The Most Controversial Enchantment In Minecraft

Summary

视频脚本深入探讨了《我的世界》中“修复”附魔的争议性。自1.9版本引入以来，修复附魔允许玩家使用经验值修复装备，这一特性因其无风险、高回报而备受玩家青睐，但也引发了关于游戏平衡的讨论。一方面，修复附魔被认为过于强大，减少了玩家探索和收集资源的动力，改变了游戏的核心机制。另一方面，它被视为提高生活质量的附魔，让玩家有更多时间进行创造性活动而非重复劳动。此外，随着游戏更新，获取修复附魔变得更加容易，这进一步加剧了争议。视频还讨论了修复附魔对钻石资源价值的负面影响，以及它如何从传奇资源变成了多人服务器中的货币。最后，作者认为尽管修复附魔存在争议，但它为游戏带来的积极变化超过了其潜在的问题。

Takeaways

• 🔍 Minecraft的beta预发布版本中，Mojang引入了附魔系统，这一更新极大地增加了游戏的复杂性，并永久性地改变了游戏。
• ⚔️ 附魔为玩家提供了一种独特的方式，使得相同的工具之间产生差异，例如锋利附魔可以增加剑和斧的伤害。
• 📚 '丝绸之触'等更复杂的附魔允许某些方块在被挖掘时直接掉落物品，而非它们的常规掉落物。
• 🎮 附魔的成功让玩家感到满意，但也导致了一些附魔比其他的更受欢迎，忠诚附魔尤其受到玩家的青睐。
• 🔥 '火矢'附魔因其双面性而备受争议，它在增加伤害的同时也给玩家带来了风险。
• 🛡️ '耐久'附魔通过添加耐久度来帮助工具更持久，但与'修复'附魔相比，它具有随机性。
• 🚫 '掠夺'附魔虽然强大，但它仅限于剑和斧，而'修复'附魔可以应用于所有工具，使其在实用性上超越了'掠夺'。
• 🔝 '修复'附魔因其无与伦比的实用性而备受争议，它允许玩家使用经验值修复装备，极大地提高了装备的耐用性。
• 💎 '修复'附魔的普及对钻石作为资源的价值产生了负面影响，因为玩家不再需要频繁地替换工具，从而减少了对钻石的需求。
• 🤔 '修复'附魔是否破坏了Minecraft的沉浸感，因为它使玩家倾向于长时间使用单一工具，减少了探索和收集资源的乐趣。
• 🧐 一些玩家认为'修复'附魔实际上让游戏更有趣，因为它允许玩家跳过他们不喜欢的游戏部分，专注于他们喜欢的内容。
• 📈 '修复'附魔的获取方式变得更加容易，这进一步强化了它在游戏中的地位，但也引发了关于它是否过于容易获得的争议。

