【UG# 464】2022/11/20 金ロー『すずめの戸締まり』予習解説

岡田斗司夫

5 Apr 202415:18

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses the film 'Suzume no Tojimari' directed by Makoto Shinkai, known for his previous works like 'Your Name'. The reviewer, Okada Toshiyoshi, compares Shinkai's evolution as a filmmaker to major directors like George Lucas and Steven Spielberg, suggesting that while his mainstream success has somewhat diluted his unique artistic voice, it has allowed him to create grander works. The script touches on the film's themes, storytelling, and its appeal to a wide audience, including those who don't often watch movies. It critiques the film's lack of realism and depth, particularly in the protagonist's unrealistic stamina. However, it acknowledges the film's beautiful visuals and music, and its potential to be a hit with the general Japanese audience. The video also includes a discussion on the film's reception and its role as a national film for Japan, suggesting it might be a comforting narrative in the context of the 3.11 earthquake. The script ends with a mention of a paid membership for further content.

Takeaways

🎥 The script discusses the film 'Eizō Suzume no Tōdome' directed by Makoto Shinkai.
🌟 It mentions that Shinkai is known for his unique artistic vision, comparing him to filmmakers like George Lucas and Steven Spielberg.
📊 The reviewer rates the film similarly to 'Your Name' with a score of 88 points, suggesting it's a must-watch for most people.
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 The film is described as enjoyable for the whole family and particularly appealing to those who are not resistant to anime.
🎬 The story revolves around a girl traveling across Japan to seal away supernatural creatures, which is likened to a 'monster extermination' narrative.
🏞️ The film features beautiful scenery and a series of events that keep the audience engaged without getting bored.
💪 The main character, Suzume, is portrayed as having an unrealistic amount of stamina, which the reviewer finds hard to believe.
🎶 The use of Radwimps' music is mentioned as a way to evoke emotion, but the reviewer feels it lessens the impact of the story's reality.
🤔 The script suggests that the film lacks depth and philosophical substance, with a focus on strong themes and spectacle over realism.
🔄 The reviewer believes that Shinkai has successfully transformed himself into a 'national' filmmaker, but at the cost of some of his unique artistic edge.
🔄 The film is viewed as a reflection of 21st-century entertainment, with a gender-swapped approach to traditional storytelling elements.

Q & A

What is the main theme of the video script discussing?
-The main theme of the video script is the analysis and review of the movie 'Suzume no Tojimari' (Weathering with You) directed by Makoto Shinkai.
Who is the director of the movie being discussed in the script?
-The director of the movie being discussed is Makoto Shinkai.
What is the script's perspective on the movie's appeal to a general audience?
-The script suggests that the movie is very appealing to a general audience, especially those who do not watch many movies a year, and would enjoy a film that is entertaining, moving, and suitable for family viewing.
What is the script's view on the movie's setting and storyline?
-The script describes the storyline as a mix of 'cow and tiger' elements, suggesting a blend of mundane and fantastical aspects. It involves a girl traveling across Japan, dealing with supernatural creatures, and developing relationships.
What does the script say about the movie's music?
-The script mentions that the music in the movie is excellent and plays a significant role in the emotional impact of the film.
How does the script evaluate the movie's realism?
-The script criticizes the movie for lacking realism, particularly in the portrayal of the main character's limitless physical strength and the unrealistic depiction of certain scenes.
What is the script's opinion on the director's transformation into a mainstream filmmaker?
-The script suggests that Makoto Shinkai's transformation into a mainstream filmmaker has been a success, but it also implies that this transformation may have come at the cost of some of his unique artistic vision.
What does the script imply about the target audience for the movie?
-The script implies that the movie is well-suited for a wide Japanese audience and those who do not have a resistance to animation, comparing its appeal to that of 'Kimi no Na wa' (Your Name).
What is the script's stance on the movie's handling of the theme of sacrifice?
-The script criticizes the movie for having a happy ending without any real sacrifices, suggesting that this approach lacks depth and thought-provoking elements.
How does the script relate the movie to the broader context of Japanese cinema?
-The script positions the movie within the context of Japanese cinema by comparing it to other works and discussing its place as a film that can be enjoyed by the general Japanese public.
What is the script's final evaluation of the movie?
-The script gives the movie a score of 88 points, indicating that while it has its flaws, particularly in terms of realism and depth, it is still a movie that can be enjoyed by a wide audience.

