Are Winstrips Worth It?
Summary
TLDRIn diesem Video spricht Farmer Jesse über Wind Strips, eine spezielle Art von Anzuchtschalen für Setzlinge. Er erklärt, dass Wind Strips eine langlebigere und bessere Option als herkömmliche Zellschalen sind, aber im Vergleich zu Erdblöcken eher ein seitlicher oder sogar rückwärtiger Schritt. Jesse hebt die Vorteile der Luftwurzelbeschneidung und die Flexibilität hervor, bemängelt jedoch das Design, insbesondere die Löcher in den Schalen, die zu Bodenverlust führen. Trotz ihres höheren Preises hält er Wind Strips für eine sinnvolle Investition, besonders für bestimmte Pflanzenarten wie Tomaten oder Gurken.
Takeaways
- 🌱 Windstrips sind spezielle Setzlingstrays, die teurer, aber langlebiger sind als herkömmliche Zelltrays.
- 📈 Für Gärtner, die Zelltrays verwenden, sind Windstrips ein klarer Fortschritt, bieten jedoch keine wesentlichen Vorteile gegenüber Bodenblöcken.
- 💰 Obwohl Windstrips teurer sind (ca. 12 $ pro Tray), können sie länger halten und somit kosteneffektiv sein.
- 🌬️ Windstrips bieten eine gewisse Luftbeschneidung der Wurzeln, um das Wurzelwachstum zu kontrollieren und eine Verfilzung zu verhindern.
- 💧 Ein Nachteil des Designs ist, dass die Erde durch Löcher im Trayboden herausfällt, was zu einer doppelten Füllung führt.
- 💦 Windstrips neigen dazu, schnell auszutrocknen, was bei der Bewässerung berücksichtigt werden muss. Eine Bodentränkung ist oft erforderlich.
- 👍 Der Vorteil von Windstrips ist, dass man Setzlinge leicht mit dem Finger herausdrücken kann, was bei Zelltrays schwieriger ist.
- 🧑🌾 Für bestimmte Pflanzen wie Tomaten und Kürbisgewächse sind Windstrips ideal, da sie die empfindlichen Wurzeln schonen.
- ♻️ Windstrips sind umweltfreundlicher, da sie länger halten und weniger Plastikmüll erzeugen als herkömmliche Zelltrays.
- 🤔 Der Sprecher verwendet Windstrips hauptsächlich im Frühling, greift jedoch für die meisten Aufgaben weiterhin auf Bodenblöcke zurück.
Q & A
Was sind Windstrips und wofür werden sie verwendet?
-Windstrips sind spezielle Saatgutschalen, die für die Anzucht von Pflanzen verwendet werden. Sie haben eine besondere Bauweise, die das Luftbeschneiden der Wurzeln fördert und somit die Wurzelbildung verbessert.
Wie vergleicht Farmer Jesse Windstrips mit herkömmlichen Zellenplatten?
-Farmer Jesse glaubt, dass Windstrips im Vergleich zu herkömmlichen Zellenplatten einen klaren Vorteil bieten. Sie sind zwar teurer, halten aber länger und führen zu besseren Pflanzensetzlingen.
Wie vergleicht Farmer Jesse Windstrips mit Erdpresstöpfen?
-Jesse betrachtet Windstrips im Vergleich zu Erdpresstöpfen als eher seitwärts gerichteten Schritt oder sogar als einen Rückschritt. Er erklärt, dass Erdpresstöpfe mehr Flexibilität bieten, insbesondere bei der Entnahme der Pflanzen.
Was ist der Hauptvorteil von Windstrips laut Jesse?
-Der Hauptvorteil von Windstrips ist laut Jesse die Fähigkeit zur Luftbeschneidung der Wurzeln, was das Wurzeln im Kreis verhindert und es den Pflanzen ermöglicht, ihre Energie effizienter zu nutzen.
Was gefällt Jesse an der Bauweise der Windstrips nicht?
-Jesse kritisiert die Löcher an der Oberseite der Windstrips. Diese führen dazu, dass beim Befüllen mit Erde etwa ein Viertel der Erde durch die Löcher verloren geht.
