16 Personalities: Why Type 8 ENTJ is a BAD combination

Summary

In this video, the speaker challenges the idea of combining the ENTJ personality type with Enneagram type 8, arguing that these two types are fundamentally incompatible. The speaker explains that ENTJs are future-oriented, rational, and strategic, while type 8s are impulsive, action-driven, and focused on immediate gratification. Using both theoretical and real-world observations, they critique the lack of evidence supporting the ENTJ-type 8 combination, suggesting that such a combination is likely a misinterpretation. The speaker remains open to new insights but firmly believes that this combination doesn't align with observable behavior or personality theory.

Takeaways

• 😀 The ENTJ type combined with the Enneagram Type 8 is a highly debated and controversial topic in personality communities.
• 😀 Type 8s focus on the present moment, rejecting both the past and the future, and seek immediate gratification, which leads to impulsivity and impatience.
• 😀 Type 8s are grounded and concrete in their thinking, often focused on sensory experiences and action rather than abstract thought.
• 😀 The combination of ENTJ and Type 8 would require completely abandoning Ni (introverted intuition), which goes against the natural preferences of an ENTJ.
• 😀 ENTJs, who are naturally long-term thinkers and value strategic planning, would find it contradictory to prioritize immediate gratification like Type 8s.
• 😀 Type 8s are not rational types but rather impulsive, emotional, and driven by desires in the moment, which contrasts with the ENTJ's rational and methodical approach.
• 😀 The example of Silco from 'Arcane' is used to demonstrate the misinterpretation of certain characters as ENTJ Type 8s, highlighting a flawed understanding of these personality types.
• 😀 The ENTJ Type 8 combination doesn't align with observable, real-world examples, with no clear instances of such a combination found in modern interviews or studies.
• 😀 Theories about personality types should align with real-world evidence, and just because a theory fits a pattern doesn't mean it represents reality.
• 😀 The speaker challenges the idea of an ENTJ Type 8 combination, emphasizing that it is more likely a mistyped combination due to conflicting traits in the type descriptions.
• 😀 If an ENTJ believes they exhibit Type 8 behaviors, they are encouraged to explore other Enneagram types, such as Type 1 or Type 3, for a more accurate understanding of their personality.

Q & A

What is the primary focus of Type 8 personalities as discussed in the script?

Type 8 personalities are focused on immediate satisfaction and living in the present moment, often rejecting the past and future. This leads them to seek instant gratification, which can result in impatience and impulsivity.

How do Type 8s' desire for instant gratification influence their behavior?

The desire for instant gratification leads Type 8s to act impulsively and irrationally. They prioritize sensory experiences and external stimuli over long-term planning or rational decision-making.

What are the key characteristics of the ENTJ personality type as described in the video?

ENTJs are strategic, long-term thinkers who prioritize rational decision-making through extroverted thinking (Te) and have a dominant introverted intuition (Ni) that helps them plan and foresee future possibilities.

Why does the speaker believe an ENTJ 8 combination is not possible?

The speaker argues that the traits of Type 8 (impulsivity and focus on immediate gratification) contradict the long-term, strategic thinking of an ENTJ. For an ENTJ to align with Type 8, they would have to completely abandon their introverted intuition (Ni), which is essential for their decision-making process.

What role does introverted intuition (Ni) play in the ENTJ personality type?

Introverted intuition (Ni) in ENTJs helps them think long-term and make decisions based on future possibilities. It is a critical aspect of their cognitive process, and the speaker suggests that Type 8s, who focus on the present, would not prioritize this aspect of ENTJ thinking.

How does the speaker view the portrayal of Silco from *Arcane* as an ENTJ 8?

The speaker disagrees with the portrayal of Silco as an ENTJ 8, arguing that his behavior does not align with Type 8 traits like impulsivity or action-oriented decisions. Instead, Silco is portrayed as methodical, a long-term thinker, and emotionally repressed, which contradicts the typical characteristics of Type 8s.

What is the speaker's criticism of theories related to the ENTJ 8 combination?

The speaker criticizes the reliance on theory without real-world examples. They argue that just because a theory may seem plausible, it does not necessarily reflect reality. The speaker challenges the idea that an ENTJ 8 combination exists, demanding observable, modern examples to support the theory.

How does the speaker differentiate between theory and reality in personality typing?

The speaker emphasizes that theory alone does not equate to truth. They argue that the truth comes from real-world observations, and any theory about personality types must align with observable behavior to be considered valid.

What is the speaker’s stance on people who identify as ENTJ 8s?

The speaker believes that individuals who identify as ENTJ 8s are likely mistyped. They suggest that those people may need to reconsider their personality type and explore other possibilities, like Type 1 or Type 3, as they are more likely to align with their characteristics.

What does the speaker request from those who claim an ENTJ 8 combination exists?

The speaker requests concrete examples and evidence to support the existence of an ENTJ 8 combination. They challenge others to provide real-world examples or observable instances, rather than relying on theoretical constructs or unsupported claims.