Ayn Rand & Karl Marx, Key Differences - EXPLAINED

Summary

In this video transcript, the speaker discusses the parallels between the philosophy of Ayn Rand and Marxism, emphasizing the importance of individual morality in shaping economic systems. They critique the lack of true capitalism in the U.S., arguing that regulations and government programs distort the free market. The speaker also addresses the issue of child labor, asserting that it historically declines with economic development and capitalism, contrary to the narrative that capitalism inherently exploits children.

Takeaways

• 🤔 The speaker discusses parallels between the philosophy of Ayn Rand and Marxism/Communism, noting that both philosophies believe in the moral actions of individuals leading to societal benefits.
• 🏭 The speaker contrasts the views of Marx, who admired the factory system as a modern miracle, with Rand's belief in the moral benefits of a free economy.
• 👶 The issue of child labor is raised, with the speaker arguing that capitalism has historically reduced child labor as societies become wealthier and parents can afford to keep their children out of the workforce.
• 💡 The speaker emphasizes that every political system is based on some form of morality, but not all moralities are equal in promoting human life.
• 🚫 The speaker criticizes the current state of the United States, arguing that it is not true capitalism due to the presence of government intervention and welfare programs.
• 🌎 The speaker asserts that the closer a society gets to pure Marxism, the more death and destruction it experiences, citing examples like the Soviet Union and China.
• 💰 The speaker argues that capitalism, when practiced closer to its ideal form, leads to increased wealth, longer life spans, and reduced poverty.
• 🏛️ The speaker refutes the idea that capitalism inherently leads to negative outcomes like pollution and lack of regulation, instead suggesting that these are symptoms of a mixed economy, not pure capitalism.
• 📚 The speaker points out that children historically worked on farms and in factories, and it was only with the rise of capitalism and increased productivity that children were able to stop working and attend school.
• 🌾 The speaker argues against the romanticization of pre-capitalist societies, stating that children worked out of necessity and high mortality rates.
• 🔄 The speaker suggests that nationalization and socialism have consistently failed, and privatization leads to success and growth in industries.

Q & A

What is the main similarity between the philosophies of Ayn Rand and Marxism according to the speaker?

The main similarity is that both philosophies are based on the premise that if people act morally, they will make decisions that benefit both themselves and others.

What does the speaker argue about the morality in different political systems?

The speaker argues that every political system is based on some form of morality or ethics, but not all moralities are the same; some promote human life while others destroy it.

Why does the speaker reject the morality of Marxism?

The speaker rejects the morality of Marxism because it rejects individual sovereignty, denies the individual's ability to make decisions for their own life, and ultimately leads to a dictatorship where the state decides for you.

What does the speaker believe about the current state of the economy in the United States?

The speaker believes that the United States does not have a true capitalist system, but rather a mixed economy with elements of socialism and capitalism, which they describe as 'rotten'.

What is the speaker's view on the relationship between child labor and capitalism?

The speaker argues that child labor has historically been a part of life in poor societies, and it is only when societies become wealthy enough through capitalism that children are no longer required to work, thus improving their quality of life.

According to the speaker, what is the outcome of implementing Marxist policies in various countries?

The speaker claims that the implementation of Marxist policies has historically led to death, destruction, and famine on a large scale, citing examples like the Soviet Union and China.

What does the speaker suggest is the alternative for children if sweatshops in poor countries are shut down?

The speaker suggests that if sweatshops are shut down, the alternative for children in poor countries is often poverty, as there are no schools or government support to provide for their education or well-being.

What does the speaker believe about the role of government programs in a capitalist society?

The speaker believes that in a true capitalist society, there should be no government programs such as welfare, social security, Medicare, or Medicaid, as these are forms of intervention and not part of pure capitalism.

How does the speaker describe the impact of privatization on industries?

The speaker describes the impact of privatization as overwhelmingly positive, stating that industries thrive when they are privatized, in contrast to when they are nationalized and often fail.