Warum bevorzugt Jesse es, die Windstrips mit nasser Erde zu befüllen?
-Jesse empfiehlt, die Windstrips mit nasser Erde zu befüllen, da dies sicherstellt, dass die Erde in der Mitte der Zellen ausreichend befeuchtet ist und somit eine bessere Wasserverteilung gewährleistet wird.
Wie lange halten Windstrips im Vergleich zu herkömmlichen Zellenplatten?
-Windstrips sind teurer, aber sie halten deutlich länger als herkömmliche Zellenplatten, die oft nur zwei bis drei Mal verwendet werden können, bevor sie unbrauchbar werden.
Für welche Pflanzenarten bevorzugt Jesse die Verwendung von Windstrips?
-Jesse verwendet Windstrips gerne für Tomaten und Kürbisgewächse (Cucurbitaceae), da diese empfindliche Wurzeln haben und die Luftbeschneidung in den Windstrips das Wurzelwachstum unterstützt.
Welche Probleme sieht Jesse bei der Verwendung von Windstrips?
-Jesse erwähnt, dass Windstrips dazu neigen, am Boden sehr schnell auszutrocknen, was eine ständige Überwachung und sorgfältiges Gießen erfordert.
Sind Windstrips für jede Art von Pflanze geeignet?
-Nein, laut Jesse sind Windstrips nicht für jede Pflanze geeignet. Zum Beispiel würde er sie nicht für den Anbau von Salat verwenden und stattdessen entweder Erdpresstöpfe oder kleinere Windstrips (128er) verwenden.
Outlines
🎥 Einführung in Windstrips und Vergleich mit anderen Methoden
Jesse erklärt seine Motivation, ein Video über Windstrips zu machen, nachdem er ausreichend Erfahrung damit gesammelt hat. Er gibt eine schnelle Antwort auf die Frage, ob sich Windstrips im Vergleich zu herkömmlichen Saatgutschalen oder Erdblöcken lohnen. Windstrips sind eine deutliche Verbesserung gegenüber Saatgutschalen, bieten jedoch keinen großen Vorteil gegenüber Erdblöcken. Das Video wird detailliert auf die Vor- und Nachteile von Windstrips eingehen.
📜 Geschichte und Rückkehr der Windstrips
Windstrips waren einst schwer zu bekommen, und Jesse erklärt, dass Connor Crickmore von Neversink Farm sie vor einigen Jahren wieder eingeführt hat. Seitdem hat Jesse diese Saatgutschalen getestet, um sie mit Erdblöcken zu vergleichen. Er hebt seine Vorliebe für die Einfachheit der Windstrips im Gegensatz zu herkömmlichen Saatgutschalen hervor, obwohl Erdblöcke viele Vorteile bieten.
🌱 Vorteile der Luftbeschneidung und Flexibilität der Windstrips
Windstrips bieten durch ihre seitlichen Schlitze eine Luftbeschneidung der Wurzeln, was das Wurzelwachstum optimiert und eine Flexibilität ermöglicht, die bei herkömmlichen Saatgutschalen nicht gegeben ist. Pflanzen können länger in den Windstrips verbleiben, ohne Wurzelverdrillung zu erleiden. Jesse beschreibt dies als einen großen Vorteil, insbesondere bei wechselnden Wetterbedingungen oder Zeitplänen.
🔧 Nachteile des Designs und Verbesserungsmöglichkeiten
Jesse kritisiert das Design der Windstrips, insbesondere die Löcher an der Oberseite, die zu einem Verlust von Anzuchterde führen. Auch trocknen die Böden der Schalen schnell aus, was eine ständige Bewässerung erfordert. Obwohl er einige Verbesserungen für das Design vorschlägt, bleibt er von den Windstrips als langfristige Lösung zur Anzucht überzeugt, trotz des höheren Preises im Vergleich zu traditionellen Saatgutschalen.
💡 Anwendungstipps und Preisüberblick
Jesse gibt Tipps, wie man die Windstrips am besten verwendet, zum Beispiel das Befüllen mit feuchter Erde. Er erklärt, dass die Windstrips zwar teurer sind als andere Methoden, aber aufgrund ihrer Langlebigkeit auf lange Sicht günstiger sein können. Er erwähnt auch die Verfügbarkeit in verschiedenen Größen und empfiehlt den Kauf im größeren Umfang, um die Kosten zu senken.
