Othello Theme of Appearance and Reality Analysis - Shakespeare Today Series

Summary

This video script delves into Shakespeare's exploration of deception through the character Iago in 'Othello'. It highlights how Iago manipulates truth and appearances to create chaos, using soliloquies and asides to reveal his true, malevolent nature to the audience. Shakespeare employs language, metaphors, and stage management to depict Iago's skill in twisting reality, cautioning viewers to question what they see and hear, rather than blindly accepting it.

Takeaways

• 🎭 Shakespeare's plays often explore the theme of appearance versus reality.
• 🐍 Iago from 'Othello' is a master manipulator who deceives others with a facade of honesty.
• 🗣️ Iago uses language to create a false image of himself as a loyal friend.
• 👥 He convinces Roderigo of his loyalty by using inclusive language and a friendly tone.
• 👻 Iago's true nature is revealed through soliloquies, where he shares his malicious plans with the audience.
• 🔮 Iago's soliloquies often end with rhyming couplets, a tool used by Shakespeare to emphasize key points.
• 😈 Iago's language and actions are linked to Satan, suggesting his evil intentions.
• 🤔 Iago warns of his own duplicity by saying 'I am not what I am', a twist on a biblical phrase.
• 🕷️ Iago is compared to a spider, weaving a web of deceit to manipulate those around him.
• 🎻 He also likens himself to a musician, tuning the situation to create the desired outcome.
• 🍷 Iago manipulates Cassio into drinking, leading to his downfall and dismissal.
• 👀 Iago uses 'ocular proof' to convince Othello of Desdemona's supposed infidelity, despite no affair occurring.
• 🎭 Iago's staging skills are evident as he constructs scenes to fit his narrative and deceive Othello.
• 📜 The handkerchief incident is a pivotal moment where Iago's manipulation leads Othello to believe in Desdemona's unfaithfulness.
• ⚖️ The play serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of blindly accepting appearances and the importance of seeking the truth.

Q & A

How does Shakespeare use Iago to explore the theme of deception?

Shakespeare uses Iago as a master of deception to demonstrate how appearances can be manipulated to hide one's true intentions. Iago presents himself as an honest friend while secretly plotting against others.

What is the significance of Iago's soliloquies in revealing his true nature?

Iago's soliloquies are significant because they allow the audience to hear his innermost thoughts, revealing his true malicious nature, which contrasts with his outward appearance.

How does Iago manipulate Roderigo in Act 1, Scene 3?

Iago manipulates Roderigo by convincing him not to drown himself and promising to help him win Desdemona's love. He uses a friendly tone and inclusive language to make Roderigo feel like they are a team.

What does Iago's language reveal about his true feelings towards Roderigo after he leaves?

After Roderigo leaves, Iago uses derogatory language, referring to him as a 'fool' and a 'snipe,' showing his contempt and revealing that he is using Roderigo for his own gain.

How does Iago's rhyming couplet at the end of his soliloquy contribute to his characterization?

Iago's rhyming couplet, 'Hell and night must bring this monstrous birth to the world's light,' uses religious imagery to link him to Satan, emphasizing his evil intentions and the contrast between his outward appearance and his true nature.

What is the significance of Iago's statement 'I am not what I am'?

Iago's statement 'I am not what I am' is a direct inversion of a biblical reference, aligning himself with deceit and the devil, rather than honesty and God.

How does Shakespeare use the epithet 'honest' to develop Iago's character?

Shakespeare uses the epithet 'honest' to highlight Iago's successful facade as an honest and faithful friend, despite his true deceptive nature.

What is the role of asides in Iago's manipulation of appearances?

Asides allow Iago to share his secret thoughts with the audience, revealing his plans to manipulate others. They also serve to create dramatic irony, as the audience is aware of his schemes while the characters are not.

How does Iago use the metaphor of a spider to describe his deception?

Iago likens himself to a spider weaving a web of deceit, suggesting that he is trapping his victims with his cunning plans.

