Apa Kabar Anime Sekarang? Mana yang Ratingnya Naik dan Turun?

Megane Sensei

21 Sept 202406:56

Summary

TLDRThe video discusses current anime ratings and viewer reception. It highlights how certain anime, like 'Oshi no Ko' and 'Fairy Tail,' maintain high ratings, while others, such as 'Alya,' see drops despite strong fan support. The speaker questions how anime like 'Fairy Tail,' often criticized online, holds a solid 7.95 rating, and compares it with other shows like 'Make Heroin' that succeed due to fresh storytelling. They also express surprise at 'BL' anime outperforming many isekai titles, calling into question fan preferences and discussing the hype vs. rating disconnect.

Takeaways

🎶 The speaker starts by discussing anime ratings for the current season, including 'Oshi no Ko' and 'Fairy Tail' with a 7.9 rating.
🤔 The speaker is surprised that 'Fairy Tail' maintains a high rating despite frequently being criticized online for its 'nakama power' theme.
📉 'Alya' anime has seen its rating drop from 8+ to 7.87, which doesn't align with its heavy social media presence.
🧐 The speaker questions why 'Alya' dominates their timeline, speculating it may be due to its Russian character twist.
💡 'Makai Heroin' is praised for having more to offer beyond typical 'waifu' content, including a fresh romance story and excellent visual execution.
😱 The speaker points out that 'Kanoko' has dropped drastically in rating, now at 7.3, from its previous higher score.
👀 The speaker is shocked that a 'homo' anime (likely BL) has a higher rating than almost all isekai anime this season, with some isekai falling to ratings as low as 6 or 5.
🎞️ The speaker mentions various anime like 'Overlord,' 'Tensura,' and 'Monogatari' which have maintained high ratings, particularly 'Monogatari' at 9.
💥 Despite lower ratings during the season, the speaker believes that anime like 'Alya' and 'Vistoria' could see a ratings boost once they finish airing.
🔥 The speaker is intrigued by 'Mega Min Cafe' having a 7.5 rating, which they find surprisingly high.

Q & A

What anime is considered to have the highest rating in the current season?
-According to the script, 'Oshi no Ko' currently holds the highest rating in the season.
Which anime's rating has dropped unexpectedly?
-'Alya' saw a significant drop in its rating, initially starting at 8.x but now down to 7.87.
What are some of the criticisms of 'Fairy Tail' mentioned in the script?
-'Fairy Tail' is often criticized for its reliance on 'nakama power' or friendship power, yet it still holds a relatively high rating of 7.95.
Why is 'Alya' mentioned frequently in social media, despite its rating drop?
-'Alya' frequently appears in the timeline because of its Russian character, which has garnered a lot of attention despite the anime's rating declining.
What differentiates 'Make Heroin' from 'Alya' in terms of quality?
-'Make Heroin' is praised for its fresh romance concept and well-executed visuals, while 'Alya' is seen as more of a typical school romance with a unique twist of having a Russian female lead.
How does the script describe the ratings versus the hype for 'Alya'?
-The script notes that the hype for 'Alya' does not align with its rating, which has dropped from over 8 to 7.87 despite appearing frequently on social media.
What is surprising about the rating of 'Megami Café'?
-'Megami Café' has a surprisingly high rating of 7.5, which is mentioned as unexpected given its content.
How does the script describe anime fans’ opinions on 'BL' (Boys' Love) anime compared to isekai anime?
-The script highlights that 'BL' anime currently has higher ratings than many isekai anime this season, suggesting that isekai fans might have poorer taste, according to the speaker.
Which anime are seen as having potential for a ratings increase by the end of the season?
-'Alya' and 'Vistoria' are mentioned as having the potential to improve their ratings once they conclude.
How does the speaker feel about 'Oshi no Ko' and 'Make Heroin' compared to other anime?
-The speaker considers both 'Oshi no Ko' and 'Make Heroin' to be high-quality anime and finds it reasonable that they hold top spots in the ratings.

Outlines

00:00

📊 Analyzing Anime Ratings for the Current Season

The speaker starts by checking the ratings of currently popular anime, noting that 'Oshi no Ko' and 'Make Heroines' have received high ratings, while 'Fairy Tail' surprisingly holds a 7.95 rating. Despite being a widely criticized anime for its 'nakama power' or friendship-based plot, its rating remains solid. In contrast, the hype around 'Alya' doesn’t align with its rating, which has dropped to 7.87. The speaker expresses confusion over the constant presence of 'Alya' on their timeline, suggesting its popularity is driven more by fan service and its Russian-themed characters. They reflect on how anime like 'Make Heroines' succeeds due to its fresh romance concept, while 'Alya' follows a more typical school romance trope.

