Should We BAN Red Purple Law For Realsies?

Summary

The video script discusses the dominance of the Red-Purple Law (Repa) deck in the One Piece trading card game meta, comparing it to past dominant decks like Whitebeard and Sakazuki. It explores the reasons behind Repa's strength, including card effects and meta shifts, and debates possible solutions such as banning or restricting certain cards. The script also provides historical context on how Bandai has addressed similar issues in the past, suggesting potential actions they might take to balance the game.

Takeaways

• 🃏 The video discusses the prevalence of Red Purple Law in the current One Piece trading card game meta, suggesting it may be too dominant.
• 🎥 The video is sponsored by Card Market and Sleeve Chief, with a promotion for a discount on the latter's Solo Hunter collection.
• 🤔 The creator initially made a joke video about the topic but decided to make a serious one after receiving feedback from the community.
• 🔥 Red Purple Law has been the top deck in every major tournament in Asia for the OP08 set, indicating a potential imbalance.
• 📚 The video provides a historical context by comparing Red Purple Law to previous dominant decks like Whitebeard and Sakazuki in the game's meta.
• 🚫 Past strategies to deal with overpowered decks included banning key cards or restricting leaders, as seen with Whitebeard and Sakazuki.
• 🔄 The video suggests that Red Purple Law's strength may be due to recent card additions in the OP08 set, specifically Pudding and Black Maria.
• 💡 The discussion proposes potential solutions, such as banning or restricting certain cards, or adjusting the game mechanics to balance the meta.
• 🛠️ The creator suggests 'power creep' as a solution, implying that other leaders could be buffed to compete with Red Purple Law.
• 📉 The video acknowledges the complexity of balancing a trading card game, especially when dealing with a dominant deck that affects deck design space.
• 💻 The creator experienced technical difficulties, which added an unplanned element to the video's creation process.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the video script?

The main topic of the video script is discussing whether the 'Red Purple Law' deck should be banned in the One Piece trading card game meta.

What is the context of the video being sponsored?

The video is sponsored by Card Market and Sleeve Chief, with the latter offering a discount code for their solo Hunter collection.

Why did the video creator initially make a joke video about the topic?

The video creator initially made a joke video about the topic because many viewers were expecting a serious discussion on whether to ban the Red Purple Law deck.

What is the significance of the 'Red Purple Law' deck in the current meta?

The 'Red Purple Law' deck is significant because it has been the top one and two decks in every major tournament in Asia for the OP08 set, indicating a high level of dominance in the meta.

What historical decks are compared to 'Red Purple Law' in the video?

The historical decks compared to 'Red Purple Law' are Saka Suzuki and Whitebeard, which were also dominant in their respective metas.

What was the unique aspect of Whitebeard's leader ability in the game?

Whitebeard's unique leader ability allowed him to take a life card to his hand every turn, starting with six life, which set a clock for the game as players had to defeat their opponent before running out of counters.

What card was considered a staple in Whitebeard decks and why was it eventually banned?

Moby Dick was a staple in Whitebeard decks because it provided a significant power boost when the player had one or less life. It was eventually banned due to its impact on the game's balance, making Whitebeard too dominant.

What is the role of 'Black Maria' in the Red Purple Law deck and why is it controversial?

Black Maria is a card that provides significant utility to the Red Purple Law deck, allowing for Dawn recovery and potentially making the deck too strong. It is controversial because it might be making the deck too dominant and limiting the design space for other decks.

What is the suggestion for addressing the dominance of the Red Purple Law deck?

One suggestion is to either ban or restrict cards like Black Maria or Pudding that significantly strengthen the Red Purple Law deck. Another suggestion is to 'erata' Black Maria to limit its effect to only work with specific leaders.

What is the video creator's personal stance on banning or restricting cards?

The video creator's personal stance is not to ban or restrict any cards, but they acknowledge the prevalence of Red Purple Law and its impact on the game's meta, suggesting that some form of adjustment may be necessary.

What is the video creator's proposed solution for the Red Purple Law issue?

The video creator proposes that the most diplomatic solution would be to 'erata' Black Maria so that it only works with specific leaders, allowing other purple leaders to still use the card while limiting its impact on the Red Purple Law deck.