Q & A

在Minecraft的beta预发布版本中，Mojang做出了哪个重大决策，改变了游戏的进程？

Mojang在Minecraft的beta预发布版本中引入了附魔系统，这个更新为游戏增加了复杂性，并允许玩家以独特的方式区分相同的工具。

附魔系统如何为Minecraft增加了复杂性？

附魔系统通过为工具和武器添加不同的增益效果，使得即使是相同的工具，也会因为不同的附魔而有所区别，增加了游戏的策略性和深度。

为什么说锋利（Sharpness）附魔很简单？

锋利附魔很简单，因为它直接增加了剑和斧头的伤害，每级增加半颗心的伤害，提供了直接且易于理解的增益。

丝绸之触（Silk Touch）附魔是如何工作的？

丝绸之触附魔允许玩家在挖掘某些方块时，这些方块会以它们自己的形态掉落为物品，而不是它们通常的掉落物。

修补（Mending）附魔是如何影响Minecraft玩家的游戏体验的？

修补附魔允许玩家使用经验值（XP）来修复装备，这使得装备几乎不会损坏，从而减少了玩家在资源收集和装备维护上的时间，使他们可以更专注于游戏的其他方面。

为什么修补（Mending）附魔会引起争议？

修补附魔引起争议的原因是它被认为过于强大和多功能，几乎可以应用于所有工具和武器上，减少了游戏的挑战性，并且因为它的稀有性，玩家认为它应该更难获得。

在1.9版本中，Mojang对Minecraft的战斗系统做了哪些改动？

在1.9版本中，Mojang对Minecraft的战斗系统进行了全面重做，这是一个有争议的改动，同时这个版本还增加了修补附魔。

为什么说修补附魔对钻石的价值产生了负面影响？

因为修补附魔可以让工具几乎永久使用，减少了玩家对钻石工具的需求，从而降低了钻石作为资源的珍贵性和特殊性。

在Minecraft中，有哪些因素导致了钻石资源价值的下降？

除了修补附魔外，还有其他因素如游戏机制的变化、新的资源和工具的引入等，共同导致了钻石资源价值的下降。

为什么说修补附魔是Minecraft中最具争议的附魔之一？

修补附魔因其多功能性和强大的效果而备受争议，一方面它极大地提高了游戏的便利性，另一方面它改变了游戏的探索和资源收集的核心机制，对游戏的平衡性和挑战性产生了影响。

在Minecraft中，有哪些方法可以获得修补附魔？

玩家可以通过在丛林神庙、堡垒图书馆、远古城市中找到的附魔书获得修补附魔，也可以通过钓鱼获得，或者在末地城中找到被附魔的装备。

为什么说修补附魔改变了Minecraft的游戏体验？

修补附魔允许玩家使用经验值修复装备，这意味着装备可以几乎永久使用，减少了对资源的依赖和装备的更换频率，从而允许玩家更多地专注于游戏的其他方面，如探索、建筑和战斗。

Outlines

00:00

🔍 探索Minecraft附魔系统的历史与争议

本段落回顾了Minecraft中附魔系统的引入，特别是修复附魔（Mending）的加入。Mojang的这一决策为游戏带来了深远的影响，它不仅增加了游戏的复杂性，也引发了玩家之间关于其是否破坏游戏平衡的讨论。附魔系统允许玩家通过使用经验值（XP）来修复装备，其中修复附魔因其独特性而备受争议，它没有负面效果，只需消耗一半的经验值即可修复装备。此外，还对比了火矢（Fire Aspect）、无限（Unbreaking）和抢夺（Looting）等附魔，以展示修复附魔的独特地位和它在游戏中的作用。

05:02

📈 修复附魔的争议与平衡性

修复附魔因其多功能性和强大效果而备受争议。它被认为是游戏中最好的附魔之一，因为它允许玩家使用经验值来修复工具，这减少了玩家在游戏过程中的资源收集压力，使他们能够更专注于探索和创造。然而，这也导致了一些玩家认为修复附魔减少了游戏的探索和制作乐趣，因为它使得工具几乎不会损坏。此外，修复附魔的稀有性也引发了争议，因为它原本应该只在宝藏箱或钓鱼时罕见地出现，但随着游戏更新，玩家可以通过交易更轻松地获得修复附魔，这进一步加剧了关于其是否过于强大的讨论。

10:03

💡 修复附魔对游戏玩法的影响

修复附魔被一些玩家视为生活质量的提升，因为它允许玩家减少装备的磨损，从而有更多时间进行游戏的其他活动。它并不直接影响游戏的难度，因此被认为是一个合理的游戏特性。然而，它对钻石资源的影响是显著的，因为一旦玩家拥有了修复附魔，他们就几乎不再需要钻石来制作或修复工具。这导致钻石作为资源的价值下降，减少了玩家探索洞穴寻找钻石的动力。此外，修复附魔的普及也反映了Minecraft耐久度机制的潜在问题，引发了关于游戏设计和玩家行为的深入讨论。

15:04

💎 修复附魔对钻石资源的影响

修复附魔对Minecraft中的钻石资源产生了重大影响。在修复附魔出现之前，钻石是制作高级工具和装备的关键资源。然而，随着修复附魔的引入，玩家不再需要频繁地更换工具，因此对钻石的需求大幅减少。这导致钻石的地位从珍贵的资源转变为游戏中的货币等价物，尤其是在多人服务器中。尽管修复附魔对钻石价值的下降负有部分责任，但还有其他因素也导致了钻石不再像以前那样特殊。对于长期玩家来说，看到曾经珍贵的钻石资源地位下降，可能会引起怀旧和情感上的不满。