How does Iago use stage management to frame reality in Act 2, Scene 3?

Iago uses stage management by getting Cassio drunk and then manipulating the situation to make it appear as though Cassio has attacked Roderigo and Montano, leading to Cassio's dismissal.

What is the significance of the 'ocular proof' Iago provides to Othello in Act 4, Scene 1?

The 'ocular proof' Iago provides is a false piece of evidence that convinces Othello of Desdemona's infidelity. It is significant because it is the final piece of manipulation that drives Othello to extreme actions.

How does the handkerchief incident in Act 3 contribute to Iago's plan?

The handkerchief incident, where Iago plants the handkerchief in Cassio's room and Cassio gives it to Bianca, provides the 'ocular proof' needed to convince Othello of Desdemona's supposed infidelity.

Outlines

00:00

🎭 Master of Deception: Iago's Manipulation

This paragraph delves into how Shakespeare uses the character Iago to explore the disparity between appearances and reality. Iago is portrayed as a master manipulator who deceives others through his facade of nobility and honesty. He butters up Roderigo, convincing him not to drown himself and promising to make Desdemona fall in love with him. Iago's friendly tone and inclusive language are contrasted with his true feelings revealed through derogatory terms and metaphors when alone. Shakespeare uses soliloquies to reveal Iago's true nature to the audience, highlighting his evil intentions. Iago's duplicity is further emphasized by his confession, 'I am not what I am,' which inverts a biblical reference to signify his two-faced character. The paragraph also discusses how Iago uses asides to manipulate Othello's perception of Desdemona's fidelity, skillfully spinning innocent interactions into something sinister.

05:01

🕷️ Web of Deceit: Iago's Stage Management

This section examines Iago's ability to manipulate appearances through his mastery of language and staging. Iago is likened to a spider weaving a web of deceit, using minimal information to ensnare his victims. He positions himself as a musician tuning the situation to his liking, further developing his image as a master deceiver. Iago's staging skills are showcased as he orchestrates events to frame reality in a way that isn't accurate, such as getting Cassio drunk and then using his inebriated state to create a false narrative. Iago's ultimate goal is to convince Othello of Desdemona's infidelity, which he achieves through the use of ocular proof. The paragraph highlights Iago's strategic use of asides to create dramatic irony, where the audience is aware of his manipulations, while the characters are not. The handkerchief incident, where Iago plants evidence in Cassio's room and manipulates the situation to appear as proof of an affair, is a key example of his skillful staging.

10:03

🔍 Unveiling Truth: The Consequences of Deception

The final paragraph discusses the dramatic irony and the consequences of Iago's deceptions. Iago shares his plans with the audience through asides, revealing his manipulations to be far more sinister than the characters on stage realize. The paragraph highlights how Iago uses the stolen handkerchief to frame Cassio and further convince Othello of Desdemona's unfaithfulness. The handkerchief becomes the 'ocular proof' that seals Cassio's fate in Othello's eyes. The paragraph concludes with a reflection on the importance of skepticism and inquiry, warning against blindly following appearances and emotions. It emphasizes the tragic outcomes that can result from failing to uncover the truth behind lies, as demonstrated in the play's final scenes.

Keywords

💡Deception

Deception refers to the act of deliberately causing someone to believe something that is not true, often with the intention of gaining an advantage. In the context of the video, Iago is a master of deception, manipulating others through lies and half-truths. His ability to deceive is highlighted when he convinces Roderigo not to drown himself by promising to help him win Desdemona's love, while secretly plotting against him.

💡Facade

A facade is a false outward appearance or a pretense that hides a person's true character or intentions. The video discusses how Iago establishes his facade as a noble and honest friend, which contrasts with his true, malicious nature. This is exemplified when Iago speaks kindly to Roderigo's face but insults him as soon as he leaves.

💡Soliloquy

A soliloquy is a dramatic device where a character speaks their thoughts out loud while alone on stage, revealing their innermost feelings and intentions to the audience. The video mentions that Iago's soliloquies allow the audience to see his true nature, which is in stark contrast to the facade he presents to others.