What is the speaker's view on the criticism of child labor in poor countries by people from wealthy backgrounds?

The speaker criticizes this perspective, stating that it is often people from wealthy backgrounds who do not understand the harsh realities of life in poor countries and why children must work to survive.

What does the speaker suggest is the reason for the persistence of socialist ideas despite historical failures?

The speaker suggests that the persistence of socialist ideas is due to a lack of self-esteem and confidence in people's ability to live for themselves, and a belief that others cannot survive without state intervention.

Outlines

00:00

🤔 Philosophical Parallels and Capitalism's Morality

The speaker initiates a discussion on the philosophical similarities between Ann Rand's views and Marxism, noting that both philosophies propose that moral actions lead to benefits for individuals and society. They contrast Rand's advocacy for a free economy with Marx's vision of a collective good, pointing out the disparities in outcomes such as child labor and pollution due to lack of regulation. The speaker challenges the notion of deregulation in the face of apparent moral failings, suggesting that the current state of capitalism leads to discontent and a superficial freedom to consume, rather than a substantive freedom.

05:02

📚 Capitalism vs. Socialism: Impact on Life and Child Labor

The speaker refutes the notion that capitalism equates to the current socio-economic systems, arguing that true capitalism involves minimal state intervention and emphasizes private property and the rule of law. They compare the outcomes of socialist policies to those of capitalistic ones, asserting that the former often results in death and destruction, while the latter correlates with increased wealth and life expectancy. The discussion then shifts to child labor, with the speaker arguing that children historically worked due to necessity and high mortality rates. They claim that it is only during periods of economic prosperity, brought about by capitalism, that child labor decreases, as parents can afford to keep their children out of the workforce and in education.

10:03

💡 The Myth of Child Labor and the Reality of Economic Prosperity

Continuing the debate, the speaker dismantles the myth that capitalism inherently causes child labor, asserting that it is poverty, not economic systems, that forces children into work. They explain that as countries reach a certain GDP per capita, child labor naturally declines as parents can afford to provide for their children without requiring their labor. The speaker also addresses the misconception that shutting down sweatshops would benefit children in poor countries, arguing that without alternative educational or employment opportunities, this action could lead to increased poverty. The conclusion emphasizes the importance of understanding the economic context and the role of capitalism in reducing child labor and improving living standards.

Keywords

💡Philosophy of Ayn Rand

Ayn Rand's philosophy, known as Objectivism, emphasizes rational self-interest and individualism. It posits that moral actions lead to benefits for both the individual and society. In the script, the speaker compares this philosophy to Marxism, highlighting the contrast in their views on morality and its impact on economic systems.

💡Marxism

Marxism is a social, political, and economic theory originated from the works of Karl Marx, advocating for the establishment of a classless society. The script discusses the parallels between Marxism and Rand's philosophy, noting that both philosophies believe in the moral actions of individuals leading to societal benefits, although they diverge on the means to achieve this.

💡Communism

Communism is a political ideology and movement that seeks to establish a classless, moneyless society where the means of production are owned and controlled by the community as a whole. The script contrasts communism with Ayn Rand's views, particularly in how it addresses the role of the individual in society and the concept of self-sacrifice.

💡Capitalism

Capitalism is an economic system based on private ownership of the means of production and their operation for profit. The script discusses the perceived shortcomings of capitalism, such as child labor and pollution, and contrasts it with the ideal of a laissez-faire economy as envisioned by Ayn Rand.

💡Regulation

Regulation refers to rules or directives made and maintained by an authority. The script mentions the debate over the level of regulation in economies, with the speaker arguing that a lack of regulation can lead to negative outcomes like child labor and environmental pollution.

💡Morality

Morality is the differentiation between right and wrong, often influenced by cultural, religious, or ethical beliefs. The script explores the concept of morality in the context of economic systems, suggesting that the speaker believes that the current capitalist system lacks the moral considerations promoted by Ayn Rand.