Keywords

💡附魔

附魔是Minecraft游戏中的一个机制，允许玩家通过使用附魔台、附魔书或特定的游戏机制来增强他们的工具、武器和盔甲。在视频中，附魔是主题，因为它引入了“修复”附魔，这对游戏玩法有重大影响。例如，视频中提到了“锋利”附魔可以增加剑和斧的伤害。

💡修复附魔

修复附魔是一种特殊的附魔，允许玩家使用经验值（XP）来修复他们的装备。这个附魔在视频中被详细讨论，因为它极大地改变了游戏的耐久性机制，使某些工具几乎无法损坏。视频中提到，修复附魔是一个有争议的话题，一些玩家认为它使游戏变得更好，而另一些玩家则认为它破坏了游戏的某些方面。

💡经验值（XP）

在Minecraft中，经验值是一种资源，玩家可以通过击败怪物、制作某些物品或完成特定的游戏活动来获得。视频中提到，修复附魔使用XP来修复装备，这改变了玩家获取和使用XP的方式，因为它不再仅仅是用于附魔或升级。

💡耐久性

耐久性是指Minecraft中工具、武器和盔甲可以使用的次数，使用越多，耐久性越低，直至损坏。修复附魔直接与耐久性机制相关，因为它允许玩家通过消耗XP来恢复物品的耐久性。视频中讨论了耐久性机制如何影响玩家的游戏体验，以及修复附魔如何改变这一机制。

💡争议

视频中提到修复附魔是Minecraft中最具争议的附魔之一。争议的焦点在于修复附魔的多功能性和强大效果，一些玩家认为它过于强大，影响了游戏的平衡，而另一些玩家则认为它提高了游戏的可玩性和便利性。

💡宝藏附魔

宝藏附魔是Minecraft中一种特殊的附魔类型，不能通过普通的附魔台获得，只能通过特定的游戏机制如钓鱼、探索特定的结构或从商人处购买获得。修复附魔就是一种宝藏附魔，这增加了获取它的难度和价值。

💡村民交易

村民交易是Minecraft中的一个系统，玩家可以通过与村民互动并提供他们需要的商品来换取物品或附魔书。在视频中，提到了村民交易是获取修复附魔的一种方式，而且随着游戏更新，这种获取方式变得更加容易，这也成为围绕修复附魔争议的一部分。

💡钻石

钻石是Minecraft中的一种珍贵资源，用于制作高级工具和装备。视频中讨论了修复附魔对钻石价值的影响，因为一旦玩家有了修复附魔，他们就不再需要频繁地替换工具，这减少了对钻石的需求。

💡探险

探险是Minecraft游戏的一个重要组成部分，玩家通过探索新地形和结构来发现资源和宝藏。然而，视频中提到，由于修复附魔的存在，玩家可能会减少探险的动机，因为他们不需要频繁地寻找资源来替换损坏的工具。

💡游戏平衡

游戏平衡是指游戏中各种机制和元素之间的相互作用，以确保公平和有趣的游戏体验。修复附魔的争议部分源于玩家对它可能破坏游戏平衡的担忧，因为它提供了一种避免耐久性损失的方法，这可能会减少游戏的挑战性。

💡玩家体验

玩家体验是指玩家与游戏互动时的感受和满意度。视频中讨论了修复附魔如何改变玩家体验，一些玩家认为它提高了生活质量，使他们能够更自由地进行游戏，而另一些玩家则认为它减少了游戏的某些核心乐趣，如探险和资源收集。