Outlines

00:00

🃏 Sponsorship and Ban Discussion

The video script begins with a sponsorship mention and a plea for help regarding the impact of certain trading card game strategies on players' lives. The creator admits to initially mocking the situation but then feeling remorseful. The primary focus is on whether a card named 'Repa' should be banned due to its dominance in the game's meta. The video is intended to be a serious analysis of this issue, contrasting with a previous joke video on the same topic. The script also humorously mentions a lost script due to a computer crash and a call to support the creator by purchasing from sponsors.

05:02

🔥 Historical Deck Dominance and Bans

This paragraph delves into the history of dominant decks in the trading card game, focusing on the 'Whitebeard' and 'Sakazuki' decks. It discusses how Whitebeard's unique abilities and the introduction of the 'Moby Dick' card led to a ban by Bandai, the game's publisher. The narrative then shifts to the 'Sakazuki' deck, detailing its rise to prominence with the help of cards like 'Great Eruption' and 'Rebecca'. The paragraph also touches on the impact of the 'Gecko Moria' card, which significantly boosted the power of black decks, leading to Sakazuki's eventual ban.

10:03

🚫 Controversy Over Card Banning and Meta Shifts

The script continues with a discussion on the controversy surrounding card bans and their impact on the game's meta. It examines the cases of Whitebeard and Sakazuki, where specific cards were banned to balance the game. The paragraph also explores the implications of these bans on deck diversity and the challenges of maintaining a healthy meta. The creator expresses a preference for a meta where multiple distinct decks can coexist, even if one color dominates, as was the case with the red decks after the bans.

15:05

🤔 Analysis of Red-Purple Law's Dominance

The focus shifts to the current meta, where the 'Red-Purple Law' deck is dominant. The script explores the reasons behind this dominance, including the deck's leader ability to cheat out additional bodies and the impact of cards like 'Ru' and 'Rais Max'. It also considers whether the perceived balance of minusing Dawn for powerful effects is fair, and how the introduction of new cards in set '08' may have contributed to the deck's current strength.

20:05

🛑 Potential Solutions to Red-Purple Law's Dominance

The creator proposes potential solutions to address the dominance of the Red-Purple Law deck. Suggestions include banning or restricting certain cards like 'Black Maria' or 'Pudding', which are seen as problematic. The paragraph also discusses the possibility of 'power creep', where other leaders are buffed to compete, and the idea of 'erratum', which would limit the effects of certain cards to specific leaders. The creator expresses a preference for the most diplomatic solution, which would allow Red-Purple Law to remain viable while addressing the issues it presents to the game's balance.

📊 Conclusion and Call for Community Feedback

In the final paragraph, the creator summarizes their thoughts on the Red-Purple Law issue and the overall state of the game's meta. They express curiosity about what actions Bandai might take to address the situation and advocate for a solution that maintains the integrity of the game. The script concludes with a call for community feedback and a humorous note about the challenges of creating content, including a computer issue that led to the loss of a prepared script.

Keywords

💡Red Purple Law

Red Purple Law refers to a specific deck combination in the trading card game being discussed, which is currently dominant in the game's meta. The video explores whether this deck should be banned due to its prevalence and power. It is mentioned repeatedly throughout the script as a central topic of discussion, with various tournaments showing a 'Red Purple Law mirror,' indicating that the deck is so strong that players often use it to the exclusion of other strategies.

💡Ban

In the context of trading card games, a 'ban' refers to the official prohibition of using certain cards in official tournaments, typically due to their overpowered nature. The script discusses the possibility of banning 'Red Purple Law' and uses historical examples of other decks and cards that have been banned to maintain game balance.

💡Meta

The 'meta' in trading card games denotes the current state of the game's competitive environment, including which decks and strategies are most popular and successful. The script uses the term to describe the dominance of 'Red Purple Law' and compares it to past metas where different decks were dominant.

💡Sponsored

The term 'sponsored' in the script indicates that the video content is supported by advertisements or endorsements, specifically mentioning 'Card Market' and 'Sleeve Chief' as sponsors. This is a common practice in online media where companies pay for product placement or promotional content.