💡Freedom

Freedom, in the context of the script, refers to the lack of government intervention in economic affairs. The speaker argues that while some advocate for more freedom in the economy, the consequences can be dire, such as the examples of child labor and environmental disasters.

💡Self-interest

Self-interest is the action of prioritizing one's own welfare or gain. Ayn Rand's philosophy promotes rational self-interest as a moral virtue. The script discusses the idea that individuals acting in their self-interest can also benefit society, a concept that is central to Rand's philosophy.

💡Child Labor

Child labor refers to the employment of children in work that is inappropriate for their age. The script uses child labor as an example of the negative consequences of a laissez-faire economic approach, suggesting that without proper regulation, children can be exploited.

💡Socialism

Socialism is an economic and political system where the means of production are owned or controlled by the community as a whole. The script contrasts socialism with capitalism, discussing the historical outcomes of socialist policies and their impact on society, such as the famines in socialist countries.

💡Nationalization

Nationalization is the process where a government takes ownership of an industry or asset. The script mentions the failures of nationalization, such as in the case of the French banking system, to argue against the effectiveness of socialist policies.

💡Privatization

Privatization is the process of transferring ownership of a company or industry from the state to the private sector. The script suggests that privatization leads to success and growth, in contrast to the failures of nationalization.

💡Empirical Evidence

Empirical evidence refers to information that is based on observation and experience rather than theory. The script uses the term to emphasize the historical and observable outcomes of economic policies, such as the reduction of child labor as a result of economic prosperity.

Highlights

The comparison between the philosophies of Ayn Rand and Marxism, emphasizing the role of morality in both systems.

Ayn Rand's view that a moral free economy benefits both the business creator and society as a whole.

Marx's perspective on the factory as a modern miracle and the potential benefits of a moral society working for the common good.

The critique of deregulation leading to negative consequences such as child labor and environmental pollution.

The argument that the current capitalist system does not reflect the true principles of capitalism as defined by Ayn Rand.

The distinction between the moral philosophies of Ayn Rand and Karl Marx, and their impact on individual freedom.

The claim that every political ecosystem is based on a moral code, which influences the system's structure and outcomes.

The assertion that the United States does not practice true capitalism, but rather a mixed economy.

The historical context of child labor and its relation to economic development and societal wealth.

The assertion that child labor decreases as a country's GDP per capita increases, leading to legislation against it.

The argument that shutting down sweatshops in poor countries can lead to increased poverty and a lack of alternatives for children.

The discussion on the failure of state nationalization of industries and the success of privatization.

The critique of the middle class and wealthy individuals' perspective on child labor without understanding the context of poverty.

The call for self-esteem and confidence in individuals to live for themselves without relying on state intervention.

The final remarks on the importance of supporting the Iran Brook show and engaging with the content.

