You're Not A "Conservative Goth," You're Just Cosplaying

Summary

In this humorous and sarcastic video, the creator discusses the concept of 'conservative goths,' highlighting the contradictions between conservative political views and the values of goth subculture, which are traditionally anti-establishment, anti-capitalist, and pro-LGBTQ+. The speaker shares their experience with heated social media debates, providing a light-hearted critique of individuals who identify as both goth and conservative. With wit and playful jabs, they explore how the goth aesthetic has been commercialized, while encouraging viewers to engage and share their thoughts on this controversial topic.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker is wearing a green corset and black skirt from the early 2000s brand Trip NYC, and humorously compares the outfit to a 'goth leprechaun' vibe.
• 😀 The speaker introduces the topic of conservative goths, stating that they find the subject amusing and will approach it with a sarcastic, light-hearted tone.
• 😀 A recent Instagram post from the speaker jokingly asks for cosplay tips from conservative goths, which sparked heated debates in the comments, with people defending or opposing the idea of being a conservative goth.
• 😀 The speaker provides a brief history lesson on the goth subculture, explaining its roots in punk and its political values, including anti-capitalism, anti-consumerism, and pro-LGBTQ+ rights.
• 😀 The goth subculture, especially in its early days, was a space for challenging traditional views on gender and sexuality, allowing for androgyny and LGBTQ+ exploration.
• 😀 The speaker argues that claiming to be a conservative goth is contradictory, as goth values are inherently opposed to conservative ideologies such as capitalism, racism, and fascism.
• 😀 The speaker critiques modern conservative goths who claim that being conservative is more countercultural in today's political climate, arguing that conservatism is now part of the establishment, not opposition to it.
• 😀 The speaker highlights the commercialization of goth culture, pointing out that modern goth aesthetics often focus on fashion over politics, with fast fashion companies like Shein capitalizing on the goth look.
• 😀 The speaker emphasizes that while one can have a gothic style and be conservative, being a true goth involves identifying with the subculture’s political and musical values, not just the aesthetics.
• 😀 The speaker invites feedback from viewers, expressing an openness to learning and considering differing perspectives on the topic of conservative goths, while maintaining their own position on the contradiction.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in the video?

The video mainly discusses the concept of 'conservative goths' and the controversy surrounding people who identify as both conservative and goth, a subculture that typically values anti-establishment, anti-consumerism, and progressive ideals.

How does the speaker feel about the concept of 'conservative goths'?

The speaker finds the idea of conservative goths amusing and comical, often taking a sarcastic and slightly mean-spirited tone when discussing it. They believe that conservative values do not align with the core principles of the goth subculture.

What core values are associated with the goth subculture?

Goth subculture is rooted in values such as anti-capitalism, anti-consumerism, anti-racism, and inclusivity, particularly for the LGBTQ+ community. It challenges traditional standards regarding sexuality and gender identity.

How does the speaker describe the modern perception of goth culture?

The speaker notes that goth has become more of a fashion style and aesthetic in recent times, rather than a politically-driven subculture. However, they emphasize that goth's roots are in political and musical rebellion.

What is the speaker's view on the idea that being conservative today is countercultural?

The speaker rejects the notion that being conservative today is countercultural, stating that many large corporations and media outlets (such as Walmart and Facebook) support conservative causes, which contradicts the very essence of being counter to the establishment.

What historical influence does the goth subculture have?

The goth subculture is derived from the punk subculture, which was inherently political. Early goth scenes in the 70s and 80s were spaces for people to explore alternative gender identities, sexualities, and challenge traditional societal norms.

What kind of reactions did the speaker receive when discussing 'conservative goths' on social media?

The speaker's social media post about conservative goths sparked heated debates, with people either not understanding the joke, agreeing with it, or fiercely defending their stance as conservative goths.

What does the speaker think about the commercialization of the goth aesthetic?

The speaker criticizes the commercialization of the goth aesthetic, pointing out that fast fashion brands like Shein have watered down the subculture's original values, particularly anti-consumerism.

Can someone be a conservative and have a goth aesthetic?

Yes, someone can have a goth aesthetic while holding conservative views, but the speaker argues that it is inconsistent to label oneself as a goth while rejecting the subculture's core values, which are inherently anti-establishment and progressive.

How does the speaker respond to those who argue that goth is just about the fashion and not political values?

The speaker explains that while goth can be seen as a fashion, it is also a subculture with strong political and musical roots. Simply adopting the goth look without embracing the political values associated with it dilutes the meaning of being a goth.