💡Leader Ability

A 'Leader Ability' in trading card games is a special power or effect associated with the leader card, which is a central card in a player's deck. The script discusses the unique leader abilities of different characters like Whitebeard and Sakazuki, and how these abilities influence the game's strategy and balance.

💡Ramp

In card games, 'ramp' refers to cards or effects that help a player accelerate their resource generation, typically allowing them to play more cards sooner. The script mentions 'ramp cards' in the context of 'Red Purple Law', suggesting that these cards help the deck play more aggressively by advancing the player's 'Dawn' resource, which is crucial for its strategy.

💡Counter

A 'Counter' in trading card games is a card or effect that can be used to negate or reduce the impact of an opponent's move. The script discusses 'Counter' in relation to the 'Whitebeard' deck's defensive capabilities and the 'Sakazuki' deck's offensive capabilities.

💡Combo

A 'Combo' in card games is a sequence of moves or card plays that interact in a beneficial way, often resulting in a significant advantage. The script uses the term to describe how certain cards, like 'Gecko Moria', enable powerful combinations in the 'Sakazuki' deck.

💡E-Reader

Although not explicitly mentioned in the script, the term 'E-Reader' is implied when discussing 'Dawn' and 'cards', suggesting a digital or virtual card game platform where players use an interface to play, similar to how one would use an E-Reader for books but for gaming purposes.

💡Banlist

A 'Banlist' is a list of cards that are not allowed in official play due to their power level or other reasons. The script suggests that the 'Red Purple Law' might end up on the banlist if its dominance continues, referencing past instances where cards or decks have been restricted to maintain a healthy game environment.

💡Power Creep

Power Creep refers to the gradual increase in the power level of new cards or strategies over time, often necessitating older cards to be updated or replaced. The script suggests power creep as a potential solution to the dominance of 'Red Purple Law', by introducing new cards that can compete with its current power level.

Highlights

Discussion on whether Red-Purple Law (Repa) should be banned in the One Piece TCG meta.

Sponsorship of the video by Card Market and Sleeve Chief.

Red-Purple Law's prevalence in major tournaments, being the top deck in multiple events.

Historical comparison with other dominant decks like Whitebeard and Sakazuki in the game's meta.

Whitebeard's unique 6K leader ability and its impact on the game's strategy.

The introduction of Moby Dick as a game-changer for the Whitebeard deck.

Ban of Moby Dick to balance the Whitebeard deck in the meta.

Sakazuki's powerful leader ability and its effect on the game's hand cycling and attacking.

Gecko Moria's role in making Sakazuki the best deck in format from OP06 to EB01.

Ban of Sakazuki and greater option to address the deck's dominance.

Analysis of Red-Purple Law's strength, including its leader ability and card interactions.

Debate on whether Ru, a 4-drop card, is too powerful and contributes to Red-Purple Law's dominance.

Introduction of Raise Max '06 as a potential issue for Red-Purple Law's power level.

Pudding and Black Maria's impact on Red-Purple Law's ability to recover and maintain Dawn.

Suggestion to ban or restrict certain cards like Black Maria or Pudding to balance Red-Purple Law.

Discussion on the potential solutions to Red-Purple Law's dominance without outright banning the leader.

Proposal to limit Black Maria's effect to specific leaders to balance the game.

Personal stance on preferring card errata over bans to maintain deck diversity and playability.

Anticipation for Bandai's decision on how to address Red-Purple Law's dominance in the meta.

Transcripts

please someone help these are human

lives that says

wrong they have families children

they're are friends and we're watching

them not subscribe card

kaizoku please buy my

[Music]