💡Metaphor

A metaphor is a figure of speech that describes an object or action in a way that isn't literally true, but helps explain an idea or make a comparison. The video uses the metaphor of Iago making Roderigo his 'purse' to illustrate Iago's exploitation of Roderigo for personal gain.

💡Religious Imagery

Religious imagery is the use of symbols, stories, or characters from religious traditions to convey deeper meanings or comparisons. In the video, Iago's evil plans are linked to Satan through religious imagery, highlighting his malevolent character.

💡Duplicitous

Duplicity refers to the quality of being deceitful or untrustworthy. The term 'duplicitous' is used in the video to describe Iago's two-faced character, as he pretends to be loyal while plotting against those he claims to befriend.

💡Epithet

An epithet is a descriptive term or phrase, often used as an insult or a nickname. In the video, Shakespeare uses the epithet 'honest' ironically to show how Iago maintains his facade of honesty, despite his deceitful actions.

💡Aside

An aside is a statement or comment made by a character in a play, which is intended to be heard only by the audience and not by other characters. The video explains how Iago uses asides to share his manipulations with the audience, creating dramatic irony.

💡Irony

Irony is a rhetorical device, event, or situation in which there is a contrast between expectation and reality. The video discusses dramatic irony, where the audience is aware of Iago's manipulations, which the characters on stage are not.

💡Staging

Staging refers to the way a scene or action is set up in a play or performance. The video highlights how Iago's skillful staging of scenes manipulates reality, leading Othello to believe Desdemona is unfaithful despite no affair occurring.

💡Ocular Proof

Ocular proof refers to evidence that is believed because it is seen or witnessed. In the video, Iago's manipulation leads Othello to believe he has witnessed proof of Desdemona's infidelity, when in fact it is all a deception.

Highlights

Shakespeare's exploration of the gap between appearance and reality.

Iago as a master of deception, orchestrating the play's major conflicts.

Iago's facade as a noble and honest friend.

Iago's manipulation of Roderigo in Act 1, Scene 3.

Contrast between Iago's friendly tone and his true disdain for Roderigo.

Iago's soliloquies revealing his true nature to the audience.

Religious imagery linking Iago to Satan.

Iago's duplicity revealed to Roderigo in Act 1, Scene 1.

Iago's contempt for honest people symbolized by the metaphor of predatory birds.

Iago's inversion of the biblical 'I am that I am' to signify his deceit.

Iago's successful facade as 'honest'.

Iago's use of asides to reveal his secret thoughts to the audience.

Iago's metaphor of a spider weaving a web of deceit.

Iago's stage management to manipulate appearances.

Iago's cunning plan to get Cassio fired in Act 2, Scene 3.

Iago's framing of Cassio's reality to Othello.

Iago's use of ocular proof to convince Othello of Desdemona's infidelity.

Iago's construction of a scene to incriminate Cassio.

The dramatic irony of Iago's manipulation.

Iago's control over Othello through manipulation.

The consequences of failing to find the truth behind the lies.

Shakespeare's reminder to be skeptical and inquisitive.

