PAK Army Big Victory | America saves India from Pakistan | Rafale aircraft destroyed | Big Analysis

Summary

In this insightful discussion between retired military officials, the evolving Pakistan-India relations are analyzed, focusing on the aftermath of a ceasefire. Key points include Pakistan's newfound confidence, India's military failures, and the strengthening of ties between Pakistan and China. The conversation critiques India's military strategies, especially following their setbacks with operations like 'Operation Bandar' and 'Sindoor.' It also highlights the shifting balance of power in South Asia, with India's dominance now being questioned. Furthermore, diplomatic failures are emphasized, as India is forced to seek third-party mediation, raising doubts about the country's future diplomatic conduct.

Takeaways

• 😀 The current situation in Pakistan-India relations is under intense scrutiny, especially after the ceasefire. Pakistan's confidence is high, and a reevaluation of foreign policy, particularly towards Kashmir, is expected.
• 😀 India's actions since the Modi government came to power in 2014 have led to a strained relationship with Pakistan. The verbal attacks and media campaigns have hurt the bilateral ties significantly.
• 😀 Pakistan's economic and political weaknesses were exposed during these tensions, but despite this, Pakistan has not given in to India's provocations or criticisms.
• 😀 India's military failures, particularly during the 2019 Balakot strike and the repeated Operation Sindoor, have severely damaged its international reputation.
• 😀 A major loss of face has occurred for countries like Israel, the U.S., and France due to India's inability to operate advanced military hardware effectively.
• 😀 The S-400 defense system purchased from Russia did not perform well against Pakistani JF-17 jets, further tarnishing India's military image.
• 😀 The conventional warfare window that India once believed it had over Pakistan is now closed due to Pakistan's nuclear threshold being better understood and more respected internationally.
• 😀 Western nations, particularly the U.S., had long underestimated the military capabilities of China and Pakistan, but recent events, including the failure of India’s military actions, have shifted global perceptions.
• 😀 India's dominance in South Asia has been seriously challenged, particularly in the context of its relationship with China and its failure to assert influence over Pakistan effectively.
• 😀 Pakistan's diplomatic strategy must be cautious, as India’s diplomacy is often deceptive. However, Pakistan could pressure India into negotiations if it partners with others and holds firm on its position regarding Kashmir and other matters.

Q & A

What is the significance of the ceasefire mentioned in the script?

The ceasefire is seen as a 'winning point' for Pakistan, and it has boosted Pakistan's confidence. This event is considered a turning point, with a shift in how both nations approach military and diplomatic relations moving forward.

How did India’s media and government approach Pakistan in recent years?

India's media and government, especially after the 2014 Modi administration, took a very aggressive stance against Pakistan. This involved a verbal war, undermining Pakistan's reputation, and showcasing Pakistan in a negative light internationally.

What role did Pakistan’s economic and political conditions play in the conflict with India?

Pakistan's relatively weak economic and political conditions made it difficult for the country to assert itself on the international stage. However, despite these challenges, Pakistan managed to maintain its stance and avoided conceding to India's aggressive actions.

What was the significance of the 2019 operation mentioned in the script?

The 2019 operation, which the script refers to as 'Operation Bandar,' ended in failure for India. The operation aimed to target Pakistan, but India faced embarrassment and had to scale back its actions after encountering military setbacks.

How did Pakistan respond to India’s aggressive actions, such as the operation in 2019?

Pakistan responded assertively to India's military operations, with the Pakistan Air Force successfully countering India's aggression. This highlighted Pakistan’s improved military capabilities, particularly its JF-17 aircraft, which outperformed India’s more advanced Rafale jets.

What impact did the international community's perception have on India after these military setbacks?

India faced significant loss of face in the international community, particularly with the failure of its military operations and the inability to contain Pakistan’s defensive measures. This tarnished India's reputation as a dominant military power and raised questions about its strength.

Why is the relationship between Pakistan and China mentioned in the script?

The script highlights the strengthening of the Pakistan-China partnership, particularly as a result of India’s failures in the conflict. This partnership has become increasingly important, especially with the shifting balance of power in South Asia.

What lessons can be drawn from the conflict in terms of conventional warfare?

The conflict revealed that India’s earlier belief in the possibility of defeating Pakistan through conventional warfare alone is no longer valid. Pakistan’s nuclear threshold has been strengthened, indicating that future conflicts may not follow the traditional modes of warfare.

How did the Western world view India’s military hardware compared to that of China or Russia?

The Western world, particularly the U.S., had long believed that their military hardware was unmatched, but India’s failure against Pakistan’s newer aircraft, such as the JF-17, and China’s J-20, has shifted this perception. This has also led to a re-evaluation of military technology in Asia.

What does the script suggest about India's diplomatic strategies in the future?

The script suggests that India will continue to pursue aggressive diplomatic strategies, often relying on deceit and manipulation, especially when dealing with Pakistan. However, it also implies that Pakistan can leverage international partnerships to counterbalance India’s moves.