MANAGEMENT ETHICS | MOVIE REVIEW | NORTH COUNTRY

hawa yahya

19 Jun 202303:33

Summary

TLDRThe video script offers a critical review of the film 'North Country,' directed by Nikki Caro, highlighting four main ethical issues: employee right to privacy, unconducive working conditions, gender discrimination, and air pollution. The film showcases the struggles of a female employee, Josie, who faces sexual harassment and gender bias at her workplace, leading to her resignation. It also addresses the environmental impact of mining activities, such as air and water pollution, and land degradation. The review emphasizes the movie's importance in raising awareness about workplace harassment and environmental harm, recommending viewers to watch it for a thought-provoking experience.

Takeaways

🎬 The film 'North Country' directed by Nikki Caro is reviewed for its ethical issues.
🔒 The movie highlights the issue of employee right to privacy, where a doctor leaks personal information of Josie.
💥 Unhealthy working conditions are depicted through daily harassment and sexual harassment faced by Josie at her workplace.
🚫 Gender discrimination is a central theme, showing bias and preferential treatment based on sex.
🗣️ The film illustrates the inaction of supervisors when Josie reports the sexual harassment she experiences.
🌳 Environmental concerns are raised, particularly air pollution caused by mining activities.
🌫️ Specific pollutants like carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide from mining equipment are mentioned in the film.
💧 Water pollution from mining, including heavy metals and acid runoff, is also a depicted issue.
🏞️ The movie showcases other environmental impacts such as land subsidence and damage to the water environment.
👀 The review emphasizes the film's ability to open viewers' eyes to real-world issues of sexual harassment and environmental harm.
👍 The reviewer recommends watching the movie for its portrayal of significant social and environmental issues.

Q & A

What is the main purpose of the video review?
-The main purpose of the video review is to discuss the ethical issues presented in the movie 'North Country' directed by Niki Caro.
What are the four ethical issues identified in the movie 'North Country'?
-The four ethical issues identified are employee right to privacy, uncooperative working conditions, gender discrimination, and air pollution.
How does the movie depict the issue of employee right to privacy?
-The movie shows a doctor leaking personal information about Josie to her supervisor, which is a violation of her privacy rights.
What kind of uncooperative working conditions does Josie face in the movie?
-Josie faces daily harassment, sexual harassment, physical harm, and degrading treatment from male workers, leading to an uncomfortable and demeaning work environment.
Why does Josie quit her job at the mines in the movie?
-Josie quits her job at the mines due to the uncooperative and hostile working conditions she experiences there.
What is the main form of gender discrimination depicted in the movie?
-The gender discrimination in the movie is shown through biased and preferential treatment based on sex and gender, where women working in the mines face sexual harassment and their complaints are ignored by supervisors.
How does the movie address the issue of air pollution caused by mining activities?
-The movie shows that mining activities result in air pollution through the release of carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide from diesel generators and other equipment, as well as water pollution from heavy metals and acid runoff.
What other environmental issues are mentioned in the movie besides air pollution?
-Other environmental issues mentioned include land subsidence, damage to the water environment, and mining waste disposal.
What is the recommendation given by the reviewer at the end of the video?
-The reviewer recommends watching the movie 'North Country' to the audience, as it opens eyes to the reality of sexual harassment in the workplace and the negative environmental impact of industrial activities.
What is the significance of the movie in raising awareness about workplace issues?
-The movie is significant as it highlights the real-life issues of sexual harassment and environmental harm caused by industrial activities, prompting viewers to reflect on these important social and ethical concerns.
How does the movie 'North Country' contribute to the discussion on management ethics?
-The movie contributes to the discussion on management ethics by showcasing real-life ethical dilemmas and the consequences of unethical practices in a workplace setting.

Outlines

00:00

🎬 Ethical Issues in 'Not Country' Movie

This paragraph introduces the video review of the film 'Not Country' directed by Nikki Caro, highlighting the intention to discuss the ethical issues portrayed in the movie. The student from University of Otara Malaysia, studying management ethics, identifies four key ethical concerns: employee right to privacy, unprofessional working conditions, gender discrimination, and environmental pollution. The review aims to shed light on these issues to raise awareness among viewers.

🔒 Employee Right to Privacy Breached

The first ethical issue discussed is the violation of employee right to privacy. The video script describes a scenario where a doctor discloses personal information about Josie to her supervisor without consent, which is a breach of privacy. This action could lead to legal consequences for the doctor, as employees have the right to keep personal information confidential and any unauthorized disclosure may result in civil action for invasion of privacy.

🚫 Unhealthy and Harassing Work Environment

The second issue is the unprofessional and unsafe working conditions faced by Josie at the mines. She experiences daily harassment from male co-workers, including sexual harassment, physical harm, and degrading treatment. This hostile work environment eventually leads Josie to quit her job, illustrating the serious impact of such conditions on an employee's well-being and career.

