Krystal And Saagar DEBATE FRATS VS Palestine Protestors

Breaking Points
6 May 202428:21

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses a range of current events with a focus on the political and social implications. It addresses the protests in support of Palestine that have extended to university graduation ceremonies, prompting a strong political reaction. The discussion also touches on the potential impact on the Democratic majority if corruption allegations against a Congressman affect the House balance. Additionally, the script covers the debate over lab-grown meat and the controversy surrounding a book by a potential Trump VP pick. It further delves into historical parallels, such as the Kent State incident, and a significant economic scandal related to price-fixing that contributed to inflation. The conversation emphasizes the importance of fair and accurate media coverage, especially in relation to protests and political movements, and criticizes the perceived hypocrisy in the media's and politicians' reactions to different protest movements.

Takeaways

  • 📢 The media is covering various protests, particularly those related to Palestine, which have reached graduation ceremonies and sparked political reactions.
  • 💥 Israel has begun the evacuation and forceful displacement of Rafah, with bombing and a potential ground invasion as ceasefire talks break down.
  • 🚨 Democratic Congressman Henry Cuellar faced a close primary challenge, winning by only 300 votes, and has been indicted for corruption.
  • 🌱 There is a political debate over lab-grown meat, with differing views that will be discussed in the show.
  • 🤥 Noam Chomsky, a potential Trump VP pick, has been accused of lying in her book about a meeting with Kim Jong-un that apparently never occurred.
  • 🏛 President Biden has made a statement regarding campus protests, distinguishing between peaceful protests and those that turn violent, which he says are against the law.
  • 🔥 There is a perceived hypocrisy in the reactions to the protests, with different standards applied to the Black Lives Matter movement compared to the current protests around Israel and Palestine.
  • 📉 The protests may have political implications, particularly for the narrow House Majority, and could be consequential if Democrats manage to pick up a few seats.
  • 🚨 There is a significant scandal involving price-fixing that has directly impacted consumers, contributing to inflation.
  • 🎓 University protests in support of Palestine have been occurring nationwide, including at the University of Michigan, which is in a battleground state.
  • 🤔 The discussion raises questions about the priorities of young voters, the influence of the Israel-Palestine conflict on national discourse, and whether the protests are an elite-driven concern.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of discussion in the provided transcript?

    -The main topic of discussion in the transcript is the protests in support of Palestine that have occurred at various universities, including graduation ceremonies, and the political and media reactions to these events.

  • What does the speaker suggest about the nature of the protests?

    -The speaker suggests that the majority of the protests have been peaceful and that the portrayal of protesters as violent is a smear intended to distract from the central issues and dismiss the movement.

  • How does the speaker compare President Biden's response to the Palestine protests with his response to Black Lives Matter protests?

    -The speaker points out a perceived hypocrisy, stating that President Biden's response to the Palestine protests is more dismissive and less nuanced compared to his response to Black Lives Matter protests, where he acknowledged the peaceful majority and the validity of their demands.

  • What political implications does the discussion suggest for the Democratic Party?

    -The discussion suggests that the Democratic Party could face political consequences if they do not address the concerns of young voters, who are increasingly critical of the party's stance on Israel and Palestine.

  • What is the significance of the mention of Congressman Henry Cuellar?

    -The mention of Congressman Henry Cuellar highlights the narrow majority in the House and the potential impact of corruption charges on the balance of power, emphasizing the importance of individual races and the overall political landscape.

  • How does the discussion characterize the media's role in the situation?

    -The discussion characterizes the media as having a significant role in shaping public perception, with a focus on how certain incidents are either amplified or ignored, depending on the narrative they wish to promote.

  • What is the speaker's stance on the importance of the Israel-Palestine issue among young voters?

    -The speaker acknowledges that while the Israel-Palestine issue may not be the top priority for all young voters, it is a significant concern for some, and the way it is handled can have a substantial impact on their political engagement and voting behavior.

  • What does the speaker claim about the situation at UCLA?

    -The speaker claims that at UCLA, there was a case of violence where counter-protesters attacked a peaceful pro-Palestine encampment, and the police response was delayed and inadequate.

  • What is the context of the discussion about lab-grown meat?

    -The discussion about lab-grown meat is mentioned as an upcoming debate between two individuals with differing views, suggesting it will be a contentious and engaging segment.

  • How does the speaker describe the situation at the University of Michigan?

    -The speaker describes a significant protest at the University of Michigan, where students walked out during a graduation ceremony in support of Palestine, highlighting the breadth of the movement.

  • What is the significance of the mention of a price-fixing scandal?

    -The mention of a price-fixing scandal indicates that there is a significant economic issue that has had a direct impact on consumers, contributing to inflation and costing people money.

Outlines

00:00

📢 Morning Show Overview and Political Updates

The host kicks off the show with a recap of the day's agenda, highlighting the significant events including protests in Palestine affecting graduation ceremonies, political and media reactions, and the potential consequences for the Democratic majority. The host also discusses the indictment of Congressman Henry Cuar for corruption, touching on the broader implications for the Republican side of the House. Additionally, a debate on lab-grown meat is teased, along with a discussion on a fabricated meeting in a book by a potential Trump VP pick. The segment concludes with a mention of an upcoming debate on Counterpoints and thanks to the viewers for their support.

05:03

🤔 Analyzing Biden's Stance on Protests and Political Implications

The paragraph delves into President Biden's response to campus protests, contrasting his stance with his previous comments on Black Lives Matter protests. It critiques the perceived hypocrisy and lack of action from the administration regarding the Israel-Palestine conflict. The discussion also touches on the potential political fallout, especially among young and suburban voters, and the impact of the protests on Biden's image as a calming influence. The paragraph concludes with a look ahead to further analysis on polling related to the protests.

