Splatoon 2 is Better Than Splatoon 3, IMO

Summary

The video discusses the creator's controversial opinion that Splatoon 2 is better than Splatoon 3. The creator compares the live service eras of both games, noting that Splatoon 2 offered more fun, unpredictable updates, and immersive experiences, particularly during Splatfests. They also highlight the superior weapon kits and map designs in Splatoon 2, contrasting them with issues in Splatoon 3's design. The creator acknowledges that these opinions are subjective but stresses how Splatoon 2 felt like a unique experience in ways that Splatoon 3 hasn't matched yet.

Takeaways

• 🎮 Splatoon 2 is often viewed more fondly by the creator than Splatoon 3, which is a controversial opinion in the community.
• 🕹️ Comparing the live service era of Splatoon 2 (2017-2020) to Splatoon 3 (2022-now) is more meaningful than comparing the current states of both games.
• 😄 Splatoon 2 had more fun and engaging updates compared to the predictable and somewhat boring updates of Splatoon 3.
• 🎉 Splatoon 2's Splatfests were a unique, exciting experience that many players feel can't be replicated in Splatoon 3.
• 📜 The creator highlights the excitement of using the Killer Whale for the first time and other nostalgic memories from Splatoon 2.
• 🔫 Weapon kit balancing in Splatoon 2 was better, and the idea of a third weapon kit is sorely missed in Splatoon 3.
• 🗺️ Map design in Splatoon 2 was more distinct, with a clearer sense of place within the world of Inkopolis compared to the disorienting maps of Splatoon 3.
• 💬 Splatoon 2 veterans tend to have fond memories of specific Shifty Station maps, which added variety and excitement to the game.
• 🎨 The style and art design of Splatoon 2 felt more cohesive, with maps that made players feel like they were truly in Inkopolis.
• 📖 Side Order from Splatoon 3 is considered the worst story in the series, while Octo Expansion in Splatoon 2 is praised for its storytelling.

Q & A

Why does the speaker prefer Splatoon 2 over Splatoon 3?

The speaker prefers Splatoon 2 because its live service era, updates, and special events like Splatfests felt more engaging and exciting compared to the more predictable updates of Splatoon 3. They also believe Splatoon 2's content was more memorable and unique.

What is the speaker’s main criticism of Splatoon 3?

The main criticism is that Splatoon 3 has less exciting and predictable updates, uninspired weapon kits, and maps that lack the distinctive style and charm of Splatoon 2. Additionally, they feel that the content in Splatoon 3 is less engaging compared to the updates in Splatoon 2.

How does the speaker compare the map design of Splatoon 2 and Splatoon 3?

The speaker believes Splatoon 2 had a more cohesive map design that made players feel like they were part of the world of Inkopolis, while Splatoon 3 has maps that feel disconnected and hard to place in the game’s world.

What was special about Splatoon 2's Splatfests according to the speaker?

Splatoon 2's Splatfests were special because they featured unique maps like MC Princess Diaries, provided monthly updates, and created memorable moments that players still remember fondly. The speaker argues that Splatoon 3’s Splatfests have not been able to replicate this experience.

What does the speaker think about the weapon kits in Splatoon 3?

The speaker feels that Splatoon 3's weapon kits are poorly designed and less balanced compared to Splatoon 2. They are disappointed by the lack of good weapon kits in Splatoon 3 and miss the diversity and balance of kits in the previous game.

How does the speaker feel about the lore in Splatoon 3 compared to Splatoon 2?

The speaker finds Splatoon 3’s lore confusing and hard to access, especially compared to Splatoon 2. They highlight the difficulty in understanding where certain maps are located and feel that Splatoon 2's world was more immersive and clear.

What does the speaker say about the Octo Expansion in Splatoon 2?

The speaker praises the Octo Expansion in Splatoon 2 as one of the best examples of storytelling in a Nintendo game. They consider it to be some of the highest-quality storytelling Nintendo has produced, especially in the context of Splatoon.

Why does the speaker find Splatoon 2's live service era superior to Splatoon 3's?

The speaker believes Splatoon 2's live service era (2017-2020) was more dynamic and fun, with monthly updates, special events, and unique maps. In contrast, Splatoon 3’s live service updates feel repetitive and less creative.

What criticism does the speaker have regarding the maps in Splatoon 3?

The speaker criticizes Splatoon 3 for having more maps from previous games (Splatoon 1 and 2) than unique new maps. They feel the maps in Splatoon 3 lack the same character and connection to the game’s world compared to the maps in Splatoon 2.

How does the speaker address differing opinions about Splatoon 2 vs. Splatoon 3?

The speaker acknowledges that everyone is entitled to their own opinion and that it’s fine to prefer Splatoon 3 over Splatoon 2. They emphasize that at the end of the day, it’s just a game, but they humorously point out that the Splatoon community is often divided over these opinions.