Transcripts

we will go through the way Shakespeare

explores the differences between how

things appear and how they actually are

reminding us why it's not a great idea

to blindly believe the things we hear

let's begin by looking at Iago who is a

master of deception and orchestrates all

of the sins that we will be looking at

Iago's ability to manipulate the truth

is clear as he establishes his own

facade or outward appearance as being a

noble and honest friend let's look at

the way Iago butters up Roderigo in act

1 at the end of scene 3 he convinces

Roderigo not to drown himself because he

is sure that he can get Desdemona to

fall in love with him his tone is

friendly and he seems concerned for the

welfare of Roderigo as he says no more

of drowning do hear he also uses

inclusive pronouns as he talks about our

revenge to show Roderigo that they are a

team

however this contrasts with his language

and demeanor as soon as Roderigo leaves

he uses derogatory or disrespectful

language such as fool and snipe to

describe him he says that he is

metaphorically making Roderigo his purse

that is he is only using Roderigo for

his own profit

Shakespeare clearly shows us the huge

chasm between how Iago presents himself

to others and how he truly is by using

soliloquies to share his real nature

with the audience remember that a

soliloquy is when a character shares

their innermost thoughts with the

audience and usually happens when they

are alone on stage Iago finishes his

soliloquy with a rhyming couplet two

lines which rhyme a common tool which

Shakespeare users to highlight important

points Iago says hell and night must

bring this monstrous birth to the

world's light

the religious imagery here links Iago to

Satan who uses the dark forces of Hell

to ruin good people so even though he

acts like a good guy around Rodrigo

secretly he is full of evil plots Iago

is so good at twisting reality that he

even tells Rodrigo exactly what he is

doing earlier in act 1 scene 1

he shares his duplicitous nature with

Rodrigo meaning his two-faced character

Iago explains that he is only pretending

to be loyal to a fellow he shows

complete disdain for honest people who

wear their heart on their sleeve for

doors to peck at he uses the metaphor of

these hearts being pecked at and eaten

by predatory birds to show his contempt

for such honesty this should be a huge

warning for Rodrigo that Iago is not to

be trusted

Iago even explicitly says I am not what

I am while he seems to be reassuring

Rodrigo of his friendship by explaining

how he is only pretending to be loyal to

a fellow Shakespeare uses this biblical

reference to deepen Iago's character his

admission is an inversion or twisting of

the line I am that I am from the book of

Exodus in the Bible in this passage God

is presenting his true face to the

Israelites in order to help them but

Iago subverts or undermines the honest

portrayal and aligns himself with the

devil by saying he is not how he seems

this is developed throughout the play as

well sello frequently refers to Iago

using the epithet honest remember an

epithet is a descriptor in this case

Shakespeare's use of honest shows us how

successful Iago is in maintaining this

facade

in act 2 scene 1 Shakespeare also gives

us a taste of the way Iago is able to

successfully manipulate appearances

through the use of asides which is a

device used to tell the audience what

the character is secretly thinking after

sharing with the audiences planned to

convince Othello that Desdemona and

Cassio are having an affair he stands

back to watch the happy bridal party

arrive at Cypress remember that Cassio

is good friends with Desdemona and

Othello and even helped them to elope so

it's no surprise that they all greet

each other warmly in an aside Iago

commentates the way Cassio and Desdemona

behave spinning the innocent

relationship into a sordid affair he

says I

well said whisper I smile upon her do

well kissed indicating the way he will

twist the innocent interactions of two

friends into something more sinister

Shakespeare uses the metaphor of a

predatory spider weaving a web of deceit

Iago notes that with as little a web as

this will iron snare as great a fly as

Cassio this is reinforced when Iago

likens himself to a musician later in

the scene he remarks about Othello you

are well tuned now but I'll set down the

pegs that make this music the metaphor

of the musician tuning his musical

instrument to make the tune of his

choosing further develops Iago's

characterization as a master of

deception continuously molding the world

to appear the way he wants it to

while Iago is a master of language and

uses his words to present himself as an

honest and faithful friend he is also a

master of staging have you heard the

saying seeing is believing

Shakespeare uses Iago's stage management

to show how easy it is to frame reality

in a way that isn't necessarily accurate

we see this first in act 2 scene 3

when Iago causes Cassio to be fired

remember the way he used a friendly

humorous tone to convince Roderigo that

