마칸 일렉트릭 나왔는데... 반응이 왜 이래? // 1년 전에 나왔어야 했다... 포르쉐, 전기차, EV, PPE, 3.3초, 639마력

mediaAUTO 미디어오토

28 Jan 202411:48

Summary

TLDRThe script is a review of the new Porsche Macan EV by a Korean car enthusiast. He discusses the Macan EV's specs and performance compared to the Hyundai Ioniq 5 and Tesla Model Y. While the Macan is fast with great torque, its range and efficiency are lower than the rivals. The enthusiast debates whether the Macan is worth double the price of the Ioniq 5 despite having similar acceleration. He struggles to wholeheartedly endorse the Macan EV due to the tough new competition.

Takeaways

😀 The video discusses the newly released Porsche Macan EV
😞 The host expected more excitement around the Macan EV launch
🤔 The host debates cancelling his Macan EV order for a Hyundai
😲 The Macan EV torque and 0-100km/h time beats the Ioniq 5
😕 But the Macan EV price is double the Ioniq 5
🧐 The Macan EV specs don't seem to justify the higher price
💡 The Macan EV software issues likely caused the delays
😢 The host is disappointed by the Macan EV reveal
😅 The host keeps having to compare the Macan EV to Hyundai and Tesla
😟 The host is conflicted on whether to keep his Macan EV order

Q & A

Why was the launch of the Porsche Macan EV delayed?
-The launch was delayed due to issues with software development schedules at Porsche's parent company Volkswagen. There were reports of executives being fired from VW's software subsidiary Cariad.
How does the performance of the Macan Turbo EV compare to the Hyundai Ioniq 5?
-The Macan Turbo has 639 hp, does 0-100 km/h in 3.3 seconds, and has a WLTP range of 591 km. The Ioniq 5 has 650 hp, does 0-100 km/h in 3.4 seconds, and has a WLTP range of 450 km.
What battery technology is used in the Macan EV?
-It uses a 95 kWh NCM 811 lithium-ion battery supplied by Chinese company CATL. This chemistry has 80% nickel content for higher energy density.
How does the regenerative braking capability compare between the two EVs?
-The Ioniq 5 has superior regen braking at 0.6G and up to 320 kW power recovery. The Macan Turbo can regen brake at 0.4G up to 240 kW.
What features are optional extras in the Macan Turbo EV?
-Items like the electronically controlled limited slip differential, larger wheels, rear view camera, and advanced driver assistance systems are optional extras.
What is the expected base price of the Macan Turbo EV?
-In the US market, the base Macan Turbo EV is expected to start around $173,000 or 1.7 billion Korean won.
Does the Macan EV have all-wheel drive capability?
-Yes, both the Macan Turbo and Macan 4 models are equipped with dual motors for AWD.
How practical is the Macan EV for daily use?
-With the large trunk space and AWD capability, the Macan EV is well-suited for daily use and family transportation.
Does the author seem satisfied with the Macan EV?
-No, the author expresses some disappointment given the high expectations and long wait. The comparison to Hyundai and Tesla models also leaves the author unsatisfied.
What alternatives is the author considering besides the Macan EV?
-The author has deposits down on the Hyundai Ioniq 7 and Kia Niro EV. There is hesitation about cancelling the Macan EV order after waiting so long.

Outlines

00:00

🚗 Anticipation and Disappointment with Porsche Macan Electric

The speaker shares their anticipation for Porsche's second electric vehicle, the Macan Electric, for which they had placed a pre-order deposit in October 2022. Despite the excitement, the reception of the vehicle has been lukewarm, sparking a comparison with Hyundai's electric offerings, particularly the Ionic 5 with its superior power metrics at a significantly lower price point. The Macan Electric's specifications, including horsepower and torque, are discussed in detail, noting that while the Porsche model boasts impressive figures, it surprisingly falls short in comparison to the Hyundai Ionic 5 in terms of power. The speaker expresses a sense of disillusionment with the Porsche brand, as expectations for an exceptional vehicle were not fully met, especially when considering the advancements and competitive pricing of electric vehicles from other manufacturers like Hyundai.