10:04

📊 Dissecting Young Voter Priorities and the Israel-Gaza Conflict

This section questions whether the Israel-Gaza conflict is an elite-driven concern rather than a widespread public priority. It discusses the potential disconnect between the priorities of young voters and the focus of the national discourse. The paragraph also explores the possibility that the issue might not significantly impact the general population, given that many are either indifferent or ill-informed about the conflict. It concludes with a reflection on the importance of understanding the protesters' motivations and the public's perception of the movement.

15:04

🚨 Campus Protests and Reactions to Palestinian Solidarity

The focus shifts to specific incidents of protests and counter-protests on university campuses, highlighting the disruption of graduation ceremonies and the reactions of various universities. The paragraph details instances of violence and police inaction during counter-protests, particularly at UCLA, and criticizes the double standards in responses to violence. It emphasizes the importance of student safety and the need for a balanced approach to maintaining order without suppressing peaceful protest.

20:05

🤬 Racist Incidents and the Media's Role in Protest Narratives

The paragraph discusses an incident involving a fraternity member making racist gestures at a black Palestinian protester and the response from a Republican Congressman. It debates the media's role in amplifying certain narratives and the potential for such incidents to define entire movements. The discussion emphasizes the need for fairness in media coverage and the importance of not allowing distractions to overshadow the core issues of the protests, which are centered around human rights and stopping violence.

25:07

🌟 Breaking Points Media and the Fight for Fair Coverage

The final paragraph makes a call to action for viewers to support Breaking Points Media as a subscriber-funded, independent media organization. It positions the media outlet as an alternative to mainstream media, aiming to provide fair and comprehensive coverage of events like the campus protests and the Israel-Gaza conflict. The paragraph encourages viewers to become premium subscribers to help build a platform that offers a different perspective on current events.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Palestine protests

The term refers to demonstrations and civil unrest in support of Palestine, particularly in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In the video, these protests are highlighted as having reached graduation ceremonies and causing significant political and media reactions, indicating their impact on societal and political discourse.

💡Graduation ceremonies

Graduation ceremonies are formal events where educational institutions confer degrees upon students who have completed their studies. The script mentions that Palestine protests have extended to these events, suggesting the extent of student involvement and the use of these platforms to voice political opinions.

💡Media freak out

This phrase is used to describe an overreaction or sensationalism by the media regarding a particular issue. In the context of the video, it implies that the media's response to the protests and related events has been exaggerated or overly dramatic, potentially influencing public perception.

💡Evacuation of Rafah

Rafah is a city in the Gaza Strip, and the term 'evacuation of Rafah' refers to the forced displacement of its residents, likely due to military actions. The video discusses this as a significant development in the Israel-Palestine conflict, indicating the severity of the situation and its humanitarian implications.

💡Political debate over lab-grown meat

This refers to discussions and disagreements within the political sphere regarding the production and consumption of meat that is cultured in laboratories, as opposed to being sourced from live animals. The video suggests that this topic is contentious and will be debated, reflecting broader conversations about technology, ethics, and the environment.

💡Corruption indictment

An indictment is a formal accusation or charge, and in the context of the video, it refers to the legal action taken against a Democratic Congressman for alleged corruption. This is significant as it impacts the political landscape, particularly given the narrow majority in the House and the potential consequences for the Democratic party.

💡Price-fixing scandal

Price-fixing is an illegal practice where companies collude to set prices for goods or services, often leading to inflated costs for consumers. The video mentions a scandal involving price-fixing that had a substantial impact on inflation and consumer costs, highlighting the economic and legal implications of such actions.

💡

💡Protest and disorder

The terms 'protest' and 'disorder' are central to the discussion in the video. A protest is a public expression of objection to policies or actions, often through demonstrations. Disorder, on the other hand, refers to a breakdown of public order, which can accompany protests but is not synonymous with peaceful protest. The video contrasts the two, emphasizing the importance of peaceful protest and the lawfulness of dissent.

💡Suburban white majority

This phrase refers to the demographic group of white suburban residents who are often considered a significant voting bloc in elections. The video discusses the political strategy of appealing to this group, particularly in the context of the Democratic party's efforts to secure votes.

💡National Guard intervention

The National Guard is a reserve military force that can be called upon for various situations, including maintaining civil order. In the video, the question of whether the National Guard should intervene in the context of protests is raised, reflecting on the potential use of force to manage civil unrest.

💡Fraternity counter-protests

Fraternities, or 'frat' for short, are social organizations at colleges and universities. The video discusses instances where fraternity members have engaged in counter-protests against Palestine protesters, sometimes leading to confrontations and accusations of racism, highlighting the divisive nature of the issue on campus.

Highlights

Palestine protests have impacted graduation ceremonies, causing a massive political reaction and media attention.

Israel has begun the evacuation and forceable displacement of Rafa, with bombing indicating an imminent ground invasion as ceasefire talks break down.

Democratic Congressman Henry Cuellar, narrowly winning his primary challenge by 300 votes, has been indicted for corruption, similar to the Bob Menendez case.

The narrow House Majority on the Republican side could be consequential if Democrats manage to pick up a few seats.

A big political debate has emerged over lab-grown meat, with differing views expected to be discussed.

Noam Chomsky, a top potential Trump VP pick, has been caught lying in her book about a meeting with Kim Jong-un that apparently never happened.

Kent State lessons seemingly not learned, with potential parallels to a national catastrophe being discussed.

Matt Stoller is set to join the show to break down a massive scandal that directly impacted consumers' wallets during a period of high inflation.

President Biden's response to campus protests has been criticized for not considering the policies regarding the region.

The Senate is essential to democracy, but dissent must not lead to disorder or the denial of others' rights, according to President Biden.

Protests and counter-protests at various universities, including UCLA and the University of Michigan, have led to incidents of violence and chaos.

The media's coverage of the protests and counter-protests has been inconsistent, with some incidents receiving more attention than others.

A Republican Congressman's positive tweet about a racist incident at a university has raised concerns about public figures endorsing harmful behavior.

