Cracks in the US-Israel relationship are beginning to show | The Listening Post

Al Jazeera English
30 Mar 202424:57

Summary

TLDRThe United Nations Security Council passes a ceasefire resolution in response to the crisis in Gaza, but its effectiveness is questioned as Israel continues its actions and the US calls it non-binding. The role of media in shaping public opinion is highlighted, with Western media criticized for biased coverage. Additionally, the use of mass surveillance by Israel in Gaza and the political strategy of India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi's re-election campaign are discussed, emphasizing the power of technology and messaging in contemporary politics.

Takeaways

  • 🌍 A ceasefire resolution at the United Nations regarding Gaza was passed, marking a significant moment despite Israel's non-compliance and the US's declaration of it being non-binding.
  • 📡 The resolution's defiance by Israel and the lack of enforcement highlight challenges in the international rules-based order, where rules are selectively applied.
  • 🇺🇸 The US's stance of supporting the resolution's objectives while labeling it non-binding illustrates complex political dynamics and undermines the resolution's impact.
  • 🔍 The lack of interest from American news outlets in the story underscores media biases and the influence of domestic politics on coverage of international events.
  • 🔎 Accusations against the UN of anti-Semitism by Israeli officials reflect tensions and the complex history of Israel's relationship with the UN.
  • 📲 Narendra Modi's reelection campaign in India is powered by an extensive ground campaign and a digital blitz, leveraging WhatsApp and social media.
  • 🗳️ Modi's government's control over mainstream media and its portrayal in a positive light showcase the interplay between politics and media in shaping public perception.
  • 🛰️ Israel's use of surveillance technology in Gaza for control and monitoring raises human rights and privacy concerns.
  • 💡 The BJP's election strategy in India combines extensive volunteer networks and digital platforms, showcasing the power of technology in modern political campaigns.
  • 🚫 Criticism of the UN special rapporteur on Palestine by the US and Israeli governments highlights the contentious nature of discourse surrounding the Israel-Palestine conflict.

Q & A

  • What was the significance of the United Nations Security Council resolution demanding a ceasefire in Gaza?

    -The resolution was significant as it marked the first time the UN Security Council called for a ceasefire in Gaza, and it represented a potential shift in the international community's stance towards Israel's actions. However, the US's characterization of the resolution as 'non-binding' and Israel's defiance of it complicate the situation and raise questions about the effectiveness of such resolutions.

  • How has the Israeli media reacted to the UN's call for a ceasefire?

    -The Israeli media has shown almost unanimous opposition to the UN vote, with some officials dismissing the UN as anti-Semitic. This reaction reflects a broader narrative in Israel that views international criticism as biased and unjustified.

  • What does the US's stance on the UN resolution's binding nature indicate?

    -The US's claim that the resolution is 'non-binding' suggests a reluctance to pressure Israel into changing its actions. This stance has been criticized as hypocritical and politically motivated, as it undermines the authority of the UN Security Council and sends a message to Israel that it can act with impunity.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 UN Ceasefire Resolution and International Reactions

A ceasefire resolution was passed at the United Nations, calling for a ceasefire in Gaza, marking a significant event despite Israel's refusal to comply and the U.S. declaring it non-binding. This resolution's passage could signify a pivotal moment in Israel's increasing international isolation, challenging its Western backers. The resolution, defied by Israel through its continued bombardment of Palestinians, complicates the defense of Israel's actions by its allies. The lack of interest from American media and the resolution being labeled non-binding by the U.S. ambassador to the UN raises questions about the enforcement and implications of such resolutions. Despite the resolution, the violence and killing in Gaza by Israeli forces continued, underscoring the deep challenges in implementing and honoring ceasefire agreements.

05:03

📰 Media Coverage and Domestic Politics Influencing International Perceptions

The story explores the complex dynamics between media coverage, domestic politics, and international relations, focusing on the lack of American media attention to the UN ceasefire resolution and its implications for Israel and the U.S. This neglect is attributed to domestic political considerations, especially within the U.S., where media outlets aligned with the Democratic Party are cautious about covering the resolution unfavorably ahead of presidential elections. The narrative also touches on the consistent portrayal of Palestine in Western media through an Israeli lens, influenced by social media's rise, which challenges mainstream narratives and exposes the limitations of Western media's coverage on issues like the Israeli forces raiding hospitals in Gaza.