Transcripts

yes um well first of all thank you for

coming here very interesting

so when I think of the philosophy of Ann

ran and what the speakers have said

today I I can't but think about the

parallels with Marxism and communism

because both say people if they act

morally

will make decisions that will benefit

themselves and others

so Ann ran says if everybody is moral

then this free economy will not only

bring benefits to the person creating a

business but also I'm a student to

everyone else sure Marx also says

the greatest miracle in the modern world

is the factory greater than the pyramids

itself and he comes to a different

conclusion and if we're all moral we can

all work for the common good and the

working class who actually provides the

labor will benefit so my question to you

is we right now in some economies

have freedom from regulations

some of them I know you want more I just

I'll be honest I would want less and we

see for example child labor

until very recently child labor was

common

right now in the United States which I

think you're from there was a big train

derailment for a lack of regulations and

people in a town are suffering pollution

owner is allowed to do what they want

they might be doing more

now you can argue they don't have the

morality that Anne Rand is talking about

by making decisions that are in the best

interest of everyone but you it seems

like you're advocating to remove

regulation when this morality doesn't

exist and the result is death and often

poverty and people are very discontent

with the current states of capitalism

right now because it is hard to afford

things and the freedom that they have is

just the freedom to consume and choose

between various tastes of ice cream or

makeup so I find that to be kind of the

kind of the comments here because our

capitalist system causes people to bang

in the streets and the young man who

said oh I want to help this person but

that is the reality of what we see and

we also see in the United States with

homeless encampments sure

oh wait there's a lot there

um so let me try to let me try to unpack

this a little bit one

yes there uh is it there is a similarity

between Marxism and Iran in the sense

that both systems are based on morality

I think every system in the world is

based on some model code some ethics

that's true Marxism that's true of every

single idea but some moralities are true

in some moralities are false some

moralities actually promote human life

in some moralities destroy human life

um the morality that I ran bases her

ideas on is a very different morality

than Marx bases his ideas on and I will

take Iran any day over Marx and pretty

much over anybody else for a couple of

reasons one Marx's morality rejects the

individual denies the individual denies

the individual any sovereignty you don't

have a say in your own life ultimately

the proletarian decide for you what you

do the positivity decides for you what

is truth there is the dictators of the

palitarian in which you don't get to

make decisions for yourself

that's you know and secondly again why

should I sacrifice other people why not

live for yourself there is no ultimate

answer to the to the to that question

let me get to the child they haven't

finished believe me we'll get to the

child

um so so to begin with I don't expect

anybody to sacrifice for me and I don't

I will not sacrifice for anybody else

that is a moral code that results in

Freedom in in a capitalist in a

capitalist version

so morality always leads to a certain

political system you cannot have a

political ecosystem with no morality

every political ecosystem assumes

something about a mall code

and I'm arguing that I'm all code of

Marxism the Marco's of status and the

moral code that exist today in America

and the mall code that exists today in

in Colombia All Along because they're

not I'm random consequence we have

political systems that are huggable that

are bad that are wrong that Iran Rejects

and I reject

which brings me to the question about

but what about America well first

put aside the morality of America we

don't have capitalism in America

you people like to call anything they

don't like capitalism but the reality is

what is capitalism actually mean

capitalism means a separation of States

from economics capitalism means a system

where the econ the state doesn't

regulate some the state the state

doesn't regulate at all

not capitalism means

private property the rule of law the

protection of contracts and no

regulations

no intervention by the government

if you allow intervention then it's a

mixed economy some socialism some

capitalism in capitalism there's no

welfare state in capitalism there's no

social security Medicare Medicaid and a

million other government programs that

they're there to facility now I know the

common definition dictionary definition

of capitalism is

describes everything in the world today

but that's not the capitalism I Iran

talks about it's not the capitalism I

talk about the system in the United

States today is rotten

it's better than a lot of other places

but it's rotten

but let me just make this comparison

with Marx because you brought Marxism in

the closer we get to Marx

the more people die

not just kids working we'll get to kids

working in a minute but literally kids

dying by the tens of Millions

that's the Soviet Union

that's China indeed every country in the

world that is socialized farming that is

socialized fruit production suffers from

famines and death and destruction just

look at Venezuela right now

socialism kills and it kills in large

numbers

now the Socialists always say well we've

never tried it fully we've never gotten

it right

but the closer you get to it the more

death and destruction there is

capitalism on the other hand the closer

we get we've never really achieved it

but the closer we get the more wealth