The discussion emphasizes the importance of focusing on the central issues of the protests rather than getting distracted by individual incidents.

The protests are centered around stopping a perceived genocide, while counter-protests seem to support continued conflict.

The media's role in amplifying or downplaying certain aspects of the protests and counter-protests is a point of contention.

The need for fair-mindedness in reporting and not allowing individual actions to define entire movements is emphasized.

Transcripts

play00:03

good morning everybody happy Monday we

play00:05

have an amazing show for everybody today

play00:06

what do we have Crystal indeed we do um

play00:08

Palestine protests have now hit

play00:10

graduation ceremonies we have massive

play00:12

political reaction we have total media

play00:14

freak out we've got all the highlights

play00:16

and low lights from that also big news

play00:18

while we were all sleeping uh Israel has

play00:21

started the evacuation or forceable

play00:23

displacement of Rafa they also are

play00:25

bombing that City it appears that that

play00:27

ground invasion is imminent as ceasefire

play00:29

talks break down we will uh bring you

play00:31

all of those very Grim details meanwhile

play00:34

Democratic Congressman Henry quar that

play00:37

Nancy Pelosi and others moved Heaven and

play00:39

Earth to save he had a very close

play00:42

primary challenge um only won by 300

play00:44

votes oh he's been indicted he's been

play00:46

indicted for corruption him and his wife

play00:49

very similar honestly to the Bob

play00:50

Menendez thing although they have not

play00:52

located any gold bars as of yet not yet

play00:54

that we know about um but incredibly

play00:57

impactful because you have you know very

play00:59

narrow House Majority on the Republican

play01:01

side if Democrats managed to pick up a

play01:03

few seats this could be very

play01:04

consequential so break that down for you

play01:06

we've also got a big political debate

play01:08

over lab grown meat this will be fun

play01:10

Sager and I will both weigh in I think

play01:12

we have different views on this one so

play01:14

it should be a fun one um and Christy

play01:16

Noam who was at least a top potential

play01:18

Trump VP pick caught lying flagrantly in

play01:22

her book about a meeting with Kim

play01:24

Jong-un that apparently never happened I

play01:26

don't know why you would lie about such

play01:27

a thing but she did so we'll uh show you

play01:30

that we also are taking a look I'm

play01:32

taking a look in my monologue about um

play01:34

Kent State any lessons that were learned

play01:36

apparently not and whether we are

play01:37

recording another version of that

play01:39

National catastrophe and Matt Stoler is

play01:41

going to join us to break down what is

play01:43

truly a massive Scandal that had a

play01:47

direct impact on you and your wallet

play01:49

some quarter of the inflation during the

play01:52

height of the worst period of inflation

play01:54

likely came from a price fixing Scandal

play01:58

um ster and himself help to do some of

play02:00

the uh journalistic uncovering of this

play02:03

Scandal so he'll talk to us about what

play02:05

the hell happened and what it all means

play02:06

yeah that's right in real media they

play02:07

would actually cover it but here here it

play02:09

is it's it's I mean domestically it's

play02:11

one of the biggest stories in the

play02:12

country and you probably I mean I don't

play02:14

think they covered at all on the Sunday

play02:16

shows like we're talking thousands of

play02:18

dollars that came out of your pockets

play02:21

because of this price fixing Scandal so

play02:23

it is really he have he has the receipt

play02:25

it's not even a journalistic story it's

play02:26

the FTC getting involved so he'll break

play02:28

that down for us I'm really excited to

play02:29

talk

play02:30

before we get started though uh thank

play02:31

you to everybody who watched um

play02:33

counterpoints latest debate they've got

play02:35

another one awesome one that is set for

play02:37

uh this Friday so as a reminder you can

play02:40

watch it early and you can support that

play02:41

work here breakingpoints outcom their

play02:43

show has been doing incredibly well

play02:44

they've made record downloads a lot of

play02:45

views on their last one on Israel

play02:47

Palestine the next one uh I think in

play02:49

particular is going to set there's going

play02:51

to be some feathers that are ruffled and

play02:52

some familiar personalities that's all

play02:54

we can say now at this moment little

play02:56

speech debate let's just put it there

play02:58

yeah well we'll leave it there and you

play02:59

can decide um who it might be

play03:01

participating so go ahead and support us

play03:03

at breakingpoints

play03:07

docomo it at least that's what the

play03:09

ratings tell us so thank you all very

play03:10

much we appreciate you let's get started

play03:12

like crystal said with the protest so

play03:14

there's been the political reaction

play03:16

President Biden taking the White House

play03:18

Podium to react to the campus protest

play03:20

these were his first words in reaction

play03:22

after Columbia University let's take a

play03:24

listen so let me be clear peaceful

play03:27

protest in America violent protest is

play03:30

not protected peaceful protest is it's

play03:33

against the law when violence occurs

play03:36

destroying property is not a peaceful

play03:38

protest it's against the law vandalism

play03:42

trespassing breaking Windows shutting

play03:44

down campuses forcing the cancellation

play03:46

of classes and graduations none of this

play03:49

is a peaceful protest threatening people

play03:52

intimidating people instilling fear in

play03:54

people is not peaceful protest it's

play03:56

against the law the Senate is essential

play03:59

of democracy but descent must never lead

play04:02

to disorder or to denying the rights of

play04:04

others so students can finish the

play04:06

semester and their college education

play04:09

look it's basically a matter of fairness

play04:12

it's a matter of what's right there's

play04:14

the right to protest but not the right

play04:16

to cause chaos Mr President have the

play04:19

protests forced you to reconsider any of

play04:22

the policies with regard to the region

play04:24

no so the two questions that were asked

play04:27

there at the end were have the protest

play04:28

force you to Recon consider any of your

play04:30

policies in the region President Biden

play04:32

no do you think the National Guard

play04:33

should intervene President Biden no

play04:35

before he was then uh exited the room so

play04:38

President Biden then definitively

play04:40

speaking on the matter there Crystal

play04:41

what' you think dissent must never lead

play04:44

to disorder uh I think the founding

play04:46

fathers would like to have a word with

play04:48

you about that conception of protest uh

play04:51

I think the civil rights leaders I think

play04:53

the abolitionists I think the suff for

play04:54

Jetts I think the Vietnam War protesters

play04:57

would like to have a word with you about

play04:59

all of that I mean disorder the the

play05:03

whole point of the media smearing of

play05:06

these protesters the political class

play05:07

mearing of these protesters is they

play05:09

don't want to deal with the central

play05:12

claim they don't want to deal with the

play05:14

central issue and the reality is in Saga

play05:16

and I were talking about this before

play05:18

this started um and we have an element

play05:20

we'll get to in a little bit but 99% of

play05:23

these protests have been peaceful in