05:04

🛡️ Comparing Anime Genres: Romance, BL, and Isekai

The speaker continues by comparing the ratings of romance and isekai anime. 'Senpai wa Otokonoko,' a BL (Boys' Love) anime, has a higher rating than 99% of the current season’s isekai anime, which the speaker views as generally poor in quality. They humorously critique isekai fans, calling their tastes 'trash' in comparison to BL fans. Noteworthy anime like 'Tensura' (That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime) maintain higher ratings, offering a beacon of hope for isekai lovers. They also point out that some anime tend to see their ratings rise after the season ends, such as 'Alya' and 'Vistoria,' indicating potential for improvement as more viewers finish the series.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Oshi no Ko

Oshi no Ko is an anime title that is frequently mentioned as one of the highest-rated anime of the season. It highlights its popularity and critical success in contrast to other shows. The speaker emphasizes the significance of its rating, showcasing it as the benchmark of quality for this season.

💡Alya

Alya is another anime discussed in the video, but it is noted for having a rating that has dropped significantly from its original score. The speaker expresses surprise at the hype around Alya compared to its current rating, implying a disconnect between online discussions and actual critical reception.

💡Fairy Tail

Fairy Tail is referenced as an anime that is often ridiculed online for its 'nakama power' (power of friendship) trope. Despite this criticism, it maintains a high rating (7.95), which the speaker finds surprising, given its frequent mockery within the anime community.

💡Nakama power

Nakama power refers to a common trope in anime where characters overcome challenges through the power of friendship. This concept is particularly tied to Fairy Tail, where it is often criticized for being overused, yet it still has a strong fanbase as reflected in its rating.

💡Make Heroin

Make Heroin is another anime title that the speaker praises for its high rating and fresh romance concept. It is highlighted as having good execution in both story and visuals, which sets it apart from more typical anime like Alya, making it more critically successful.

💡Isekai

Isekai is a genre of anime where characters are transported to another world, often involving fantasy or gaming elements. The speaker discusses how most isekai anime this season have low ratings compared to other genres, suggesting that the genre's quality may have declined.

💡Fan service

Fan service refers to elements in anime that are added to please the audience, often through suggestive content or visual appeal. In the script, fan service is mentioned in connection to Alya and other anime, suggesting that shows relying on fan service may not always receive high ratings.

💡Rating drop

Rating drop is a recurring concept in the video, where the speaker notes several anime, like Alya and Kanoko, experiencing a decline in their ratings over time. This trend contrasts with their initial hype or high scores, revealing a shift in viewer perception as the season progresses.

💡Shikaku

Shikaku is mentioned as the highest-rated isekai anime of the season, with a score of 7.07. Despite its relatively low rating compared to other genres, it stands out among isekai anime, reflecting the overall weaker performance of this genre during the current anime season.

💡BL anime

BL (Boys' Love) anime refers to a genre focused on romantic relationships between male characters. The speaker contrasts the high rating of a BL anime with the lower ratings of isekai anime this season, using it as a point of humor and surprise about shifting tastes within the anime community.

Highlights

Checking the current ratings for the new anime season, especially Oshinoko and other top-rated shows.

Fairy Tail has a surprising rating of 7.95, despite often being mocked on the internet.

Alya's rating dropped to 7.87, which doesn't match the hype it generates online.

Oshinoko and Make Heroine stand out as the highest-rated anime this season.

Review mentions of Alya being overhyped due to fan service but lacking substantial narrative quality.

Alya's constant presence on social media despite not being searched for highlights its unusual popularity.

Make Heroine is praised for its fresh romance concept and excellent execution.

Discussion around why Alya's Russian character twist didn't elevate its rating beyond the visual appeal.

Observation that fan service-heavy anime tend to garner more attention, even with lower ratings.

Surprise at how some highly visual-based anime are ranked alongside more complex storytelling anime like Fairy Tail.

A sharp drop in ratings for shows like Si Kanoko, which fell to 7.3 despite initial high expectations.

Shikaku is one of the few isekai anime to maintain a rating above 7, highlighting the lackluster performance of isekai this season.

Anime such as 'Senpai wa Otokonoko' outperformed most isekai anime, drawing attention to the shift in audience preferences.

Strong commentary on how even BL anime are rating higher than many isekai titles, hinting at changing tastes.

Predictions that Alya and other titles might see a rating surge once they conclude their seasons.