🌾 Windstrips für verschiedene Pflanzentypen
Jesse beschreibt, dass Windstrips besonders gut für Pflanzen wie Tomaten und Gurken geeignet sind, die empfindliche Wurzeln haben. Er betont, dass Windstrips für bestimmte Pflanzenarten wie Salat möglicherweise nicht ideal sind, da andere Systeme wie Erdblöcke besser funktionieren. Trotzdem schätzt er die Flexibilität der Windstrips in bestimmten Anwendungsfällen.
🤔 Zusammenfassung der Vor- und Nachteile von Windstrips
Jesse fasst die Vor- und Nachteile der Windstrips zusammen. Zu den Vorteilen gehören die schnelle Befüllung, die Langlebigkeit und die Möglichkeit der Luftbeschneidung, was besonders bei empfindlichen Pflanzen nützlich ist. Ein Nachteil ist jedoch der Preis und die Tatsache, dass sie immer noch zusätzliche Schritte erfordern, um die Pflanzen zu entnehmen, im Vergleich zu Erdblöcken.
🙋♂️ Abschließende Gedanken und Feedback-Aufruf
Jesse lädt die Zuschauer ein, Fragen zu den Windstrips oder anderen Anzuchtmethoden zu stellen. Er ermutigt sie, seine Inhalte zu abonnieren und bedankt sich für ihre Unterstützung. Am Ende gibt es einen humorvollen Moment, in dem er bemerkt, dass sein Mikrofonkabel während des gesamten Videos sichtbar war.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Windstrips
💡Luftbeschneidung
💡Zelltabletts
💡Bodenblöcke
💡Flexibilität
💡Kosten
💡Wurzelbindung
💡Bewässerung
💡Plastikverbrauch
💡Anzucht von Setzlingen
Highlights
Introduction to the video and the topic of Wind Strips, a specific type of seed starting tray.
Wind Strips are compared to soil blocks and standard cell trays in terms of cost and plant quality.
Jesse states that Wind Strips are a definite step up from standard cell trays due to their longevity and better plant starts.
In comparison to soil blocks, Wind Strips are considered a lateral move or possibly a step down.
Wind Strips offer more flexibility in timing since they prevent root binding, unlike standard cell trays.
The design of Wind Strips allows for air pruning, helping roots grow healthier by stopping them from circling.
Jesse dislikes the holes in the top of the trays because they cause soil loss during filling.
Wind Strips can dry out faster at the bottom, making consistent watering necessary.
The trays are priced around $12 each when bought in bulk, but are more cost-effective over time due to their durability.
The ease of popping plants out of Wind Strips with a finger is a key benefit compared to standard cell trays.
Jesse finds loading the trays with wet soil mix more effective for even watering and avoiding dry spots.
Wind Strips are ideal for crops like tomatoes and cucurbits, which benefit from air pruning and flexibility in transplant timing.
Jesse prefers soil blocks for crops like lettuce and beets, but Wind Strips have specific use cases in his farming.
Overall, Wind Strips offer a longer-lasting, more flexible solution compared to cell trays, though they may not fully replace soil blocks.
Jesse closes by inviting viewers to share their thoughts on Wind Strips and subscribe to his channel for more content.