play05:25

terms of a mass Nationwide uh student

play05:29

driven protest movement I don't know

play05:31

that there has ever been a more peaceful

play05:34

protest movement so that's number one

play05:37

number two many people contrasted these

play05:40

comments and this approach with the very

play05:43

different and much more nuanced

play05:45

commentary from Biden specifically when

play05:47

it came to Black lives matter protest he

play05:50

made sure to Center the actual you know

play05:53

core of the claims and the demands that

play05:55

were being made there and said listen

play05:57

you know the the violence here doesn't

play05:59

speak for the majority of the protesters

play06:02

who are peaceful now I supported many of

play06:05

the calls and demands and those protests

play06:07

in general and they were majority

play06:10

peaceful but there was much more

play06:13

violence including property damage

play06:15

during the black lives matter protest so

play06:18

it is blatantly hypocritical his

play06:20

approach here versus his approach and

play06:22

his commentary with regards to Black

play06:24

lives matter it's just and then the the

play06:27

final piece that I'll add here is then

play06:29

he asked you know is this changing your

play06:31

mind he says no it's actually a lie

play06:33

because no he doesn't care about

play06:35

Palestinian lives yes he's still

play06:38

committed Zionist wants to do everything

play06:39

to support Israel he's clearly Sager

play06:42

feeling the pressure we're going to get

play06:43

to some of this in terms of the Israel

play06:45

segment um reportedly he was trying very

play06:49

aggressively to secure some sort of a

play06:50

ceasefire deal that appears to have

play06:52

fallen through no he's not really

play06:54

willing to use leverage to compel Israel

play06:57

to actually fall in line but there's no

play07:00

doubt they realize this is a massive

play07:02

political problem for them and guess

play07:05

what the only reason that it is a

play07:07

political problem for them is because of

play07:09

the size of the movement because of the

play07:12

Persistence of the movement and because

play07:14

it's not just staying in the confines of

play07:16

something that is you know nice and

play07:18

decorous and can just be easily

play07:19

handwaved away and dismissed that's what

play07:21

him I'm going to talk about M brzinsky

play07:23

today Peggy Nan in my monologue what

play07:26

they want is a protest that is so Meek

play07:30

so timid so decorous that it can just be

play07:35

vanished erased that they don't have to

play07:37

actually grapple with it because to

play07:39

actually grapple with it is to deal with

play07:41

the fact that this country has been

play07:42

complicit in carpet bombing babies

play07:44

starving them to death Cindy McCain head

play07:46

of the world food program says now there

play07:48

is a full-blown famine in Northern Gaz

play07:50

that is rapidly moving south that sort

play07:52

of protest that is stays within the

play07:54

confines of oh write a letter to your

play07:56

Congressman if you feel upset and can

play07:58

easily be ignored is what they want

play08:01

because this type of protest that's in

play08:02

their face that shows up at every Biden

play08:05

rally that's president graduation

play08:07

ceremonies that's present not just at

play08:09

Ivy League colleges but colleges across

play08:11

the entire country that's much harder to

play08:13

dismiss it's much harder to ignore yeah

play08:15

I think the thing is President Biden is

play08:16

trying to make a political calculation

play08:17

where he doesn't believe at the end of

play08:19

the day I mean he believes basically in

play08:20

the silent majority bet of the uh Nixon

play08:22

Administration or in some sort of like

play08:24

sister Soldier distancing uh hearkening

play08:26

back to the 1992 campaign well honestly

play08:29

we'll see I I have no idea tomorrow

play08:31

we're actually going to be talking a lot

play08:32

about the polling in terms of the

play08:33

reaction to the campus protest it's

play08:36

difficult to gauge there's no real way

play08:37

to know on the one hand we have to talk

play08:39

about the margins on the other hand we

play08:40

have to talk about Biden basically

play08:41

trying to solidify the Suburban white

play08:43

majority especially amongst young you

play08:45

know like women and adults goad can I

play08:47

say something about that though he

play08:48

already has the Suburban white majority

play08:51

well the women who are voting on

play08:52

abortion they're already in the

play08:54

Democratic party Camp that's number one

play08:56

number two before what has given the

play09:00

appearance Nationwide of this like

play09:03

campus chaos and violence and and all of

play09:06

you know all of that which I agree is

play09:09

not a great Vibe for Biden because you

play09:11

know his whole thing was like restore

play09:13

calm and it's not going to be chaos and

play09:14

Trump is chaos what created the chaos

play09:17

was the police Crackdown these protests

play09:19

have been going on at many college

play09:21

campuses since very soon after October

play09:23

7th and it hasn't been oh my God chaos

play09:26

it's because of and he greenlit with his

play09:30

commentary this police response so I

play09:33

think he is putting himself in the worst

play09:35

of all worlds where of course young

play09:37

people absolutely hate his guts there's

play09:40

no way that a young person for whom this

play09:43

issue is important and sees the

play09:45

president smearing them as violent

play09:47

anti-semites is going to want to vote

play09:49

for this dude so that's a disaster he

play09:51

needs to win young people and then if

play09:54

you're the person who's like once the

play09:56

Law and Order candidate do you think Joe

play09:58

Biden's going to be your guy I know

play09:59

you've got a you know more aggressive

play10:01

more hardcore authoritarian Law and

play10:03

Order dude on the ballot so once again I

play10:06

mean it reminds me sort of of his

play10:08

immigration positioning right where it's

play10:10

like let me just accept the right-wing

play10:12

framing of this no if people if you're

play10:14

buying into the rightwing framing

play10:15

they're not going to just go with like

play10:17

the uh the lesser of the right-wing FL

play10:20

framing they'll go with the guy who's

play10:21

all in on that so I think it's a

play10:23

political disaster all the way across

play10:25

the board but it's a question of young

play10:27

people and their priorities so yes I we

play10:29

can go look at our poll there were some

play10:31

young people who said they wouldn't

play10:32

necessarily vote for Biden but uh there

play10:34

was a later poll that just came out a

play10:36

couple of days ago Harvard Harris where

play10:38

they had Israel Gaza as number 15 out of

play10:41

16 for priorities I mean I do think

play10:43

there is a danger that this is just an

play10:45

elite movement and the truth is that

play10:47

most people even if they do care about

play10:48

Israel Palestine I'll say this for

play10:50

myself it's not my number one not even

play10:51

my top five issue I care much more about

play10:53

our country and policies that affect

play10:55

here I don't think that that's

play10:56

necessarily an immoral thing to say and

play10:58

by the way I'm not going to tell people

play11:00

what to do if that wants to be your top

play11:01

priority you be you I think that's fine

play11:04

but the question does come for is this

play11:07

an elite driven concern and I don't even

play11:09

mean necessarily in terms of left I

play11:11

would say right too I mean how much of