10:04

🔍 Surveillance, Elections, and Propaganda in Conflict and Politics

This section delves into the use of surveillance technology by Israel in Gaza and its implications for the Palestinian population, illustrating a broader trend of technology's role in conflict and control. It further transitions into the political landscape in India, highlighting Prime Minister Narendra Modi's reelection campaign's reliance on a combination of ground-level volunteer networks and digital messaging, particularly through WhatsApp, to influence voters and spread propaganda. This narrative underscores the evolving nature of political campaigns and governance in the digital age, where technology plays a crucial role in shaping public opinion and election outcomes.

15:06

📲 Modi's Political Strategy and the BJP's Dominance

The narrative focuses on Narendra Modi's political strategy, emphasizing his effective use of media and technology to bolster his image and the BJP's dominant position in Indian politics. It details Modi's omnipresence in Indian media, his strategic use of WhatsApp to communicate directly with the electorate, and the BJP's comprehensive messaging tailored to various constituencies. The piece highlights the financial and organizational strength of the BJP, including its extensive volunteer network and the significant financial resources at its disposal, enabling an unparalleled election strategy and emphasizing the party's ambition and the challenges it poses to the democratic playing field in India.

20:07

🗳️ Electoral Bonds Controversy and Modi's Campaign Innovations

This section examines the controversy surrounding electoral bonds in India and their impact on the BJP's funding, leading to a discussion on the broader implications for democracy and transparency. The narrative describes how the BJP leveraged these funds to craft a pervasive public relations campaign and build an organizational behemoth, outmatching opposition parties in reach and resources. It also portrays the BJP's strategic approach to electioneering, including personalized voter outreach and the exploitation of digital platforms for propaganda, underscoring the sophistication of Modi's campaign strategy and its implications for the political landscape in India.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Ceasefire Resolution

A ceasefire resolution refers to an agreement or proposal made within international bodies like the United Nations to halt hostilities between conflicting parties for a certain period. In the context of the video, a ceasefire resolution was passed concerning the conflict in Gaza, aiming to pause the violence. Despite the resolution's passage, it's mentioned that Israel did not honor it, and the US deemed it non-binding. This reflects the complex dynamics of international politics, where resolutions, even when passed, may not lead to immediate changes on the ground due to the positions and actions of influential member states.

💡International Isolation

International isolation occurs when a country faces widespread condemnation or distancing from the global community, often due to its policies or actions. The video suggests that Israel's continued bombardment and treatment of Palestinians could mark a pivotal moment leading to its increased international isolation, especially as the US declined to veto a UN resolution demanding a ceasefire. This concept is significant because it underscores the potential consequences of international relations and diplomacy, affecting a nation's standing and support globally.

💡UN Security Council

The UN Security Council is one of the six principal organs of the United Nations, charged with ensuring international peace and security. It has the power to make legally binding decisions that member states are obligated to follow. The video discusses a specific instance where the Security Council passed a resolution demanding a ceasefire in Gaza, highlighting the council's role in addressing international conflicts. However, it also points out the complexities, as the US labeled the resolution 'non-binding', challenging the usual understanding of Security Council resolutions' authority.

💡Non-binding

In international law, 'non-binding' refers to agreements, resolutions, or declarations that do not carry legal obligations for the parties involved. The video mentions the US ambassador to the UN arguing that, unlike other Security Council resolutions, the one on Gaza's ceasefire was non-binding. This statement is controversial as it contradicts the general view that Security Council resolutions are legally binding, indicating a deviation in how different actors interpret or wish to adhere to international norms and laws.

💡Ethnic Cleansing

Ethnic cleansing involves the removal of a certain ethnic or religious group from a specific area through force or intimidation to create a homogenous region. The video describes the situation in Gaza as involving aspects of ethnic cleansing, compounded by Israeli surveillance technology. This terminology underscores the severity of the conflict's impact on the civilian population, highlighting human rights concerns and the drastic measures taken against Palestinians.