Outlines

00:00

🎬 Director Makoto Shinkai's Latest Work: 'The Garden of Words'

This paragraph introduces the video script, which is a review of Makoto Shinkai's 2020 film 'The Garden of Words'. The speaker, Okada Toshiyoshi, expresses anticipation for Shinkai's new work, comparing him to renowned directors like George Lucas and Steven Spielberg. The speaker also discusses the appeal of the film to a broad audience, including those who rarely watch movies, and highlights the film's potential to be a hit with its blend of storytelling, emotional impact, and family-friendly entertainment. The video is described as a detailed discussion of the film, with minimal spoilers, and is a rebroadcast of the 464th episode originally released on November 20, 2020.

05:01

🤔 A Critical Look at 'The Garden of Words': Realism and Emotional Depth

The speaker delves into a critical analysis of 'The Garden of Words', discussing the film's narrative and its departure from reality. They compare the story to a 'bull and tiger' approach, suggesting it's a straightforward tale of a girl traveling across Japan to seal doors and battling a powerful fox demon. The speaker finds the film's theme strong but its philosophical depth lacking, attributing this to Shinkai's transformation into a mainstream director. They critique the unrealistic portrayal of the protagonist's stamina and the film's tendency to avoid difficult themes, such as the pain and sacrifice inherent in the story of a character becoming a 'pillar' to stop disasters. The speaker also mentions the use of Radwimps' music, which they feel reduces the impact of the film's emotional moments.

10:03

🔄 Reflections on a Changed Perspective: Revisiting 'The Garden of Words'

In this paragraph, the speaker reflects on their initial impressions of 'The Garden of Words' and how their views have evolved after some time has passed since the film's release. They acknowledge the film's direct approach to addressing the 3.11 Tohoku earthquake and tsunami disaster, and how it presents a message of healing without the need for significant sacrifice. The speaker also discusses how the film might be seen as a comforting narrative for the Japanese people, providing a sense of closure and optimism. They reference a conversation with a Mr. Yamawaki, who offers a different perspective, suggesting that the film's lack of sharp edges or deep philosophical messages might be a deliberate choice to make it accessible and palatable for a wide audience.

15:06

📣 Closing Remarks and Invitation to Further Discussions

The speaker concludes the video script by inviting viewers to engage with further discussions on the film and related topics. They mention the availability of the full video for paid members and encourage viewers to subscribe to their channel or become members on YouTube to access more content. The speaker also hints at ongoing discussions in a Gundam seminar, indicating a continued interest in exploring anime and its themes. They sign off with a friendly farewell, looking forward to future interactions with their audience.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Suzume no Tojimari

Suzume no Tojimari, also known as 'The Secret of the Weathering' in English, is the main subject of the video script. It refers to a film directed by Makoto Shinkai, who is known for his previous works like 'Your Name'. The film is a central theme of the video, with the speaker discussing its themes, narrative, and the director's approach to storytelling. The script mentions it as a movie that is enjoyable and emotionally impactful for a wide audience, including those who rarely watch films.

💡Makoto Shinkai

Makoto Shinkai is a renowned Japanese film director, known for his animated films that often feature intricate narratives and visually stunning scenes. In the context of the video, he is discussed in relation to his latest work, 'Suzume no Tojimari', and how his directorial style has evolved from his earlier, more personal and artistic films to more mainstream productions that still maintain his signature touch.

