[DIALOG] WAJIB MILITER UNTUK SISWA 'NAKAL', APAKAH TEPAT?

Summary

The provincial government of West Java plans to implement mandatory military service for troubled youths involved in motor gang violence and brawls. This initiative aims to instill discipline, responsibility, and character in participants through a military program monitored by the military and police. However, the proposal faces opposition from educational experts and lawmakers who stress the importance of consulting with educational authorities and ensuring the program aligns with existing educational regulations. Critics argue that military training may not address underlying mental health issues and could disrupt the students' education.

Takeaways

• 😀 The West Java Provincial Government plans to implement a mandatory military program for troubled youth, especially those involved in gangs and street violence.
• 😀 The program aims to foster discipline, responsibility, and character development among participants, with military training under the supervision of the TNI (Indonesian National Armed Forces) and the Police.
• 😀 The program is set to begin in May 2025 and will include troubled children, such as those caught in brawls or involved in criminal activity.
• 😀 The military program will be monitored closely to ensure it achieves its goals and reduces juvenile delinquency in the region.
• 😀 The provincial government has already started preparing facilities, such as barracks, for the program, particularly in areas like Bandung.
• 😀 West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi emphasized the need for a solution to the ongoing gang and street violence problem, suggesting this initiative as a potential remedy.
• 😀 There are concerns from the DPR (Indonesian Parliament) about whether the program aligns with existing educational policies and regulations, and whether it will achieve the desired outcomes.
• 😀 Some critics argue that while the program has good intentions, it could conflict with existing educational frameworks and potentially disrupt the students' academic progress.
• 😀 Educational experts suggest that the program may lack the legal and regulatory foundation needed to be implemented properly and could lead to unintended consequences if not aligned with national education laws.
• 😀 There is a call for more coordination between the local government, educational authorities, and central government agencies to ensure that the program is in compliance with existing policies and laws related to education and youth development.

Q & A

What is the purpose of the mandatory military program being proposed by the West Java provincial government?

The purpose of the program is to address juvenile delinquency by instilling discipline, responsibility, and character-building in troubled youths, particularly those involved in motorbike gangs and school brawls.

How long will the military program last, and who will oversee it?

The program will last for six months, and it will be supervised by the Indonesian National Army (TNI) and the Indonesian Police (Polri).

What happens to the students who participate in the program in terms of their school status?

Participants will remain enrolled in their original schools but will attend special classes tailored to the program. They will be placed in a military-style training environment while maintaining their educational status.

What are some of the preparations being made for the program in West Java?

Some areas, such as Bandung, are already preparing military barracks and facilities for the program, and the government is working to ensure readiness for its launch in May 2025.

How does Governor Dedi Mulyadi justify the need for this program?

Governor Dedi Mulyadi believes that the program is necessary because the issue of motorbike gangs and youth involvement in criminal activities has persisted for a long time. The program is seen as a solution for children whose parents are unable to properly guide or educate them.

What are the concerns raised by members of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR) regarding the program?

Members of the DPR, like Lalu Hadrian, expressed support for the program's intentions but urged the provincial government to consult with the Ministry of Education to ensure the program aligns with broader educational goals and does not conflict with existing educational policies.

What are Baratno Listiarti's concerns about the program?

Baratno Listiarti, an education observer, is concerned that the program might violate existing regulations and that military training may not effectively address the root causes of troubled youth behavior. She emphasizes the need for a more holistic approach to solving juvenile delinquency.

What specific challenges does Baratno Listiarti highlight about the military program?

Baratno highlights the lack of a legal framework for mandatory military training in schools and questions whether the program will truly transform troubled youths. She also stresses that the program may overlook the underlying emotional and mental health issues that contribute to juvenile delinquency.

Why does Lalu Hadrian stress the need for consultation with the Ministry of Education and the central government?

Lalu Hadrian stresses the need for consultation to ensure that the program aligns with national educational policies and that its implementation does not cause unintended negative effects. He also suggests that discussions with various stakeholders, including parents and educational institutions, are necessary.

What is the potential impact of this military program on the education system in West Java?

The military program could disrupt the current educational system by diverting troubled youths from regular schooling. There are concerns that it might undermine existing educational frameworks, especially if it is not coordinated with relevant educational bodies like the Ministry of Education.