💡Surveillance Technology

Surveillance technology includes various tools and systems used for monitoring and collecting information on individuals or groups. The video outlines how Israel employs such technology in Gaza, part of a broader strategy to control and suppress the Palestinian population. This utilization of technology for surveillance in conflict zones raises ethical and privacy concerns, especially regarding the impact on civilians' rights and freedoms.

💡WhatsApp

WhatsApp is highlighted in the video as a tool used in Narendra Modi's reelection campaign in India, demonstrating the platform's power in disseminating information and influencing public opinion. The mention of WhatsApp underscores the significance of social media and messaging apps in modern political campaigns, allowing for direct communication with voters and the spread of propaganda or disinformation.

💡International Rules-based Order

This term refers to the concept of conducting international relations according to a set of agreed-upon rules and norms, including respect for sovereignty, human rights, and legal obligations. The video critiques the selective application of these rules, as evidenced by the US and Israel's response to the UN ceasefire resolution. The discussion points to a broader debate on the effectiveness and fairness of the international system, particularly when powerful states may bypass or reinterpret the rules to their advantage.

💡Mainstream Media

Mainstream media refers to the predominant mass media outlets that reach a large audience. The video criticizes the American mainstream media's lack of interest in the UN resolution on Gaza, suggesting a bias or unwillingness to challenge the US government's position. This concept is crucial for understanding the role media plays in shaping public opinion and the narrative around significant events, revealing potential biases and gaps in coverage.

💡Genocide

Genocide involves deliberate actions aimed at destroying, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. The video mentions a report titled 'Anatomy of a Genocide' regarding Israel's actions in Gaza, indicating the severe level of accusation against Israeli policies towards Palestinians. This term is significant as it represents one of the most serious accusations in international law, reflecting on the gravity of the conflict's impact on the Palestinian population.

Highlights

The United Nations Security Council passes a ceasefire resolution, marking a pivotal moment for Israel's international isolation.

The US declines to use its veto, signaling a potential shift in its stance towards Israel's actions.

Israel continues its bombardment and defiance of the UN resolution, highlighting the difficulty for Western backers to defend its actions.

American news outlets show a lack of interest in covering the story, possibly due to discomfort with the implications of the US's mixed message on international rules.

The US ambassador to the UN incorrectly claims the resolution is non-binding, which is contrary to the UN Charter and could embolden Israel's defiance.

Israel's media shows near-unanimous opposition to the UN vote and a lack of interest in international law or criticism.

The Indian election campaign uses technology and social media, including WhatsApp, to spread propaganda and influence voters.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi's party, the BJP, has a significant advantage in media coverage and funding, which could impact the election's fairness.

The BJP's extensive ground network and messaging strategy create a powerful electoral machine that reaches every corner of the country.

The Indian election process is marked by a lack of a level playing field, with the BJP dominating the political landscape.

Israel's use of surveillance technology in Gaza contributes to a dystopian reality for Palestinians, with severe consequences for those wrongly identified as threats.

The UN Special Rapporteur on Palestine publishes a report titled 'Anatomy of a Genocide,' which is rejected by both the Israeli government and the US State Department.

The US State Department's spokesman is criticized for accusing the UN Special Rapporteur of anti-Semitism without evidence, reflecting a pattern of attempting to discredit critics of Israel.

The Israeli military uses Gaza as a testing ground for new methods of killing and spying on Palestinians, turning the area into a 'hellscape'.

The BJP's use of electoral bonds has made it the wealthiest political party in India, allowing it to fund an extensive PR and organizational machine.

The BJP's messaging strategy focuses on presenting Modi as a strong, unapologetic leader and a symbol of development for India.

The Indian political landscape is deeply polarized, with domestic politics influencing media coverage and public opinion.

The international community's double standards and hypocrisy are exposed by the situation in Gaza, leading to a loss of moral authority.

The BJP's extensive use of social media and technology in elections represents a new frontier in political campaigning, with potential implications for democracy.

