What Makes Something a "Cult"?
Summary
TLDRこのビデオでは、カルトと宗教の違いについて詳しく解説しています。辞書による宗教の定義は、神や超自然への崇拝や、熱意と信仰をもって宗教的な信念や儀式への献身です。一方、カルトは、非正統と見なされる宗教や、人や思想、物体、運動、作品への熱狂的な信仰です。カルトと呼ばれるものは、一般的に新規性、秘密主義、金銭的な要求、家族や友人との疎外、強いリーダーシップ、そして非伝統的な信念を共有している傾向があります。また、Jonestownのような破壊的なカルトの例も紹介され、その危険性と、家族や友人との関係を断つような言動が問題視されています。最後に、危険性のある活動に関与していると思われる親戚や友人と話す際には、「カルト」という言葉よりも具体的な懸念を共有することが効果的であるとアドバイスしています。
Takeaways
- 📜 宗教は、神や超自然への奉仕と崇拝、または宗教的な信仰や遵守への熱意的なコミットメントを意味します。
- 🛕 宗教は、神々を崇拝するだけでなく、神の存在を必要としない原則や信念に熱心に献身することも含まれます。
- 🏛 カルトは、非正統と見なされる宗教、または人、アイデア、物、運動、または作品への熱狂的な献身として定義されます。
- ⏳ 新しい宗教は、長い歴史を持つ宗教に比べて、しばしばカルトと呼ばれやすくなります。
- 🔏 秘密主義は、組織が危険と見なられる可能性を高める要因の1つです。
- 💰 金銭を要求するグループは、宗教的な集団よりもカルトと見なされる傾向があります。
- 👪 家族や友人を離れるよう求めるグループは、一般的にカルトと呼ばれる傾向があります。
- 🧲 カルトは、魅力的な指導者を崇拝する傾向があります。その人物を批判することは、組織から排除される可能性があります。
- 🌌 カルトは、伝統的な信仰とは大きく異なる、時には暴力的に反対される信念を持つ傾向があります。
- ☠️ ジョーンズタウンのような破壊的なカルトは、非正統な生活形態、家族や友人を離れること、強いカリスマティックな指導者を持つことを結合しています。
- 💬 「カルト」という言葉には強い否定的な響きがあるため、危険な活動に関与している親しい人との会話では、具体的で効果的な言い回しを選ぶことが重要です。
Q & A
「カルト」と「宗教」の違いは何ですか?
-「カルト」は通常、非統正的または偏愛された人物、考え方、物、運動、または作品への偉大な献身を意味します。一方、「宗教」とは、神や超自然への奉仕と崇拝、または宗教的な信仰や掟への熱意と献身を意味します。
「カルト」と呼ばれることが多い集団にはどのような共通の特徴がありますか?
-「カルト」と呼ばれる集団には、新しい宗教であること、秘密主義、金銭を要求すること、家族や友人との関係を断つこと、強いリーダーシップ、そして非統odoxな信仰などが共通の特徴です。
なぜ「カルト」と呼ぶのは問題があるとされていますか?
-「カルト」と呼ぶことは主観的であり、個人のバイアスを示すことになるため、問題があります。また、何がカルトであるかは人それぞれ異なるためです。
時間はどのようにして宗教とカルトを区別するのに関与しますか?
-長い歴史を持つ宗教や信仰は、社会的な資本を持っており、新しい宗教よりもカルトと呼ばれる可能性が低くなります。新しい宗教は、それが新しいため、奇妙に見られる傾向があります。
秘密主義は宗教集団をどのように見なす影響を与えますか?
-組織が秘密主義的であれば、人々はそれが潜在的に危険であると見なしやすくなります。何を隠しているのか、と疑問に思うことができます。
金銭を要求する宗教集団はなぜ危険と見なされる傾向がありますか?
-金銭を要求する集団は、入会費用を求められる、定期的な支払いを求められる、または全財産を手放すように求められることがあります。これにより、その金銭が誰かのポケットに入っている可能性があるとして、狩猟的であると見なされる傾向があります。
家族や友人との関係を断つ要求はなぜ問題ですか?
-家族や友人との関係を断つ要求は、友人や家族が最も強い影響力を持つため、最も強い反対の声を排除し、メンバーを脆弱でしばしばとさせます。
カルトと呼ばれる集団はなぜ強いリーダーシップを持つ傾向がありますか?
-カリスマ的なリーダーシップは、新しいメンバーを引き寄せる最初の要因であり、明らかに狩猟的になる前に、魅力的に見えます。また、その公的な人物を批判することは、組織から排除される可能性のある重罪です。
カルトと呼ばれる集団はなぜ非統odoxな信仰を持つ傾向がありますか?
-カルトと呼ばれる集団は、多くの人々にとって非統odoxであり、他の宗教グループとは大きく異なる信仰を持つ傾向があります。これには、異星人や宇宙に焦点を当てたグループ、または一般的なキリスト教とは大きく異なるセクトなどが含まれます。
Jonestownはなぜ最も有名な破壊的なカルトの一例とされていますか?
