If U Use GitHub CO-PILOT I Wont Hire You!?

Summary

The speaker expresses his controversial stance on AI coding tools like Co-Pilot, stating he wouldn't hire those who rely on them. He argues that while AI can assist with boilerplate code, it hinders creative problem-solving and innovation, which are essential in engineering. He emphasizes the importance of critical thinking and originality in the tech industry, urging engineers not to become overly dependent on AI tools.

Takeaways

• 🚫 The speaker won't hire those who rely on AI coding tools like Co-Pilot, as they believe it hinders creativity and innovation.
• 💡 The tweet about not hiring Co-Pilot users was intended to provoke discussion and not meant to be taken absolutely seriously.
• 🌟 The speaker values creativity and innovative thinking over speed in writing boilerplate code.
• 🤖 AI tools like Chat GPT are used daily by the speaker but are seen as a tool for guidance, not a replacement for human thought.
• 🛠️ Engineering is about solving problems and bringing value through technology, not just about writing code.
• 🔍 The speaker's company, Lau, is focused on innovation in the fintech space and requires engineers who can think outside the box.
• 🚀 Productivity in engineering comes from creative innovation and problem-solving, not from the ability to write boilerplate code quickly.
• 🌱 AI tools are seen as complementary to human work and are not expected to replace human creativity and innovation anytime soon.
• 🎨 The speaker compares coding to an art form, like painting, and believes that AI tools can disrupt the natural creative process.
• 👵 The speaker has a personal goal of reaching 100K subscribers to make their grandmother proud before she passes away.

Q & A

What was the main point of the tweet that caused a stir in the tech community?

The main point of the tweet was that the speaker would not hire someone if they used co-pilot or similar AI tools.

How does the speaker feel about AI tools in general?

The speaker acknowledges that AI tools can be helpful and they use them themselves, but they also express concern about becoming overly reliant on them, as they believe it could hinder creative and innovative thinking.

What is the speaker's perspective on the use of co-pilot in engineering?

The speaker views co-pilot as a tool that can write boilerplate code efficiently, but they believe it may impede an engineer's ability to think critically and come up with innovative solutions.

What does the speaker suggest is the true purpose of engineering?

The speaker suggests that the true purpose of engineering is to solve problems and bring value through technology to end users, not just to write code.

How does the speaker use chat GPT in their daily work?

The speaker uses chat GPT as a tool to guide them in their work, similar to a more advanced Google search, helping them with code suggestions and guiding them in the right direction.

What is the speaker's stance on hiring practices in relation to AI tool usage?

The speaker indicates that they would still hire someone who uses AI tools like co-pilot, but they prefer engineers who can think creatively and innovatively, rather than just relying on AI for code generation.

Why did the speaker make the controversial tweet?

The speaker made the tweet partly as a troll to get people's attention and to provoke thought and discussion on the over-reliance on AI tools in engineering.

What is the speaker's view on the future of AI in innovation?

The speaker believes that while AI is currently good at replicating and assisting, it is not yet capable of true innovation and that this is likely to remain the case for a very long time.

How does the speaker compare coding to other creative processes?

The speaker compares coding to painting, suggesting that having AI tools input code into a project could block the individual's creativity, similar to how having someone else paint your canvas might not reflect your original vision.

What is the speaker's advice to engineers regarding AI tools?

The speaker advises engineers not to become too emotionally attached to AI tools and to focus more on creative engineering and innovative thinking, rather than just using languages, editors, and tools.

What personal motivation does the speaker share for reaching 100K subscribers?

The speaker wants to reach 100K subscribers to make their grandmother proud before she passes away, as they had made a promise to her.

Outlines

00:00

💡 Controversial Tweet on Co-Pilot引发讨论

该段落讲述了作者发表的一条关于不会雇佣使用Co-Pilot或类似工具的人的推文，这条推文在技术社区引起了轩然大波。作者表达了自己对这一现象的困惑，并提到了自己对达成订阅者目标的承诺，呼吁观众加入社区并参与讨论。作者提出了关于Co-Pilot的看法，认为虽然每个人都有使用任何他们想用的工具的自由，但Co-Pilot并不是他所喜欢的，因为它缺乏创造性。作者解释了自己为何发表这条推文，并分享了他对Co-Pilot的看法，强调了他对工程世界的理解和对AI工具的态度。

05:02

🤖 对AI工具的过度依赖可能阻碍职业发展

在这一段中，作者深入探讨了他对Co-Pilot的看法，认为Co-Pilot会在编辑器中不断生成代码，这可能会阻碍工程师的思考和创新。他通过自己的经验，说明了编写基础代码时，工程师应该思考下一步的逻辑和解决方案，而Co-Pilot的即时代码生成可能会干扰这一过程。作者强调，工程不仅仅是编写代码，而是通过技术解决问题并为最终用户创造价值。他提到了自己的公司和团队，说明了他寻找具有创新思维的工程师的原因，并表达了对AI工具可能限制人类创造性的担忧。