new

P this video is sponsored by Card Market

Europe's largest Online Marketplace for

trading card games this video is

sponsored by sleeve Chief their solo

Hunter collection is dropping on Sunday

use code card kaizoku for 5% off your

order so should we ban red purple law a

few days ago I made a joke video about

the topic but it did seem like a lot of

you were expecting a serious video and

yeah I admit I did laugh at first at

your misery but then I started to feel

bad so yeah I'm doing this video to

answer that question in Earnest should

repa be banned we'll take an actual look

into whether or not we should do that

and just to preface this video my stance

is not to ban or restrict any cards but

despite that I think you can't deny how

prevalent red purple law is at the

moment and I actually wrote a script for

this video I typed for like 40 minutes

but my computer blue screened so I lost

it all so I'm going to do this live on

the Fly while that information from the

script is still fresh in my mind I hope

and yeah uh help fund me fixing my

computer by buying my Dawn if you can

thanks okay so the last few or actually

every major tournament in Asia so far in

op08 has been a r law mirror we have the

Singapore Grand Asia open the Singapore

championship series The II prefecture

Hiroshima prefecture and Tokyo

prefecture championship series every

single one of those was a red purple law

mirror there's that Philippines GR as

open too I don't know if it finished or

not or if the deck list are anywhere

online pretty sure it was a repot mirror

too if it was but yeah that is at least

five six tournaments where red purple LW

is the top one and two decks I don't

believe it has ever been this ubiquitous

in representation of one particular deck

in The Meta now when you think of best

deck in format in the history of One

Piece the two other leaders that come to

mind are Saka Suzuki and Whitebeard so I

guess before judging repa let's take a

look at the history of the other two

best decks in formats in their

respective metas so we'll start with

op02 Whitebeard Edward Nate he is

special in that he's a 6K leader the

first of his kind and his leader ability

is also very unique you took a life card

to your hand every turn so to compensate

for that he starts at six life this was

a very ambitious design choice for a

card especially in the games second ever

expansion really like flips the game on

its head cuz his leader ability

basically sets you on a clock you want

to kill your opponent before you run out

of Counter in hand and defensive counter

events as well now the reason why P was

strong in his meta was that pretty much

every other color at the time was not as

developed as red right red had the best

aggressive cards with rush and like

cards that could bypass blockers red

also had the best defensive events with

radical Beam countering for four Dawn

for one Dawn and guardo countering for

3K for one Dawn as well and white bir

himself being able to swing 6K over

every other 5K leader at the time

meaning it takes a 2K to even stop his

bear leader hit so this makes it really

hard for your opponent to basically

survive against you cuz even if you go

to zero life with your leader ability

you do have a lot of Defense in your

hand to even survive that but it wasn't

undoable right there was a way to kill

Whitebeard that is until people started

running Moby Dick in their deck so Moby

Dick is a stage card that also came out

in op02 it was debated whether you

should run this card or not some

whitebeards like to run it some thought

it was too inconsistent depending on the

stage card to win you the game cuz what

this stage card does is if you have one

or less life your leader and all your

characters with the wi Parts type get

plus 2,000 power for free basically

games where you drew the stage card and

played it early enough you're able to

bust out your opponent with ease it was

getting to the point at the end of The

op02 Meta where it was becoming white

bird mirrrors and the white bird who ran

Mo deck was able to overwhelm the white

bird who didn't run mob deck so yeah it

became a staple in the deck it was

around this time that people were having

the same complaints with r prop a lot

nowadays right white be was too strong

it was gatekeeping other weaker decks

from being able to be viable in The Meta

it was practically the only deck in The

Meta but Bandai still did not do

anything about the deck in op03 in the

beginning at least so if the strategy in

O2 to play against what people called

dickbeard Moby dickbeard was to Hope

they'd never draw the stage card it

became a lot harder to do that in op03

with the introduction of this Searcher

so for one Dawn it greatly increased the

consistency of fting the stage card it

became such a consistent strategy that

Bandai did in fact ban Mooby deck I

believe a couple weeks into the meta so

this was an instance where Bandai

actually reacted really quickly they

didn't wait until the end of op03 to

stop this they also banned uh kabaji for

the Nami deck they didn't let Nami get a

chance to become too oppressive I guess

I guess we'll never see that meta though

but yeah Whitebeard after the ban of

Moby Dick did become less ubiquitous in