Transcripts

play00:00

finally a ceasefire resolution passes at

play00:03

the United Nations but what difference

play00:05

does it make when Israel will not honor

play00:08

it and the US calls it

play00:10

non-binding in Gaza the horrors of

play00:12

ethnic cleansing are compounded by

play00:15

Israeli surveillance technology and

play00:18

Narendra modi's reelection campaign in

play00:21

India powered by an army of foot

play00:23

soldiers on the ground and a messaging

play00:25

Blitz on

play00:28

WhatsApp

play00:33

this past week's United Nations security

play00:36

Council resolution demanding a ceasefire

play00:38

in Gaza the first to do so is

play00:41

significant although not for the reasons

play00:43

its authors may have intended the

play00:46

passage of the resolution at the highest

play00:48

body of the UN with the US declining to

play00:51

use its veto could Mark a pivotal moment

play00:54

in Israel's increasing International

play00:57

isolation for its Western backers the

play00:59

fact that Israel through its continued

play01:01

bombardment and starvation of

play01:03

Palestinians is defying that resolution

play01:07

makes their role that much harder to

play01:08

defend in the Israeli media the

play01:10

opposition to the UN vote is almost

play01:13

unanimous more striking is the lack of

play01:16

interest from American news outlets the

play01:18

implications this story raises are a

play01:21

little uncomfortable for them as well

play01:23

they hit close to home because a fallacy

play01:26

has been exposed the one about the

play01:28

us-led inter interntional rules-based

play01:31

order in which the rules are selectively

play01:36

applied we those in favor of the draft

play01:39

resolution please there raise their hand

play01:43

it was the ultimate mixed message sent

play01:45

from Washington to Tel Aviv that upon

play01:47

examination amounts to some cynical

play01:50

politics

play01:55

abion for at least 32,000 Palestinians

play01:59

in G

play02:00

including those who have been starved to

play02:02

death in front of our eyes the ceasefire

play02:05

resolution that passed at the United

play02:07

Nation Security Council this past week

play02:10

comes too late for those still getting

play02:13

killed by Israel's bombing of Rafa the

play02:16

patients and medical staff at alifa

play02:18

hospital still getting shot by Israeli

play02:20

soldiers it has had no discernable

play02:23

effect after vetoing three previous

play02:26

ceasefire resolutions the American

play02:28

government finally allowed this one

play02:30

which would last just 2 weeks to carry

play02:33

but the US's ambassador to the UN then

play02:36

argued incorrectly according to Legal

play02:39

experts that unlike every other

play02:41

resolution the security Council has ever

play02:44

passed this one was in a category of its

play02:47

own that it was somehow

play02:49

non-binding we fully support some of the

play02:52

critical objectives in this non-binding

play02:54

resolution and we I hope she was being

play02:57

merely rhetorical because she certainly

play02:59

can't can't be speaking from a legal

play03:01

perspective all un Security Council

play03:04

resolutions are binding the UN Charter

play03:06

makes that perfectly clear it then takes

play03:09

another resolution to determine what

play03:12

actions will be taken if the parties

play03:14

defy it as Israel uh has said it's going

play03:18

to do but whether or not it's enforced

play03:20

it's certainly binding as a matter of

play03:22

law if the Americans are arguing that

play03:26

this is a non-binding resolution they

play03:28

are winking at Netanyahu by saying you

play03:30

really don't have to implement it the

play03:32

message to the Israelis is that you can

play03:35

carry on with the war until you achieve

play03:38

whatever objectives you have in mind I

play03:40

don't think uh Benjamin Netanyahu cares

play03:44

much about the International Community

play03:46

the United Nations security Council the

play03:48

UN they've made it clear within minutes

play03:51

of the resolution passing that the

play03:54

Israelis have no intention of abiding by

play03:56

it and indeed less than 24 hours after

play03:58

the passage of that resol olution about

play04:00

17 Palestinians were killed in an

play04:03

Israeli bombardment with scores of

play04:05

others injured so the message is clear

play04:07

Israel has no intention of abiding by

play04:09

resolution 2728 call on the parties to

play04:13