Transcripts
[Music]
so
[Music]
so
[Music]
hey you all farmer jesse here i've been
wanting to do this video for a while
uh but i also wanted to get a lot of
experience with the wind strips before i
really weighed in on them
and but i'm going to do it today i'm
going to kind of give you a rundown
of wind strips this is a specific
kind of seed starting cell tray
that i want to talk about because
they're a little bit expensive and i
want to talk about whether or not
they're worth it and then also compare
them a little bit to soil blocks
so let's do it all right first things
first i'm actually going to give you the
answer to whether or not i think wind
strips are
worth it first and then we'll get into
the nerdy details so if you just kind of
came around you were wondering what my
answer was
um let's do that first so if your
standard
is cell trays i believe that wind strips
are
a definite step up and in fact they're a
little bit more expensive but they will
last significantly longer and you'll get
a lot better plant starts out of them
now if your standard is soil blocks i
believe that wind strips are a lateral
move or maybe even a step down
i explain all of that to follow but if
that answered your question
hit the like button hit the subscribe
button we'll see you later go enjoy your
day
it may be beautiful may be winter i have
no idea when you're watching this
all right into the video wind strips
these were around for a long time and
i'm not sure exactly what happened
uh but they were really hard to get i
remember when i first started farming
everybody talked about wind strips but
nobody could get them and maybe they
were a little pricey
and i feel like you had to import them
but a few years ago conor crickmore from
neversync farm
brought them back and people were very
excited including myself who had never
used them but had heard about them
for years so i bought a bunch of them
and i've been trialing them for the last
few years to kind of get a feel for how
i like them
especially in comparison to soil blocks
if you've
followed this channel for a while you
know that i'm not a big fan of cell
trait to be clear you can grow
great transplants in cell trays and
certainly lots of people do that but my
issue with cell trace was always that
you grew it in the cell tray you kind of
had a limited number of days to get
out of the cell tray otherwise it
started to become root bound and when
you did get it out of the cell tray you
had to pop it so it added a whole extra
step
whereas with soil blocks you can take
that whole tray immediately out of the
greenhouse
you know beyond its general maturity
depending on what crop it is
and then just pull it straight off the
tray and put it in the soil i like that
i've always liked that but i was
attracted to the idea
of the wind strip for a number of
reasons
i liked the idea of having something i
could do early on that didn't involve me
getting out the soil block maker and
getting the soil all wet
i also like the idea of having something
i can load up really quickly like a cell
tray
and that would also allow for that
flexibility in the season
so if the plant was getting over mature
but my bed wasn't ready or the previous
crop hadn't come out or whatever the
raining or snowing or hungover or
whatever and i couldn't get the crop out
i liked the idea of having a little bit
more flexibility
so let's talk about this design a little
bit because that's where the flexibility
comes from
the advantage with soil blocks is air
pruning now
as you can see here in the wind strip
you get a little bit of air pruning
because those
little slats on the side of each cell
allow for a little air to come in and
the air pruning is essentially when the
roots hit air they stop
growing in circles so they
essentially the roots will stop at that
point and allow the plant to keep
growing
putting its energy into the plant
instead of putting its energy into
producing winding routes so
that's one of the advantages of these
and that allows you to go a little
longer
with a crop if you need to and then you
know ultimately pull it whenever you
need it instead of
before it gets root bound so it gives
you a little bit more flexibility and i
like that
i think if there's one thing i don't
like about the design it's these holes
i love those slats in the side of the
cell but these holes in the top of the
tray
they actually are kind of obnoxious
because when you put
your soil mix in you lose what roughly
a quarter of it through those holes just
onto whatever's below
and that is uh that just means that you
kind of have to fill these trays twice
because you lose so much soil mix in
filling them
that's not the end of the world but it's
not my favorite thing
another thing about the design is
there's a lot of space here there's just
a lot of
air which is good for the air pruning
but i find that the bottoms of the wind
strips dry out extremely fast and that
you know with a good bottom watering
system or a capillary mat or something
that can take care of it a little better
generally speaking though you do have to
water these and be careful how you're
watering them
if you have a good bottom watering
option that's great i think that
neversink farm is releasing soon bottom
watering trays for these
but that does add to the cost so which
is another thing we should talk about
when you look at the site never saying
farm site
um the wind strips are going for
something like 19
a piece but that's kind of misleading
that's actually not accurate nobody's
going to buy a single win strip
so really they started about 12 a piece
for 10
and then they go down from there the
more you buy 12