10:02

🎨 编程与创造性：保持对技术的批判性思考

最后一段中，作者总结了他对AI工具和编程的看法。他认为，尽管AI工具可以帮助我们，但它们不能取代人类的创新和创造性思维。他强调，工程师应该保持对技术的批判性思考，并专注于创造性的工程问题解决，而不仅仅是依赖工具。作者提醒观众不要过于依赖AI工具，并鼓励他们保持独立和创新的思维方式。他还提到了自己的个人目标，即在祖母去世前达到100K的订阅者，再次呼吁观众支持他的频道。

Keywords

💡Co-pilot

Co-pilot in the context of the video refers to AI coding tools that assist developers by generating code snippets or entire sections of code. The speaker expresses a dislike for such tools, arguing that they hinder a programmer's creativity and critical thinking during the coding process. The term is used throughout the video to discuss the impact of AI on software engineering and the potential downsides of relying too heavily on automated code generation.

💡Engineering

In the video, engineering is described as the process of solving problems through technology, rather than simply writing code. It emphasizes the need for innovative thinking and creative solutions, which the speaker believes are crucial aspects of an engineer's role. The term is used to distinguish between the technical act of coding and the broader, more strategic responsibilities of an engineer.

💡Productivity

Productivity in the context of the video is discussed in relation to the efficiency and effectiveness of an engineer's work. The speaker argues that true productivity comes from the ability to innovate and think creatively, rather than from the speed of writing boilerplate code. The term is used to challenge the notion that AI tools like Co-pilot necessarily improve an engineer's output.

💡Innovation

Innovation is a central theme in the video, where it is portrayed as the key to advancing the tech industry and solving complex problems. The speaker believes that while AI tools can replicate and assist, they currently lack the ability to innovate in the same way humans can. The term is used to emphasize the importance of human creativity and the potential limitations of AI in driving new ideas and breakthroughs.

💡AI Tools

AI tools refer to artificial intelligence software that assists with various tasks, such as coding, in the video. The speaker acknowledges the utility of AI tools but also warns against over-reliance on them, as they may stifle a programmer's independent problem-solving skills and innovative thinking. The term is used to discuss the balance between leveraging technology and maintaining human agency in the engineering process.

💡Boilerplate Code

Boilerplate code refers to generic, reusable code that can be used in various programming tasks without significant modification. In the video, the speaker argues that while AI tools like Co-pilot can efficiently generate boilerplate code, they may also hinder a programmer's ability to think critically and come up with innovative solutions. The term is used to discuss the potential downsides of relying on AI for routine coding tasks.

💡Creative Thinking

Creative thinking is the ability to come up with original ideas and innovative solutions to problems. In the video, the speaker emphasizes the importance of maintaining this skill in the face of increasingly advanced AI tools. The term is used to highlight the unique and irreplaceable aspects of human intelligence in the engineering field.

💡Troll

In the context of the video, trolling refers to the act of posting controversial or provocative content to elicit a strong reaction from others. The speaker admits to using trolling tactics with their tweet about Co-pilot to spark discussion and attention within the tech community. The term is used to describe a strategy for engaging an audience and encouraging them to think critically about the role of AI in their work.

💡Community

Community in the video refers to the group of followers, subscribers, and engaged individuals who share the speaker's content and participate in discussions. The speaker encourages viewers to join their community, indicating a desire to build a supportive and interactive network of people interested in technology and engineering. The term is used to foster a sense of belonging and collaboration among the audience.

💡Grandma

In the video, the mention of 'Grandma' serves as a personal and emotional appeal to the audience. The speaker shares a personal goal of reaching 100K subscribers by the end of the year to make their grandmother proud before she passes away. This term is used to create a connection with the audience, showing vulnerability and adding a human element to the speaker's message.

💡Fintech

Fintech, short for financial technology, is a term used in the video to describe the industry focused on innovative technology solutions for financial services. The speaker mentions their involvement in fintech, indicating that their work is at the intersection of technology and finance. The term is used to provide context for the type of problems the speaker and their company are trying to solve and the innovative nature of their work.

Highlights

The tweet stating 'if you use co-pilot or something similar, I won't hire you' has caused a stir in the tech community.

The speaker is not entirely against co-pilot, but believes it can hinder creative thinking in engineering.

The speaker has a goal of reaching 100K subscribers to make their grandmother proud before she passes away.

AI tools like Chat GPT are used daily by the speaker, but not for innovative tasks.

The speaker values the ability to come up with creative solutions over writing boilerplate code quickly.