Highlights

Minecraft的beta预发布版中，Mojang做出了一个将永远改变游戏的决定，引入了附魔系统，为中国的游戏体验增加了健康的复杂性。

附魔是区分相同工具的独特方式，例如锋利附魔可以增加剑和斧头的伤害。

丝绸之触附魔可以使某些方块在被挖掘时掉落自身而非通常的掉落物。

附魔的成功使玩家感到满意，但也带来了一些比其他更好的附魔。

忠诚附魔是作者个人最喜欢的附魔。

1.9版本中加入了修复整个战斗系统的更新，同时引入了修复附魔。

修复附魔允许使用经验值修复装备，是游戏中无与伦比的附魔。

与火矢、耐久和抢夺附魔相比，修复附魔没有缺点，只有奖励。

耐久附魔是修复附魔的表亲，通过添加耐久度来帮助工具，但带有随机性。

抢夺附魔是一个强大的附魔，可以增加重要物品的掉落率，但仅限于剑和斧头。

修复附魔因其多功能性和略微的过度强大而备受争议。

修复附魔的争议点在于它太好用了，几乎可以应用于所有装备。

Mojang意识到修复附魔的强大，将其与无限附魔设为互斥。

修复附魔的稀有性本应限制这一强大特性，仅在中后期游戏中获得。

1.14版本改进了村民交易，使玩家更容易获得修复附魔，进一步强化了反修复观点。

修复附魔是一个生活质量附魔，它并没有让玩家在PvE或PvP中变得更强。

修复附魔对Minecraft游戏玩法的影响是一个有争议的话题，有人认为它解决了耐久性机制的潜在问题。

修复附魔对钻石作为资源的价值产生了巨大的负面影响，减少了玩家开采钻石的需求。

资深玩家对修复附魔的看法分歧，一些人认为它破坏了Minecraft的探索元素。

作者认为修复附魔是一个好的添加，尽管它有争议，但好处大于坏处。

Transcripts

in the beta pre-release of Minecraft

moyang will make a decision that would

change the game forever

this was the update that introduced

enchantments to the game and China's

added a healthy layer of complexity to

the game they were a unique way of

differentiating two of the same tools

from each other there were simpler ones

like the sharpness enchantment for

swords and axes which makes your swords

and axes sharper increasing their damage

by half a heart per level and that's it

then there was slightly more complex

ones such as silk touch causing some

blocks to drop themselves as items

rather than their usual drops when mined

bookshelves glass and the chest ice and

beehives for example however this came

at the cost of making your tool mutually

exclusively Fortune to avoid experts I

assume needless to say the addition of

enchantments was an absolute success and

players were happy but when there's

variety there's bound to be some that

are better than others much like I've

said in my video about Minecraft Foods

having plenty of options is like having

kids you will always pick favorites

you're more likely to prefer Smite and

sharpness for your sword unless you had

Arachnophobia try the enchantments are

cool but I prefer loyalty above all else

while some enchantments Rose to

popularity because they were simply

better than others there was one

enchantment that Rose to the top for

Infamous controversial reasons before

swiftening in 1.19 before Soul speed in

1.16 before every Trident enchantment in

1.13 Our Story begins in 1.9

it reworked the entire combat system a

controversial change that requires a

video of its own but more importantly

this was the update that added mending

to the game moyang may not have known at

the time but they've created a monster

that would play their game for many

years to come welcome to episode 1 of

Minecraft's most controversials for this

episode we will be talking about mending

an enchantment then either ruined the

game or made it better depending on who

you ask

before we go into the goods and bads of

mending to explore why it became such a

controversial enchantment here's a quick

Refresh on what it is and what it does

mending is a treasure enchantment

meaning it is unobtainable from

enchantment tables you could only obtain

them as books from jungle temples

stronghold libraries ancient cities as

well as a rare drop from fishing they

could also be obtained as tools

enchanted with mending from end cities

in the simplest terms mending allows you

to use XP in order to repair your

equipment the more XP you get the more

durability gets restored now if all of

this sounds really freaking good that's

