[영화 '곡성' 리뷰] 황정민씨 굿 장면을 현직무당에게 보여드렸더니! '감독의 의도를 잘 모르겠다?' [구슬동자 윤도령]

Summary

The video discusses the portrayal of shamanism in Korean films and dramas, specifically focusing on themes like possession, exorcism, and the role of shamans. The speaker reflects on the practices shown, such as the use of knives in exorcisms and rituals to expel evil spirits, drawing attention to the misrepresentation of shamans in media. The speaker also critiques the sensationalized depiction of shamans as frauds, acknowledging the real-life controversies surrounding the practice. Despite the negative portrayals, the speaker believes that with proper understanding, shamanism could eventually be shown in a more positive light in the future.

Takeaways

• 😀 The script discusses the portrayal of shamanistic practices in Korean films, especially focusing on the movie *Gokseong* (곡성).
• 😀 A central theme in the discussion is the ritual of exorcism and spirit banishment, where objects like knives and fire are used symbolically.
• 😀 The speaker critiques the negative portrayal of shamans in media, where they are often shown as fraudulent or manipulative.
• 😀 They emphasize that shamanistic rituals depicted in films are often exaggerated for dramatic effect, such as the use of large swords or knives to ward off spirits.
• 😀 The discussion also mentions how traditional shamanistic practices, like burning bad items in fire, are culturally significant and have practical applications in the rituals.
• 😀 The speaker reflects on the negative consequences of portraying shamans in a bad light, which leads to societal prejudice and misunderstanding about their role.
• 😀 There is a mention of how media portrayals often sensationalize fraudulent practices within shamanism, though proving such frauds legally remains difficult.
• 😀 The speaker expresses disappointment over the negative impact media has on the public image of shamans, as their real-life practices are often misunderstood.
• 😀 Despite the negative portrayals, the speaker suggests that the future could bring a more positive representation of shamans, if practices are properly validated and ethically conducted.
• 😀 Acknowledging the complexity of shamanism in the real world, the speaker hopes that a more balanced and authentic representation of shamans will emerge in future films and media.

Q & A

What is the main theme of the movie discussed in the script?

The main theme of the movie discussed in the script is about possession and how it leads to misfortune and disturbances in a household. The story centers around the idea of a person becoming possessed, which causes problems such as conflicts and even death within the family.

What is the significance of the 'nine lines' mentioned in the transcript?

The 'nine lines' mentioned in the transcript refers to a ritualistic concept that is featured in the movie. It is a part of a traditional practice, where certain rituals, such as performing an exorcism or cleansing, involve specific acts related to the number nine, potentially linked to spiritual beliefs and ceremonies.

How does the script describe the use of fire in the context of the ritual?

Fire is used in the movie as a cleansing tool to burn and destroy objects that are considered 'bad' or dangerous. The fire symbolizes a purification process where negative energy or unwanted objects are burned away to prevent further disturbances, with the ritual taking place in the yard.

What is the role of the large sword mentioned in the script?

The large sword in the script is used by the spiritual practitioners, referred to as shamans. It is described as having great power, especially for driving away evil spirits or exorcising possessions. The sword symbolizes strength and authority in combating evil forces during rituals.

Why does the script mention that the depiction of shamans in media is often negative?

The script suggests that shamans are often depicted negatively in movies and dramas, which is a result of public perceptions of some shamans engaging in fraudulent or unethical practices. This portrayal is influenced by real-life scandals, where some shamans have been involved in scams, leading to the stigmatization of the entire profession.

How do media portrayals affect the public’s view of shamans?

The media’s portrayal of shamans as fraudulent or deceptive has contributed to a negative public perception. These portrayals often focus on instances of scams or questionable behavior, which can reinforce the stereotype of shamans being dishonest, despite the efforts of legitimate practitioners.

What is the significance of the ritualistic use of knives in the script?

The knives mentioned in the script are not used for violence but as part of a ritual to provoke or interact with spirits. The use of knives symbolizes spiritual authority and is part of the traditional tools used in possession-related exorcisms or cleansing rituals.

Why does the script mention that it’s difficult to legally prove scams involving shamans?

The script explains that scams involving shamans are hard to prove legally because the interactions are often based on verbal agreements and personal belief. If a client agrees to follow a shaman's advice, it becomes challenging to legally categorize the act as fraud, even if the outcome is negative.

How do shamans contribute to the societal understanding of spirituality in the context of the script?

Shamans, as presented in the script, serve as intermediaries between the spiritual and physical worlds. Their role in society is to help people deal with spiritual issues, like possession or misfortune, through rituals and ceremonies. However, societal skepticism arises due to the negative portrayals and potential misconduct within the community.

What is the overall message about the depiction of shamans in films and dramas?

The overall message in the script is that while shamans are often portrayed negatively in films and dramas, this reflects real-life controversies and scandals within the profession. However, the script also suggests that not all shamans are fraudulent and that there is a need for a more balanced and respectful portrayal in the future.