Co-pilot can help with productivity in certain company environments, but it's not a replacement for innovative thinking.

The speaker emphasizes that engineering is about solving problems and bringing value through technology.

AI tools should complement human abilities, not replace the need for innovation.

The speaker has a startup in Europe and is looking to hire like-minded engineers.

The tweet was partly a troll to get people's attention and spark discussion.

The speaker believes that AI cannot innovate at the current time and is good for replicating tasks.

Coding should be seen as an art form, like painting, and not just about filling in the blanks.

The speaker encourages the community to not take everything at face value and to think critically.

The speaker's company, Lau, is involved in fintech and has done multiple acquisitions.

The speaker advocates for a balance between using AI tools and maintaining one's own creative problem-solving skills.

The tweet was meant to provoke thought and discussion about the role of AI in engineering.

The speaker concludes by reiterating the importance of not being too emotionally attached to AI tools.

Transcripts

if you use co-pilot or something similar

I won't hire you that's a tweet I made

yesterday and it's causing the Tech

Community by storm I don't know what's

going on people are so emotional um the

question rather it is do I is do I mean

this tweet or not is this a troll uh

what the hell is going on and why I

actually posted that but before we

continue with this video guys listen I

said it before I promised my grandma to

have 100K subscribers by the end of the

year and my grandma has not long to live

anymore so please don't let Grandma down

make her proud right join the community

uh the links Discord Community the links

are all in the description so let me

know guys what you think about this

tweet uh what you think about this

statement of course first check out the

video so you know the context about what

I actually are trying to say with that

let leave them in the comments I'm uh

very curious to see what you guys think

about that all right so let's continue

so basically if you use co-pilot or

something similar I won't hire you do I

mean this tweet uh of course not right

uh I

think in in the engineering world people

people are free to use whatever they

want right uh that's what it is of

course do I like co-pilot of course not

I think it's BS uh but that's that's

everybody that's everybody's own opinion

so why did I make this tweet guys and

I'm going to explain why I think

co-pilot is BS so the prim agent Mr

Prime himself made this tweet also

yesterday I guess uh I am one week

without co-pilot I'm really happy I

don't use it anymore it's honestly a

relief and it's hard to describe

describe why right I saw this tweet and

I said man actually this is so true um

I'm happy that he basically experienced

that because he's using copilot for a

while now and I just made this

tweet without thinking and like maybe

some kind of a troll a troll tweet and

everybody is basically uh emotionally

hurt you know what I mean people did not

sleep yesterday unfortunately so the

thing

is that what worries me the most what I

learned by all these comments here uh is

that a lot of people are so emotionally

attached to their AI tools and am I

going to hire somebody that's basically

have copilot active of course right why

why wouldn't I everybody does what he

wants uh but am I going to hire people

that are so emotionally attached you you

check the comments out it's wild man

people are basically it's like an a

complete new uh Rel belief system uh

that is being invented uh it's crazy and

it's going to basically block your

career right um so why do I think

co-pilot is actually um not that great

first of all I use AI tools all the time

right I even made startups with AI uh I

built it in three weeks without co-pilot

and it's making more money already than

you basically earn in a month but that's

something else without co-pilot because

people say they are way faster than me

and people are I don't know people are

crazy man these comments it's it's

insane I use chat GPT every day right

and how do I use it um I think I use

chat GPT as a better as a Google search

on steroids right uh most of the time I

already know chat GPT is going to

basically give me or not the

code that I want but it's going to guide

me in a certain direction it's going to

guide me some packages I need to import

it's going to guide me it's going to

help me uh fill in the blank spaces in

my brain whenever I want to right the

problem with co-pilot is that co-pilot

is basically vomiting codes in your

editor all the time and is it

going to help you with writing boilers

plate yes it's it it will it will right

it's going to write boilers plate and

it's going to do that very well the

problem

is productivity in engineering depends

on on your company because a lot of I

call them PR monkeys right A lot of

people are uh in some kind of a big

company and the only thing you need to

do is these simple tasks bum bum bum bum

from 9 to 5 the all these simple task

and go pilot can probably help you with

that of course uh we need these people

also right uh but the thing is

that you can see that in my streams if I

code if I if I do live

coding I like to write this border plate

code because the moment you write boiler

plate

code you can basically do that on an

automated pilot not co-pilot but like on

an automatic pilot like a muscle memory

and in the time that I'm w writing that

code in the time that I'm writing this

boiler plate code I'm already thinking a

step ahead on the problem right and you

can see that in my live stream most of

the time I'm writing that code and

suddenly oh guys wait I have a I have a

better idea and I basically delete my

code and write it again so it writing

this boiler plate code gives me gives my

brain the time to think about the

problem to time to think on what what

what code is coming next what's coming

next what's the next pattern what's the