um cease

play04:15

fire the Netanyahu government put on a

play04:19

display of outrage over the Biden

play04:21

administration's refusal to veto the

play04:24

resolution by initially cancelling a

play04:26

visit by an Israeli delegation to

play04:28

Washington before or quietly

play04:30

rescheduling it it could have recalled

play04:33

its defense minister yoab Galant who was

play04:36

already in DC Shoring up more American

play04:39

Arms shipments to Israel it did not

play04:43

other political figures like security

play04:45

minister itamar benir dismissed the UN

play04:48

as

play04:49

anti-semitic this in a country that owes

play04:52

its very existence to the United Nations

play04:55

on the Israeli Airwaves the calls for

play04:58

Palestinian blood keep

play05:03

coming and partisan domestic politics

play05:06

are also a big part of the mix cast our

play05:10

mind back pre October 7th where you have

play05:13

a deeply polarized

play05:15

Society the anti- BBY Camp the

play05:18

demonstrations every week and the pro

play05:20

BBY Camp reaction splits along those

play05:23

lines what you will see from journalists

play05:26

in the anti-b camp is aha he we have bi

play05:30

destroying the reputation of

play05:43

Israel for the other

play05:45

side this is dangerous un America losing

play05:50

its

play05:58

way

play06:03

who's the guy who can stand up to this

play06:05

you guessed it Benjamin

play06:09

Nat what stands out in the American

play06:11

media coverage of this story is the

play06:14

noticeable lack of it for the US to fail

play06:17

to side with Israel at the UN is almost

play06:20

unheard of and is certainly newsworthy

play06:23

couple that with the legal side of the

play06:25

story The us arguing that a security

play06:28

Council resolution is somehow not

play06:30

binding one would expect journalists to

play06:33

test that position pick it apart we're

play06:36

not seeing that neither are American

play06:38

News consumers and like Israel domestic

play06:42

politics in the US are having an impact

play06:45

there has been a great deal of lack of

play06:48

interest uh uh in American media

play06:50

especially the so-called liberal media

play06:53

in the United States regarding the

play06:55

resolution the Biden Administration is

play06:57

trying to avoid the Fallout of the

play07:00

exstension and therefore media that are

play07:03

supportive of the democratic party made

play07:06

sure that they really did not dedicate

play07:08

so much time and coverage so that they

play07:11

would minimize any possible

play07:13

repercussions that would be exploited by

play07:15

their opponents in the Republican Party

play07:18

especially a few months before the

play07:19

presidential elections the lack of

play07:21

coverage it's consistent with the manner

play07:24

in which the question of Palestine has

play07:26

been

play07:27

represented in the uh West

play07:30

uh in mainstream media and that has

play07:32

basically been through the prism of an

play07:35

Israeli lens you're not Hamas Israel is

play07:38

a democracy and uh as a Jewish State uh

play07:42

supports and and believes in every life

play07:45

mattering and so and this is matched in

play07:48

Canadian and United Kingdom and other

play07:50

Western States foreign policies it's

play07:52

harder for the Western mainstream media

play07:55

to continue uh with their biased

play07:58

coverage in large park because you have

play08:01

the proliferation of social media from

play08:03

the gazin street to the rest of the

play08:06

world and because of the extent to which

play08:08

mainstream media in particular is very

play08:11

sensitive about being criticized from uh

play08:14

Israel and its uh right-wing supporters

play08:17

in particular it's been shy uh uh to

play08:21

highlight actions that are deemed to be

play08:24

critical of Israel is now actually

play08:26

supporting genocide okay we could maybe

play08:28

just avoid that language if that's okay

play08:30

for now because that is

play08:33

something and obviously a us vote of

play08:36

abstention on Security Council

play08:38

resolution demanding a ceasefire would

play08:40

certainly be something that they would

play08:42

wish to ignore or minimize or sweep

play08:46

under the

play08:47

rug among the other stories getting

play08:49

swept under Israeli forces raiding

play08:52

hospitals in Gaza such as Al shifa

play08:55

producing horrific testimonies of the

play08:57

coldblooded execution

play09:32

[Music]

