⚠️ НЕ ОНОВЛЮЙ ДАНІ В РЕЗЕРВ + та ЩО БУДЕ ЯКЩО ОНОВИТИ.

Адвокат Болтик

18 Jun 202410:33

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses the 'Rezerw Plus' application, a platform for updating military service data in Ukraine. It raises concerns about the lack of a formal contract, the absence of state funding, and the involvement of a charitable foundation in its development. The video also addresses the legal aspects of the application, the lack of Cabinet of Ministers' decrees, and the implications for Ukrainian citizens living abroad. It concludes with a call to action for viewers to subscribe to the channel for more insights and a reminder of the importance of legal awareness.

Takeaways

😯 The 'Rezerw Plus' application was developed without the involvement of state funds; it was funded by a charitable foundation.
🔍 There is no contract between the Ministry of Defense and the developer of the 'Rezerw Plus' application, raising questions about the legitimacy and accountability of the project.
🏛 The Ministry of Defense claims they did not choose a contractor for the development of the application, suggesting a lack of direct involvement in the selection process.
🤔 There is confusion and lack of clarity regarding the origin of the funds used for the development of the application.
📝 The company that developed the application has full administrative access to it, which raises concerns about data security and user privacy.
📜 The application was developed by a company with property rights to the software, which was funded by the Charitable Foundation for the Development of Defense Capacity in Ukraine.
👥 There are concerns about the transparency of the agreements and contracts involved in the development of the application.
📊 The application is designed for updating military service-related data, but there is a debate about whether it has the necessary legal framework and approval.
🌐 'Rezerw Plus' is accessible globally, with provisions for Ukrainian citizens abroad to verify their identity and register through bank ID or video calls.
🛡 The video transcript suggests that there may be legal issues with the application, advising viewers to be cautious and seek professional advice.
📞 The speaker encourages viewers to join a legal protection community for support against potential illegal actions by state representatives, including the police and military enlistment offices.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in the video script?
-The main topic discussed in the video script is the 'Reserve Plus' application, its development, funding, and the legal issues surrounding its use for updating military service data in Ukraine.
Who is stated to have funded the development of the 'Reserve Plus' application?
-The development of the 'Reserve Plus' application was funded by a charitable foundation, specifically the Charitable Foundation for the Development of Defense Preparedness in Ukraine.
What is the controversy regarding the selection of the developer for the technical task in the script?
-The controversy is that no state funds were used for the development, and the Ministry of Defense did not choose the developer. Instead, a charitable foundation funded the project, raising questions about the transparency and legality of the process.
What is the role of the 'Reserve Plus' application in updating military service data?
-The 'Reserve Plus' application is intended for updating the data of military service personnel and reservists in Ukraine, which is a requirement under the new mobilization laws.
Why is there a concern about the legality of the 'Reserve Plus' application?
-There is a concern because there seems to be a lack of official government resolutions or regulations that clearly authorize the creation and use of the 'Reserve Plus' application for updating military service data.
What does the video suggest about the involvement of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine?
-The video suggests that the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine was supposed to ensure the creation and functioning of the electronic cabinet for conscripts and reservists within two months of the publication of the law, but there is no evidence of this being done.
What is the significance of the electronic cabinet mentioned in the script?
-The electronic cabinet is significant as it is the platform through which military service data is to be updated, and it is supposed to be created and managed by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine according to the law.
How does the video script address the issue of transparency in the development and funding of the 'Reserve Plus' application?
-The script raises questions about the transparency by pointing out the lack of public information about the agreements and the source of funds for the development of the application.
What is the recommendation given by the video regarding the use of the 'Reserve Plus' application?
-The recommendation given is for individuals to exercise caution and not to update their data through the 'Reserve Plus' application until there is clear legal regulation and transparency about its operation.
What additional service is offered for Ukrainian citizens abroad regarding the 'Reserve Plus' application?
-For Ukrainian citizens abroad, the script mentions the possibility of using bank ID for authorization in the application or obtaining a bank ID through video calls for those who do not have it, ensuring they can comply with the data update requirements.
What is the stance on double citizenship in the context of the 'Reserve Plus' application discussed in the script?
-The script clarifies that double citizenship is not allowed in Ukraine, and even if some individuals abroad have dual citizenship, they are still subject to Ukrainian law and must update their data through the 'Reserve Plus' application if they are military reservists or veterans.

Outlines

00:00

😐 Controversy Over the 'Reserve Plus' App Development

The first paragraph discusses the controversy surrounding the development of the 'Reserve Plus' application in Ukraine. It raises questions about the selection of the developers for the technical task without the involvement of state funds, which were instead donor-funded. The speaker expresses the impossibility of providing a direct answer to the question of who chose the developers due to the absence of a contract. The paragraph also touches on the involvement of a charitable foundation in financing the project and the lack of transparency regarding the legal framework and the origin of funds. The main concern is the legality and accountability of the process, as well as the mysterious nature of the 'Reserve Plus' application's development and funding.

