Muhammed PBUH Is Allah?! Mohammed Hijab and Christian Speakers Corner

Summary

In this discussion, the participants explore the concept of the 99 names of Allah and Prophet Muhammad, addressing common misconceptions and sources. One participant emphasizes that the 99 names are not definitively listed in the Quran or Hadith, but rather a collection of interpretations. They also challenge the idea of comparing these names with similar concepts in Christianity, such as the Alpha and Omega. The conversation touches on the importance of referencing authentic Islamic sources, dismissing unreliable websites, and emphasizing a deeper understanding of the attributes of Allah and Muhammad within Islam.

Takeaways

• 😀 The 99 names of Allah are often cited but they are not universally agreed upon and are not directly from the Qur'an or Hadith. Many websites list them based on interpretations.
• 😀 There is a common misconception that there are only 99 names of Allah, but in reality, there could be more than 99, and understanding them is key to living by Allah's attributes.
• 😀 Memorizing the names of Allah can help in seeking forgiveness, but it is important to also live by the principles they represent, such as mercy and forgiveness.
• 😀 The terms 'merciful' and 'forgiving' are distinct in Islamic teachings. Allah’s mercy (Rahman) is unearned kindness, while His forgiveness (Afuw) is the act of erasing sins.
• 😀 The Quran mentions Allah as 'the first and the last,' which refers to His eternal nature, not a direct comparison to Christian interpretations of Jesus as the first and last.
• 😀 Christians' use of the Bible, and Muslims' use of the Qur'an and Hadith, are fundamentally different in how each group treats their scriptures as authoritative sources.
• 😀 The conversation raises skepticism about using non-authoritative sources, such as websites, to discuss religious teachings or beliefs, urging reliance on primary texts like the Qur'an and Hadith.
• 😀 The Bible's claim of Jesus being the first and the last is disputed in Islam, with the belief that pre-eternality and post-eternality only belong to Allah, not to Jesus.
• 😀 The idea of eternal beings in religious texts is clarified by pointing out that while Jesus may be described as eternal, figures like Melchizedek are also mentioned in the Bible without clear divinity, questioning the logic of equating eternal status with divinity.
• 😀 The debate on the 99 names of Prophet Muhammad mentions that while these names can be found on some websites, they are not necessarily authentic or part of established Islamic doctrine.
• 😀 The discussion stresses that Muslims should refer to authentic Islamic sources (Qur'an and Hadith) rather than websites or interpretations that might be misleading or non-Islamic.

Q & A

What is the misconception about the 99 names of Allah mentioned in the Quran?

The misconception is that there are only 99 names of Allah. In reality, there are more than 99 names, and the number 99 comes from a hadith that encourages memorizing and understanding these names rather than limiting them to just 99.

Can memorizing the 99 names of Allah lead to the forgiveness of sins?

Yes, memorizing the names and living by them can lead to forgiveness of sins, as long as one follows the principles behind the names. However, it's essential not only to memorize them but also to embody their meanings in life.

What is the difference between mercy and forgiveness in Islam?

Mercy (Rahman) is an attribute of Allah that refers to kindness given without the recipient deserving it, often compared to the mercy a mother shows her child. Forgiveness (Afuw) is the act of erasing sins, while Rafal refers to continually forgiving sins. These concepts are distinct but interconnected.

What does the term 'first and last' mean when referring to Allah in the Quran?

'First and last' in the Quran refers to Allah being pre-eternal and post-eternal, meaning He existed before everything else and will continue to exist after everything has passed away. This concept is distinct from the Christian understanding of Jesus being 'the first and the last.'

Why do Muslims not consider the Bible to be a primary source of truth?

Muslims do not consider the Bible as the authentic or primary source because they believe the Quran is the final revelation from Allah, and the Bible has been altered over time. Therefore, the teachings in the Bible are not considered to be fully accurate from an Islamic perspective.

What is the argument against believing the 99 names of Muhammad are valid based on the websites mentioned?

The argument is that the list of the 99 names of Muhammad on various websites, such as Pakistanpedia, is not based on authentic Islamic sources like the Quran or Hadith. It is an interpretation or estimation by individuals, not a universally accepted list within Islam.

What role do the 99 names of Muhammad play in Islamic teachings?

The 99 names of Muhammad, like the names of Allah, represent his attributes and qualities. However, the authenticity of the list varies, as there is no standardized or universally accepted list in authentic Islamic texts.

How should Muslims refer to the names of Allah and Muhammad in discussions?

Muslims should refer to the names of Allah and Muhammad based on authentic sources such as the Quran and Hadith, not from websites or secondary sources that may contain inaccurate or non-Islamic information.

What does the term 'pre-eternal' and 'post-eternal' mean in the context of the Quran and the discussion about Jesus?

'Pre-eternal' means existing before time or creation, and 'post-eternal' means existing after everything else has ended. In the Quran, this concept applies solely to Allah, whereas in the Christian tradition, it is applied to Jesus, but Muslims do not accept this in the same context.

What does the speaker suggest about using websites like Pakistanpedia for understanding Islam?

The speaker suggests that relying on websites like Pakistanpedia for understanding Islamic principles is not advisable because such sites may not reflect authentic Islamic teachings. Instead, one should refer to the Quran and Hadith as primary sources for accurate religious knowledge.