💡Mainstream appeal

The term 'mainstream appeal' refers to the ability of a film or work to attract a wide audience, often by conforming to popular tastes and expectations. In the script, it is used to discuss how Makoto Shinkai's films, while maintaining their artistic integrity, have gained broader appeal and commercial success, making them accessible and enjoyable for many viewers beyond niche audiences.

💡Emotional impact

Emotional impact is the effect that a film, story, or piece of art has on the audience's emotions. The video script mentions that 'Suzume no Tojimari', like Shinkai's other works, is designed to be emotionally impactful, aiming to move the audience and provide a meaningful cinematic experience.

💡Family-friendly

A 'family-friendly' movie is one that is suitable for all ages, typically offering a balance of entertainment and content that can be enjoyed by both children and adults. The script suggests that 'Suzume no Tojimari' is a film that families can watch together, enjoying its story and emotional depth without any inappropriate content.

💡Anime resistance

Anime resistance refers to a reluctance or aversion some people may have towards anime as a medium. The script mentions that 'Suzume no Tojimari' is a film that even those who do not typically enjoy anime might find appealing, indicating its broad appeal and potential to overcome such resistance.

💡Sacrifice

Sacrifice is a theme often explored in storytelling, where characters give up something valuable for the sake of a greater good or to achieve a goal. The video discusses how 'Suzume no Tojimari' deals with the concept of sacrifice, particularly in the context of the film's climax and resolution.

💡National writer

A 'national writer' is a term that might be used to describe an author or filmmaker whose work has achieved widespread recognition and influence within a country. The script uses this term to discuss Makoto Shinkai's evolution as a filmmaker, suggesting that he has become a 'national writer' by creating films that resonate with a broad Japanese audience.

💡Youth story

A 'youth story' typically refers to a narrative that focuses on the experiences, emotions, and growth of young characters. The script mentions that 'Suzume no Tojimari' contains elements of a youth story, which may contribute to its appeal to younger audiences and those who enjoy coming-of-age narratives.

💡3.11

The number '3.11' is a reference to the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami, a significant event in Japan's recent history. The script suggests that 'Suzume no Tojimari' may have themes or elements related to this disaster, possibly as a form of healing or reflection for the audience.

💡Happy ending

A 'happy ending' in a narrative is one where the story concludes on a positive note, often with the characters achieving their goals or finding resolution. The video discusses how 'Suzume no Tojimari' provides a happy ending, which may be seen as a comforting and satisfying conclusion for viewers.

Highlights

The story revolves around a girl and a tanuki, likened to a cow and a tiger, a narrative that resonates with the Japanese audience.

The film is described as a must-watch for those who rarely see movies, offering a delightful and touching experience suitable for family viewing.

The movie is targeted towards people who enjoy animation and are not resistant to it, similar to the appeal of 'Kimi no Na wa'.

The video discusses Makoto Shinkai's work 'Suzume no Tojimari', highlighting its significance as his latest film.

Shinkai's transition from an indie director to a mainstream one is likened to George Lucas' move from 'American Graffiti' to 'Star Wars'.

The film is scored 88 points, indicating its appeal to ordinary people who do not watch many movies annually.

The reviewer finds the film's theme strong but criticizes its lack of realism, particularly in the portrayal of the protagonist's limitless energy.

The narrative is compared to a 'bull and tiger' story, a Japanese folklore approach to dealing with supernatural creatures.

The film is seen as a successful transformation of Shinkai into a national writer, despite the loss of some of his unique quirks.

The reviewer suggests that the film's happy ending and lack of sacrifices make it a feel-good movie for the masses.

The video touches on the film's potential as a form of consolation for the Japanese public, particularly in relation to the 3.11 earthquake disaster.

The reviewer reflects on the film's initial reception and how opinions have evolved over time, with some finding it more convincing upon reevaluation.

The video includes a discussion on the role of music in the film, particularly the use of Radwimps' songs and their impact on the audience's emotional experience.

The film's ending is critiqued for its lack of depth and the absence of any significant sacrifices, which contrasts with traditional storytelling.

The video concludes with a call to action for viewers to support the channel through memberships or other platforms.