-Jonestownは南アメリカのユートピア的なコミュニティで、900人以上のアメリカ人が移住し、コメットが通過する際にサイアン化カストに満たされたクールエイドを飲んで大量自殺(または潜在的に殺害)を行った場所です。これは、先ほど話した特徴のいくつかを組み合わせています。
「カルト」という言葉はなぜ慎重に使われるべきですか?
-「カルト」という言葉は非常に強い否定的な響きを持っており、危険な活動に従事している家族や友人と話す際には、具体的な表現を使う方が効果的です。例えば、「家族との距離を置いていることに問題があります」や「これほどお金を払う必要があるとは正しくない」と言えるでしょう。
Outlines
📚 宗教とカルトの定義と違い
この段落では、宗教とカルトの概念を探求し、両者の間に存在する議論と違いを明らかにしています。宗教は神や超自然への奉仕と崇拝、またはそれに熱心に献身するという意味で定義されています。一方、カルトは非正統的な宗教や、人やアイデア、物、運動、作品への熱狂的な信仰として定義されています。また、カルトというラベルは主観的であり、何をカルトと呼ぶかによって個人のバイアスが示されると述べています。
🕰️ 新しさと秘密主義がカルトの特徴に
この段落では、宗教とカルトの認識に影響を与える要因として時間と秘密主義が挙げられます。長い歴史を持つ宗教は社会的な資本を持ち、新しい宗教は新しいためとんてきに見られる傾向があります。また、組織の秘密主義が強いほど、人々はその組織を潜在的に危険だと見なします。さらに、カルトと呼ばれるグループは入会費用を要求したり、定期的な支払いを求めることが多く、時には全財産を捧げるよう求めることもあります。また、家族や友人を離れるように求めることもありますが、これは宗教とカルトの間には明確な違いがあります。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡カルト
💡宗教
💡非統正
💡時間
💡秘密主義
💡金銭
💡家族との疎外
💡指導者
💡非伝統的な信仰
💡暴力
💡対話と討論
Highlights
The video discusses the distinction between cults and religions, aiming to foster dialogue and understanding.
Religion is defined as service and worship of a deity or supernatural, with a passionate commitment to faith.
A cult is described as an unorthodox religion or a devotion to a person, idea, object, movement, or work.
The label 'cult' is subjective and reflects personal bias, making it a problematic term.
Cults often venerate a person or figurehead rather than focusing on values or principles.
Time is a factor in labeling; newer religions are more likely to be called cults due to their novelty.
Secrecy in an organization can contribute to its perception as a cult and is often associated with potential danger.
Cults may be seen as predatory if they demand money or require members to give up their possessions.
Asking members to abandon friends and family is a common trait among groups labeled as cults.
Religions may encourage surrounding oneself with good role models, but not necessarily to cut ties with loved ones.
Cults typically have a strong, charismatic leader who is central to the group's identity and beliefs.
Unusual or non-traditional beliefs are often associated with cults, differing significantly from mainstream views.
The term 'drinking the Kool-Aid' originates from the Jonestown mass suicide, illustrating several cult traits.
The video suggests using specific, non-accusatory language when expressing concerns about a potentially dangerous group.
It's important to recognize that the term 'cult' carries negative connotations and to approach discussions with sensitivity.
The video series will continue to explore various religions, some with cult-like properties and others with a longer, more reputable history.
Encouragement for viewers to engage in comments for further dialogue and debate on the topic.
Transcripts
Welcome to I Am Your Target Demographic and today we’re diving into the concept of cults.
In my earlier video outlining Scientology, debates have arisen in the comments about
cults versus religions and what the difference really is, so I thought it’d be useful to
look at what these two terms really mean and how they’re used, as well as some defining
factors in both.
This is meant to stir dialogue and debate and hopefully make sure we’re all on the same page.
If your first instinct is to head down to the comments and write “all religions are
cults” in big capital letters, I’d encourage you not to.
This is a discussion about why labeling matters, why context matters, and why every opinion is subjective.
Let’s start by looking at what defines a religion.
Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary calls religion: the service and worship of God or the supernatural,
or a commitment or devotion to religious faith or observance.
They have another definition that might come into play here that also calls religion a
cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith.
In case you need a definition of ardor, it means passion.
So by this definition, religion is typically about god, or gods plural, and the passionate
commitment to these principles.
It could also mean supernatural, in that some religions might worship things that might
be considered supernatural by others, including aliens, ghosts, and gods that might be foreign to us.
However, the second definition also allows for religion to be about a cause or a principle,
without a supreme being to worship, which is why some religions might lack the godlike
figure but instead focus on the belief system and principles instead.
Now let’s look at the definition of cult, again with the Merriam-Webster verbatim definition.
A cult is a religion regarded as unorthodox or a secondary definition says that it can
be a great devotion to a person, idea, object, movement, or work.
