Banyak Yang Belum Tahu! Wajibkah Sholat Jumat Jika Sudah Sholat Ied | Ustadz Ammi Nur Baits

Summary

The video discusses the occurrence of Eid on Fridays and its impact on Friday prayers. It shares various hadiths in which the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) provided leniency regarding the obligation of Friday prayers for those who performed the Eid prayer. The video also explores the opinions of different scholars and schools of thought, including the Shafi'i perspective. It concludes that while attending Friday prayers is not obligatory for those who performed the Eid prayer, it is recommended for mosque imams to still hold Friday prayers to accommodate all attendees. Those who opt out of Friday prayers must perform the Dhuhr prayer instead.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Prophet Muhammad (sallallahu alaihi wasallam) allowed flexibility when Eid coincides with Friday, permitting attendees of Eid prayers to skip Friday prayers.
• 😀 The Prophet's leniency was based on the principle that those who miss Friday prayers after attending Eid must perform the Dhuhr prayer instead.
• 😀 A hadith mentions that when Eid and Friday fall together, those who wish to attend Friday prayers are allowed, but they must make up the missed Dhuhr prayer if they skip it.
• 😀 During the time of Uthman bin Affan, a similar leniency was given to those attending Eid prayers, permitting them to skip Friday prayers but still requiring Dhuhr as a replacement.
• 😀 Scholars discuss two major opinions: One opinion maintains the obligation of Friday prayer after Eid, while the other permits skipping it, especially for those who have attended the Eid prayer.
• 😀 The Shafi'iyah school of thought allows people to skip Friday prayers if they have already attended Eid prayers, with no further obligation to attend Friday prayers.
• 😀 There is a difference of opinion on the necessity of Friday prayers, with some scholars saying it is not obligatory after Eid, while others believe it remains obligatory for those who have not attended Eid prayers.
• 😀 A third opinion, favored by the Hambali school, holds that it is permissible to skip Friday prayers for those who have attended Eid but still recommends holding the Friday prayer for others.
• 😀 The imam is encouraged to hold Friday prayers, allowing those who wish to attend after Eid and ensuring those who did not attend Eid can also participate.
• 😀 If one skips Friday prayers after Eid, they must perform the Dhuhr prayer as a substitute, with a recommended four rakaats.

Q & A

What is the ruling on attending Friday prayers when Eid falls on a Friday?

When Eid falls on a Friday, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) allowed those who attended the Eid prayer to skip the Friday prayer. They are instead required to perform the Dhuhur prayer, as mentioned in several hadiths.

Did the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) allow flexibility regarding the Friday prayer when Eid occurs on that day?

Yes, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) granted leniency. He allowed people who attended the Eid prayer to either attend the Friday prayer or skip it, provided they perform the Dhuhur prayer instead.

What did Uthman bin Affan say about the Eid and Friday prayer on the day they coincided?

Uthman bin Affan mentioned that on days when Eid coincides with Friday, those who traveled long distances and attended the Eid prayer were given permission to skip the Friday prayer and return home. However, they were obliged to perform the Dhuhur prayer once the time for it had arrived.

What should people do if there is no Friday prayer available at their mosque after attending the Eid prayer?

If there is no Friday prayer at the mosque, people who attended the Eid prayer should perform the Dhuhur prayer. The mosque's caretaker is encouraged to organize the Friday prayer for those who still wish to attend.

Why is it important for the mosque to hold Friday prayers when Eid occurs on a Friday?

It is important because, while some people may not attend the Friday prayer due to the Eid prayer, others may still want to perform it. Keeping the Friday prayer enables both those who did not perform Eid prayer and those who wish to attend Friday prayer to participate.

How does the Shafi'i school of thought view the Friday prayer after Eid?

The Shafi'i school of thought allows individuals who live far from the mosque to skip Friday prayers after attending Eid prayers. This is based on their interpretation of the situation, particularly for those who have performed the Eid prayer.

What is the stance of other schools of thought, like Hanafi and Maliki, regarding Eid and Friday prayers?

The Hanafi and Maliki schools of thought are generally more flexible, stating that those who performed the Eid prayer do not have to attend Friday prayers. Instead, they can replace it with the Dhuhur prayer.

What is the primary difference between the first and second opinions regarding the Friday prayer after Eid?

The first opinion asserts that people who performed the Eid prayer are still required to attend Friday prayers, whereas the second opinion allows them to skip the Friday prayer but requires them to perform the Dhuhur prayer instead.

What did the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) say about the necessity of Friday prayers?

The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) stated that missing three consecutive Friday prayers could lead to the closure of one's heart. However, this was a warning directed towards those who habitually neglect Friday prayers, not those who attended Eid prayers.

What is the ruling if someone misses Friday prayer after attending the Eid prayer?

If someone misses the Friday prayer after attending the Eid prayer, they are required to perform the Dhuhur prayer. The Eid prayer is seen as an alternative to the Friday prayer, but it does not exempt one from the obligation of prayer altogether.