Raising voice during prayer and annoying other worshippers - Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem

Summary

The video script addresses the proper etiquette of reciting prayers during congregational Salah. It emphasizes that while the Imam may raise their voice during prayer, followers should avoid raising their voices to the point of disturbing others. The script explains the importance of balancing audible recitation to avoid distractions, highlighting that whispering or mumbling excessively can also be problematic. A hadith is cited to show that the Prophet (PBUH) allowed some vocalization but discouraged loud or disruptive recitations. The key takeaway is maintaining a balance in recitation that minimizes distraction while keeping the mind focused on prayer.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Imam is encouraged to raise his voice while leading the prayer, but followers should avoid raising their voices excessively.
• 😀 If a follower's loud recitation disturbs others, it is considered impermissible.
• 😀 Followers should not fall into the traps of Shaytaan by being distracted by others' loud recitation.
• 😀 If someone is trying to prevent whispers from Shaytaan by raising their voice, they should ensure their recitation does not disturb those around them.
• 😀 It's acceptable to be annoyed or distracted if the person next to you is loudly reciting, but the recitation must not interfere with your own concentration.
• 😀 A quiet, indistinguishable recitation is encouraged to avoid disturbing others, while still protecting oneself from Shaytaan's whispers.
• 😀 The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) did not reprimand a companion for raising his voice in prayer, indicating that it was not an issue if the voice wasn’t overly loud.
• 😀 The norm in prayer is for individuals to recite silently or in a low voice, not making it a frequent practice to raise one’s voice.
• 😀 If a follower’s recitation is so loud that it disrupts those around them, it’s a problem and should be avoided.
• 😀 A follower should be able to distinguish their own recitation without it becoming a disturbance to others.
• 😀 The balance between preventing Shaytaan’s whispers and not disturbing others is crucial for proper prayer etiquette.

Q & A

What is the Sunnah regarding the Imam's voice during prayer?

The Sunnah is for the Imam to raise his voice during prayer. This is allowed as he is leading the prayer and it helps the followers to follow him properly.

Is it permissible for followers to raise their voices during prayer?

It is not permissible for followers to raise their voices to the extent that it annoys or disturbs those praying next to them. This could disrupt the prayer and cause distractions.

What should individuals do if someone next to them is raising their voice too loudly during prayer?

If someone is raising their voice loudly and disturbing others, those affected should not allow themselves to fall into the traps of Shaytan. They should maintain their focus and try to push away distractions.

Why might someone raise their voice while reciting during prayer?

Someone might raise their voice to push away the whispers of Shaytan, thinking that louder recitation will prevent distractions. However, this can lead to disturbing others around them.

What does it mean to be distracted by someone’s recitation in prayer?

Being distracted means that the loud recitation makes it difficult for you to focus on your own prayer. If someone's voice is too loud, it can cause you to lose track of your own recitation or make mistakes.

What is the correct way to recite quietly during prayer?

The correct way is to recite quietly enough that only you can hear yourself, without disturbing others. It should be distinguishable enough to keep you focused but not so loud as to distract those around you.

Is it acceptable to have no noise at all during prayer to avoid distraction?

No, it is not acceptable to recite silently without any sound, as this could lead to Shaytan whispering and distracting you. A low, quiet recitation is necessary to maintain focus.

What example does the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) set regarding recitation after prayer?

The Prophet (PBUH) heard a man saying a supplication after prayer, and although the man raised his voice slightly, the Prophet did not object. This shows that while quiet recitation is preferred, it is not wrong to utter some words aloud if they don’t cause disturbance.

How does the narration about the man saying 'Allahu malakut' help clarify this issue?

The narration shows that it is permissible to utter some words loudly after prayer if it does not cause disturbance. The Prophet did not rebuke the man for his raised voice because it was not excessively loud.

What is the key takeaway from the Prophet's guidance regarding loud recitation in prayer?

The key takeaway is that reciting loudly in prayer should be done with consideration for those around you. The voice should be loud enough for you to focus but not so loud as to distract or disturb others.