What is the South China Sea dispute?

TRT World

19 Aug 202404:44

Summary

TLDRThe South China Sea is a flashpoint for territorial disputes, with multiple nations vying for control over its rich resources and shipping lanes. China's expansive claims, backed by historical maps, conflict with those of Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Brunei. The 2016 PCA ruling rejected China's claims under international law. Recent incidents have heightened fears of a regional conflict, potentially involving the US, due to defense treaties and military presence in the area.

Takeaways

🌍 The South China Sea is one of the most disputed regions in the world, with multiple countries competing for control.
⚔️ There is a risk of a regional war or even a global conflict involving powers like China and the US due to tensions in the area.
🚢 The South China Sea is crucial for global trade, with more than 20% of trade (around $3.3 trillion) passing through its waters annually.
🛢️ It is believed to hold vast natural resources, including around 11 billion barrels of oil and 90 trillion cubic feet of natural gas.
🏝️ The Paracel and Spratly Islands are central to the dispute, as they are believed to be surrounded by potential reserves of natural resources.
📜 China claims around 90% of the South China Sea, basing its claims on a 1947 map drawn by pre-communist China.
⚖️ In 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled that China's claims have no legal basis under international law.
🚨 There have been multiple confrontations, the latest being a clash between China and the Philippines in August, leading to diplomatic protests.
🤝 The US has a mutual defense treaty with the Philippines and could be drawn into the conflict if tensions escalate.
🛡️ China has vowed to defend its territorial interests by any means necessary and has multiple outposts in the disputed islands.

Q & A

Why is the South China Sea considered one of the most disputed regions in the world?
-The South China Sea is highly disputed because multiple countries, including China, Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Brunei, claim parts of its waters, leading to intense territorial competition for control over its strategic resources and trade routes.
What could potentially trigger a regional war in the South China Sea?
-A regional war could be triggered by a miscalculated attack or a clash between the involved countries, particularly if tensions between global powers like China and the US escalate.
What is the significance of the South China Sea for global trade?
-The South China Sea is crucial for global trade, with over 20% of the world's trade passing through its waters annually, amounting to approximately $3.3 trillion.
What natural resources are believed to be found in the South China Sea?
-The South China Sea is thought to contain around 11 billion barrels of oil, 90 trillion cubic feet of natural gas, and 10% of the world's fisheries, making it a highly sought-after region for natural resources.
What are the Paracel and Spratly Islands, and why are they important?
-The Paracel and Spratly Islands are at the heart of the South China Sea dispute because they are believed to be surrounded by significant reserves of natural resources, including petroleum. The US Geological Survey estimates that the Spratly Islands may hold between 0.9 to 3 billion barrels of petroleum.
Why does China claim around 90% of the South China Sea?
-China bases its claim on a map drawn by pre-communist China in 1947, which originally had 11 dashes indicating Chinese territory. After the Communist Party took over in 1949, the map was revised to exclude two dashes in the Gulf of Tonkin, giving territory to Vietnam.
What was the 2016 ruling by the Permanent Court of Arbitration regarding China’s claims?
-In 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled against China's claims in the South China Sea, stating that Beijing's territorial claims have no legal basis under international law.
How has the US become involved in the South China Sea conflict?
-The US is involved through its Mutual Defense Treaty with the Philippines, which could oblige the US to defend the Philippines in a conflict. Additionally, the US has a military presence in the region and conducts joint military exercises with its allies, such as the Philippines, Australia, and Canada.
What measures has China taken to assert its claims in the South China Sea?
-China has established 20 outposts in the Paracel Islands and 7 in the Spratly Islands. It has also conducted military exercises in the area and vowed to protect its territorial interests by any means necessary.
What does the United Nations say about the South China Sea territorial waters?
-According to the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), states can control the waters within 370 km (or 200 nautical miles) of their shores, known as Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZs). UNCLOS also grants ships the right of innocent passage through other states' territorial waters.

Outlines

00:00

🌊 The Disputed South China Sea and the Potential for Conflict

The South China Sea is one of the most contested regions globally, with multiple nations competing for control of its waters for centuries. A small conflict or miscalculated attack could escalate into a regional or even global war, potentially involving superpowers like the US and China. This body of water is more than just a sea—it is a critical international shipping route, responsible for over 20% of global trade (valued at around $3.3 trillion annually) and is believed to hold vast reserves of oil, gas, and fisheries. Central to the dispute are the Paracel and Spratly Islands, rich in resources and claimed by several nations, including China, Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Brunei.

🗺️ China’s Claims and International Rejection

China asserts control over 90% of the South China Sea, relying on a historical map from 1947. After the Communist Party took power in 1949, this map was modified but continued to serve as a basis for China's territorial claims. Despite this, a 2016 ruling by the Permanent Court of Arbitration, brought by the Philippines, invalidated China’s claims under international law. The ruling has done little to ease tensions, as several confrontations have occurred over the years, dating back to the 1970s. In 1974, a deadly clash between China and Vietnam led to China seizing the Paracels.

⚔️ Recent Clashes Between China and the Philippines

More recently, tensions between China and the Philippines have escalated. In August, a diplomatic protest was lodged by the Philippines after Chinese and Filipino forces accused each other of disrupting military operations. This followed a June confrontation where Filipino forces accused the Chinese coast guard of piracy. Despite these accusations, China defended its actions, labeling its forces as professional and restrained. Such incidents continue to fuel concerns that the US, a close ally of the Philippines, could be drawn into a direct conflict with China.