play11:13

our national discourse is captured by

play11:15

Israel and Palestine when the truth is

play11:17

that the vast majority of people like

play11:18

don't particularly care all that much

play11:20

and in fact if you look at the

play11:22

uninformed issue a lot of people don't

play11:25

know very much about the conflict

play11:26

because they just don't they either just

play11:28

don't care or they're just not consuming

play11:29

a lot of media and they decided to turn

play11:30

out I think it is fair to raise the

play11:32

question of like okay is this a bubble

play11:35

right I think entirely Fair um the idea

play11:40

I I very much descent from the idea it's

play11:42

a quote unquote Elite driven discourse I

play11:44

know the focus is on like Colombia and

play11:45

other ivy league institutions this is I

play11:48

mean City College which is famously A

play11:50

working class Institution New York City

play11:52

also saw protests you have protests at

play11:54

State schools all sorts of Institutions

play11:56

across the country so that's number one

play11:59

number two is you know okay it's one

play12:02

thing when people are ordering their

play12:03

priorities and responding to a poll it's

play12:05

another thing when you look at the poll

play12:07

numbers for Joe Biden with young voters

play12:08

that's true but the question is how much

play12:10

of that is Israel Gaza how much of it is

play12:11

that is just way too expensive some

play12:13

of that is definitely the case and we

play12:15

saw the fall off with young voters begin

play12:19

prior to Israel Gaza it has accelerated

play12:21

I mean the fact that you now have Joe

play12:23

Biden losing to Donald Trump by 11

play12:24

points is astonishing and certainly like

play12:28

smearing if you look at young

play12:31

sentiment about Israel and Palestine

play12:34

obviously very Divergent from older

play12:36

voters and then if you see the president

play12:38

United States basically smearing your

play12:40

entire generation as anti-violent

play12:42

anti-semites I have to think that that's

play12:44

probably going to have a negative impact

play12:47

for people that this issue is a real

play12:49

priority listen it only takes a few

play12:52

percentage points where like this is

play12:54

their thing and there's no recovering

play12:57

from it for it to be a you know a

play12:59

completely game-changing type of

play13:01

political event this is what you see

play13:03

frequently you know even with even with

play13:05

like abortion okay abortion is not the

play13:08

number one issue for uh like if you look

play13:11

for some people it is just like Wiz B

play13:14

for some people definitely more but it's

play13:16

not just how many people rank this as

play13:18

their number one but how strong is the

play13:20

emotion and is this like a single issue

play13:23

for some percentage of young people at

play13:24

this point it's a single issue and I

play13:26

don't think there's any recovering at

play13:28

this point for Joe Biden on this issue

play13:31

so um you know we'll see but I think

play13:34

that because the policy it it really

play13:37

ultimately comes down to like the policy

play13:39

is really bad now you have the Spectre

play13:41

of him smearing effectively an entire

play13:43

generation as like you know racist and

play13:46

um I don't think that's going to help

play13:48

them entire generation like half of the

play13:50

people in this most the people who are

play13:52

young don't even go to college so

play13:53

they're not even tangentially involved

play13:55

like how do they feel about this issue

play13:56

they may feel some way but they're not

play13:58

necessarily protests are only on college

play14:00

campuses which they're sure but I mean

play14:01

okay they'd be like saying you know all

play14:02

Millennials feel this and be like you're

play14:04

smearing My Generation for going after I

play14:07

don't know the avocado toast thing like

play14:08

I don't feel particularly that way I'm

play14:09

more just saying like it's important

play14:11

that we try and segment this out for

play14:13

like who are these protesters who are

play14:15

the people who feel affinity for them I

play14:17

don't think it's fair to say it's

play14:18

smearing an entire generation because

play14:20

not all young people do care about

play14:21

Israel and Gaza I'm just trying to zoom

play14:23

out and really think about this

play14:25

politically thinking about 1968 and the

play14:27

eventual ramification I mean there's a

play14:29

lot of Truth to the fact that a protest

play14:31

movement I we talked about this

play14:32

previously dramatically backfired and

play14:33

failed the new left as a project itself

play14:36

was a historic failure specifically

play14:38

because of the idea of mass mobilization

play14:40

and there's also a question I think

play14:42

again of the silent majority which

play14:43

became very relevant in BLM when it was

play14:46

the same thing where people were like oh

play14:47

all young people believe that there's

play14:49

like some Mass violence of police

play14:51

against black people it's like well not

play14:53

really not actually true especially if

play14:54

we look now and to what their overall

play14:56

reaction is but the question is also

play14:58

going to come to media and coverage of

play15:00

course which we of course will uh focus

play15:02

on there's been some more demonstrations

play15:04

that have been happening let's put this

play15:05

up there on the screen and I can go

play15:07

ahead and narrate some of this this is

play15:08

at the University of Michigan obviously

play15:10

a major Nexus there were walkouts during

play15:12

the graduation ceremony in support of

play15:15

Palestine there you see a lot of flags

play15:16

kefas and others who are walking out who

play15:18

are disrupting the graduation ceremony

play15:21

that Michigan one may be one of the most

play15:22

important because it's in that

play15:23

Battleground State here we have

play15:24

graduates at nor Eastern calling out

play15:26

their University for complicity they say

play15:29

Eastern has arrested me why don't you

play15:30

listen to your students Neu filing gen

play15:33

genocide divest now here is at uh we

play15:35

have Georgia State students who are

play15:37

being escorted away for wearing cfas and

play15:40

for having Palestinian Flags so this is

play15:42

all you know again feeding into a Vibe

play15:44

of chaos the only question is kind of

play15:46

like which way and how to navigate this

play15:49

now you are correct Crystal on the

play15:50

violence fronts I will give it to you uh

play15:52

very very different whenever it comes to

play15:54

the black lives matter protest let's put

play15:56

this up there on the screen this in

play15:58

particular was one that a lot of people

play15:59

focused on I know I think uh it was

play16:02

covered by Ryan and Emily and we covered

play16:04

a little bit on Thursday as well this is

play16:06

from The New York Times They say how the

play16:07

counter protesters at UCLA provoked

play16:10

violence and unchecked for hours this in

play16:12

particular was a grievous case because

play16:14

you had the like Ren aop camps cops like

play16:18

lock themselves into a building and

play16:20

there was basically just like full-on

play16:21

Street violence that was just happening

play16:23

between these counter protesters who

play16:25

were like firing fireworks and others at

play16:27

the Palestinian encampment and it

play16:29

happened for a period of almost 3 to 4

play16:32

hours in the middle of the night that

play16:34

was you know fostering all over social

play16:35

media and it took them until 6:00 a.m.

