【快速廃止】猛反発で京葉線が見直し？利便性も運行効率も悪い？混雑緩和は？ひろゆきと考える｜アベプラ

ABEMA Prime #アベプラ【公式】

20 Jan 202419:50

Summary

TLDRJR East Japan's announcement to discontinue the Commuter Rapid and Rapid services during rush hours on the Keiyo Line, connecting Soga Station in Chiba City to Tokyo Station over 43km, sparked controversy. The decision, viewed as highly unusual and without precedent, aimed to review part of the timetable in response to intense backlash from local residents, businesses, and the Chiba municipal government, who argued the changes failed to consider future urban development. The Keiyo Line, a vital commuter artery linking Tokyo with Chiba City and hosting popular attractions like Disney Resort and Makuhari Messe, plays a crucial role in the region's economy and daily transit. The proposed discontinuation threatened to extend travel times significantly, affecting commuters and local economic activities, leading to serious security concerns including threats to public safety. Amidst this turmoil, JR East Japan reversed its decision, highlighting the critical balance between operational efficiency and community needs in urban transit planning.

Takeaways

🛣️ JR East announced the discontinuation of the Commuter Rapid and Rapid services during rush hours on the Keiyo Line, sparking controversy.
📊 After backlash from local residents, businesses, and the Chiba City government, JR East decided to review and ultimately reversed the decision to discontinue these services.
🚨 Concerns were raised about the impact on commuting times and economic activities along the line, with travel times potentially increasing from 40 to 60 minutes between Soga and Tokyo.
📖 The Keiyo Line is a critical commuter artery linking Tokyo with Chiba City and hosts popular destinations like the Disney Resort and Makuhari Messe.
🛤️ The revision of the timetable after its announcement is highly unusual, indicating strong opposition influenced JR East's decision-making.
🚧 A threatening incident involving a bomb threat to Tokyo Disneyland and DisneySea was reported, heightening security concerns and demonstrating the severity of public reaction.
📰 Local officials, including the mayor of Ichinomiya Town, strongly advocated for the importance of the rapid services in maintaining regional connectivity and population stability.
🔧 Discussions highlighted the balance between operational efficiency and user convenience, suggesting alternative solutions like premium pricing for rapid services.
💻 The debate underscored the necessity for careful planning and consultation with communities before implementing significant changes to public transportation services.
🚲 The situation illustrates the broader challenges of managing public transit in a way that supports both regional development and the operational sustainability of transportation companies.

Q & A

Why did JR East decide to eliminate some express trains on the Jōban Line?
-To help even out passenger congestion and improve convenience for stations with only local train stops.
How would eliminating express trains negatively impact areas along the Jōban Line?
-It would greatly increase travel times to Tokyo, hurting local economies and viability of living in those areas.
Why is direct access to Tokyo so important for Ichikawa's viability?
-Surveys show it's the main attractive factor drawing people to live there despite declines in surrounding areas.
How could eliminating express trains also hurt JR East's efficiency?
-Local trains are more costly to operate than express trains per passenger due to more stops and slower speeds.
What consultation with local authorities was missing prior to the initial plan announcement?
-JR East seemingly did not sufficiently consult with local governments and residents to account for the major impacts.
What are some alternatives for addressing overcrowding issues without eliminating expresses?
-Options like stopping some expresses at major intermediate stations to disperse passengers were proposed.
What financial incentives could local towns provide to maintain status quo?
-Proposals like subsidizing JR East or buying company stock to gain influence as shareholders.
How has JR East's focus changed from its origins as a railway operator?
-There is more emphasis on real estate and ancillary businesses rather than transit operations.
Why would totally eliminating express trains likely be unfeasible?
-It would excessively damage both customer convenience and operating efficiency.
What recourse do local authorities have to influence decision making?
-They have limited options, but could try increasing financial ownership stakes in JR East.

Outlines

00:00

🚆 JR East's Controversial Decision and Its Reversal

This segment discusses JR East's initial decision to discontinue the JR Keiyo Line's Commuter Rapid and Rapid services during rush hours between Tokyo and Chiba, covering a 43 km distance. This decision sparked significant controversy due to its unprecedented nature and potential impact on commuters and local economies. Facing strong backlash from local residents, businesses, and government authorities, JR East reconsidered and decided to revise this plan. The segment emphasizes the importance of the Keiyo Line, which serves key locations like Disney Resort, Marine Stadium, and Makuhari Messe. The proposed changes would have extended commute times significantly, affecting daily life and economic activities along the route. The segment also touches upon a concerning incident where threats were made to bomb Tokyo Disneyland and Tokyo DisneySea, heightening tensions and police vigilance in the region.

