Israel's Army Claims it is Impossible to Defeat the Hamas | Vantage with Palki Sharma

Summary

The script discusses the ongoing conflict in Gaza, highlighting the Israeli government's stated aim to destroy Hamas and the military's acknowledgment that this is impossible due to its deep roots in the population. It delves into the internal divisions between Prime Minister Netanyahu and the military, the potential for a second front with Hezbollah in Lebanon, and the US's concern over the escalating situation. The summary underscores the complexity of the conflict, the risks of further escalation, and the international implications.

Takeaways

• 🗓️ The conflict in Gaza has been ongoing for almost 9 months, with Israel's stated goal to eliminate Hamas remaining unchanged.
• 💣 Israel's military has acknowledged that completely destroying Hamas is not possible, calling it an 'idea' deeply rooted in the hearts of the people.
• 🗣️ Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly insisted on the elimination of Hamas as a war objective, in contrast to the military's stance.
• 🤔 There is a clear division between Netanyahu and the military, with differing views on the feasibility and strategy of eliminating Hamas.
• 🛑 The military has called for a tactical pause in Rafa, which Netanyahu opposed, highlighting disagreements on the conduct of the war.
• 🇺🇸 US military support is crucial for Israel, and Netanyahu's policies have reportedly angered Washington, potentially affecting the flow of military aid.
• 🔥 The situation is further complicated by the potential for a second front opening with Hezbollah in Lebanon, which could escalate the conflict.
• 🎯 Israel's military has targeted Hezbollah positions in Lebanon, and Hezbollah has responded with rocket attacks on Northern Israel.
• ⚠️ Hezbollah has warned Cyprus about the consequences of allowing Israel to use its bases, indicating a readiness for a broader conflict.
• 🏛️ The US has sent a special envoy to West Asia to meet with Lebanese officials and call for de-escalation at the border.
• 🕊️ Despite the threats, there seems to be no appetite for war in Lebanon unless Israel escalates the situation further.

Q & A

How long has the conflict in Gaza been ongoing according to the script?

The conflict in Gaza has been ongoing for almost 9 months at the time the script was written.

What has been Israel's stated position towards Hamas during the conflict in Gaza?

Israel's stated position has been to destroy Hamas, as they have expressed a desire to eliminate the group completely.

What does the Israeli Army spokesperson say about the possibility of destroying Hamas?

The Israeli Army spokesperson states that destroying Hamas is impossible, referring to it as an idea and a party rooted in the hearts of the people.

What has been the Israeli Prime Minister's stance on the elimination of Hamas?

The Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has repeatedly stated that Israel would destroy Hamas, emphasizing it as a necessary step and a priority in the war.

What controversy has arisen due to the differing statements between the Israeli military and the Prime Minister?

The controversy arises from the public disagreement between the Israeli military's view that Hamas cannot be destroyed and the Prime Minister's repeated assertions that it is a goal of the war.

What clarification did the Israeli military provide regarding the spokesperson's statement on Hamas?

The Israeli military clarified that the spokesperson was referring to Hamas's ideology, not the group itself, in the statement about the impossibility of destroying Hamas.

What are the three main reasons for the divisions between Netanyahu and his military as mentioned in the script?

The three main reasons for the divisions are tactical disagreements on post-victory governance in Gaza, military support concerns, particularly from the US, and the potential for a second front in the war involving Hezbollah.

Why might the US be concerned about the situation in Gaza and the actions of the Israeli military?

The US is concerned because of the potential for the conflict to escalate, the strain on military support, and the impact on regional stability.

What is Hezbollah's stance on the conflict and its potential involvement?

Hezbollah has stated that it is ready for war and is not just threatening Israel but also Cyprus, indicating a willingness to expand the conflict if necessary.

What actions by Israel have potentially escalated the situation with Hezbollah?

Israel's targeting and killing of a senior Hezbollah commander in response to rocket fire from Lebanon have escalated the situation, as it may provoke further retaliation.

How does the script describe Netanyahu's strategy in relation to the conflict and its potential risks?

The script describes Netanyahu's strategy as risky and dangerous, suggesting that he is trying to draw out the war and keep the US interested, which could lead to an expanded conflict.

Outlines

00:00

🏳️‍🚩 Disparity Between Israeli Military and Political Stance on Hamas

The first paragraph discusses the ongoing conflict in Gaza, highlighting the Israeli government's stated goal of eliminating Hamas, which is contradicted by the Israeli military's acknowledgment that such a task is impossible. The military spokesperson emphasizes that Hamas is an idea deeply rooted in the people, suggesting that the public is being misled by political rhetoric. The paragraph also touches on the internal divisions between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the military, particularly regarding the handling of the situation in Rafah and the broader strategy for post-war Gaza. The potential for a second front opening with Hezbollah in Lebanon adds another layer of complexity to the situation, with the US expressing concern and sending a special envoy to the region to call for de-escalation.

