Which was created first? Heaven or earth?

Summary

In this video, the speaker addresses the common claim that there is a contradiction in the Quran regarding the creation of the heavens and the earth. The speaker clarifies that while Surah 2:29 mentions the creation of the earth first, the phrase 'attended to the heaven' indicates that the heavens were already created before the earth. The explanation is further supported by references to Surah 79 and Surah 41, confirming that the heavens were created first, followed by the earth, with the creation of seven heavens after. The video resolves the apparent contradiction, offering a clear interpretation of the verses.

Takeaways

• 😀 The person in the video addresses a common claim about a contradiction between two Quranic verses regarding the creation of the earth and the heavens.
• 😀 Surah 2, verse 29 is often interpreted as saying that God created the earth before the heavens, but the explanation clarifies that the heavens already existed.
• 😀 The key phrase in Surah 2:29 is 'attended to the heaven,' meaning God focused on the heavens after the earth was created, not that the earth came first.
• 😀 The verse does not imply that the earth was created before the heavens, but rather that the earth was populated with everything before God attended to the heavens.
• 😀 The speaker explains that the heaven referred to in Surah 2:29 was already created, and God then made it seven heavens.
• 😀 Surah 79 confirms that the heavens were created first and then the earth, supporting the argument that there is no contradiction between the verses.
• 😀 Surah 41 also describes the creation process in a similar manner, stating that the heaven existed before the earth, clarifying the order of creation.
• 😀 The term 'attended to the heaven' indicates that the heavens were perfected and made into seven heavens after the earth was created.
• 😀 The explanation emphasizes that the creation of the earth and the heavens are described in different stages, but there is no contradiction in the sequence.
• 😀 The speaker concludes by stating that the apparent contradiction is based on a misunderstanding, and there is no conflict between the verses once properly understood.

Q & A

What is the perceived contradiction in the Quran regarding the creation of the heavens and the earth?

The perceived contradiction is that Surah 2:29 suggests the earth was created before the heavens, while Surah 79:27 states that the heavens were created first, followed by the earth.

How does Surah 2:29 address the order of creation?

Surah 2:29 states that God created everything on the earth first, then attended to the heavens. This does not imply the earth was created before the heavens, but rather that the heavens existed before the earth, and the earth's creation occurred first in the context of all earthly elements.

What does the term 'attended to the heaven' mean in Surah 2:29?

The term 'attended to the heaven' in Surah 2:29 suggests that the heavens were already in existence before God focused on them. This implies that the heavens were not created after the earth, but were pre-existing.

What is the significance of God making seven heavens after creating the earth?

The creation of seven heavens after the earth in Surah 2:29 indicates that, while the heavens existed, God further shaped and structured the heavens, making them seven distinct heavens after the earth's creation.

How does Surah 79:27 confirm the creation of the heavens before the earth?

Surah 79:27 confirms that the heavens were created first by stating that God raised its height and perfected it before the earth was spread out. This clearly supports the idea that the heavens existed prior to the creation of the earth.

Why does the explanation emphasize the pre-existence of the heavens?

The explanation emphasizes the pre-existence of the heavens to resolve the apparent contradiction and to clarify that the Quran presents a consistent order: the heavens were created before the earth, followed by the creation of the seven heavens.

What is the importance of Surah 41 in understanding the creation of the earth and heavens?

Surah 41 contributes to the understanding by describing the creation sequence where the earth was created first, then God 'settled to the heaven,' which was initially in a smoky state. This confirms that the heavens were pre-existing, and the earth came afterward.

How does the creation of the seven heavens relate to the sequence of events?

The creation of seven heavens, mentioned in Surah 2:29 and supported by other verses, follows the creation of the earth. It indicates a further development of the heavens, which had already been created before the earth's formation.

What does 'the heaven was already there' suggest about the timeline of creation?

'The heaven was already there' suggests that the heavens were created prior to the earth, as indicated in the Quranic verses. The earth's creation happened after the heavens had already been established.

Why does the explanation dismiss the idea of a contradiction between the verses?

The explanation dismisses the contradiction by showing that Surah 2:29 does not state that the earth was created before the heavens but rather speaks about God attending to the already existing heaven after the earth's creation. Both verses, when understood in context, align with the sequence of creation where the heavens predate the earth.