The Problem with "Transvestic Disorder"

Summary

In this video, the speaker addresses a critical issue within the DSM-5, particularly the classification of 'Transvestic Disorder' and its impact on the transgender community. The speaker highlights how outdated and harmful diagnostic labels, such as 'Gender Dysphoria' and 'Transvestic Disorder,' contribute to the invalidation of non-heteronormative gender identities. The video calls for action, urging viewers to sign a petition to remove these disorders from the DSM-5 and supports awareness and advocacy for trans rights. The speaker emphasizes the importance of understanding and challenging the systemic issues affecting transgender people.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker shares their concern about the DSM-5's inclusion of a disorder called 'transvestic disorder,' which is a reclassification of 'transvestic fetishism.'
• 😀 They express frustration with how this disorder invalidates the identities of transgender people, particularly male-to-female transsexuals who aren't attracted to men.
• 😀 The speaker critiques the DSM-5's approach as being heteronormative and binary, as it forces gender identities and sexual orientations into restrictive categories.
• 😀 They argue that labeling transgender people as having a mental disorder perpetuates harmful stereotypes and undermines their rights, especially for those in the trans community.
• 😀 The speaker emphasizes that being transgender is not a mental disorder and that gender identity should not be pathologized.
• 😀 A key issue is the way the DSM-5’s diagnostic criteria invalidates various identities like lesbians, bisexuals, pansexuals, and asexuals by imposing a heteronormative framework.
• 😀 The speaker encourages viewers to take action by signing a petition to remove transvestic disorder from the DSM-5, as it negatively affects the trans community's rights and medical transitions.
• 😀 A petition link is provided on the genderqueer Tumblr, where the speaker encourages people to join the cause and spread awareness.
• 😀 The speaker praises genderqueer Tumblr spaces for their role in educating and supporting diverse gender identities, highlighting their personal experience with these communities.
• 😀 The video ends with a request for viewers to share their video ideas, as the speaker is looking for input on future content for the channel.

Q & A

What is the purpose of the Tumblr page 'genderqueer' mentioned in the script?

The 'genderqueer' Tumblr page is a platform for people who don't conform to the binary gender structure. It serves as a space for individuals to share their experiences and discuss their gender identities.

What is the DSM-5, and why is it relevant in the context of this video?

The DSM-5 is the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, used to diagnose mental health conditions. It is relevant in this video because the speaker discusses how it includes a disorder called 'transvestic disorder,' which is seen as problematic by the transgender community.

What is the main issue with the DSM-5's classification of 'transvestic disorder'?

The main issue is that 'transvestic disorder' is a problematic term because it pathologizes non-heteronormative gender identities and behaviors. It invalidates identities that do not align with traditional heterosexual norms and reinforces a rigid gender binary.

What are the implications of the DSM-5’s inclusion of 'transvestic disorder' for the trans community?

The inclusion of 'transvestic disorder' in the DSM-5 could further stigmatize transgender individuals, limit their rights, and hinder access to medical treatment. It could also promote harmful stereotypes about gender nonconformity being a mental disorder.

How does the DSM-5's categorization of transvestism affect people who are not heterosexual?

The DSM-5's categorization of transvestism as a disorder discriminates against people who are not heterosexual, particularly invalidating the experiences of lesbians, bisexual, pansexual, and asexual individuals by implying that only heterosexual attraction is acceptable for transgender people.

Why is the term 'gender dysphoria' controversial among trans activists?

The term 'gender dysphoria' is controversial because it frames a transgender identity as a disorder or something to be 'fixed' through medical intervention. Many trans activists argue that being transgender is not a mental illness but a valid form of gender expression.

What is the proposed change in terminology from 'transvestic fetishism' to 'transvestic disorder,' and why is it problematic?

The change from 'transvestic fetishism' to 'transvestic disorder' is problematic because it still frames gender nonconformity and cross-dressing as pathological. This reinforces harmful stereotypes and stigmatizes people who may not fit within traditional gender roles.

What action does the speaker encourage viewers to take regarding the DSM-5's inclusion of 'transvestic disorder'?

The speaker encourages viewers to sign a petition to remove 'transvestic disorder' from the DSM-5 and to share the petition with others. The petition is sponsored by the International Foundation for Gender Education, and it advocates for the recognition and rights of transgender individuals.

How does the concept of 'remission' in the DSM-5's definition of 'transvestic disorder' affect trans people?

The concept of 'remission' suggests that even if someone with 'transvestic disorder' receives treatment, they are never truly 'cured.' This can be used to justify denying transgender people the right to transition medically and politically, reinforcing discrimination and limiting their rights.

What role does the Tumblr page 'genderqueer' play in educating and raising awareness about gender issues?

The 'genderqueer' Tumblr page plays a crucial role in educating people about gender issues by providing a platform for diverse voices, fostering discussions about gender identity, and challenging societal norms related to gender. It helped the speaker explore and understand gender issues more deeply.