05:01

🌍 Netanyahu's Provocative Actions and Regional Tensions

The second paragraph delves into the potential motivations behind Netanyahu's actions, suggesting a strategy to prolong the conflict and maintain US interest, which is risky and dangerous. It contrasts the lack of appetite for war in Lebanon with Netanyahu's provocative moves, such as targeting senior Hezbollah commanders, which could potentially draw out the war. The paragraph also mentions the killing of Iranian commanders in Syria by Israel, which led to retaliatory attacks from Iran. The narrative is set against the backdrop of Allison Lrange's introduction to a news segment focusing on Africa, indicating a shift in the global news focus.

Keywords

💡Gaza

Gaza is a small self-governing Palestinian territory located on the eastern coast of the Mediterranean Sea. It is the primary focus of the conflict discussed in the video, where the Israeli military and Hamas have been in a state of ongoing conflict for several months as mentioned in the script. The situation in Gaza is central to the video's theme of the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

💡Israel

Israel is a country in the Middle East and one of the main parties involved in the conflict mentioned in the video script. The script discusses Israel's stated goal of eliminating Hamas and the internal disagreements between the Israeli military and the Prime Minister regarding this objective. Israel's actions and policies are central to understanding the narrative of the conflict presented in the video.

💡Hamas

Hamas is a Palestinian Sunni-Islamic fundamentalist and militant organization, which is the de facto governing authority of the Gaza Strip. The script highlights the Israeli military's view that Hamas, being an idea and a party rooted in the hearts of the people, cannot be destroyed, contrasting with the Israeli Prime Minister's stance on the issue. Hamas is a key concept in the video's exploration of the intractability of the conflict.

💡Benjamin Netanyahu

Benjamin Netanyahu is the former Prime Minister of Israel, who is mentioned in the script as having repeatedly stated that Israel would destroy Hamas. His statements and actions are presented as a source of controversy and division within the Israeli government, particularly in contrast with the Israeli military's views.

💡Elimination

The term 'elimination' in the script refers to the Israeli goal of completely destroying Hamas. It is a central theme of the video, illustrating the stated objectives of the Israeli government and the controversy surrounding this goal, as well as the military's belief that such a goal is unattainable.

💡Controversy

Controversy is a key concept in the script, highlighting the disagreements between different factions within the Israeli government regarding the strategy and objectives of the conflict in Gaza. The script mentions a 'public spat' and 'divisions' between Netanyahu and his military, which is a significant aspect of the video's narrative on the internal dynamics affecting the conflict.

💡Tactical Pause

A 'tactical pause' is a temporary halt in military operations, which is mentioned in the script as a point of contention between the Israeli military and Netanyahu. The military's decision to announce a pause in Rafah was opposed by Netanyahu, indicating a difference in approach to the conflict.

💡Hisbah

Hisbah, also known as Hezbollah, is a Lebanon-based Shia Islamist political party and militant group. The script discusses the potential for a second front in the conflict, with Hisbah and Israel exchanging fire and the group's readiness for war, which adds another layer of complexity to the regional conflict.

💡Cyprus

Cyprus is an island country in the eastern Mediterranean, which is mentioned in the script in the context of its defense agreement with Israel and potential involvement in the conflict. The script discusses Hisbah's threats to Cyprus and the US's concern over the situation, indicating Cyprus's strategic importance in the regional dynamics.

💡De-escalation

De-escalation refers to the process of reducing the intensity of a conflict or tension. In the script, the US sends a special envoy to West Asia to call for de-escalation at the border, highlighting the international community's concern and efforts to prevent the conflict from worsening.

💡Strategy

The term 'strategy' is implied throughout the script in discussions of Netanyahu's actions and the potential for escalating the conflict. The script suggests that Netanyahu's approach is risky and dangerous, aiming to draw out the war and keep the Americans interested, which is a critical aspect of the video's analysis of the conflict's geopolitical implications.

Highlights

Israel's stated position to destroy Hamas in Gaza remains unchanged after 9 months of conflict.

Israeli Army acknowledges the impossibility of completely eliminating Hamas, an idea deeply rooted in the people.

Controversy arises as Israeli Prime Minister Benin Nan repeatedly claims Israel will destroy Hamas, contradicting the military's stance.

Netanyahu's office reiterates the official war goal of destroying Hamas, despite the military's clarification.

Divisions between Netanyahu and the military are evident, with differing views on the handling of post-war Gaza.

Tactical pause in Rafa by the Israeli military is opposed by Netanyahu, reflecting internal disagreements.

Three main reasons for the internal conflict: tactical concerns, military support issues, and the potential for a second front in the war.

US military support is crucial for Israel, with concerns over potential weapon shortages affecting the conflict.

Hisbah's readiness for war and threats to Israel and Cyprus highlight escalating tensions in the region.

Cyprus denies providing military support to Israel amid Hisbah's threats during the ongoing conflict.