play09:59

starved and so on and that coverage that

play10:01

is coming from below is challenging the

play10:03

Western media coverage on these things

play10:06

the Western

play10:08

media even subconsciously is aware that

play10:12

it is feeding Into The Narrative of the

play10:14

demise of its

play10:16

own

play10:18

standing outside of a western

play10:21

space it's

play10:23

done no one takes seriously Weston

play10:26

claims to be standing up for

play10:28

international nor no one wants to hear

play10:30

it after Gaza the world will not be

play10:32

lectured to there's no moral Soap Box to

play10:36

stand

play10:37

on it has dissolved away in the double

play10:42

[Applause]

play10:43

standards and the naked

play10:47

transparency of the hypocrisy over Gaza

play10:51

that leaves us with a real problem we do

play10:53

not have a space that we can go

play10:58

to

play11:02

last year Amnesty International revealed

play11:04

that Israel was using facial recognition

play11:06

systems in the West Bank to entrench its

play11:09

occupation of Palestinians there new

play11:12

details have now emerged about the

play11:13

technology that Israeli solders are

play11:16

using in Gaza and Tark NAFA is here with

play11:18

more well for months now we've heard

play11:21

reports and seen videos of Palestinians

play11:24

forced from their homes Crossing

play11:26

checkpoints where they are scanned by

play11:29

isra isi cameras some of these videos

play11:31

are truly dystopian in addition to being

play11:33

watched Palestinians are also harassed

play11:36

by Israel

play11:41

forces this week a New York Times piece

play11:43

revealed more information about the mass

play11:46

surveillance Israel has deployed on

play11:48

Palestinians in Gaza according to

play11:51

Israeli intelligence officials who spoke

play11:53

to the times anonymously it's part of an

play11:56

expansive and experimental effort to

play11:58

collect C and catalog the faces of

play12:01

Palestinians without their knowledge or

play12:04

consent developed by a private Israeli

play12:07

company called corite Israeli officials

play12:10

say the system was initially used to

play12:12

search for Israeli captives in Gaza but

play12:15

has since been used on a much wider

play12:17

scale to hunt down Hamas suspects one of

play12:21

the problems with this kind of

play12:23

Technology as one Israeli officer

play12:25

confirms is that it routinely gets it

play12:28

wrong with Israeli soldiers accused of

play12:31

abusing torturing and executing

play12:33

Palestinians in Gaza the consequences of

play12:37

being incorrectly identified as a Hamas

play12:39

fighter can cost you your life the

play12:42

Israeli military has always used Gaza as

play12:45

a lab in which it can test and develop

play12:48

new ways of killing or spying on

play12:51

Palestinians artificial intelligence is

play12:53

reportedly being used to generate

play12:56

Targets in Gaza facilitating what one

play12:59

Former Intelligence officer has called a

play13:02

mass assassination Factory we've also

play13:05

seen several videos of Israeli drones

play13:08

shooting at and killing unarmed

play13:10

Palestinians all of this technology has

play13:13

turned Gaza into a hellscape in which at

play13:15

least 32 and a half thousand

play13:17

Palestinians have been killed by Israeli

play13:20

forces thank you TK in just under 3

play13:24

weeks time on April 19th India will

play13:26

begin a 6 week long election process

play13:29

cess for its next national government it

play13:31

will all culminate on June 1st and prime

play13:34

minister Narendra Modi is expected to

play13:36

win an historic third term in office

play13:39

Mod's popularity ratings are high many

play13:42

of his opponents are mired in corruption

play13:44

cases filed by Mod's government and then

play13:47

there's the news media mainstream

play13:49

outlets in India have been almost

play13:51

entirely captured by modi's party the

play13:53

BJP churning out coverage that ranges

play13:56

from the sycophantic to the openly Pro

play13:59

government and that surval media

play14:01

landscape may not be the most powerful

play14:04

weapon in the bjp's Arsenal it also has

play14:07

a formidable get out the vote machine

play14:09

that combines an extensive volunteer

play14:11

network with the power of WhatsApp to

play14:14

influence voters spread propaganda and

play14:17

at times soow disinformation the

play14:20

listening posts Mino shiavi now on the

play14:22

all-encompassing information ecosystem

play14:25

that is likely to help putting NRA Modi

play14:27

back in the prime minister's office in

play14:29

New

play14:33

Delhi Indians have grown used to the

play14:35

omnipresence of their prime minister

play14:38

he's on billboards he's in the papers

play14:40

both in ads and in the news TV channels

play14:43

seem to have little else to cover and on

play14:45

March 16th the very day the dates for

play14:48

India's elections were

play14:52

announced Narendra Modi was whatsapping

play14:54

the country a letter from the Prime

play14:57

Minister was delivered straight into the

play14:59

phones of hundreds of millions of

play15:02

[Music]