next what's the next step to do here to

come to my solution and it sometimes it

Alters the code that I'm actually going

to write sometimes it Alters the Border

plate I need to write and if you have

something like co-pilot it's going to

Boom instantly paste vomit code on your

um on your on your on your

screen but you don't have time to think

about what's next and you're basically

are so used to getting these things

printed

in I don't know it doesn't work for me

it doesn't work for me and I would love

to and I have these Engineers on my team

and if you don't know why I have this

company laue it's it's it's a big

company uh in Belgium actually in Europe

to be honest um 8 million of funding

written in goine Temple all that stuff

check it out it's it's wide open we did

three Acquisitions already so um I'm

trying to hire Engineers that are kind

of like-minded of course not everybody

has the same but I want people that can

think because productivity in

engineering does not come from how fast

can I write boilerplate

code productivity comes from how fast

can I creatively innovate new solutions

for the problems I am that I'm occurring

right that are occurring that I need to

solve because we at laue we have so much

we are basically innovating the whole

Tech scene about the finance the fintech

the the recurring Revenue funding of

course there are a lot of companies

right now but we were basically four

years ago we were one of the first so we

need to do a lot of innovating thinking

outside of the box with how we going to

we're going to do these things

and boiler plate is not going to help us

right co-pilot cannot innovate I already

told this before in other videos like AI

is good AI is great and I think

everybody should use it I'm using it all

the time but we cannot you we cannot

block our own create creative

thinking our own Innovative Thinking by

these tools and that's what happening

right that's what that's what starts to

happen and these AIS they they they

cannot innovate but maybe they can in in

10 years I don't know what's

going on we need to whatever happens at

the moment we we we need to adjust right

that's life we need to adjust on new

technologies every every time and every

day but they at this moment of time they

cannot innovate right they can only

replicate so

productivity does not come from writing

boiler plate productivity comes from how

fast can an engineer come up with

Creative Solutions Innovative thinking

outside of the box solutions for the

problem right and most of the time it's

not going to be a complete product at

levenue we we do a lot of trial and

errors right we come up at some quick

and dirty uh proof of concept uh that's

nobody that's never been done before and

we're going to test that is that working

is that not working how does it feel how

does it go what do we think about that

uh that's that's what I'm trying to say

with this uh co-pilot tweet but I'm not

a big fan I think coding is like

painting like Bob Ross The Joy of

Painting it's going to be the joy of

programming I think um having somebody

paint stuff into your canvas is going to

block your creativity it's going to uh

basically impact the result right maybe

maybe your trees maybe your Forest maybe

your landscape is going to be painted

way

faster but maybe it's not exactly the

landscape you had in mind you know what

I mean maybe it's going to block your

further

creative shapes you want to put into it

you know what I mean it's really hard to

explain it's also probably really hard

to understand for new people coming into

coding people that are just like two

three four years in um it's because

you're already used to all this

technology but engineering is not

writing code right engineering is not

neovim engineering is not vs code

engineering is not your language

python Ruby whatever engineering is

solving a problem man solving a problem

bringing value through technology uh to

an end user or or or something like that

right and that's what people tend to

forget and that's basically what I

trying to teach what I'm trying to

preach um in my videos and in in my

community and in my presence online and

sometimes it hurts some feelings but

guys do not always take everything what

I say for granted right also a little

bit of a troll but sometimes you need to

do that um to get people's attention

right from time to time and you don't

need to believe me um like I said you're

free you're free to use whatever you

want that's good for me I will still

hire you but um that's basically what I

mean by that right um don't be too

emotionally attached to these AI tools

they will they are here to help us they

are here to um comp how do you say that

to complement us um but they will never

be here to replace us because there's

always needs to be some Innovation there

always needs to be some creative

Innovation and that's what I where I see

AI lacking for a very very long time um

so if you want to still be how you say

that if you still want to be if you want

to still have some meaning in your

career try to shift a little bit away uh

of course you can use it but try to

shift a little bit away emotionally from

these tools and try to focus a little

bit more on creative

engineering right in the in the in the

bigger scope um than only languages

editors and tools right uh so that's

what is for the people that I heard with

this tweet I'm not sorry uh because hey

sometimes you need to be heard to change

right I mean that happens with me all

the

time that's what I want to say guys I

hope you had something about this video

this is coming from somebody with a lot

of experience with a lot of failures but

also a lot of successes right so

whatever you do with this that up to you

and whatever happens

still we are still going to be uh we're

still going to be friends and like I

said before don't let Grandma down

subscribe to the channel so I can reach

these 100K and my Grandma will be proud

before she pass

away thanks for watching this video and

I'm looking forward to see you in one of

my next live streams or videos bye-bye