US concern over the situation leads to the dispatch of a special envoy to West Asia for de-escalation efforts.

Netanyahu's actions towards Iran and Hisbah may be aimed at drawing out the war and maintaining US interest.

The strategy of provoking conflict with Hisbah commanders risks escalating the war and is seen as dangerous.

Allison Lrange introduces Africa-focused news coverage, emphasizing elections, climate change, and innovation.

First Post reports from Africa, providing a global perspective on the continent's developments and challenges.

Transcripts

speaking of which let's turn to the war

in Gaza it's been almost 9 months now in

this time Israel's position has been the

same we want to destroy the Hamas that's

what they've said throughout we want to

eliminate this group completely but

Israel's Army says that's impossible

look at what an army spokesperson said

and I'm quoting this business of

destroying Hamas it's simply throwing

sand in the eyes of the public Hamas is

an idea Hamas is a party it's rooted in

the hearts of the people whoever thinks

we can eliminate Hamas is

wrong now this is a big statement

Israel's Army says you cannot destroy

Hamas it's impossible but that's not

what Benin Nan has been saying he kept

telling the world that Israel would

destroy Hamas not once not twice but

multiple times listen to

this the elimination of Hamas is a

necessary step to ensure that the day

after there will be no element in Gaza

that threatens

us we spoke about recent developments in

the war including Israel's commitment to

achieving all of the war's objectives

eliminating

Hamas to win this

war We Must Destroy the remaining Hamas

battalions in

Rafa the necessary goal of the war is

first of all the elimination of Hamas

we will continue to fight until all the

objectives of the war are achieved and

the priority is the elimination of

homas so who should we trust the Israeli

military or the Israeli Prime Minister

as expected the statement has triggered

a controversy netanyahu's office has

commented on it they reiterated Israel's

official War goal to destroy Hamas the

military also released a clarification

they said that the spokesperson was

talking about the 's ideology and not

the

group but I'm afraid that the damage is

done the public spat has confirmed the

obvious there are divisions between

Netanyahu and his military we saw that

earlier this week too Israel's military

announced a tactical pause in Rafa again

Netanyahu was not happy he was totally

opposed to any pause in fighting before

that the defense minister rebelled he

asked Netanyahu to plan for post-war

Gaza again the Prime Minister refused

and all of these developments confirm

the divisions but the question is what

has caused it there are three main

reasons the first one is tactical

Netanyahu wants his army to defeat Hamas

in Rafa but what comes after that who

will govern the Gaza Strip without a

plan Israel could face insurgencies and

the Army is not keen on that they would

like some clarity on the next step the

second reason is Military Support mainly

from the US nany's policy has already

enrage Washington they have withheld one

shipment of

bombs but what if more shipments are

paused Israel's Army may run out of fire

power which brings us to the third

reason a second front in this war at

this rate we cannot rule it out Israel

and hisbah are regularly exchanging fire

hisbah and

Lebanon last week Israel took out a

senior hisbah commander in response they

fired rockets at Northern Israel it's a

very dangerous situation on Wednesday

Israel's Army released operational

footage it shows them striking seven

Targets in Lebanon take a look at

this the hisbah says it's ready for war

and it's not just threatening Israel it

is threatening Cyprus

too now Cyprus is an island on the west

of Lebanon it has a defense agreement

with Israel both sides have held join

drills in the past Cyprus has also

allowed Israel to use its airports but

all of that was during peace time not in

the middle of a war nonetheless hisbah

is not taking any chances they're

warning Cyprus

to if the war is imposed on Lebanon the

resistance will fight without control

without rules and without a ceiling

Cyprus should be warned that opening

cypriate bases and airports to the

Israelis to Target Lebanon means that

the cypriot government has become part

of the war and the resistance will deal

with Cyprus as if it is part of the

war Cyprus has denied these claims they

say no Military Support is being given

to Israel but how serious is the hisbah

threat well the US is really concerned

this week Joe Biden sent a special Envoy

to West Asia in beut he met lebanon's

primee Parliament

speaker who is an ally of his of hisbah

the US official called for deescalation

at the

border but the problem seems to be

Netanyahu hisbah could have intervened

any time in the last 9 months but they

did not and what does that tell you

there is no appetite for war in Lebanon

not unless Israel escalates and that's

where Nan's actions are worrying

consider what he did with Iran the

regime in thran was watching from the

sidelines but Israel killed their top

commanders in Syria that's when Iran

attacked Israel and now Netanyahu is

going after senior hisbah commanders

again the same agenda to draw out this

war and to keep the Americans interested

it's a very risky and dangerous strategy

but then again that's been netanyahu's

game plan

[Music]

throughout first post reports from the

world's second largest continent

hello I'm Allison lrange a very warm

welcome from Durban South Africa we get

you the news and the News makers from

Africa from elections to climate change

to

Innovations and

opportunities as the world's attention

shifts we report from Africa the heart

of the global South join me every

weekday live on first pose

[Music]