[FULL] Percakapan Cekcok Zelensky, Trump, dan Vance di Ruang Oval AS

Summary

In this intense dialogue, Ukrainian President Zelensky and former U.S. President Trump engage in a tense exchange over the ongoing war in Ukraine. Zelensky asserts Ukraine’s struggle for survival and defends his country’s position, emphasizing the lack of international support in past years. Trump expresses frustration with the war, claiming his approach would have ended it swiftly, stressing diplomacy and the U.S. role in supporting Ukraine. The conversation becomes heated as Trump critiques U.S. foreign policy under previous administrations, while Zelensky insists on the need for gratitude and cooperation to end the conflict.

Takeaways

• 😀 President Zelensky expresses gratitude for U.S. military support but also stresses the importance of continued assistance to Ukraine's survival in the war with Russia.
• 😀 President Trump emphasizes the need for peace and diplomacy, portraying himself as a peacemaker who aims to end the conflict quickly and save lives and resources.
• 😀 Zelensky acknowledges the significance of U.S. support, but criticizes the lack of international action during the earlier stages of Russia's occupation of Crimea in 2014.
• 😀 President Trump defends his approach, suggesting that his ability to negotiate with both sides is essential for peace, rather than taking a tough stance against one side.
• 😀 Zelensky strongly advocates for security guarantees and a peace deal but points out the repeated violations of ceasefires by Russia in previous years.
• 😀 The conversation shifts toward tensions in how diplomacy and military support are handled, with the focus on how different U.S. presidents (Obama, Trump, Biden) responded to Russia's aggression.
• 😀 Trump suggests that the U.S. should be thankful for the support given to Ukraine and asserts that without U.S. military aid, the war would have been much shorter, potentially ending in just days.
• 😀 There is a significant clash in tone between Zelensky and Trump, with Zelensky showing frustration over what he perceives as a lack of understanding of Ukraine's situation.
• 😀 Trump hints at a more aggressive stance against Russia, positioning himself as someone who could have negotiated a deal, unlike other U.S. leaders who failed to act effectively.
• 😀 The dialogue includes sharp criticisms of President Biden and prior U.S. administrations, with Trump positioning himself as the stronger leader capable of dealing with Putin effectively.

Q & A

What was President Zelensky's stance on U.S. support for Ukraine during the interview?

President Zelensky expressed gratitude towards the U.S. for its support, stating that the United States has been on Ukraine's side since the beginning of the war. He acknowledged the importance of U.S. military aid and emphasized that Ukraine is relying on continued support to defend its territory.

How did President Trump view the situation regarding military support for Ukraine?

President Trump mentioned that the U.S. had provided significant military aid to Ukraine, including $350 billion in military equipment. He suggested that without this support, Ukraine's situation would have been much worse and that the war might have ended quickly without U.S. intervention.

What did President Trump mean when he referred to himself as a 'peacemaker'?

President Trump expressed a desire to be remembered as a peacemaker, hoping to end the war quickly. He believed that resolving the conflict would save lives and reduce the costs of war, positioning himself as someone who could bring diplomacy and peace rather than prolonging conflict.

Why did President Zelensky criticize the previous U.S. administrations?

President Zelensky criticized past U.S. administrations for failing to stop Russia's actions, particularly in 2014 when Russia annexed Crimea. He pointed out that while diplomatic talks and agreements were made, Russia continued its aggression and violated ceasefires, causing significant loss of life.

What were President Trump's views on aligning with Russia in the negotiation process?

President Trump explained that in order to make a deal, he had to engage with both sides, including Russia. He clarified that his goal was not to align with Putin but to align with the interests of the United States and the world, aiming to negotiate a peaceful resolution rather than taking an adversarial stance.

How did President Zelensky respond to Trump’s question about his attire and the respect for the office?

President Zelensky responded humorously, stating that he would wear a suit after the war was over. He suggested that once the war finished, he would dress more formally, hinting at the chaotic nature of the conflict that left little room for such concerns.

What was the disagreement between the two leaders about U.S. military involvement?

President Zelensky emphasized the importance of U.S. military aid in the conflict, suggesting that without it, Ukraine would have lost the war quickly. President Trump countered that his administration had provided substantial aid, but he also stated his hope that the war would end soon, reducing the need for continued support.

How did President Trump view the potential for a ceasefire?

President Trump stated that while he would support a ceasefire, he believed that security issues, such as guaranteeing the end of hostilities, were not the primary concern. His main focus was on negotiating a deal to end the war swiftly, even if the ceasefire was not yet in place.

What did President Zelensky say about Russia’s actions in 2014 and beyond?

President Zelensky recounted how Russia had occupied parts of Ukraine starting in 2014, with ongoing violence and territorial disputes. He criticized the lack of action from previous U.S. administrations, such as those of Obama and Trump, to stop Russia's aggression, and emphasized the importance of addressing these historical events in the current peace negotiations.

What was the overall tone of the meeting between President Zelensky and President Trump?

The meeting was tense and confrontational, with both leaders expressing strong opinions on the handling of the conflict in Ukraine. President Zelensky was focused on the importance of continued U.S. support, while President Trump emphasized his role in providing aid and facilitating negotiations. There was a notable disagreement about past U.S. policies and the overall approach to the war.