The Meta I guess I like saying that word

ubiquitous yeah he just was not the only

red deck in The Meta red was still the

strongest color of course but he did

share the spotlight with the Ron noro

Zoro op01 and also op01 tragar law red

green law and actually people still

complained about the meta at this point

where all the decks were red they

complained there was too much red red

was too strong but honestly I kind of

like this meta cuz despite one color

being over represented it was still

three very distinctive play style decks

making up the top of the meta right it

wasn't just red prop La it wasn't just

sakazuki it wasn't just Whitebeard it

was Whitebeard plus Zoro plus law three

Decks that played completely differently

from each other they don't even share

too many of the same cards so because of

that I I kind of felt like this was a

healthy meta of course we would have

loved to see other colors at the top but

honestly it's a lot better than it is

now at the moment with red purple law so

that was pretty much the meta until op05

well I guess yeah katakuti made his way

in there at some point too in 03 but

yeah op05 hit and then uh this guy took

over not at first though so sakazuki is

a blue black leader that means he has

four starting life cuz he's dual color

but what his leader ability does is

activate main once per turn you can

discard a card from your hand and then

draw a card basically allowing you to

cycle your hand to find answers and then

when you attack with the leader you give

minus one cost to a character so pretty

much this leader had no downside to use

his leader ability it was only positives

usually with other leaders it kind of

cost something or there's like strict

requirements to meet but with sakazuki

from the first turn you could use your

leader ability from the first turn you

can attack you could take advantage of

both parts of his leader ability so yeah

just a very strong leader that just

needed people to figure out his deck so

at first yeah he was not as overwhelming

in The Meta white beards was still

winning katak was still winning Zoro was

still winning but as the meta progress

people started to figure this deck out

with with cards like great eruption

being able to get minus two cost to

something and then replacing itself this

card did get banned at some point we'll

get to that later and then hel Blaze

being able to buff your Searchers to

make them into attacking bodies and get

rid of a character by bottom decking it

that's way better than koing cuz this

gets rid of cards that can't be koed and

then people were starting to catch on to

Rebecca being an insane card it's a four

cost blocker that can bring back a 3 to7

cost black character to your hand and

then you can play a three cost from your

hand these are two separate effects too

so you have a lot of ability and how you

want to use this blocker and they would

play cards like this Hina from the

starter deck pretty much people rode off

starter deck six as like one of the

worst starter decks but this sakazuki

deck brought it back into popularity it

pretty much raised the price of the deck

to insane Heights and then people

started to figure out that oh if you

combo cards like Hina great eruption and

your leader ability this o5 Luchi that

came in the same set being able to kill

a one cost and a two cost that's pretty

much any card in the game you can make

into a one or two cost so this became

like the premier removal card in the

format CU he himself is a 6K attacker

for for on too so he's great as a

vanilla so not only does this leader fix

your hand it also is able to remove

stuff on board and develop attackers and

attack for big numbers himself with

cards like H Blaze and yeah Hina even

Hina herself is an attacker at 5K so

people were starting to realize how

strong of a deck this was it still

shared the spotlight with purple Luffy

though it was starting to lose Theme by

the end of The Meta as people were able

to figure out how to make purple Luffy's

characters be able to be koed by this

Luchi in fact I think the only

opposition to sakazuki at this time was

katakuti and enl to a degree playing

characters that were just too big to be

ko'ed but that that all kind of changed

once uh this [ __ ] came out Obi 06

gecko Moria this pretty much carries the

entire black color and is the reason why

sakazuki is the best deack in format

from op0 6 to the end of e01 cuz what

gecko Maria does is it lets you play a

four cost or less and a two cost or less

character from your trash one of them

comes out active the other one comes out

rested there's so much combo potential

in a sakazuki deck or any black deck

with this card cuz uh conveniently they

have access to a blocker that they can

play from the discard that can also draw

you a another card on top of that you

can also play out the [ __ ] removal

card that is also a strong attacker and

can KO two things and then with the two

cost portion of effect you have access

to a lot of strong like cost reduction

cards so basically you develop a 9k

attacker you develop a 6K attacker that

ko2 things and then you probably cleared

your opponent's board so you you're left

with uh two strong attackers your

opponent has nothing you come back from