because it is on a chair list of

enchantments no enchantments in the game

would even come close to the level of

mending and to understand why let's

compare mending to three other unique

enchantments fire aspect Unbreaking and

looting I picked these three as examples

for specific reasons a comparison

against each of them would highlight the

three main reasons why mending is quite

literally in a league of its own

let's start with fire aspect fire aspect

is one of my personal quality checks for

enchantments because it stands out as an

enchantment for the wrong reasons

enchanting your sword with fire aspect

turns it into a double-edged sword

it is one of the OG enchantments added

in beta pre-release and has remained

unchanged throughout all of Minecraft

history fire aspect made any sort of ax

ignite their targets on fire dealing an

extra three to seven hearts of fire

damage on top of your usual attacks

serving you cooked meat the way you

prefer it medium rare and below for the

caveman medium well for the refined and

well done for the covet patients because

they're tasteless in Bedrock fire aspect

can also be used to light up candles

campfires and TNTs

this even works with Enchantment books

but when I say enchanting fire aspect

makes things a double-edged sword I mean

it unless you have fire resistance fire

aspect makes your enemies take three to

seven hearts of damage extra but it also

makes them do three to seven extra to

you mending doesn't have any downsides

unlike fire aspect mending is all reward

with no risk there is a little trade-off

in it half of your XP is used for

repairs but it is a tremendously less

dangerous risk compared to being

barbecued alive what's more important is

that XP usually isn't a problem for the

Casual player and even less of a problem

for psychopaths like me who kill

everything they see therefore mending in

general is better because you don't have

to worry about any significant risk or

downsides to having it on something

however it isn't the only enchantment in

the durability side of things which

brings us to Unbreaking mending's much

older cousin that's been in this world

for much longer than mending has but

eventually grew apart from when they

started sharing conspiracy theories on

WhatsApp

sorry was that too specific basically

Unbreaking also helps if the durability

of equipment it turns shares from a

fragile tool that breaks when you use it

on anything harder than a marshmallow

into a slightly less fragile tool that

breaks on anything harder than four

marshmallows instead of a guaranteed

repair on XP like mending Unbreaking as

RNG into the mix on average each level

of Unbreaking adds an extra 100 to 300

of a Tool's durability doubling to

quadrupling its use this meant that

Unbreaking was only better than mending

in tools that are super fragile and

commonly don't receive XP in their uses

like flint and steel shears yeah that's

about it bending is a godsend for

unlucky people because it was a

guaranteed fix with no random chance

making it better than Unbreaking in

almost every way and a much better

enchantment overall this leads us to a

final comparison looting looting is also

a super strong enchantment so strong in

fact that enchantment XP calls are

noticeably higher whenever it is

involved it helps you with super

important drops such as ender pearls

blaze rods

[Music]