play16:38

actually for the LAPD to come in and uh

play16:41

it's obviously very blatantly

play16:43

hypocritical whenever you do look at

play16:44

some of the other police reactions so I

play16:46

on this one I'll will absolutely give it

play16:48

to you it was ridiculous uh that it even

play16:49

took so long for them to come in and

play16:51

because you know look you know we

play16:52

believe in student safety right I

play16:53

believe that for all the students who

play16:55

are involved if you got people who were

play16:57

coming there looking to start a brawl

play16:58

and then the get that's part of the most

play17:00

worst things about mob violence is that

play17:02

it begets itself and it's you know just

play17:04

keeps a vicious circle and that's

play17:05

basically what happened at UCLA well

play17:07

what happened is you had a peaceful

play17:08

encampment that was violently attacked

play17:10

and police stood by and let it happen

play17:12

for five freaking hours five hours they

play17:15

were violently assaulted LA Times

play17:18

student reporters now the New York Times

play17:20

all look at this and say this was

play17:23

entirely one-sided that this protest was

play17:26

entirely peaceful and then these counter

play17:28

protesters who were funded by the way by

play17:30

Bill akman and Jerry Seinfeld's wife a

play17:33

bunch of other people came in and began

play17:37

assaulting and shooting fireworks and

play17:38

sent um significant numbers the numbers

play17:41

I saw originally uh to roughly two dozen

play17:43

students to the hospital and the police

play17:46

did nothing nothing and then when they

play17:49

did do something did they arrest the

play17:51

violent people who were assaulting

play17:53

students I thought we cared about

play17:54

student safety no they didn't arrest

play17:55

them no arrests were made of the the

play17:58

thugs that were violently assaulting the

play18:00

peaceful protesters they got off scott

play18:03

free no the peaceful protesters got

play18:06

assaulted so after night number one

play18:09

where they're violently beaten by these

play18:11

thugs funded by a billionaire on night

play18:14

number two the cops came in and did the

play18:17

violence themselves and were shooting

play18:18

rubber bullets um the image of of that

play18:21

and the you know the violence inflicted

play18:23

against these students the injuries from

play18:25

those arrests also quite significant so

play18:29

it is outrageous and this is the most

play18:34

significant incident of violence that we

play18:36

have had it was as I said entirely

play18:38

one-sided and going back to Joe Biden's

play18:41

comments and the comments of all these

play18:42

other freaking people have you condemned

play18:44

that are you calling for you know

play18:47

where's your concern about disorder here

play18:49

where's your concern about lawlessness

play18:51

here absolute silence where's your

play18:54

concern about Jewish student safety

play18:56

because guess what there were many

play18:57

Jewish students in that encamp

play18:59

where is any of that concern when it's

play19:02

coming from the pro-israel Zionist

play19:05

agitator thugs coming into assault

play19:08

students it's in police standing by and

play19:11

letting it happen and then doing it

play19:12

themselves the next day no I agree hear

play19:14

any of that I do think it's very

play19:15

hypocritical and this is part of the

play19:16

issue and we all start taking sides and

play19:17

we're all going to start into street

play19:19

gangs and it's like no that's not what

play19:20

we want here that's actually the

play19:22

opposite of uh what I mean if you do

play19:24

care about order and disorder and uh

play19:26

student safety I actually do care about

play19:28

all those those things just not willing

play19:30

to say that words are violence which is

play19:32

part of a segment that we'll get to and

play19:34

that people being snowflakes and saying

play19:36

hearing dangerous Chan is upsetting uh

play19:39

however if you have people who are

play19:40

actually firing fireworks and are

play19:42

beating people up and then you allow

play19:44

that to happen terrible right absolutely

play19:46

terrible and you are absolutely correct

play19:48

you don't have a lot of people in the

play19:49

media even condemning or even frankly

play19:51

commenting on some of the stuff here

play19:53

which is just pretend that it doesn't

play19:55

exist very very common amongst a lot of

play19:57

the Israel first crowd let's go put this

play19:59

uh next part up here on the screen there

play20:01

was uh let's just say a troubling

play20:03

incident that broke out over at Old Miss

play20:05

University yeah had kind of a frat

play20:07

brothers versus some of these Palestine

play20:09

protesters some uh people were saying

play20:12

that they were mocking This Woman This

play20:14

Palestinian protester who is black and

play20:16

they're calling him a racist this man

play20:18

has already actually been expelled um

play20:20

from his from his fraternity so you've

play20:21

seen outbreak of kind of like fraternity

play20:24

versus Palestinian wouldn't call

play20:26

violence per se but I guess what clashes

play20:28

on campus people screaming at each other

play20:31

uh kind of like that so I guess as a

play20:33

former frat boy let me just say to all

play20:34

my brothers out there don't ruin your

play20:36

life for the sake of um literally

play20:38

getting expelled and trying to go viral

play20:40

on social media I would just advise you

play20:42

not to do that and uh think about your

play20:44

future as I had talked about previously