the game you leave your opponent in

shambles this is what makes sakazuki

such a strong deck and opo six onward

but this time Bandai didn't do anything

about it op05 sakazuki was like top meta

but I guess not at the level that white

white beard was in his prime so yeah I

guess you could forgive Bandai for

letting it pass one more set but 06

sakazuki was a different

story and in fact the world

championships at this time was a

sakazuki mirror in the end too between

Guan Rong and Jackson so it just goes to

show you the power of sakazuki in the

meta and then oddly enough even though

sakazuki was the top prevalent deck in

The Meta they still printed out support

for the deck ezor 1 gave him T-Bone a

Navy 2K counter that can KO on play that

they could search with the deck 06 gave

them T shigi another one cost Searcher

that can search even for brand new so

you can search into another Searcher and

this one doesn't discard too so even

with sakazuki being the best deck in the

format they printed out more cards that

made it even better in the format the

best deck in the format I guess and yeah

it wasn't until the end of eb01 after

the conclusion of the World Championship

Finals that they announced that sakazuki

and greater option was going to be

banned reject to so that took what three

sets or two sets and like a midet extra

booster to handle sakazuki and this time

they didn't just ban a stage card right

Banning a stage card for Whitebeard made

him within the acceptable power limit

but in sakazuki case they banned the

leader out entirely and not only that

they kind of hit other black decks by

getting rid of uh great eruption but to

be honest I think the problematic card

is geeko Moria cuz even in today's meta

Luchi runs them black yellow Luffy runs

them gecko Moya runs them there's no way

to play any of these black decks without

this card I feel like that is a crutch

in design it's a big problem right there

should be black Decks that can compete

that can exist without this card This

One Singular card but for some reason

the integral like identity and play

style of the top three black decks in

The Meta at the moment do depend on this

geekam Moria card so yeah if we do ban

this card like it cripples three decks I

don't think they should have design

those leaders in the way that like they

need this card to even survive oh yeah

this Brook to I forgot to mention Brooke

this is another card that benefit

sakazuki and any deck that runs eight

koria so we've seen two approaches now

where you ban the cards that make the

leader strong and that fix Whitebeard at

least and then we have the approach

where we ban the leader in general cuz I

guess they couldn't figure out a way to

fix it so let's take a look at red

purple law and why he's strong in The

Meta so some people think it's just his

leader ability being able to cheat out a

second body for the turn without having

to pay Dawn for anything cuz you're

minusing Dawn some people think that the

minusing dawn is the trade-off for that

strong effect cuz you're playing

something with the cost of four or less

so minus three Dawn is equal to the

opportunity cost of playing a four drop

from your hand for free cuz it does set

you like more than a turn behind you're

a turn and a half behind in that case

but but this does get eleviate somewhat

with all the ramp cards you run in the

deck so the balance there is that you're

minusing Dawn to play out mediocre ramp

cards that are for cost that have like a

5k stat line so in that regard it I I

personally think it's kind of fair some

other people also point to Ru being an

issue so Ru is a four drop 5K attacker

that was introduced in ' 06 that does uh

onplay if you have equal to or less Dawn

on your field than your opponent and if

you have five or less cards in your hand

you draw two cards so one of the

weaknesses of repal law was that yeah

you're dumping two cards from your hand

every turn this does mean that you do

run out of steam and you only have four

life to take cards from into your hand

as a resource so it was like a balancing

act of playing characters where you know

that you can get value out of them and

they won't die and also keeping yourself

alive so that you can finish off your

opponent in a like geom Moria and

sakazuki heavy meta playing out two four

drops they're not going to last long

right that's the reason sakazuki was get

into purple Luffy they're able to kill

two five cost on board so two four cost

is even easier than that but Ru does is

lets you refill your hand it's one card

for plus two in hand that's great card

advant replaces yourself and then plus

one on top of that and then yeah you

just play out more bodies than the

opponent has removal to handle at this

point so a lot of people point to Ru

being a card that is what makes rep a

lot broken my stance on that is that in

the 06 and 07 meta this is fine actually

right if this was an issue that makes

law broken then it would have been an

issue in ' 07 but clear clearly it

wasn't as law sheded the spotlight with

Luchi and black y Luffy and enl could it

be that people just didn't figure out

how to play repa optimally yet it could

be but but that's the more like

complicated reasoning behind it I'd like

to go for the more simple one that's