Trident and wither skeletons cars

nothing is more frustrating than

fighting mods for hours on end only to

not get the resources you need because

RNG hates you Looting increases the

maximum for common drops by one per

level a zombie will drop zero to Two

Rotten flash but with a Looting 3 sword

that drops 0-5 with equipment and other

red drops increasing by one percent per

level tldr looting strong looting good

bugabuga Muse looting me get more food

me happy but despite all of this looting

will never be on the same level as

mending because unlike mending looting

is exclusive to swords and axes mending

will always be above strong enchantments

such as looting and Fortune because just

like Unbreaking mending could be applied

to everything it's like having a battle

between a super strong sniper rifle that

is super accurate but it can only shoot

scarecrows versus a nuke that's also

like super accurate

not the best analogy but you get the

point so mending is really good Soko in

fact that is arguably the best

enchantment but why is it controversial

but these comparisons combine into the

first controversial point of mending

it's controversial because it's arguably

the best enchantment did you get a

diamond sword might also throw mending

on it and let the XP from mobs make it

unbreakable did you just upgrade to a

netherite pickaxe remember to put

mending on it you wouldn't want to find

4 engine debris again now would you

wow you just got a full set of netherite

armor it will break and crumble to dust

leaving you completely vulnerable to

attacks from racism terrorism sexism

ableism and islamophobia

but there's an easy solution for this

mending a point of controversy is that

mending is so good you kind of just put

it in everything they're like Neapolitan

ice cream there's something for everyone

vanilla for the boring chocolate for

those with low standards and strawberry

for those who pretend to like it mending

has never really been a choice as to

which equipment you should enchant it

with with an enchantment this

overpowered is more of which enchantment

do and mending to First and which later

you simply can never have enough of it

there's no such thing as too many

mending books it's simply so good that

you just can't ignore it to give you a

sense as to how broken mending is in

1.11 two updates after the addition of

mending moyang will make infinity and

mending mutually exclusive on both

that's right moyang quickly discovered

that giving players an infinite

durability infinite Aero ball was

bad it won't even surprise me if mending

could be used to fix things other than

your equipment 6 out of 9 marriage

counselors recommend mending to fix your

broken marriage the other three play

Terraria in summary controversial 0.1

was that mending is too versatile and

most slightly overpowered players

unanimously agree that it is one of the

best enchantments with people calling it

indispensable the most valuable as well

as the best and most vital enchantment

in the game some players felt that

mendic broke the immersion of Minecraft

it made them attached to a single tool

for them making tools using them to get

resources until they break and then

replacing those tools with set resources

was part of the fun banding discouraged

exploration and collecting resources

required to make the equipment mending

ironically made Minecraft less Mining

and less crafting which makes sense if I

had a pickaxe and I would do enchanted

with mending this pickaxe will most

likely last me throughout my entire

survival world and I will do my absolute

hardest to make sure it never goes below

one durability so I can repair it later

the game simply had to be centered

around mending or be affected by it but

some would argue that mending actually

made the game more fun to play rather

than turning Minecraft into a Korean

MMORPG where you'll be spending more

time grinding than actually playing the

game it made Minecraft the sandbox that

it is with mending on your tools you had

the time and freedom to do whatever you

wanted in a ends mending allows you to

escape the parts of the game you have to

do and let you do the parts of the game

you want to do mending is an essential

quality of life enchantment for mid to

late gameplay that they find how the

player approach projects and builds

which also makes sense if I hate strip

mining for diamonds which I do mending

allowed me to skip getting the resources

needed to get the equipment and allow me

to do whatever I want and that spending

my time raiding and conquering Villages

have I ever mentioned how much I love

tormenting villagers in my videos yet I

like enslaving their entire populations

for cheap labor while I melt the iron

color protectors into iron ingots which

I sell back to the villagers at the meat

of tax evasion

while we're on the topic of villagers

these arguments of both sides will be

incomplete without the second point of

controversy mending charity it's

arguably the best enchantment so surely

it has the Rarity to limit such a broken

feature to only mid and late game it

will only be found in the likes of

treasure chests and rare fishing drops

since mending is a treasure enchantment

our release is supposed to be what the

hell is it doing in the hands of

librarians don't they know I'm busy

spoiling myself

who would win a Superman and China book

only found an ancient historical

structures containing magical text that

makes your tools unbreakable and

infinite or Squidwards a point of

controversy is that many could also be

obtained through villager trading before

1.14 Librarians existed but their traits

were locked so you basically hoped that

they had that chantment you wanted in

other words your best bet was trapping

two villages in the breeder and having

the Freak Out smart librarian babies

eventually one of them will give you

mending while the other Librarians study

history or some other failing degree I

don't know so mending's power is kind of

kept in check with his Rarity the easy

way to obtain them was still extremely

Troublesome which is why for some

players it is a point of worry that

recent updates have made it easier and

easier to obtain 1.14 reworked villager

trading by cycling workstations with a

lectern you will eventually get a

librarian that will give you mending for

a cheap price this further reinforce the

anti-mending Viewpoint with a viable

renewable method of obtaining mending

you were discouraged from exploring the

world for resources mending was so good

there was practically no reason not to

form for it when it was this easy he

could just kidnap a few villagers stay

in your base forever and never have any

incentive to explore the outside world

again unless you want to which leads us

on to the third point of controversy

is mending a problem or is it a fix

to code the user's sorry Sable which I

hope I pronounce right mending is a

quality of life enchant it doesn't make

you any stronger in PVE or PVP it

doesn't have any effect on the actual

