely for US stocks.

Why was Peluang considered strong for advanced users?

Peluang was considered strong for advanced users because it offers features like leverage, options, advanced orders, extended hours trading, web trading, and a broad range of stocks and ETFs.

How does copy trading work, and which app supports it best?

Copy trading allows users to automatically follow the trades of experienced investors. Peluang supports this feature best, while Go Trade and Ajaib have limited or no copy trading functionality.

How did the experiment account for discrepancies like unique top-up codes or promotions?

The tester adjusted final balances to exclude bonuses and unique codes to ensure a fair comparison of the apps’ performance.

Which app is recommended for beginners or users already invested in its ecosystem?

Ajaib is recommended for beginners or those already invested in the Ajaib ecosystem, as it is simpler and offers access to Indonesian stocks, crypto, and mutual funds, despite being newer to US stocks.

How consistent was Peluang in delivering returns across market and limit orders?

Peluang was consistent, delivering the highest returns in both market orders and limit orders, maintaining performance over a period of two years.