play20:45

for proest can we put that back up on

play20:47

the screen put that back up on the

play20:48

screen okay because what you see here

play20:50

you got these dudes you know mocking her

play20:53

calling her lizo right all of that okay

play20:55

that's one thing then you have this guy

play20:58

who's making monkey noises and

play21:01

pretending like he's an ape at a black

play21:03

woman and what you have here is a

play21:06

republican member of

play21:09

Congress tweeting this video positively

play21:12

and saying miss taking care of business

play21:16

so it's not no people weren't oh saying

play21:18

that they're mocking no no no you have a

play21:20

man making literal monkey noises and

play21:24

gestures at a black woman it is as

play21:26

textbook racist as you could possibly

play21:29

get and this Republican member of

play21:31

Congress is like yes I like this this is

play21:34

good for me so I agree that we should

play21:35

call out the Republican Congressman but

play21:37

in the same way Chris we shouldn't

play21:38

elevate a single person from this thing

play21:40

and say that this is uh who who they are

play21:42

well here's why it's important because

play21:44

when it's a single anyone associated

play21:46

with the you know ceasefire movement

play21:48

with the anti-war movement then this is

play21:51

representative of the whole movement

play21:53

right and we have to get a presidential

play21:55

decree multiple presidential statements

play21:57

in a press conference about how they

play21:58

vile anti-semites but when you have like

play22:01

the most racist imaginable oh well

play22:03

that's just that's just a one one guy

play22:05

that's just a onef the rest of the guys

play22:07

are there and they're just shouting and

play22:08

that's fine I don't think there's

play22:09

anything wrong with it so Mor what I

play22:10

would say is I think unfortunately

play22:12

there's been a bit of some left

play22:14

hypocrisy here where everybody's like no

play22:15

see like all these kids are racist no

play22:18

here's what happened at UNC those

play22:20

Palestinian protesters took down an

play22:22

American flag stupid idea by the way and

play22:24

then a bunch of UNCC fra Ros surrounded

play22:27

and defended the American flag while

play22:29

they were pelted with trash again

play22:32

explicitly aligning yourself against the

play22:33

US flag wouldn't advise it in uh in the

play22:35

United States those people went viral

play22:37

and basically from then on all frat

play22:39

brothers around the country are like

play22:41

okay we got to get involved in this so

play22:42

again I would say to my brothers out

play22:44

there please don't do this uh do not uh

play22:47

engage in racist mocking of protesters

play22:49

because it's not going to work out well

play22:50

for you as it worked out in this

play22:51

instance but I do think it's important

play22:53

to say that just because one guy did it

play22:55

doesn't mean that all of them are racist

play22:56

for coming up and for shouting against

play22:58

and I I don't I have seen unfortunately

play23:00

a lot of people use the same tactics

play23:03

which I don't think is fair cuz it'd be

play23:04

like saying that all of that all of the

play23:06

campus protesters are anti-semites

play23:08

because one guy who like barely even

play23:11

goes there said something about Jews and

play23:13

it's like well you know that's not

play23:14

really what it's all about so and I just

play23:16

wanted to put that out there I don't

play23:17

think it's fair sure but I I think

play23:19

that's fine yeah um I think there's a

play23:21

lot of hypocrisy on the other side where

play23:23

as I said one incident can be used to

play23:26

Tar an entire movement as anti-Semitic

play23:29

whereas here this is not even

play23:30

acknowledged and actually to the extent

play23:32

it was acknowledged it was celebrated

play23:33

and uh the governor of the state also

play23:36

you know celebrating and louing saying

play23:38

it warmed his heart um these individuals

play23:41

at Old Miss so fine let's be fair minded

play23:45

and focus on what one side stands for

play23:47

and what the other side stands for one

play23:49

side stands for stopping a genocide the

play23:51

other side stands for fair these kids

play23:53

they're just pissed off because people

play23:54

have taken over their Camp their

play23:56

movement about what

play24:00

movement is about continue slaughtering

play24:03

children that's what the conflict is

play24:05

about and so yeah I agree with you to

play24:07

focus on who are they and are they

play24:09

racist what are they saying whatever is

play24:11

to miss the point of what these protests

play24:13

and counter-protest are about the

play24:15

protests are about let's stop a genocide

play24:17

the counter-protests are about let's

play24:19

contining so yes okay we let's have that

play24:22

conversation because this is all a

play24:23

distraction from the real issue that

play24:25

these kids are out there protesting

play24:27

about well we will have our real

play24:28

discussion absolutely but I'm saying I

play24:30

don't think it's fair to say that people

play24:31

who are annoyed about protesters are

play24:33

coming on their campus and who are

play24:35

screaming and shouting and are basically

play24:37

like going out there to mock them be

play24:38

like hey please get out of here because

play24:39

we don't necessarily agree with you I

play24:41

don't think that means that they're pro-

play24:42

genocide in fact I didn't even see a

play24:44

single isra flag amongst a single one of

play24:45