play15:05

Indians the transformation that has

play15:08

taken place in the lives of people is

play15:10

the biggest achievement of our

play15:12

government over the last 10 years it is

play15:15

your support that gives me immense

play15:18

strength I am confident that we will

play15:21

continue to take our nation to Great

play15:23

Heights

play15:25

together it was unvarnished election

play15:27

hearing by the ruling part party using

play15:30

the resources and access to phone number

play15:32

databases of the government and it was

play15:35

unsurprising it was all happening on

play15:37

WhatsApp technology is very much part of

play15:41

the Arsenal which the BJP or prime

play15:43

minister Narendra Modi uses the BJP

play15:46

understood before any other party every

play15:48

Indian may not have literacy and public

play15:51

health and so on so forth but they have

play15:53

their cell phones India has the cheapest

play15:55

data in the world so the BJP in areas

play15:59

where it wishes to contest seriously it

play16:01

develops messaging for each constituency

play16:04

that was something that Prime Minister

play16:06

Modi and the Baria J party understood

play16:09

very well Mr Amit sha who is actually

play16:11

virtually the number two to Mr Modi in

play16:13

the within the BJP few years ago while

play16:16

speaking to party workers he had

play16:19

actually boasted you know it is very

play16:21

easy for us to take the message because

play16:23

we have the largest WhatsApp Network in

play16:25

the

play16:27

country

play16:42

now that was not a Bast that is actually

play16:44

true you actually have a centralized

play16:47

cell within the BJP which actually in

play16:50

the morning it decides okay these are

play16:52

today's messages which are to be

play16:54

publicized and they're kind of broadcast

play16:57

to various parts of the country

play17:01

the bjp's messaging is carefully

play17:03

tailored and highly produced with the

play17:05

party's star campaigner front and center

play17:08

in virtually all of

play17:09

[Music]

