Más sobre la estructura de puntos del dióxido de azufre

Summary

In this video, the presenter discusses two resonance structures of sulfur dioxide (SO2), comparing a structure with extended valence shell and no formal charges, and another that adheres to the octet rule but has formal charges. The presenter explains that both structures are valid and that SO2 is represented by a hybrid of these two, with both single and double bonds. Despite differing opinions in textbooks, the video emphasizes that both structures are geometrically similar and correct. Ultimately, the answer depends on perspective, but quantum calculations could provide further clarity.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video discusses the resonance structures of sulfur dioxide (SO₂) and explains the different possible structures that represent the molecule.
• 😀 One structure of SO₂ involves sulfur double-bonded to two oxygens, with one oxygen having two lone pairs of electrons, while sulfur has one lone pair.
• 😀 Another structure shows sulfur with formal positive charge and oxygens with a formal negative charge, fulfilling the octet rule.
• 😀 The sulfur in one structure exceeds the octet rule, having 10 electrons in its valence shell, which is possible due to sulfur's ability to use d-orbitals.
• 😀 The video points out that the structure with extended valence electrons (more than 8) is considered valid because sulfur is in the third period of the periodic table.
• 😀 The structure with formal charges, although fulfilling the octet rule, presents charges on the atoms, which is a less ideal configuration.
• 😀 Both resonance structures are considered correct, with the real molecule existing as a hybrid of these two forms.
• 😀 In the hybrid structure, some bonds are represented as partially double and partially single, as indicated by solid and dashed lines.
• 😀 Experimental data confirms that the bonds in SO₂ have the same length, supporting the idea of a hybrid structure.
• 😀 While textbooks may present different perspectives on which structure is 'correct,' both structures are scientifically valid and can be used depending on the context.

Q & A

What are the two structures being compared in the video?

The video compares two different resonance structures of sulfur dioxide (SO2). One structure features sulfur with double bonds to oxygen, while the other shows sulfur with a single bond to oxygen and formal charges.

What is the main difference between the two structures discussed in the video?

The key difference is that the structure with double bonds has no formal charges on sulfur or oxygen, while the structure with a single bond results in formal charges on sulfur and oxygen, with sulfur having a positive charge and oxygen a negative charge.

Why is sulfur capable of having more than 8 electrons in its valence shell?

Sulfur is in the third period of the periodic table and has access to d-orbitals, which allows it to accommodate more than 8 electrons in its valence shell, as seen in the extended valence shell structure.

Which structure follows the octet rule and which does not?

The structure with sulfur having a positive charge and oxygen having a negative charge follows the octet rule, with sulfur having 8 electrons in its valence shell. The structure with no formal charges involves sulfur having 10 electrons, which does not follow the octet rule but demonstrates an extended valence shell.

What does the speaker suggest about the two resonance structures?

The speaker suggests that both resonance structures are valid, as they represent a hybrid state where the actual bonding is a mix of both structures, with the sulfur-oxygen bonds being somewhere between single and double bonds.

What is the significance of the hybrid structure of SO2?

The hybrid structure of SO2 reflects the fact that experimentally, the sulfur-oxygen bonds in the molecule have the same length, which is intermediate between a single and double bond. This is depicted by using a solid line for a double bond and a dashed line for a single bond.

What does the speaker recommend as the best approach to determine the correct structure?

The speaker recommends using quantum calculations for a more accurate determination of the structure, though this goes beyond the scope of the video.

How does the geometry of SO2 relate to its structures?

Regardless of which structure is used (with or without formal charges), the resulting geometry of SO2 is angular, which is consistent with the molecular shape for a molecule with two bonding regions around the central sulfur atom.

What did the speaker find in different textbooks regarding the correct structure of SO2?

The speaker found that some textbooks claim the structure with no formal charges (extended valence shell) is correct, while others support the structure with formal charges. This highlights the ambiguity in how the structures of SO2 are represented.

What is the speaker’s opinion on the debate over the correct SO2 structure?

The speaker believes both structures are correct and that the debate is unnecessary, as both structures contribute to the hybrid representation of SO2, which is experimentally observed to have bonds of equal length.