[FULL] Debat Ketiga Pilgub Jakarta 2024: Paslon Adu Gagasan soal Lingkungan dan Tata Kota

Summary

In this intense political debate for the 2024 Jakarta gubernatorial election, candidates discuss key issues affecting the city, including urban planning, climate change, and environmental challenges. Topics like traffic congestion, flooding, and the potential relocation of government offices are debated, with candidates proposing various solutions such as better management of Jakarta's urban space, development of new business hubs, and strategies to reduce flooding. Tensions rise as candidates challenge each other's plans, but the debate emphasizes the importance of dialogue and collaboration in shaping the city's future.

Takeaways

• 😀 The debate is between gubernatorial and vice-gubernatorial candidates for the 2024 Jakarta elections, discussing urban planning and climate change issues.
• 😀 One candidate, Ridwan Kamil, discusses his plan for relocating the government center from Jakarta's city center to the northern region of the city, aiming to alleviate congestion.
• 😀 Ridwan Kamil highlights the importance of urban space management in Jakarta, proposing to shift government offices to reduce congestion in the city center.
• 😀 The candidates discuss the idea of the new capital city (IKN) in East Kalimantan, with some candidates proposing that Jakarta should adjust its urban planning in response to this change.
• 😀 The debate emphasizes the need for collaborative dialogue between stakeholders in Jakarta to address transportation, urban planning, and environmental challenges.
• 😀 Environmental issues, such as flooding in Jakarta, are a recurring topic. Candidates suggest that solutions should go beyond just improving infrastructure and include better management of natural resources.
• 😀 Several candidates, including Ridwan Kamil, advocate for improving green spaces and planting trees to reduce environmental issues like air pollution and flooding in Jakarta.
• 😀 The importance of the Ciawi and Sukamahi dams is discussed, with candidates expressing differing views on their effectiveness in preventing flooding from incoming rains.
• 😀 Candidates mention the need for a comprehensive approach to address the flooding problem in Jakarta, with some proposing solutions ranging from better flood management systems to restoring ecosystems upstream.
• 😀 Candidates stress that Jakarta’s flooding problem is not just a local issue but is tied to environmental degradation in surrounding areas, such as in Bogor, and requires regional cooperation to resolve.
• 😀 Throughout the debate, the theme of political will and transparency in managing infrastructure projects, like the dams, is brought up, with concerns over corruption and project mismanagement.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in this debate segment?

The main topic of the debate is urban development, environmental issues, and the handling of Jakarta's infrastructure challenges, especially in relation to urban flooding, traffic, and climate change. The candidates discuss their plans for improving Jakarta's urban space and tackling these issues.

What was the concern raised by Candidate 3 (Pramono Anung and Rano Karno) about relocating government offices?

Candidate 3 raised the question of whether relocating Jakarta's central government offices to the North is a serious proposal, especially with the upcoming move of the capital city to Nusantara (IKN). They questioned whether this plan was more of an imaginative idea or a feasible solution for reducing Jakarta's congestion.

How did Candidate 1 (Ridwan Kamil and Suswono) respond to the question about relocating government offices?

Candidate 1 responded by explaining that relocating government offices in Jakarta to the North, such as near Ancol, could help reduce congestion in the central city. They suggested this as part of a broader urban planning strategy to alleviate traffic and improve the city’s spatial organization.

What environmental issue is raised regarding Jakarta's flooding problem?

The environmental issue raised is the recurring flooding problem in Jakarta, which is caused by both local factors such as poor urban planning and external factors like excessive rainfall from nearby areas, particularly Bogor. The candidates discuss strategies to address the situation, including better management of water resources and improving the city’s natural ecosystems.

What solutions for managing floods in Jakarta were proposed by Candidate 2 (Darma Pongrekun and Kun Wardana)?

Candidate 2 proposed a comprehensive, integrated approach to flood management, which would involve improving water absorption in the upstream areas (such as restoring ecosystems in West Java) and creating storage solutions like 'monkey cheek' reservoirs to manage excess water. They emphasized that floods should be seen not just as disasters but as natural events that need effective management.

What is the stance of Candidate 3 on Jakarta’s flood management, particularly with respect to reservoirs in West Java?

Candidate 3 criticized the management of reservoirs like Sukamahi and Ciawi, arguing that although they were built to reduce floodwater coming into Jakarta, their current management practices were ineffective. They also mentioned that, despite the construction of these reservoirs, Jakarta still faces significant flooding due to the lack of proper utilization and coordination.

What did Candidate 1 (Ridwan Kamil) say about his role in managing water resources in West Java?

Ridwan Kamil stated that, as the Governor of West Java, he had been actively involved in the creation of reservoirs such as Sukamahi and Ciawi. He described the project as a contribution from West Java to help reduce flooding in Jakarta. He also mentioned ongoing efforts, such as planting 80 million trees, to address environmental issues.

What specific environmental challenge does Ridwan Kamil highlight during his tenure as Governor of West Java?

Ridwan Kamil highlighted the environmental crisis, particularly the need to address the deteriorating ecosystem. He emphasized his administration’s efforts to mitigate this by planting trees and improving water resource management, which would benefit Jakarta by reducing flood risks.

What does Candidate 2 (Darma Pongrekun and Kun Wardana) say about the management of water resources in West Java?

Candidate 2 discussed the importance of properly managing the reservoirs, particularly Sukamahi and Ciawi, as 'monkey cheek' reservoirs to store excess water. They criticized past management and emphasized that if properly utilized, these water management systems could significantly reduce Jakarta’s flooding problems.

What did Candidate 3 say about Jakarta's future as the capital city and the impact on urban planning?

Candidate 3 addressed the issue of Jakarta’s future as the capital city, especially in light of the move to Nusantara (IKN). They suggested that with the reduced importance of Jakarta as the nation’s capital, urban planning should shift to prioritize more effective distribution of government offices and services outside the central area, potentially alleviating traffic and congestion.