usually the more correct one in that Ru

doesn't break red purle law it

definitely helps it makes it a viable

top meta Contender but it did not make

it the Menace that he is now on its own

in a vacuum in 07 and 06 some people

also point to rais Max and 06 also being

an issue right cuz prior to this we only

had four copies of the minus 3K effect

for one Dawn with the Gordon promo

Gordon 06 give us this functional

reprint allowing allowing us to run

eight copies of this effect some people

think that having eight copies is too

much that lets us answer everything on

board but to be honest I also feel like

this isn't an issue right cuz sakazuki

and geeko Moria and Luchi also have

access to this kind of effect I mean

yeah they banned great eruption but this

one Drew you a card so you didn't go

Downing card Advantage you just got a

free minus two K to kill something rais

Max at least goes to the bottom of your

deck so yeah it doesn't replace himself

you're down one card in hand if you play

this but yeah my reason for not Banning

raax is that there's cards like Ice Age

In Black that pretty much do the same

thing one Dawn for minus five cost that

allows black decks to KO anything

similarly to a raise Max one Dawn for

minus 3K allows us to bottom deck

anything they even printed out Tempest

kick rankyaku and 07 which is basically

a great option but you need to have 10

cards in your trash to use it so one

Dawn for minus resource to be able to

meet a removal threshold is a design

space that Bandai does not have a

problem with and I don't think it's an

issue either so we have to look at the

cards in' 08 right cuz this is the meta

where Ripa is the Menace that he is so

what did 08 give us that kind of broke

the meta well here's putting a three

cost 4K attacker what she does is on

your turn once per turn when Dawn is

returned to your Dawn deck you can add a

dawn from your Dawn deck as rested

pretty much like five cost kid that is a

staple in the deck except the dawn

doesn't come back active but what makes

pudding especially devastating in a r

law deck is that you now have something

you can do on your three Dawn turn you

have something you can do on your four

Dawn turn even prior to this you kind of

want to wait until you're at six Dawn to

play your five cost kid on top of a

Gordon to give minus 3K to something and

then bottom deck it and get a dawn back

so you're not too far behind in Dawn

pting kind of mix it so that we can do

this on our four Dawn turn right three

Dawn for pudding play out of Gordon

minus 3K to something

bottom deck it you get a dawn back from

pudding you cheat out such a penguin you

get two more Dawn back you're back up to

four allowing you go to six next turn

which case you can play a kid foron

bottom deck you get two Dawn back after

that so it just snowballs it lets you

start activating Your Leader ability a

turn earlier which makes all the

difference in the world if your opponent

has no early game to contest you you're

just dominating from from the start and

then it just cost one Dawn onto pudding

to make her an attack or too the other

card added an ' 08 which is I think a

lot of people kind of point the finger

at black Maria it's a new 2k and what

she does is uh for three you can play

her out and then activate main ones per

turn if you have no other black Maria

you can add up to five Dawn cards when

your Dawn deck is rested then at the end

of your turn you can return Dawn cards

from your field to your da deck until

you have the equal amount as your

opponent so this is like a turbo insane

utility card for the deck not only is

she a 2K counter meaning that she's

useful in hand even if you don't play

her out the fact that she can ramp you

five Dawn and then you keep however many

to match your opponent that is an insane

comeback mechanic of rep purle law this

allows you to be really really greedy

with your leader ability too at worst

she's a shachi and penguin which is

basically meaning that you have eight

copies of shachi and penguin in your

deck now and at best she completely

ramps you the five Dawn you get to keep

all five against opponents that don't

minus Dawn you're able to recover a lot

of dawn with black Maria does that you

be really aggressive early cheating out

stuff like

Sanji and Ru to draw you more cards

without having to worry about keeping up

Dawn because again the other weakness of

law or I guess inexperienced rep La

players in the past was that if you use

your leader ability too much you just

don't have any Dawn to play out bigger

characters or to combo right you won't

have Dawn to play kid and a Gordon

that's six Dawn you won't have Dawn for

your characters to attack for lethal you

just have a lot less options if you if

you use your leader ability to willly

neilly a lot of people feel that black

Maria kind of cancels out that nuance in

the play style you could just play out

Ru draw two cards play out Sanji and

then when [ __ ] hits the fan cheat out

black Maria recover five Dawn and you're

back in the game on your next turn so

the combination of these two cards make

it really really unrestrictive to use

your leader ability it removes a lot of

the Nuance you don't have to really plan

