중국이 축구를 못하는 진짜 이유

Summary

The video analyzes why China struggles in soccer despite its large population and investment. It cites factors like high salaries reducing motivation, lack of grassroots interest, a flawed top-down government plan, and rampant corruption. The script argues China must develop organic passion for the sport, quality coaching, soccer role models to inspire kids, and long-term qualitative training, instead of just using money and quantity-based methods.

Takeaways

• 😥 China has struggled in football despite being a sports powerhouse, only qualifying for the World Cup once
• 💰 Chinese football leagues pay extremely high salaries but this reduces players' motivation and incentives
• 👨‍👦 China's one-child policy and culture of spoiling kids have created selfish players who struggle with teamwork
• 🏫 Lack of school football facilities and infrastructure limit youth participation and development
• 😠 Widespread corruption and match-fixing scandals discourage youth talent and enthusiasm
• 🤦‍♂️ The government's rushed football reform plan has largely failed due to top-down mandates and unrealistic targets
• 🌟 Lack of domestic superstar role models reduces children's dreams and parents' support of football
• ⚽ Most successful football countries have grassroots passion rather than top-down initiatives from the government
• 🇰🇷 Countries like South Korea and Japan have better long-term planning from football experts
• 💰 China's focus on naturalizing foreign stars for short-term gains won't build sustainable success

Q & A

Why has China struggled to excel in international football despite its success in other sports?

China has been successful in sports, especially in the Olympics, but has struggled in football due to factors like the lack of high-quality domestic leagues, inadequate youth development, and a focus on short-term achievements by clubs.

What was the last year a Chinese team won the AFC Champions League?

The last time a Chinese team won the AFC Champions League was in 2015.

How does the average salary of Chinese Super League players compare to those in the J-League and K-League?

Chinese Super League players' average salary is about six times that of the J-League and twelve times that of the K-League.

Why might Chinese football players prefer playing domestically over going abroad?

Chinese players may prefer playing domestically due to significantly higher salaries and the comfort of living in their home country, reducing their motivation to play abroad where they might face language barriers and tougher competition.

How has the 'single child policy' affected team sports like football in China?

The 'single child policy' led to a generation of children who grew up with a strong sense of entitlement, often being referred to as 'Little Emperors'. This mentality is thought to hinder the collaborative and selfless nature required in team sports like football.

What is the registered number of football players in China compared to Japan?

China has about 700,000 registered football players, while Japan has 800,000, despite Japan having a significantly smaller total population.

Why do Chinese schools have a lack of football infrastructure?

Many Chinese schools lack football infrastructure, such as football goals, partly due to a preference for other sports like basketball and a general lack of emphasis on football in the education system.

How does corruption within Chinese football affect young talents?

Corruption and a culture of nepotism within Chinese football can demotivate young talents, as opportunities may be unfairly distributed based on connections rather than merit, leading to a loss of motivation among talented individuals.

What was the aim of China's 'Football Reform and Development Program' launched in 2015?

The aim was to revitalize Chinese football, with goals including creating 20,000 football schools, nurturing 50 million players, making football a compulsory part of the school curriculum, and achieving top status in Asia by 2030 and winning the World Cup by 2050.

Why has China's approach to improving its football standards been criticized?

The approach has been criticized for being overly top-down and quantitative, focusing on the rapid expansion of facilities and player numbers without adequately addressing qualitative aspects such as coaching quality, player development, and the grassroots love for the game.