🇺🇸 The United States’ Involvement and Defense Treaties

The United States has a mutual defense treaty with the Philippines, dating back to World War II, which could compel it to defend the Philippines in case of conflict. In 2023, the US bolstered its support for the Philippines, announcing a $500 million defense fund and gaining access to four new military bases in the country. These efforts were accompanied by joint military drills involving the US, the Philippines, Australia, and Canada in the South China Sea, amidst China’s own military exercises. The US also maintains military ties in the region with countries like Taiwan and Brunei.

⚖️ The United Nations and Maritime Law in the South China Sea

According to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) established in 1982, nations have the right to control waters within 370 km of their shores, known as exclusive economic zones (EEZs). This allows states to regulate trade and resource extraction within these zones, while military and civilian vessels have the right to pass through other nations' territorial waters under 'innocent passage.' With rising tensions between regional powers and ongoing competition between the US and China, the question remains whether these disputes will escalate into a larger geopolitical conflict.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡South China Sea

The South China Sea is a strategically important body of water in Southeast Asia, heavily disputed due to overlapping territorial claims from various countries. It plays a central role in the video as a region where tensions are escalating, with concerns over natural resources and major shipping lanes. The sea is also a geopolitical hotspot where the interests of global powers like China and the US collide.

💡Territorial Disputes

Territorial disputes refer to conflicts between countries over the ownership of land or sea areas. In the South China Sea, several countries, including China, Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Brunei, have competing claims. These disputes are central to the video’s narrative as they fuel tensions and have led to past and present confrontations in the region.

💡Paracel and Spratly Islands

The Paracel and Spratly Islands are two major island groups in the South China Sea that are rich in natural resources and subject to intense territorial disputes. China, Vietnam, and the Philippines, among others, claim these islands. The video highlights their strategic importance due to potential oil and gas reserves, making them a focal point of conflict.

💡Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ)

Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ) are areas of the sea where a state has special rights to explore and use marine resources. Under international law, countries can claim EEZs up to 370 km from their shores. The video refers to this concept in explaining how various countries in the South China Sea assert rights over resources like oil and fisheries, intensifying territorial claims.

💡China's Nine-Dash Line

The Nine-Dash Line is China’s demarcation line claiming approximately 90% of the South China Sea, based on historical maps. This line is at the heart of the disputes, as it overlaps with the EEZs of several other countries. The video discusses how China uses this line to justify its claims, which have been contested in international courts.

💡Permanent Court of Arbitration

The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) is an international tribunal that resolves disputes between states. In 2016, the PCA ruled that China’s claims to most of the South China Sea, based on the Nine-Dash Line, had no legal basis. The video highlights this ruling as a key point in the legal aspect of the South China Sea disputes, though China has rejected the court’s decision.

💡Mutual Defense Treaty

A mutual defense treaty is an agreement between countries to defend each other in case of an attack. The video mentions the mutual defense treaty between the Philippines and the US, which could potentially draw the US into a conflict with China if the Philippines is attacked in the South China Sea. This agreement underlines the geopolitical stakes in the region.

💡$3.3 Trillion in Trade

This figure refers to the immense value of trade that passes through the South China Sea annually. More than 20% of global trade, amounting to $3.3 trillion, flows through these waters, making the region economically crucial. The video uses this fact to emphasize why control over the South China Sea is so hotly contested, as it holds strategic importance for global trade routes.

💡Natural Resources

The South China Sea is believed to contain significant natural resources, including 11 billion barrels of oil and 90 trillion cubic feet of natural gas, as well as vital fisheries. These resources are key drivers of the territorial disputes, as countries vie for control over potential energy reserves and fishing grounds, as discussed in the video.

💡Geopolitical Conflict

Geopolitical conflict refers to political and military tensions between countries, often involving competing national interests. The video discusses the risk of a wider geopolitical conflict in the South China Sea, potentially involving major powers like the US and China. The region's importance to global trade, natural resources, and military strategy creates the conditions for such conflicts.

Highlights

The South China Sea is one of the most disputed regions in the world, with multiple countries competing for control of its territorial waters.

The region is of immense strategic importance, with more than 20% of global trade passing through its waters, amounting to approximately $3.3 trillion annually.

The South China Sea is believed to hold around 11 billion barrels of oil, 90 trillion cubic feet of natural gas, and around 10% of the globe's fisheries.

At the heart of the territorial disputes are the Paracel and Spratly Islands, which are believed to be surrounded by potential reserves of natural resources.

China claims around 90% of the South China Sea, antagonizing bordering countries such as Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Brunei.

China's territorial claims are based on a 1947 map drawn by pre-communist China, which included 11 dashes indicating Chinese territory, later reduced to 9 dashes by the Communist Party.

In 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled that China's claims have no legal basis under international law, following a case brought by the Philippines.

The South China Sea has witnessed several confrontations dating back to the 1970s, including the 1974 incident where 74 Vietnamese sailors were killed during China's seizure of the Paracels.

In recent years, tensions between China and the Philippines have escalated, with incidents occurring as recently as August 2023.

The Philippines and China have been engaged in a series of military confrontations, sparking diplomatic protests from Manila.

The US has a mutual defense treaty with the Philippines, potentially drawing Washington into a conflict in the region if tensions escalate.

In July 2023, the US announced a $500 million defense fund for the Philippines, followed by joint sea and air drills with Australia, Canada, and the Philippines in August.

China has vowed to protect its territorial interests in the South China Sea by any means necessary and maintains 20 outposts in the Paracel Islands and 7 in the Spratly Islands.

According to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982), states can control the waters within 370 kilometers of their shores, called exclusive economic zones (EEZs).

There are growing fears that tensions between China and US allies in the region could lead to a broader geopolitical conflict.