the longer life

the the the most successful people are

and indeed the fewer people die of

starvation the fewer people the poor

people they are and I even will argue

the fewer children uh work

but let's talk a little bit about uh uh

child labor one of my favorite topics

what did children do before capitalism

what do children do 500 years ago

they worked we prayed children played

the children didn't play they walked on

the farm and and and parents would have

10 12 children why did why do we have so

many children back there

one because they needed to work but B

what was the other reason we had so many

children back then they died half of

them didn't make the age 10. 50 of

children didn't make the age of 10. she

had a lot of children so the few would

survive so they would be cheap label on

your farm

children have always worked when did

children stop working

only one period in all of human history

in that hundred thousand years of human

history children stopped working only

once

you're going to answer the question

that's

so so

so so

let me answer the question because that

is that is that is complete mythology

now there's let me finish let me

know

I haven't answered

it's complete nonsense

every single country if you look at the

countries in the world when they reach a

certain GDP per capita

and when children are no longer working

in factories governments pass laws to

exclude children this happened in

England it happened in the United States

it's happening right now in Indonesia

and Malaysia and Asia when parents can

afford to keep the kids from work if

they can afford to send them to school

then they pull them out of the workplace

they send them to school and the

government then takes the credit for it

after the fact by passing a law check

your history

I you can see this in every single

country it's always at the certain at

this at the same GDP per capita oh is it

to some the same place there's a there's

a little book just about child labor and

sweatshops

um by um from Texas Tech University uh

I'll think of his name in a minute but

that documents empirically the exact

relationship between child labor and

when the laws pass and what happens the

the reality is the children have always

worked they stop working when capitalism

makes them so productive that they now

make enough money to be able to feed

their children without the child working

because what happens if today you shut

down uh sweatshops in poor countries

what happens to those kids what's the

alternative instead of working what's

the alternative for them

there is no schools the governments

don't have enough money to pay for the

schools there are no schools in these

places so what would they do

star yeah that that's a that's a route

to Poverty very very fast and Speedy

route Department you see how the

mythology survive it is fascinating to

see how in spite of all the empirical

evidence in spite of all the history of

the last 100 250 years in spite of the

fact that socialism and nationalization

have been disastrous every single time

they've been tried every single time

they've been tried we still latch onto

them because we don't have the

self-esteem and the confidence to

believe we can live for ourselves we

don't have the self-esteem and

confidence to believe that maybe you

believe that you can live for yourself

but oh no those other idiots out there

they can't they can't survive if if the

state doesn't help them God forbid we

leave them alone to live for themselves

you you know much better how other

people should live than they know about

their own life so you want to dictate

their life for them but every single

example of State nationalization of

Industries has failed empirically just

ask Francois who was the Socialist

president of France in the 1980s and who

nationalized the entire banking system

and four years later I had to

re-privatize them because it was such a

disaster as the kid would see him in

Israel who were these beautiful

socialized farming communities that seem

to be incredibly successful until it was

discovered that they were completely

subsidized by the government and as soon

as the subsidies ended they all failed

and today the Nokia would see him in

Israel you can go industry after

industry after industry when they're

nationalized they fail they die they

disappear you want a success look what

happens when you privatize Industries

then they go through the roof but the

reality is the child labor is what

happens when we're poor as soon as

parents get rich enough we pull our

children out of Labor and the

alternative children have is to walk or

to die

and it's only Rich middle class people

from relatively wealthy backgrounds and

Wealthy countries who sit back on their

nice cushy Sofas in comfortable

countries who think oh my God those kids

shouldn't work over there really I you

know my kids don't work so they could

just didn't work without having any

concept of what life is like in these

countries and why these kids have to

work in order to survive

I'm sure there are parts of the question

I didn't answer but yes

thank you for listening or watching the

Iran Brook show if you'd like to support

the show we make it as easy as possible

for you to trade with me you get value

from listening you get value from

watching

show your appreciation you can do that

by going to your own bookshow.com

support by go to patreon subscribe star

locals and just making a appropriate

contribution uh on any one of those uh

any one of those channels also if you'd

like to see the Iran book show grow

please consider sharing our content and

of course subscribe press that little

bell button right down there on YouTube

so that you get an announcement when we

go live and for you those of you who

already subscribers and those of you who

already supporters of the show

thank you I very much appreciate it