Tesla Model 3 Performance vs BMW M3 Competition — Track Battle — Cammisa's Ultimate Comparison Test

Summary

In this thrilling comparison test, the BMW M3 faces off against the Tesla Model 3 Performance, with both cars pushed to their limits on a racetrack. The video delves into a variety of performance metrics, including handling, lap times, endurance, and real-world usability. While the BMW M3 delivers exceptional performance on the track with its all-around versatility, the Tesla Model 3 impresses with its quick acceleration, digital interface, and value for money. The test explores the merits of both internal combustion and electric powertrains, leaving viewers to consider whether performance or practicality wins in the modern car wars.

Takeaways

• 😀 The BMW M3 is still regarded as the best all-around sports sedan with a long-standing reputation, but the Tesla Model 3 Performance is closing the gap.
• 😀 Tesla has significantly improved the Model 3 Performance with better handling, continuous adaptive dampers, and a more refined driving experience.
• 😀 Both the BMW M3 and Tesla Model 3 Performance are now equipped to handle track sessions without overheating, but the M3 shows a clear edge in cornering performance.
• 😀 The Model 3 Performance is faster in a straight line but struggles with tire degradation during extended high-speed sessions.
• 😀 The BMW M3 is quicker around a track, largely due to its superior tire grip and the M3’s ability to maintain consistent lap times even under high stress.
• 😀 Despite both cars being able to survive intense track sessions, the BMW M3 proves more reliable for sustained performance over time.
• 😀 The Tesla’s key advantage lies in its well-integrated digital user interface, which offers features like smart route planning, built-in dash cams, and convenient charging infrastructure.
• 😀 The BMW M3, while impressive on a track, is better suited to a daily driver, with more traditional car features like Apple CarPlay and better overall driving engagement.
• 😀 Despite the Model 3 Performance being more affordable than the M3, it's difficult to deny that the M3 delivers a more traditional, thrilling sports car experience, especially on track.
• 😀 In terms of value, the Model 3 Performance offers an exceptional all-rounder, with enough cash savings to buy additional sports cars, while still delivering impressive performance.
• 😀 The comparison highlights the ongoing ideological divide between EVs and internal combustion engines, but with the Model 3, you can enjoy both worlds without picking a side.

Q & A

What is the main theme of the comparison between the BMW M3 and Tesla Model 3 Performance?

The comparison focuses on contrasting the performance, track capabilities, and driving experiences of the BMW M3 and the Tesla Model 3 Performance, highlighting their strengths, weaknesses, and differences in handling, fun factor, and daily usability.

How has the Tesla Model 3 Performance evolved since its last iteration?

The Tesla Model 3 Performance has seen significant improvements, including a new facelift, better suspension with continuously adaptive dampers, and improved driving dynamics, which now make it more comparable to the BMW M3 in terms of handling and overall performance.

What is the key difference in driving experience between the BMW M3 and the Tesla Model 3?

The BMW M3 offers a more traditional driving experience with a manual transmission feel and internal combustion engine sound, while the Tesla Model 3 provides instant torque, a smooth electric driving experience, and greater stability through its all-wheel-drive system.

Which car is faster around a racetrack, the BMW M3 or the Tesla Model 3 Performance?

The BMW M3 is quicker around a racetrack than the Tesla Model 3 Performance. Despite the Tesla's impressive acceleration, its tires lose grip after several laps, slowing it down significantly, while the BMW M3 maintains consistent performance throughout the session.

Can both the BMW M3 and Tesla Model 3 Performance survive a 15-minute hot lap session?

Yes, both cars can survive a 15-minute hot lap session, but the BMW M3 demonstrates more consistency, maintaining its lap times with minimal degradation, while the Tesla Model 3 Performance loses speed as its tires heat up, although its brakes remain reliable.

What is the Tesla Model 3 Performance's endurance mode, and how does it impact performance?

The Tesla Model 3 Performance’s endurance mode reduces power output to enhance the car’s consistency over time. While this mode sacrifices speed and peak performance, it allows the car to last longer during hot laps without overheating, making it more durable over extended sessions.

What are the advantages of the Tesla Model 3's digital user interface compared to the BMW M3?

The Tesla Model 3 excels with its intuitive and user-friendly digital interface, featuring helpful tools like a dash cam, green light notifications, and a smart route planner. In contrast, the BMW M3’s interface, though functional, suffers from a convoluted design and lacks the same level of integration and ease of use.

How do the brakes compare between the BMW M3 and the Tesla Model 3 Performance?

The BMW M3 features carbon ceramic brakes that maintain consistent performance throughout the track session. The Tesla Model 3 Performance's brakes also performed well, with the car's reprogramming preventing false overheating warnings, but the BMW's brakes are superior in handling high-stress conditions.

Which car offers a better driving experience on back roads, the BMW M3 or the Tesla Model 3?

The BMW M3 offers a more engaging and thrilling driving experience on back roads, with superior chassis tuning and tire grip. While the Tesla Model 3 excels in acceleration and stability, the M3 provides more connection to the road and a more enjoyable driving feel.

What is the major factor influencing the decision to buy the BMW M3 or Tesla Model 3 Performance?

The decision largely depends on the buyer's priorities. Those who value traditional driving dynamics, engine sound, and track performance may lean toward the BMW M3, while those prioritizing daily usability, tech features, and electric power may find the Tesla Model 3 Performance to be a better fit.