those guys I I like I said it was a huge

play24:48

mistake for those UNCC idiots to take

play24:50

down the American flag I don't know why

play24:51

they had to do it but they decided to do

play24:53

it and it's like if you want to put

play24:53

yourself against America you are going

play24:55

to get a lot of people who are coming

play24:56

out there defend the flag

play24:59

vital there's vitriol towards people who

play25:02

you know took down a flag but so much

play25:04

less to this man making monkey noises at

play25:06

a black woman and you want to excuse him

play25:08

and you want to call them idiot excusing

play25:10

him I'm well I think I said he was an

play25:12

idiot and I don't think he should ruin

play25:13

your life for that i' absolutely don't

play25:14

condone what he did what I'm saying oh

play25:17

look it's also about convincing people

play25:19

taking down the flag of your country in

play25:21

your own country is a dumb idea I think

play25:22

it was huge uh it was a backlash there's

play25:25

a reason that it all went viral I don't

play25:27

have vitory all for anybody in fact I'm

play25:29

just trying to analyze it in terms of

play25:31

like which one is going to be more

play25:33

popular but I'm not in the business just

play25:34

as I'm not in the business of smearing

play25:36

you know counter or protesters as

play25:38

anti-semitic as a bunch of frat kids as

play25:40

racist because I've seen this happen you

play25:41

know I was in a fraternity everybody oh

play25:43

prosexual assault and all this other

play25:44

and I see a lot of the media

play25:47

basically participating and trying to

play25:48

cancel use the same tactics that I think

play25:52

pists are using as the counter

play25:53

protesters and I don't think that's

play25:54

appropriate more what I'm saying is that

play25:56

I don't look I mean at the end of the

play25:58

day I don't really believe in terms of

play26:01

uh that these guys are pro genocide I

play26:03

think that they're participating in a

play26:04

social movement where for a lot of the

play26:05

people in this country is annoying to

play26:07

have this happen and so they're coming

play26:09

out and they're like yelling and I don't

play26:10

think there's anything particularly

play26:12

wrong with that you can think that one

play26:13

side is more moral if you'd like but for

play26:15

a lot of people they either don't care

play26:17

or they're you know they think this is

play26:18

something this is worth to come out and

play26:20

just like make fun of people which again

play26:21

is a fundamental American right look I

play26:24

support their right to be

play26:25

that's part of what the first amendment

play26:27

is but

play26:29

but I think we should stay focused on

play26:32

what the actual issue is that is being

play26:35

protested and sorry I don't think one

play26:38

side is more moral than the other one

play26:40

side is more moral than the other I

play26:43

don't think that it could be there could

play26:45

be an issue that is more clear-cut at

play26:47

this point when you have so many

play26:49

children slaughtered you have we're

play26:51

going to cover this in the isal segment

play26:53

every single child in Rafa right now is

play26:56

either malnourished nished sick or

play27:00

injured okay so yeah there is a morality

play27:05

gap between the two sides and I agree

play27:08

with you it's not fair to take one

play27:10

individual and say this is reflective of

play27:11

an entire movement but that is what's

play27:13

been done to the pro Palestinian

play27:15

students and suddenly when it's these

play27:17

kids or when it's the UCLA

play27:19

counter-protesters who were the ones who

play27:21

were 100% violent that's just it's

play27:24

either completely erased or they're

play27:26

actively celebrated that's what I'm

play27:28

upset about I totally agree with you and

play27:30

and look I mean we can't we can't

play27:31

control what the rest of the media does

play27:33

we can only try and you know cover it

play27:34

the way that we can here and I don't

play27:36

think you know we're trying to erase any

play27:37

Horrors or any of the other stuff we

play27:38

have plenty of stuff about that in our

play27:40

show I don't I do think if you were on

play27:41

the Palestinian side you should be upset

play27:43

about the way that the media has treated

play27:44

you specifically MSNBC and so-called

play27:47

like fellow Travelers I'm with you I

play27:48

mean if I was on that side I'd be

play27:50

furious about the way that they covered

play27:51

BLM or others I'm only saying let's not

play27:54

descend you know Fight Fire with Fire or

play27:55

any of that because I don't think it

play27:56

will get us to a particular good place

play27:59

and if anything history shows it will

play28:00

probably backfire so I think that's a

play28:02

decent enough lesson hey guys if you

play28:04

like that video go to Breaking

play28:05

points.com become a premium subscriber

play28:07

and help us build the best Independent

play28:09

Media organization on the planet that's

play28:11

right we're subscriber funded we're

play28:12

building something new we want to

play28:13

replace these failing mainstream media

play28:15

organizations so again to subscribe it's

play28:17

breakingpoints tocom

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
PoliticsMediaProtestsPalestinianIsraelCongressCorruptionInflationPrice FixingScandalCampus UnrestBidenBlack Lives MatterLaw and OrderFraternityRacismFirst AmendmentGenocideHuman RightsCollege ProtestsUCLAOld MissUniversity ProtestsCounter-ProtestZionismAnti-SemitismEconomic ImpactInflation CrisisFTCJournalismBreaking Points