they were on the same side he takes a

similar approach with Cassio singing

drinking songs and slapping him on the

back in an attempt to get him to drink

some wine harmless right Cassio resists

for a while because he is on duty which

means that he absolutely cannot be drunk

but he eventually caves and is snared in

Iago's web when Cassio leaves Iago

begins to dismantle his good reputation

telling Montano that Cassio is a soldier

fit to stand by Caesar do but see his

vice meaning that Cassio is a great guy

but look he drinks way too much by

convincing Montano that Cassio has a

drinking problem he makes it seem more

believable that Cassio who definitely

isn't sober at the moment has lost the

plot and attacked Roderigo and Montano

out of his own drunken judgment rather

than being goaded into it by Roderigo

with Cassio finally out of the picture

Iago begins to work on twisting or

fellows reality to make it seem as

though his wife is being unfaithful

despite trying his best

Iago is unable to convince Othello of

Desdemona's infidelity until he gets the

ocular proof or hard evidence of her

affair this should be impossible to

collect considering that no affair is

actually happening but that doesn't stop

Iago in Act four scene one

he preps or fellow for the ultimate game

of bait and switch by taunting him with

images of Desdemona and Cassio having an

affair he says that Cassio has admitted

to doing a whole bunch of unmentionable

things with Desdemona with her on her

what you will knowing that by being

vague and suggestive or sellers jealous

mind will fill in the blanks with far

more outrageous and painful details than

he ever could he turns out to be right

and or fellow is so incensed by the

images of Cassio and Desdemona together

that he falls into an epileptic fit

Iago stands coldly over a fellow's

twitching body and says work on my

medicine using the metaphor of medicine

to cast himself as an evil doctor who

now has full control over his patient

now look at how Shakespeare uses staging

to show how expertly Iago constructs the

scene while Othello is out cold Cassio

enters wanting to speak with him about

getting his old job back Iago lets him

know that or thilo is a bit under the

weather and needs some rest but give him

a minute and they can have a chat about

what's been going on then he goes back

to our cellar and tells him that Cassio

is there and that if he hides himself he

will hear Iago draw a confession out of

Cassio throughout the scene we can see

the way that Iago leads or fellow

suggesting that Cassio and Desdemona are

behaving in a certain way he instructs

othello to hide and mark the flares the

jibes and notable scorns that dwell in

every region of his face knowing that a

fellow will now be unable to think of

anything else

Iago personifies Cassio's guilt that is

he gives it human qualities suggesting

that it can be seen all over his face

this makes his guilt to seem even more

real

and aside Yago shares with the audience

that he will be discussing Cassio's

interactions with Bianca a prostitute

who he enjoys but doesn't respect

Shakespeare is creating some very

effective dramatic irony which is where

the audience knows something that the

characters on stage don't hear the

audience is clearly shown how Iago is

able to manipulate the truth to suit his

own needs Shakespeare uses another aside

to show Iago predicting that Othello's

unbook ich jealousy must construe poor

Cassio smiles gestures and light

behaviors quite in the wrong the stage

is set in such a way that we can see the

way the conversation between Iago and

Cassio effects or fellow and can

immediately gauge the success of his

plan also remember back in act 3 how

Iago hid the stolen handkerchief in

Cassio's bedroom and poor unsuspecting

Cassio gave it to Bianca this is about

to come back to haunt him as Bianca

storms in to throw the handkerchief at

Cassio crying that it is some Minx's

token Bianca doesn't believe that Cassio

just innocently found it exclaiming a

likely piece of work that you should

find it in your chamber and not know who

left it there

thanks to Iago's cunning way of framing

the scene or thilo cannot believe it

either

instead seeing Cassio in possession of

the handkerchief that he lovingly gave

to his wife is the ocular proof and the

final nail in Cassio's coffin after

exits or fellow steps out of the

darkness asking how shall I murder him

Iago his tone is certain and by having

him ask Iago for advice Shakespeare

shows how powerful Iago has become he is

the director who is in complete control

by showing us the way that truth and

reality can be twisted Shakespeare is

reminding us that we need to be

skeptical and inquisitive rather than

letting friends and emotions rule us the

final scene of the play shows just how

dire the consequences can be if we are

unable to find the truth behind all the

lies we hope you enjoyed this schooling

online production

for more easy lessons on north ello

check out our analysis of the theme of

gender in the play

[Music]