【閲覧注意】Disneyウィッシュ：マグニフィコ王「こんな小娘のところではなく、私が必要なときに何故私のもとに現れなかった?」ノベライズ版から読み解く映画版へ削除された16のコト（後編）

Summary

This video compares the Wish novelization to the film, analyzing scenes and lines cut and their impact. It covers how Arsha urges Star to return to the sky in the novel, their additional communication, and Arsha's multiple magic failures. The queen's greater agency, Magnifico's critique of Star, and Arsha's reluctance to lose Star are depicted in more depth. Overall, the novelization provides more context for characters' actions and motivation, though changes likely served the film's focus on Disney cameos over plot issues.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video compares the novel and movie versions of Wish.
• 📚 In the novel, Asha urges Star to return to the sky multiple times.
• 🎥 The movie omits many of Asha's magical failures depicted in the novel.
• 📖 The novel provides more backstory for the Queen's knowledge and actions.
• 🔮 The novel includes a critique of Star's unchecked power.
• 🤴 Magnifico voices sharp criticism of Star in the book.
• 👸 The Queen shows more resolve in defeating the King in the novel.
• 📜 The book explains the forbidden book's fate after the climax.
• ☄️ Asha tries to stop Star from leaving at the end in the novel.
• 🎞 Overall, the changes may have weakened the movie's plot.

Q & A

What are the key differences between the novel and movie versions of Wish?

The novel provides more backstory and inner thoughts of characters like the Queen and Asha. It also shows Asha repeatedly urging Star to return to the sky, while the movie does not. Additionally, the novel includes more scenes of Asha failing at magic.

Why does the Queen refuse to free Magnifico at the end?

The novel makes it clear that the Queen has given up on Magnifico and is focused solely on protecting the kingdom now. She also realizes Magnifico is irredeemable and freeing him would only cause more harm.

What motivates Asha to stand up to Magnifico?

In the novel, Asha apologizes to the kingdom for her role in enabling Magnifico, showing remorse. She then defiantly states that no matter what Magnifico does, he cannot take away the dreams and spirit of the people.

Why does Magnifico criticize Star?

Magnifico resents that Star answered a trivial wish from Asha instead of appearing when he desperately needed magic as a child. This highlights the unfairness of Star's powers.

What happens to the Forbidden Book?

Realizing Magnifico can't be stopped, the Queen destroys the Forbidden Book with an axe, ensuring no one can access its dark magic again. This adds credibility to her giving up on the king.

How does the novel portray the Queen differently?

The novel shows the Queen has read all the books in the royal library, preparing for threats. This emphasizes her competence and independence absent in the movie.

Why does Asha cling to Star in the novel?

Asha implores Star to stay and talks of needing her for hope and self-belief. This contradicts her seeming indifference in the movie.

How might Magnifico's cut speech undermine the plot?

His speech highlights weaknesses around why Asha receives Star's powers with no sacrifice. Removing it avoids story inconsistencies.

Why cut the happy kingdom opening?

The initial joy hides sinister actions by Magnifico. Showing some darkness earlier on would have added credibility.

Could a male Star worked better?

If Star was a trickster boy initially, it may have diminished questions around why he answers Asha. The gender swap caused story problems.