difficulty of the game all it

realistically does is mean you spend

less time grinding out gear personally I

remember the days before mending existed

I am quite happy to not be spending as

much of my Minecraft time grinding out

yet another Fortune pick as we did then

as a purely quality of life and shine

with no real impact on difficulty it

should be relatively easy to acquire and

works just fine as it is this highlights

the third point is mending a problem

that greatly affected Minecraft's

gameplay or is it a soft fix for an

underlying problem one could always

argue that the root cause is the

durability mechanic of Minecraft and

that removing mending will be ignoring

the main underlying issue durability

turns the game into an endless crime

forcing you into a cycle of obtaining

resources for your tools using the tools

then obtaining resources to replace set

tools is it the fault of mending that

players have flocked to it to avoid

durability issues or is it the fault of

the durability mechanic itself that

drove players to mending for comparison

let's take breath of the wild it's a

very Niche game you may have heard about

it but it's made by a very small Indie

company in this game every one of your

weapons has limited durability and will

break no matter what you do in fact this

game has a much harsher durability

system there are no repairs or

enchantments to help however that's the

master sword the completely unbreakable

weapon but it requires some time to

regain its durability after use I'm sure

you can draw a bit of a parallel between

the master sword and mending there's the

argument that breath of the Wild's

durability system and courageous players

to explore and find new weapons to

replace the old ones that will break but

there's also the argument that the

durability is so [ __ ] terrible that

once players obtain the master sword

they begin to use it for literally

everything and save their other weapons

for when they actually needed them is

the master sword too strong and too good

or does it highlight an underlying issue

with the game's durability system maybe

if things didn't break so easily like a

condom people wouldn't have to use

something that's literally unbreakable

maybe if you the viewer didn't enjoy

this video so much you wouldn't have had

to smash the like button if the

durability system of Minecraft wasn't so

flawed would players still be using

mending as much as they do today it's a

fair question with no right answer to it

but there is a perfect example for this

and I want a show of hands has anyone

actually used Phantom membranes to

repair your elytros or maybe explore

other NCD ship just to replace the

elytra we have

most likely you use mending with maybe

one or two Phantom membrane repairs case

in point because durability is a [ __ ]

mending was probably the cure to an

issue that unfortunately had side

effects of their own this leads us to

the final point of controversy

controversial 0.4 is about the massive

negative impact mending has had on

diamonds as a resource there are

multiple factors that contributed to

Diamonds losing their specialty I've

mentioned plenty of them in my video

about why diamonds aren't special

anymore but the major factor that I

forgot to mention was The Mending

enchantment unlike iron where if you

Enchanted your iron 2 super mending you

still needed it for other recipes such

as Hoppers pistons and anvils or gold

which

wait why the hell are you even

enchanting your go-to's commanding point

being iron and gold had other recipes

that mending could never touch mending

didn't apply enchantments on your tools

and wheels did mending can't receive XP

and heal you as a player golden apples

and golden carrots do unfortunately

diamonds weren't as lucky we used

diamonds for diamond tools and

enchantment tables when mending was

introduced it removed any real reason

you had to get diamonds from caves since

any tour of mending is almost guaranteed

to last forever a mending Enchanted

helmet is a permanent 5 diamonds you

will never need and if you had a full

set of many tools you no longer need

diamonds at all you don't need diamonds

to replace your tools because you can't

replace something that is irreplaceable

players felt like they never needed to

go mine for diamonds anymore once they

had mending which once again further

solidified the arguments on both sides

less exploration diamonds that are

special and time ending more time for

other things diamonds are means to do

those other things pro mending this also

explains why mending is the most

controversial amongst veteran players

myself included as long as I meant what

as long time fans of Minecraft playing

truth of pre-minding and post-mending

errors having experienced both sides is

what makes a lot of us feel strongly

about the enchantment with watch mending

make diamonds fall from an absolutely

legendary resource in its prime into a

useless resource acting as currency in

multiplayer servers today Nostalgia

plays a part and I suppose for some long

time players seeing something they used

to look up to a very high status be

reduced to money for capitalistic

Society you can kind of see why some

people feel so strongly for or against

mending it's kinda sad but

understandable

but hey that's just what players

generally think about mending after

hearing these points what are your

thoughts do you like them or do you

think Minecraft would have been better

off without them do you think Mojang

should Nerf them or leave their messes

Pro mending or anti-mending I personally

think that mending was a good addition

now don't get me wrong all the reasons

listed so far are fair concerns about

mending being a controversial feature

but I see mending as something where the

good outweigh the bad I'm someone who

really enjoys having projects to do I

like having Automatic Farms and I like

having a little bit of a story in my

survival worlds but I definitely do see

what they mean when they say mending

took away the explorative aspects of

Minecraft I think go outside and touch

grass that often when I discovered how

easy mending was to obtain for every

survival world I created I found myself

simply trading with villagers stonking

my way to get the diamond gear needed

for the projects I wanted to do to me

many was an enchantment fix Minecraft by

ironically breaking the game and there

is no bigger evidence for this than the

undeniably negative impact they've had

on diamonds as a resource but it's

important to note that mending isn't

alone on this I've mentioned that there

were plenty of other factors that led to

Diamonds downfall mending is just one of

the many reasons as to why diamonds

eventually stop being special which is

why you should check out this video

where I cover everything else that

contributed to making diamonds less

special than it used to be that will

give you the full story of what happened

to diamonds that made them lose their

value in the game today I'll see you

there

foreign