[2편] '이대남' 20대 남자들의 극우화는 사실일까? l 홍대선 작가 l 혜윰달, 생각을 비추다

Summary

In this thought-provoking transcript, Hong Dae-seon, a Democratic supporter and writer, critiques the current feminist movement and the Democratic Party's stance on gender issues. He expresses frustration with the treatment of men, especially those in their 20s and 30s, who feel unfairly oppressed and humiliated. Dae-seon highlights the dangers of teaching feminist theory as an unquestioned doctrine, stressing the importance of gender equality instead. He also critiques political dynamics, referencing the rise of populist figures like Trump and the impact of divisive political tactics, urging for reconciliation and mutual understanding among citizens.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker criticizes the idea of forcing certain generations of men to be seen as potential perpetrators in society, particularly in relation to gender equality.
• 😀 The speaker identifies as a Democratic supporter but admits that not all actions by the Democratic Party are right, particularly its stance on gender issues.
• 😀 The speaker supports gender equality but argues against the teaching of feminism as an established theory in schools, stating that feminism is a philosophical trend, not a universally accepted truth.
• 😀 The speaker criticizes the government's approach to teaching gender equality and feminism, claiming it misrepresents these concepts academically and philosophically.
• 😀 There is a concern that young men, particularly those in their teens, twenties, and thirties, are being unfairly targeted and humiliated due to the way feminism is being framed in politics.
• 😀 The speaker points out that the concept of 'adult sensitivity' is an undefined and experimental term, with no official academic or legal recognition.
• 😀 The speaker believes that the pressure to accept certain ideologies as absolute truths—such as adult sensitivity or feminist theory—ultimately leads to societal violence and creates division.
• 😀 The speaker connects the rise of President Yoon Seong-yeol to the dissatisfaction of young male voters, who were angered by the Democratic Party's handling of gender-related issues.
• 😀 The speaker compares the rise of Yoon Seong-yeol to the election of Trump, suggesting that the progressive camp's failure to address the concerns of certain demographics, particularly white working-class men in the U.S., led to Trump's victory.
• 😀 The speaker calls for progressives to acknowledge their own biases and engage in dialogue with those who may hold opposing views, in order to bridge societal divides and foster reconciliation.

Q & A

What does Hong Dae-seon mean by the term 'adult sensitivity' in the transcript?

Hong Dae-seon critiques the concept of 'adult sensitivity,' suggesting that it is an undefined and unformulated idea with no concrete basis in law or established definitions. He views it as a subjective concept imposed upon individuals, especially men, without proper philosophical or legal justification.

What is Hong Dae-seon's stance on feminism in the context of gender equality?

Hong Dae-seon expresses support for gender equality, but he distinguishes feminism as a philosophical trend that originated in the 20th century, specifically structuralist philosophy. He argues that feminism should be taught academically and not as an established truth, as it could lead to a misunderstanding of gender equality.

How does Hong Dae-seon criticize the Democratic Party's approach to gender issues?

He criticizes the Democratic Party for using feminism as a political tool, particularly when it comes to alienating young men. He argues that the party creates a narrative where young men are portrayed as perpetrators, contributing to a sense of humiliation and disenfranchisement among male voters.

What does Hong Dae-seon mean when he says 'feminism is just a trend and methodology'?

Hong Dae-seon refers to feminism as a trend and methodology because it is based on a specific philosophical framework, not an absolute or universally accepted concept. He believes that feminism should be treated as a perspective, not as the definitive answer to gender equality.

Why does Hong Dae-seon mention the U.S. presidential election and Trump in his speech?

Hong Dae-seon uses the example of Donald Trump's rise to power as a way to illustrate how marginalized groups, particularly white men, feel alienated by progressive policies. He suggests that when such groups are made to feel wrong or insignificant, they may turn to figures like Trump who give voice to their frustrations.

What is the significance of Hong Dae-seon discussing the French Revolution and Marie Antoinette?

Hong Dae-seon compares the agitation surrounding Marie Antoinette during the French Revolution to modern-day political situations. He suggests that people often believe conspiracy theories when they are angry and struggling, and these beliefs can lead to social upheaval, as seen in both historical and contemporary contexts.

What does Hong Dae-seon believe is the core issue with the progressive camp?

Hong Dae-seon argues that the progressive camp faces a fundamental flaw in its approach. He claims that progressives often exaggerate non-existent problems to continue their political relevance, leading to a cycle of discontent and division among different groups in society.

What does Hong Dae-seon imply about the way men are treated in contemporary South Korean society?

He implies that men, particularly in their teens, twenties, and thirties, are unfairly portrayed as potential perpetrators in the context of gender issues. This treatment, he argues, creates resentment and leads to the alienation of a significant portion of the male population.

How does Hong Dae-seon view the role of education in teaching gender equality and feminism?

Hong Dae-seon believes that schools should teach gender equality, but he is critical of teaching feminism as an established or unquestionable theory. He suggests that feminism should be introduced as a philosophical framework, not as a definitive solution to gender issues.

Why does Hong Dae-seon suggest that the Democratic Party might have contributed to the rise of President Yoon Seong-yeol?

Hong Dae-seon attributes the rise of Yoon Seong-yeol to the Democratic Party's alienation of certain voter groups, particularly young men. He points to the controversy over the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family, suggesting that the party's stance on gender issues contributed to a backlash that helped fuel Yoon's popularity.