05:01

📉 Population Stability in Ichinomiya Town Despite National Decline

This paragraph focuses on Japan's national population decline, contrasting it with the unique case of Ichinomiya Town in Chiba Prefecture, which has maintained its population despite being a small area. The town's ability to sustain its population is attributed to its direct connectivity to Tokyo, offering fast and efficient travel, which is vital for its survival. Local residents value the town's accessibility to Tokyo, emphasizing its importance as a lifeline for the community. The loss of the Keiyo Line's rapid services poses a threat to this connectivity, impacting the wider region, including other towns in the Chiba Prefecture. The paragraph highlights the interconnectedness of transportation services and regional population trends, stressing the potential broader impacts of changes to the train service.

10:02

🚂 Balancing Efficiency and Convenience in Public Transportation

This section delves into the complexities of balancing efficiency and convenience in public transportation, specifically addressing the JR East's decision to discontinue certain rapid services on the Keiyo Line. It examines the viewpoints of local leaders and a former JR East employee, discussing the impact of this decision on towns like Ichinomiya. The discussion includes various factors like town attractiveness, population stability, and the economic implications of reduced rapid train services. The segment also addresses the operational cost differences between rapid and local services, highlighting how making all trains local could decrease efficiency and increase costs. The overall emphasis is on the need for careful consideration of local needs and efficient service management in public transport decisions.

15:04

🤝 Collaborative Approach for Sustainable Urban Development

The final segment emphasizes the importance of a collaborative approach between JR East and local authorities for sustainable urban development. It discusses the challenges faced by a former city mayor in dealing with JR West, leading to a cooperative agreement enhancing communication and benefiting both parties. The segment criticizes JR East's lack of prior consultation and coordination with local stakeholders before making significant service changes. It stresses the need for joint efforts in city planning, considering the impact on real estate values and overall urban development. The narrative suggests that incorporating local needs and feedback into transportation planning can lead to more sustainable and beneficial outcomes for all involved parties.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡JR京葉線

The JR Keiyo Line is a major commuter railway line connecting Tokyo to Chiba in Japan. It is referenced frequently in the video as the train line that JR East is proposing to change the express train schedules on, sparking backlash. The Keiyo Line is vital for many commuters and communities along its route.

💡通勤快速

Commuter express trains on the Keiyo Line that make limited stops and provide fast connections between Tokyo and Chiba. JR East proposed eliminating some of these services, angering many commuters and local governments who rely on their speed and convenience.

💡一宮町

A small coastal town in Chiba Prefecture served by the Keiyo Line. The mayor argues the express trains are critical for bringing tourists and sustaining the town's economy and population. He strongly opposes JR East's proposed changes.

💡各駅停車

Local all-stop trains that JR East proposed increasing to replace some express services. However, the longer travel times of these local trains has been criticized by commuters and communities along the line.

💡利便性

Convenience and accessibility of train services, a key concern raised by commuters and local governments opposed to the proposed changes. They argue eliminating express trains will greatly reduce convenience and connectivity.

💡混雑

Crowding and congestion on train lines and services, which JR East cited as a reason for the proposed changes. However, some doubt whether simply eliminating express trains will effectively resolve crowding issues.

💡調整

Coordination and discussions between JR East and local stakeholders before implementing schedule changes. Lack of sufficient prior consultation with commuters and communities has been sharply criticized.

💡経営効率

Business efficiency and profitability for JR East. Some argue the company prioritized its own financial interests over customers in planning the schedule changes.

💡自治体

Local municipal governments, many of which strongly objected to the proposed Keiyo Line changes, including Chiba City and Chiba Prefecture officials.

💡利用者

Rail users and commuters who rely on the Keiyo Line's express trains, and who complained the proposed changes severely impact their daily lives and connectivity.

Highlights

The video is abnormal, and we are working hard to fix it.
Please replace the link and try again.