Let’s start by looking more closely at that first definition.
A religion regarded as unorthodox.
This definition is problematic in that it’s entirely subjective.
What I view as unorthodox might be completely normal for someone else.
And this is the problem with the label of cult, in that by calling something a cult,
you’re already showing your own internal bias.
It’s unconventional and untraditional, to you anyways.
The second definition calls a cult a devotion to a person or idea, etc.
In the definition for religion, it points to worship of a god or gods.
So things that tend to be called cults usually venerate a person instead, a figurehead at
the front of the church or organization or group instead of the values that they claim to practice.
We’re starting to transition now into the common factors that tend to go along with
something being called a cult.
Since it’s a subjective label, I’m going to try my best not to make the case for something
being a cult but I’m going to outline common factors that most "cults" in recent history have shared.
What factors play into someone making the judgment in their own head that something
is a cult, an unorthodox religion, versus a more "legitimate" religion.
The first factor to consider is time.
Religions or practices that have been around a long time have more social capital.
New religions may seem outlandish to some but it’s because it’s new.
Imagine if the story of Christ and the crucifixion happened now, today, and people were now claiming
that he came back from the dead and is now the only way to salvation.
It would likely be perceived the same way that some newer religions have been treated
but older faiths have the benefit of thousands of years of history to legitimize them.
Therefore newer religions are quicker to be labeled as cults as opposed to religions that
have been called religions for thousands of years.
Another major factor that may affect how we view cults is the aspect of secrecy.
The more secret an organization is, the more likely people view it as potentially dangerous.
What is there to hide?
Often there might be books that are not available to the public, there may be places that only
members can go, there may be secrets that only longtime members have access to.
If a group is open and transparent, it’s much harder for people to feel threatened,
though it’s not impossible.
When we say dangerous, that leads to a few more traits that groups usually classified
as cults have in common.
Firstly, it might be perceived as dangerous if it’s taking your money.
Groups that either cost major money to join, demand regular payments, or ask members to
give up all their money and material goods altogether, are often seen as predatory, assuming
that this money is going into someone else’s pockets, or the organization’s pockets.
Now, most religions rely on donations and tithes to function, but I think the clear
line here is demand.
If you have to pay for certain rights and privileges, it appears much more as a moneymaking
scam as opposed to legitimate religion.
These groups can also be perceived as dangerous if they ask you to give up family and friends
that don’t share their values.
In most groups that are commonly referred to as cults, the members must leave their
friends and family, either to relocate to a confined living space with other believers,
or the group asks that they disassociate with friends and family, even if not physically moving away.
The general thinking on this is that friends and families have the most sway over the person,
so by removing them, they’re also removing the strongest oppositional voices and leaving
the member vulnerable and entrenched.
So if you notice a friend or family member that is distancing themselves, you might want to look into it.
Now, some religions might encourage them to surround themselves with good role models
and likeminded friends, which could be different than asking them, or demanding them, to leave
their friends and families behind.
There is a major difference.
Most organizations that are usually referred to as cults have a strong leader, referring
back to our opening definition.
They idolize a person, usually a charismatic leader.
This overflowing charisma is usually the first thing to draw a new member in, before becoming overtly predatory.
Criticizing this public figure is often an offense that could remove you from the organization,
it’s that severe.
In the opening, I also talked about the "unorthodox" beliefs.
Groups referred to as cults typically have beliefs that are not traditional to most people
and vary greatly, even from other religious groups.
You might see groups that focus on aliens or space, such as groups like Heaven’s Gate
that committed suicide as a comet passed overhead.
You might see sects of Christianity that vary so greatly from other Christian beliefs that
it’s called a cult.
Some groups are extremely violent in what they want and demand, so their beliefs are
often violently opposed to the mainstream.
One of the most famous and destructive cults to look at here is Jonestown, a utopian community
in South America, where over 900 Americans moved and then committed mass suicide
(or were potentially murdered) by drinking Kool-Aid laced with cyanide.
The term “drinking the Kool-Aid” comes from this event.
It combined a few of the traits we’ve just talked about, including an unorthodox way
to live life by moving to a Utopian environment, leaving your friends and family behind, and
a strong charismatic leader.
So again, a lot of these factors can be subjective, though some are much more black and white.
Since the term “cult” carries such a heavy negative conation, it might be wise to be
specific when talking to friends or family that might be engaged in dangerous activity.
Using verbiage like “I don’t like that you’ve distanced yourself from family”
or “it doesn’t seem right that you have to pay so much money for this” might be
more effective than “You’re in a cult.”
It might draw an immediate defensive posture.
No one believes they’re in a dangerous situation until it’s too late, in most cases.
After this video, we’re going to continue doing videos every once in a while about religions,
some which might border on cult-like properties and others that have a much longer history
and probably more favorable reputation.
But if you want to check out our other religion videos so far, a few are on the screen for you.
Thank you for watching and head down to the comments for some dialogue and debate, if
you feel up to it.
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)