out too much cuz you know you have these

cards that will bail you out and that's

the case against every other leader I do

have to say though in the riple laot

mirror when you play out your puddings

in Black Maria matters but that's cuz

that's the mirror right it mirrors are

always like that but yeah this does kind

of dumb down the matchups against every

other Deck with Rah now what can we do

about it well some people suggest just

Banning black Maria or even pudding

restricting pudding or something and

honestly that that may fix the issue

right if in ' 07 law was not as

dominating as he is now then removing

the cards that made him as dominating as

as he is now should in theory fix the

problem so I can't deny that but the

issue comes in that like black Maria was

not printed solely for R purple lot it

was printed to help a lot of other decks

out a lot of purple decks so removing

this because it helps R purple lot too

much kind of guts a lot of other purple

decks like even freaking starter deck 4

kaido was starting to see play again

because of this card if we remove it he

goes back into the dumpster so is that

the trade-off we want do we want one

card like this making other decks viable

to not be able to exist cuz it makes one

other deck too strong so there's that

argument there a lot of people are just

calling for the ban on the leader in

general cuz he kind of limits the design

space if red propa didn't exist black

Maria can be freely able to be in the

meta to be used by other purple decks

but again I personally don't like it

when cards get banned outright like that

especially leaders I don't like the fact

that an entire like deck play style can

just be removed like that without any

attempts to like fix it or try to figure

out Tech against it so then how do we go

about fixing it right so that we can

keep R up a la in the game well the

easiest answer and the answer that

probably a lot of people don't want is

um Power creep the other leaders right

if every other leader got new options

that could compete that would level the

playing field but that introduces a

whole like new can of worms right if you

overbuff other leaders then you have an

issue of that leader being the best deck

in the format cuz for other leaders to

even match rep's power they'll need like

a lot of game mechanic to finding cards

like this black Maria so if other colors

had a card this good who knows you maybe

you're making the next monster in the

next format another way to fix it is to

Arata cards so a lot of people were

suggesting if maybe black Maria only was

able to do this effect if you ran a

animal kingdom Pirates leader that would

fix the issues right everyone gets to

have have their cake and eat it kaido

gets to run black Maria King gets to run

black Maria law can't so that route I

feel like would be the best of both

worlds the most diplomatic solution and

it's not like they haven't done in AATA

like that before right I believe Nami

from op01 in the very first printing

stated that she only searched for straw

head type characters but it was later

corrected to straw head type cards I

forgot if that was a rule change or if

they just typoed it from the beginning

if they typoed it from the beginning and

they meant any straw head card from the

beginning then maybe that argument

doesn't hold up but yeah that's pretty

much why red propol La is the problem

that he he is now and then with bandai's

precedent for what they've done in the

past they've banned cards that made the

leaders strong so they could ban black

Maria they could erata it like they did

with Moby Dick for Whitebeard but we've

also seen them outright ban leaders like

blue black sakazuki so they could just

outright ban repal La what Bandai will

do I'm curious to see I think they have

to do something you can't have rep prop

Lobby the top two decks of the first

five major tournaments of your format

right so yeah I'm very curious to see

what they'll do me personally I would

like black Maria to be ered as I

mentioned I feel like that's the most

diplomatic solution right it it lets the

red purple law players still play red

purple law and it lets the other purple

leaders still play Black Maria and I I

can't think of any downsides to doing

that other than like having to print uh

corrected text for this card but that

would also mean that the old text

version of this card will get like

collector's value too yeah so it's like

win-win-win all around so I guess I'll

go with that solution Bandai it's in

your court now all right that's my

serious thoughts on red purple law and

the 08 meta let me know what you guys

thought of that I kind of did that one

on the Fly I don't know if you could

tell it's a lot more awkward when I do

things live like that and again I I

wrote out a freaking script and it got

deleted cuz my computer comp blue

screened I have to figure out what's

wrong with my computer I got to fix that

but yeah if you like this kind of video

if want me to do more videos like this

where I do like analysis of the game and

not just play games on the Sim let me

know so I can cater my content to what

you guys want to see unless I really

don't like to do it because I'm going to

do what I want anyway okay bye card

koku wow

[Applause]

[Music]