PEMERINTAH HARUS TEGAS, PENYEBAR HOAX PAPUA VERONICA KOMAN HARUS DICABUT KEWARGANEGARAANNYA

Summary

The video script discusses the ongoing issues surrounding Papua, focusing on the recent declaration of independence by Benny Wenda and the raising of the Morning Star flag in several international locations. Retired General Agus Supriatna provides insights on the security challenges and the government's response, emphasizing the need for revitalized strategies and better communication with local populations. He critiques the government's oversight and proposes more regional cooperation with Melanesian nations. The conversation underscores the importance of addressing internal security and diplomatic concerns while ensuring the welfare of Papua's citizens.

Takeaways

• 😀 Benny Wenda, the president of the United Movement for West Papua, declared the independence of West Papua on December 1st, but it was largely ignored domestically.
• 😀 The flag of West Papua, the Morning Star flag, was raised in various locations, including Australia and Europe, causing concerns over security and international reactions.
• 😀 Security systems in diplomatic missions were criticized after an incident where the Morning Star flag was raised at an Indonesian consulate without immediate intervention.
• 😀 There is a need for better communication and collaboration between Indonesian diplomatic missions, local authorities, and security personnel to prevent similar incidents in the future.
• 😀 The Indonesian government’s response to foreign governments like Australia, which allows such activities, was questioned, with a call for stronger diplomatic actions.
• 😀 The ongoing issue in Papua is not just about independence but also about unmet needs in infrastructure, healthcare, education, and human rights.
• 😀 The West Papuan demands include reducing military presence, increasing medical, educational, and economic support, and inviting UN human rights monitors to investigate alleged violations.
• 😀 The Indonesian government’s efforts like Special Autonomy Law are not reaching the remote areas, particularly in the highland regions, leading to dissatisfaction among local communities.
• 😀 There is a perception that the Indonesian government is not fully transparent about the allocation and distribution of funds in Papua, despite the large Special Autonomy budget.
• 😀 A regional collaboration initiative was proposed to strengthen ties between Indonesia and Pacific Island countries, particularly Melanesian countries, to better address regional issues, including the Papua conflict.

Q & A

What was Benny Wenda's declaration on December 1st?

Benny Wenda, the president of the United Liberation Movement for West Papua, declared the independence of West Papua on December 1st, but it was a unilateral declaration and did not gain significant attention domestically.

Why was the declaration by Benny Wenda not widely acknowledged in Indonesia?

The declaration was not widely acknowledged in Indonesia because it was seen as a one-sided act, and it did not resonate deeply within the country, particularly in Papua itself.

What issues were raised regarding the security response to the flag raising incident in Australia?

There were concerns about the security failure that allowed individuals to raise the Morning Star flag at the Indonesian consulate in Australia, especially considering the event's significance on December 1st. Questions were raised about the preparedness and response of the Indonesian consulate's security system.

How did General Agus Supriatna assess the government's handling of security regarding the flag-raising incident?

General Agus Supriatna expressed disappointment with the security measures, emphasizing that there should have been better anticipation and readiness given the historical significance of December 1st for Papua and the ongoing separatist movements.

What did Agus Supriatna suggest regarding the evaluation of Indonesia's security systems?

Agus Supriatna suggested that the government should conduct a thorough evaluation of security systems, emphasizing the need for revitalization and improved readiness in both the domestic and diplomatic spheres.

How does Agus Supriatna view the international response to the Papua issue, especially from countries like Australia and Vanuatu?

Agus Supriatna criticized countries like Australia and Vanuatu for supporting the Papua separatist movement. He emphasized that the Indonesian government should be firmer in responding to such foreign support and work on strengthening its regional influence.

What were the demands of Papua's separatists, according to Agus Supriatna?

The separatists' demands included a reduction of military and police presence in Papua, increased delivery of medical, educational, and economic assistance, and the establishment of a UN Human Rights Commission investigation into alleged human rights abuses in the region.

What role does Agus Supriatna believe the Indonesian government should play in addressing these demands?

Agus Supriatna suggested that the Indonesian government should better communicate the benefits of Special Autonomy to the people of Papua, ensuring that development funds are reaching the local population and addressing their concerns.

What is Agus Supriatna's opinion on Indonesia's approach to security in Papua?

Agus Supriatna criticized the slow response to security threats posed by armed groups in Papua, arguing that the government should take a firmer stance against these groups, labeling them as criminal armed groups and ensuring that illegal weapons are not allowed to proliferate.

What solutions did Agus Supriatna propose to improve Indonesia's regional influence?

Agus Supriatna proposed that Indonesia should initiate regional cooperation within Melanesian countries, leveraging shared cultural and ethnic ties to strengthen its position in the Pacific and counter international support for Papua separatists.