05:02

🔋 Electric Vehicle Specifications and Market Comparison

In this segment, the speaker delves deeper into the technical specifications and market comparisons between the Porsche Macan Electric and its competitors, notably the Hyundai Ionic 5. Topics such as battery capacity, charging speed, and regenerative braking capabilities are discussed, with the Macan Electric's features often being matched or outperformed by the Ionic 5. The speaker further explores the implications of these comparisons, questioning the value proposition of the Porsche in the face of more affordable and equally capable electric vehicles. The discussion extends to broader considerations of electric vehicle technology, such as battery chemistry and efficiency, as well as the practical aspects of vehicle design like charging port placement and optional features. The segment concludes with personal reflections on whether to proceed with the Porsche purchase or consider alternatives, highlighting the evolving competitive landscape of the electric vehicle market.

10:04

⏳ The Delayed Release of Porsche Macan Electric and Its Impact

This paragraph addresses the delayed launch of the Porsche Macan Electric, originally scheduled for release in early 2023 but postponed by nearly a year. The speaker discusses potential reasons for the delay, including software development challenges within the Volkswagen group, which owns Porsche. Speculation about the need to enhance the vehicle's powertrain in response to competing models is also mentioned. The delay has positioned the Macan Electric in a challenging market situation, where it faces stiff competition from Hyundai's Ionic 5, which offers comparable performance at a lower price point. The speaker reflects on the anticipation and expectations for the Porsche, only to find themselves reconsidering the vehicle's value amidst the evolving electric vehicle landscape. The narrative concludes with a personal contemplation on the decision to purchase the Macan Electric in light of these developments, underscoring the dilemmas faced by consumers in a rapidly advancing automotive market.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Porsche

Porsche is a luxury sports car brand that the narrator has been eagerly waiting for the release of their new electric car models, the Porsche Macan EV and Porsche Macan Turbo EV. He placed a deposit for the Macan Turbo EV a year ago but is now questioning his decision after test driving the Hyundai Ioniq 5, which offers similar performance at half the price.

💡Hyundai Ioniq 5

The Hyundai Ioniq 5 is an electric crossover SUV that was released in 2021. With a starting price of 76 million won, 650 horsepower, and 0-60mph acceleration in 3.4 seconds, the narrator considers it a competitor to the new Porsche Macan EVs, offering similar performance and features at a much lower price point.

💡Electric vehicle

The main topic of the video is electric vehicles, as the narrator compares newly released EV models from Porsche and Hyundai. Factors like horsepower, torque, charge speed, regenerative braking, and range are discussed.

💡Macan Turbo EV

The Porsche Macan Turbo EV is the top performance version of the new all-electric Macan crossover, with 639 horsepower and 0-60mph in 3.3 seconds. However, the narrator is disappointed that it doesn't offer a big jump over the cheaper Ioniq 5.

💡Price

The narrator emphasizes the large price difference between the Porsche Macan Turbo EV, starting around 1.7 billion won, versus the Hyundai Ioniq 5 at just 76 million won. He wonders if the Macan is worth paying over double despite minimal performance differences.

💡Torque

Torque is one of the key performance metrics for EVs that the narrator analyzes. The Macan Turbo EV produces over 1000nm of torque, far exceeding the Ioniq 5's torque of 600nm. This contributes to its faster acceleration.

💡Charge speed

The narrator compares the maximum charge speeds of the Porsche and Hyundai EVs. While Porsche claims 250kW for the Macan, the narrator notes that the Ioniq 5 can also charge at 350kW, so their charge speeds are similar in real world usage.

💡Regenerative braking

Regenerative braking converts the car's kinetic energy back to electric energy when decelerating. The narrator praises the Ioniq 5's class-leading regenerative braking system up to 0.6G, which outperforms the Macan's 0.4G system.

💡Range

The expected range on a single charge is compared between the vehicles. The Porsche Macan Turbo EV is estimated at 591km while the Ioniq 5 is lower at 450km. However, the narrator notes the Ioniq 5 exceeded its estimate substantially in real world testing.

💡Performance

The core discussion revolves around comparing the performance and specs of the newly released Porsche EVs versus the cheaper Hyundai alternative. The narrator tries to determine if the Macan's slightly faster acceleration and luxury branding justify its much higher cost.

Highlights

The video is abnormal, and we are working hard to fix it.
Please replace the link and try again.