05:02

🤔 Legal Concerns and Public Scrutiny of the 'Reserve Plus' App

The second paragraph delves into the legal concerns and public scrutiny of the 'Reserve Plus' application, which is meant for updating military service data. It highlights the lack of official decrees or resolutions that would typically accompany such an application, leading to confusion and suspicion. The speaker emphasizes the absence of any Cabinet of Ministers' decrees regarding the creation of the application, which contradicts the clear instructions given by law 3633-1. The paragraph also addresses the accessibility of the application for Ukrainian citizens abroad and the process of authentication through bank ID, suggesting that there may be alternative verification methods for those without current bank ID access. The speaker recommends not updating data through 'Reserve Plus' and invites viewers to join a legal protection community for support against illegal actions by state representatives.

10:04

😕 The Complexity of Citizenship and Legal Status for Ukrainians Abroad

The third paragraph, although incomplete, begins to address the complexities of citizenship and legal status for Ukrainians living abroad, particularly those who have been living outside of Ukraine for an extended period. It raises the issue of double citizenship, which is prohibited in Ukraine, and the challenges faced by these individuals in maintaining their Ukrainian citizenship while living abroad. The paragraph also touches on the discrimination against those who have chosen to live in another country and the legal processes they must go through to maintain their status. The speaker seems to be advocating for a fair and equal treatment of these individuals under Ukrainian law, despite their long-term residence outside the country.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Reserve Plus

Reserve Plus appears to be a digital application or platform mentioned in the script, which is used for updating military service-related data. It is central to the video's theme as it is the subject of discussion regarding its development, funding, and legal implications. The script mentions that there is controversy over who developed it and how it is being used.

💡Charitable Foundation

A charitable foundation is an organization that provides funding for various causes. In the context of the video, a charitable foundation is said to have financed the development of the Reserve Plus application. This is significant as it raises questions about the transparency and legitimacy of the funding source for a project related to military data.

💡Ministry of Defense

The Ministry of Defense is a government department responsible for matters related to the military. In the script, it is mentioned that the Ministry of Defense did not choose the executor for the development of the Reserve Plus application, which is a key point of discussion in the video regarding the procurement process and the role of the Ministry.

💡Data Update

Data update refers to the process of refreshing or modifying information to keep it current. The script discusses the necessity of updating data through the Reserve Plus application, which is a focal point of the video as it pertains to the legal and procedural aspects of data management for military personnel.

💡Legal Regulation

Legal regulation pertains to the rules and laws that govern a particular activity or process. The video discusses the legal framework surrounding the Reserve Plus application, including the lack of clear regulations and the implications of this for its use and the updating of military service data.

💡Electronic Cabinet

An electronic cabinet refers to a digital system or platform used for managing and storing information. In the script, the term is used to describe a system that is part of the Reserve Plus application, which allows for the management of military service data and is a point of contention in the video.

💡Funding Source

The funding source refers to the origin of financial support for a project or initiative. The script raises questions about the source of funds for the Reserve Plus application, with the mention of a charitable foundation, which is a key issue in the video's exploration of transparency and accountability.

💡Contract

A contract is a legally binding agreement between parties. The video script mentions the absence of a contract between the Ministry of Defense and the developer of the Reserve Plus application, which is a significant issue as it pertains to the legality and formalization of the project.

💡Mobilization

Mobilization in the context of the video seems to refer to the process of updating military service data. The script mentions new legislation related to mobilization and the updating of data through the Reserve Plus application, which is a central theme in the video's discussion of legal compliance and data management.

💡Verification

Verification in this context refers to the process of confirming the identity or authenticity of something, such as a user's credentials in an application. The script discusses the verification process for accessing the Reserve Plus application, which is a critical aspect of the video's focus on security and access control.

💡Legal Protection

Legal protection refers to the safeguarding of rights and interests through legal means. The video script mentions a community or club for legal protection, which is presented as a resource for individuals to protect themselves against illegal actions, including those related to the use of the Reserve Plus application.

Highlights

The 'Rezerw Plus' app was developed without state funds, using only donor funds.

The Ministry of Defense did not choose the developer for the 'Rezerw Plus' technical task.

There is no contract between the Ministry of Defense and the developer of the 'Rezerw Plus' app.

The 'Rezerw Plus' app provides access to the database of all military servicemen in Ukraine.

The developer of the 'Rezerw Plus' app is a company that has full administrative access to the app's infrastructure.

The 'Rezerw Plus' development was funded by the Charitable Foundation for the Development of Defense Capacity in Ukraine.

The Ministry of Defense received the rights to the software from a public organization under a charity contract.

There is no legal regulation or Cabinet of Ministers' decision on the creation of the 'Rezerw Plus' database.

The 'Rezerw Plus' app is not the same as the electronic office for conscripts and reservists established by law.

The law requires the Cabinet of Ministers to ensure the creation and operation of the electronic office for conscripts and reservists within two months, but this has not been done.

The 'Rezerw Plus' app is available for 176 countries worldwide for Ukrainian citizens abroad.

Ukrainian citizens abroad can authorize in the 'Rezerw Plus' app through bank ID or video call verification.

Double citizenship of Ukraine is prohibited, so Ukrainians abroad must comply with the law on updating their data.

18,000 people abroad have already updated their data in the 'Rezerw Plus' app, and others can also do it if they consider it necessary.

The process of changing citizenship takes time, and Ukrainians abroad should not be discriminated against.

The 'Rezerw Plus' app provides a convenient tool for Ukrainians abroad to update their data in accordance with their legal status.