play17:10

it the Modi motorade drives through

play17:13

throngs of cheering Indians the videos

play17:15

from that make it to Whatsapp groups

play17:18

YouTube shorts and Instagram reels the

play17:21

Prime Minister hangs out with kids in

play17:22

schools and presents 20-some social

play17:25

media influencers with awards from the

play17:27

government

play17:30

he prays at multiple temples with

play17:33

cameras in tow even if the holy sight is

play17:36

underwater those clips don't just stay

play17:38

on social media they make the Evening

play17:40

News bulletins look closely on his

play17:42

screens he even decided to go underwat

play17:45

to pray at the submerged dwara all this

play17:48

is part of media strategy creating a

play17:52

nationwide

play17:53

perception that Narendra Modi as the

play17:56

leader of this ruling party wants to

play17:59

take India

play18:01

forward wants to create a developed

play18:04

India and make it the third largest

play18:08

economy in the

play18:17

world one senior leader of the BJP had

play18:21

said about Mr Modi he said for Narendra

play18:25

Modi elections is a battle of images and

play18:30

that is what the Indian Prime Minister

play18:32

has shown himself to be very good at and

play18:35

you can agree with this ideology his

play18:37

policies or disagree but it is his

play18:41

skills at political marketing that have

play18:44

been noticed we must remember that in

play18:48

India democracy Works in different uh

play18:51

language zones so the question is how do

play18:53

you recognize a party

play18:55

Modi electoral symbols are important in

play18:59

the case of Prime Minister Modi it is

play19:01

the recognition value of the Modi name

play19:04

the Modi face he has different personas

play19:06

that he has presented to the

play19:09

public one is that of a term called

play19:12

visha Guru which means world leader his

play19:16

performance on the international stage

play19:18

is constantly projected back

play19:23

home the other aspect of the messaging

play19:26

is that of being a strong an apologetic

play19:30

Hindu who goes and leads ceremonies in

play19:33

temples almost performs like a head

play19:35

priest some of his party people have

play19:38

likened him to a Godlike figure the

play19:41

messaging is extremely comprehensive

play19:44

which is according to data the most

play19:46

expensive in India's history the bjp's

play19:49

finances are formidable the party is the

play19:52

wealthiest in India its funds boosted by

play19:54

a financial tool it launched in 2017

play19:57

called an electoral bond this powerful

play20:00

instrument ushered in a wave of

play20:02

political donations to numerous parties

play20:04

across India the bulk of the money

play20:06

however nearly 60% went to the BJP

play20:10

amounting to about 60 billion rupees

play20:12

more than 725 million earned between

play20:16

2017 and just 2 months ago February 2024

play20:21

when the Supreme Court declared

play20:22

electoral bonds illegal due to their

play20:24

lack of transparency the money is in the

play20:27

bjp's coffers though and it it Powers

play20:29

not just an incessant stream of PR but

play20:31

also an impressive organizational

play20:34

Behemoth that underpins the party's

play20:36

election strategy on paper today the BJP

play20:40

is the largest political party in the

play20:42

world it is larger than the Communist

play20:44

Party of

play20:45

[Music]

play20:47

China so there is a huge network of

play20:51

party volunteers who was spread across

play20:53

the country besides that it's very

play20:56

important to understand that the BJ is

play20:59

not a standalone organization but it is

play21:02

part of a fairly large ideological

play21:05

umbrella group the S parar it's an

play21:08

organization which was formed in 1925

play21:11

almost 100 years ago and everywhere they

play21:14

have a presence so during elections it

play21:17

is not just the BJP which is out

play21:19

campaigning but you have leaders and

play21:22

cader which fan out to virtually every

play21:25

village and every electoral booth in the

play21:28

country I think the do too campaigning

play21:31

uh is a very effective method you know

play21:33

each page of the Electoral roles is

play21:37

assigned to one person so that person

play21:40

goes you know to the visits the families

play21:43

to try and to find out have they

play21:46

benefited from the policies and the

play21:48

programs of the party if not why not it

play21:51

is a party that's driven with the will

play21:54

to par and therefore every tool becomes

play21:57

very important for them now

play22:32

[Applause]

play22:37

[Music]

play23:06

the other query we must ask is the

play23:09

playing field now a level playing field

play23:12

for the BJP and the opposition and we

play23:15

must as journalists it's our job to flag

play23:18

that yet for all the many problems that

play23:20

the opposition faces they are going to

play23:22

put up candidates and fight the BJP but

play23:25

the BJP is working on a very very simple

play23:27

tack that they part of the messaging

play23:30

right now is to say there is no

play23:31

alternative to us that is all part of

play23:33

the hype Modi versus whom you know that

play23:37

Modi is the only answer to

play23:42

India back to Israel Gaza the US and the

play23:46

UN this past week the United Nations

play23:49

special raor on Palestine Francesca

play23:51

Alban published an extensive report the

play23:54

title anatomy of a genocide which the

play23:57

Netanyahu government says it utterly

play23:59

rejects so apparently does the US state

play24:02

department its Chief spokesman Matthew

play24:05

Miller said of Alban I can't help but

play24:08

note a history of anti-Semitic comments

play24:10

that she has made Miller needs to do

play24:13

some research the Israeli government has

play24:15

been accusing Alan of anti-Semitism for

play24:18

years now conflating her legitimate

play24:21

criticism of an illegal occupation for a

play24:23

form of hatred and in late 2022 65

play24:27

Scholars all experts on anti-Semitism

play24:31

endorsed Alban's work saying that

play24:33

Israel's supporters are simply out to

play24:35

silence her some online voices have

play24:38

described Matthew Miller's comments as a

play24:41

new low for the Biden Administration but

play24:44

it's not like we haven't heard that

play24:45

before we'll see you next time here at

play24:47

the listening

play24:55

post

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
UN CeasefireIsrael-GazaSurveillance TechnologyModi CampaignWhatsApp StrategyInternational RelationsMedia CoverageElectoral PoliticsArtificial IntelligenceHuman Rights