👥 Gender Discrimination in the Workplace

The third issue is gender discrimination, which is evident in the preferential treatment based on sex and gender. Women working in the mines, like Josie, face bias and unequal opportunities compared to their male counterparts. The movie shows that despite Josie's complaints about the sexual harassment she endured, her supervisor did not take her seriously, reflecting the systemic inequality present in the workplace.

🌳 Environmental Impact of Mining Activities

The final issue is the environmental pollution caused by mining activities. The script mentions air pollution from carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide emissions, as well as water pollution from heavy metals and acid runoff. Additionally, land subsidence and damage to the water environment are cited as further consequences of mining. The movie serves as a critique of these practices, emphasizing the need for sustainable and environmentally conscious industrial operations.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Ethical Issues

Ethical issues refer to moral problems or dilemmas that arise in various situations, often involving a conflict of values or principles. In the video's context, ethical issues are central to the narrative, highlighting the challenges faced by the protagonist due to unethical practices in the workplace. Examples from the script include employee privacy rights, gender discrimination, and the environmental impact of mining activities.

💡Employee Right to Privacy

Employee right to privacy is a legal and ethical principle that employees have the right to keep personal information confidential. The script mentions this concept when discussing the doctor who leaked Josie's private medical information, which is a violation of her privacy rights and could lead to legal consequences.

💡Unconducive Working Conditions

Unconducive working conditions describe an environment that is not suitable for productive work, often due to factors like harassment, physical harm, or uncomfortable situations. The video script illustrates this through the daily harassment faced by Josie at her workplace, which led to her quitting her job.

💡Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment is a form of discrimination that involves unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, or other verbal or physical harassment of a sexual nature. In the script, it is mentioned as a part of the unconducive working conditions that Josie faced, contributing to her decision to leave the job.

💡Gender Discrimination

Gender discrimination occurs when individuals are treated differently based on their sex or gender, often resulting in unequal opportunities or treatment. The video script discusses this issue in the context of women working in mines, who face preferential treatment and are not provided the same opportunities as their male counterparts.

💡Air Pollution

Air pollution refers to the presence of harmful substances in the air, often resulting from industrial activities. The script mentions air pollution as a result of the mining activities, with carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide being emitted from mining equipment, highlighting the environmental consequences of such practices.

💡Environmental Impact

Environmental impact encompasses the effects that human activities have on the natural environment, including air and water pollution, habitat destruction, and more. The video script discusses the negative environmental impact of mining, including air and water pollution, as well as land subsidence and damage to the water environment.

💡Iron Mining

Iron mining is the process of extracting iron ore from the earth, which is then used in various industries, such as steel production. The script mentions iron mining as a cause of water pollution due to heavy metals and acid drainage, illustrating the broader environmental implications of this industry.

💡Land Subsidence

Land subsidence is the sinking or settling of the earth's surface due to various factors, including the removal of subsurface materials like in mining. The script briefly touches on this concept as one of the environmental issues caused by mining activities.

💡Water Environment

The water environment refers to the ecosystems and habitats that are related to bodies of water. The script mentions damage to the water environment as a consequence of mining activities, such as pollution from heavy metals and acid drainage affecting aquatic life.

💡Mining Disposal

Mining disposal refers to the process of dealing with waste materials generated by mining activities. The script mentions this in the context of the environmental damage caused by improper disposal methods, which can lead to further pollution and environmental degradation.

Highlights

Review of the film 'North Country' directed by Nikki Caro

Ethical issues in the movie: employee right to privacy, unconducive working conditions, gender discrimination, and air pollution

Employee right to privacy: Confidentiality of personal information and potential civil actions for invasion of privacy

Doctor leaking Josie's information to her supervisor after pelvic examinations

Unconducive working conditions: Daily harassment, sexual harassment, physical harm, and degrading of women

Josie quitting her job at the mines due to the hostile work environment

Gender discrimination: Biased and preferential treatment based on sex and gender

Inequality in the workplace: Unequal opportunities, rewards, and resources for men and women

Sexual harassment faced by women working in the mines

Josie's complaints about co-worker misconduct being ignored by supervisors

Air pollution as a threat to the environment: Carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide emissions from mining operations

Water pollution from heavy metals and acid drainage in mining

Environmental impacts: Land subsidence, damage to the water environment, and mining waste disposal

The movie's impact on raising awareness about sexual harassment in the workplace

The film's portrayal of the negative effects of industrial activities on the environment

Recommendation to watch the movie for its educational and eye-opening content

The film as a tool to understand and confront ethical issues in the workplace and industry