apiece is a lot of money it will you
know
but in general these are going to last
you quite a while so
uh i think that that 12
a tray or you know like i said the price
goes down as you buy more you go in with
a bunch of farmers
and get a bunch all at once you can get
them i think down to six or seven
dollars i'll put it on the screen
um which is great uh that's actually a
much more reasonable price especially if
they're going to last you
several years unlike your cell trays i'm
going to skip back to the design for a
second because one thing i forgot to
mention is how much i like being able to
just pop them out with a finger
you can't really do that with cell trays
you either need a popper or you pull the
plant and i just don't like doing that i
don't feel like that's a very good
i don't feel like the plant loves that i
don't know i've never enjoyed pulling
the plant itself
i'd rather grab the block so these you
can buy poppers for them i think two bad
cats sell some poppers that you can use
for these
but you can generally just use your
finger to pop them out which makes it a
little bit faster
but there is still that extra step of
having to pop these unlike the soil
blocks which
you can just yank off the tray and just
a general tip i've found that loading
them wet
with wet soil mix it's more effective
you're getting all the wet
stuff right in the middle where it's
harder to water and like i said they dry
out easier
so in my experience it's a little bit
more effective to load them
with wet soil mix than it is to load
them with dry soil mix
um and then you immediately you don't
have to soak them you don't have to you
know put a bottom watering tray on them
immediately
or water them like crazy you can just go
ahead and put your seeds in and they're
good to go
what else do i need to say about these i
still like these i like them early in
the spring when i don't feel like
busting out all of my soil
blocking stuff but generally speaking
i'm if i'm having to moisten the soil
and they're not staying as wet i'm kind
of
i still lean probably 75 on soil blocks
in about 25 on these trays
they are available these are 72s they
are also available in 50s
and 128s now when i bought these they
were only available in 72. so that's
kind of cool i haven't got to try those
other ones i would like to do that at
some point
but generally speaking yes i think
they're worth it in certain
circumstances
especially if you're growing specific
crops like i wouldn't use these 72 trays
to grow lettuce for instance i would
maybe use the 128s that they have
or i would use soil blocks and that's
what we use soil blocks
but for starting things like tomatoes i
love this we start the tomatoes early i
can pretty much do it in the house
i load these up i'm not worried about
the roots intermingling uh same thing
with cucurbits that have very sensitive
roots
i just allow those to grow up and then i
pop them up kind of like i showed in the
last video that i did
so just to recap on the pro side they're
relatively fast to load
the trays themselves are extremely long
lasting which i like is somebody who's
trying to
reduce my plastic usage especially
single time or futile
plastic usage like cell trays often are
like two or three times and then you're
kind of done with that cell tray which
is just an enormous waste of plastic
so i like that these will last quite a
bit longer they are a little bit on the
expensive side but when you weigh that
versus how much you're going to be
spending on cell trays over time
you know it may balance out staying on
the pro side
i like it for things like cucurbits i
like it for the air pruning effect it
doesn't
you do get a little bit of a wrap but
not much um
i think it could be redesigned i think
that these need to be
like like this just needs to be a solid
piece of plastic there more like you
would maybe see in a cell tray where
there's not that big gap
i like how fast they are to pop i like
that you can pop them with your finger
we tend to grow really robust plants out
of these
and like i said i like that you can
extend the
greenhouse experience that that's a
terrible way of saying that you can
extend
your uh length in the greenhouse and
your your flexibility a little bit with
with the wind strips
versus cell trays or you know something
like that and maybe even
soil blocks soil blocks when they get
too entangled when all the roots are
then you
when all the roots start growing into
the other blocks it can be kind of
difficult to get them out and some crops
like beets
get a little damage when you um when
they get too mature
and sometimes that happens it just you
know you don't have your bed space ready
or you've
planned something and changed things or
you know whatever happened so i do like
that
level of flexibility that comes with the
wind strips everybody's situation is
going to be different everybody's
preferences are going to be different
but i like wind strips a lot they will
probably never replace soil blocks
on any meaningful level for me but i
like having both of them kind of working
together
anyway let me know if you have any
questions about that let me know if you
have any thoughts on wind strips sell
trays or anything else
like this video if you like this video
make sure to subscribe to this channel
to the podcast to all the things we do
otherwise
you rock we'll see you later
as if that was totally as funny as my
other videos i had the freaking wire
from my microphone sticking out the
whole time that's a great bit
you just don't have any sense of humor
[Applause]
you
Browse More Related Video
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)